by Michael Wood
Matilda waited and studied the young man in front of her. He had shorn mousy hair, and his grey sweater was a size too big for him. He had a slight frame and the large wide eyes of a rabbit caught in the headlights.
‘Good morning,’ he said to them both. The first one of the inmates to make a polite gesture.
He made eye contact with Matilda, and the DCI stared back, mouth open. Matilda had sat opposite many killers during her time in the force. She had looked into their eyes and seen the violence and horror they inflicted on their victims and the lack of remorse. She knew evil and hatred when she saw it. When she looked across the Formica table at Thomas Hartley, she saw someone who did not belong in Starling House.
‘Ma’am,’ Scott urged when Matilda didn’t begin the proceedings. ‘Ma’am,’ he repeated.
‘Yes?’
‘Shall we start?’
‘Oh. Sorry. Right. You’re Thomas Hartley, yes?’
‘That’s right.’ Thomas was holding himself rigid: hands clasped between his legs, arms held taut. His shoulders were hunched.
‘Did you … did you speak to Ryan Asher yesterday?’ Matilda was distracted. Thomas’s name was familiar but she couldn’t quite remember the crime he was guilty of. She tried searching her memory but nothing came up. She really should have read Thomas’s file before the interview. She’d glanced at a couple but wanted to get them over with.
‘No. Well, only briefly in the dining room.’
‘What did you say?’
‘I asked him to pass the water jug.’
‘That’s it?’
‘Yes.’
‘Did you know Ryan Asher before you saw him yesterday?’
‘No.’
‘Do you know what crime he had committed?’
‘No.’
‘What did you do in the evening after your tea?’
Matilda, pen poised over an A4 writing pad, looked down. She wasn’t writing a single thing. Her knuckles were white as she gripped the biro firmly in her shaking fingers.
‘We all went to the rec. room.’
‘But what did you do?’
‘I usually just sit and watch television.’
‘Usually? Did you do that last night?’
‘Yes. We were watching all the Star Wars films on DVD.’
‘Are you a Star Wars fan?’
‘No.’ He gave a nervous smile, quickly looked up to Matilda then put his head down again.
‘Do you play pool or table tennis with the other boys?’
‘Not really. I’d rather just watch television. Or read.’
‘So at nine o’clock you all go to your rooms?’
‘Yes. We’re locked in from nine until seven the next morning.’
‘Do you sleep well?’
‘I do now.’
‘Have you had problems sleeping?’
‘I did when I first got here. I’m OK now.’
‘Did you wake up at all last night?’
‘No.’
‘Did you hear anything unusual?’
‘No.’
‘When did you first hear about Ryan being killed?’
‘Just as I was finishing breakfast. I overheard a couple of the officers talking. One of them mentioned something. I don’t know.’
Thomas’s replies were baseless. There was no emotion to his voice: he spoke in a flat drone. He looked downtrodden, as if every ounce of fight and drive had been drained out of him. This was not a sixteen-year-old boy who revelled in the glory of his crime, or a boy who felt remorse for his victims; this was an empty shell of a boy who had no idea what had happened to bring him to the dark world of Starling House.
‘Who do you think might have killed Ryan Asher?’
‘I’ve no idea.’
‘One of the other boys?’
‘I don’t know.’
‘Thomas, is there anything you would like to tell me?’
Thomas made eye contact with Matilda again and neither of them wanted to be the first to look away. The silence was palpable.
‘Like what?’ Thomas eventually asked.
‘Anything at all.’
He looked over to the officer whose stare was like acid burning into him. He turned back to Matilda. ‘No. Nothing.’
‘What was that all about?’ Scott asked Matilda when the door closed and Thomas was being taken back to the dining room.
‘What?’
‘Asking him if he had anything to tell you. Do you think he knows something?’
‘No. I don’t think he does. I’m going to give DI Brady a call. He can conduct the rest of the interviews with you.’
Matilda stood up and left the room with a perplexed look on her face. She had just interviewed a young man who did not belong here. Which begged the question: what the hell was he doing in Starling House?
THIRTEEN
Matilda went back to HQ alone. It was a good twenty-minute drive from Starling House on the outskirts of Sheffield to the city centre; longer, if traffic was bad. Fortunately, luck was on Matilda’s side (for once) and she managed to sail through. Her mind was on Thomas Hartley. She knew the name, and vaguely remembered the case, but she would have to look him up.
Matilda’s office was smaller than the one she was used to in the Murder Investigation Team, and she had only one window. The view wasn’t inspiring as it overlooked the back of the station and the large car park. She kicked the door closed and sat behind her desk.
Thomas Hartley was the first inmate of Starling House she had spoken to on their own. She had no idea if all the other inmates gave off the air of nervousness and appeared terrified of their own shadow. From what Aaron had said about Callum Nixon she didn’t think so. She had, however, spoken to many criminals in prison and not one of them had an ounce of innocence about them. Many claimed to be innocent; for some, it was a coping mechanism. Most were lying.
Matilda booted up her computer and brought up Thomas’s file. She was taken back to Manchester in January 2014 in the grip of a bitter cold snap for the north of England.
WITNESS STATEMENT
Name: Thomas Hartley
Date: 7 January 2014
My name is Thomas Hartley. I am the son of Daniel and Laura Hartley. My sister is Ruby Hartley.
I wasn’t feeling well. I’d eaten some left-over curry for my tea and I don’t think I’d heated it up enough because it made me sick. I couldn’t sleep and it was gone one o’clock by the time I was actually sick. It woke my sister up. During the Christmas holidays she’d promised us that she would try and sleep in her room all night without going to mum and dad’s room. She used to have nightmares quite a lot. Anyway, whenever she woke up she’d just go along to our parents’ room and they’d let her in. That’s what she must have done when I woke her up. If I hadn’t been sick she would have probably slept through the night and wouldn’t have gone to their room. She would still be alive now.
I took something to settle my stomach and I let the dog out because he was fussing. Then I went into the living room to lay down on the sofa. Max, he’s our dog, he woke me up by barking and nudging me, and I heard dripping. I thought we had a leak or something. I turned on the light and there was blood all over the coffee table. It was dripping onto the carpet. It was coming through the light fitting. I had no idea what was happening. I ran upstairs to get mum and dad and when I opened their bedroom door I saw that … oh my God. All I saw was red. The walls, the floor, the ceiling, the bed, it was all just red. It took me a while to work out what I was seeing. I didn’t think my parents and sister were there at first. It didn’t seem possible but when I looked closer I could see them. I recognized the watch on my mum’s arm and Ruby’s pyjamas and then I saw my dad’s face.
I didn’t know what to do. Usually if anything happens my mum or dad take control but they couldn’t so I called my Auntie Debbie. She’s my dad’s sister. She doesn’t live far away. I can’t remember what I said but she said she would come straight round. I sat at the bottom of the stair
s waiting for her and saw her coming up the road. I opened the door and she came straight in and went upstairs.
I don’t know how long she was up there for. She came down and went into the kitchen to phone for the police. Then she came and sat with me until they arrived. I don’t think we spoke to each other. I can’t remember. I can’t remember much of anything.
WITNESS STATEMENT
Name: Debbie Hartley
Date: 7 January 2014
My name is Debbie Hartley. I am the sister to Daniel Hartley, sister-in-law to Laura Hartley, and aunt to Thomas and Ruby Hartley.
I was asleep when the phone rang. It woke me up, and I didn’t answer it at first as it scared me but it kept on ringing so I answered. I remember looking at the clock on my bedside table. It was almost eight o’clock. It was Thomas. It didn’t sound like him because he was talking fast and loud, and I think he was crying. He said everyone was dead and there was blood everywhere and he didn’t know what to do. Then he hung up.
I got dressed, and I went straight round. There are three different buses to get to Daniel’s house so I didn’t have too long to wait. It’s only a ten-minute journey. Thomas opened the front door as soon as I got onto the street. I think he’d been waiting for me to arrive. He was literally covered in blood. I pushed past him and went straight upstairs to the bedroom.
It looked like a horror film: one of those slasher films that’s all blood and gore. It was horrible and smelled really bad as well. I saw Daniel straightaway on the bed. I saw his head. It didn’t look as if it was attached to his body. Then I saw Ruby. She’s only eight years old, bless her. My legs felt wobbly and I had to lean against the wall. I didn’t know it was covered in blood, and I got it all over me too. I felt sick. They’re my family. I don’t have anyone else.
I went downstairs, and Thomas was sitting at the bottom. I went into the kitchen and dialled 999. Then I went back to Thomas and put my arm around him. We waited until the police arrived.
The case appeared to be open and shut. There was no evidence of a break-in. None of the windows had been tampered with. Thomas’s fingerprints were all over his parents’ bedroom. There were no other foreign prints anywhere else in the house. However, there was one very important aspect missing from the case – a confession. Thomas vehemently denied killing his family. He stuck to his story, and it never varied no matter how many times he said it. Throughout the trial he maintained his innocence. There was absolutely no evidence to prove Thomas Hartley didn’t kill his family. A negative could not be proven.
What was Thomas’s motive for killing his family in such a disturbing and shocking way? Nobody knew. Almost three years later and still nobody knew.
Matilda turned away from the computer and looked out of the window. The clouds were gathering over the Steel City. She had heard on the radio that a storm was due later in the week. By the thickness and colour of the clouds it looked as if it had arrived. It was only early afternoon yet appeared to be late evening.
Matilda’s mind was full of questions. The case against Thomas Hartley was flimsy at best. There was no sign of a disturbance or break-in, but that didn’t mean Daniel Hartley hadn’t let his killer into the house; a killer who then let himself out afterwards. That was never followed up. And what about the sister? Debbie Hartley was home alone and didn’t have an alibi. Again, it seemed the police took her word for it. There was no mention of a murder weapon either. Had one been found? As far as Matilda was concerned the Senior Investigating Officer liked Thomas Hartley for the killings, and as there was no evidence to the contrary he didn’t bother looking too deeply.
Maybe that was true but all Matilda could think was that Thomas Hartley was innocent.
This had nothing to do with Matilda or South Yorkshire Police. The murders were committed in Manchester. She had no reason to investigate, no reason to stick her nose into a closed case apart from a gut feeling. She leaned back in her chair, a pensive look etched on her face. She picked up her phone and dialled.
‘Rory, have you been sent all the case files for the inmates?’
‘Yes. I’m going through them now.’
‘All of them?’
‘Yes.’
‘Good. Are you OK?’ she asked, noticing his less than cheerful voice.
‘Yes, fine. It’s just, well, it’s not exactly light reading, is it?’
‘No. I suppose not.’
‘Ma’am, about these boys, I was wondering … ’
‘I’ll talk to you about it later, Rory.’
She ended the called without saying goodbye. None of it was light reading. These boys were murderers; their crimes were shocking and deplorable. They were in Starling House until they were old enough to be moved to an adult prison. They had accepted their fate. Yet Thomas Hartley didn’t seem to be coping very well living among killers. Why was that?
FOURTEEN
Matilda was glad of the phone call from Adele Kean and a reminder that the post-mortem on Ryan Asher was due to take place. She had tried to concentrate on the case but the thought of an innocent young man being held at Starling House and the difficulty of trying to prove it kept distracting her. She closed down her computer and grabbed her coat. She couldn’t leave the station fast enough, even if it was to attend an autopsy.
‘I didn’t think you’d be doing the PM this quickly,’ Matilda said.
‘I’ve been asked very kindly by your ACC to bump him up to the front of the queue,’ Adele said. She did not look happy about having received a phone call from Valerie Masterson, who had obviously thrown her weight around. However, for a quiet life, Adele had acquiesced.
The door to the autopsy suite opened and in walked Claire Alexander, a small woman with a neat hair style cut into a short bob.
Adele immediately dropped her voice. ‘Whatever you do, don’t tell Claire about Valerie getting on the phone. She doesn’t like being told how to do her job.’
‘Matilda, nice to see you again,’ Claire Alexander said, a wide smile on her blemish-free face.
Claire Alexander was the senior radiologist at the Medico Legal Centre. Claire had been instrumental in bringing Digital Autopsy to Sheffield and was proud to be a trailblazer in her field. At first, Claire thought the police were sceptical of Digital Autopsy as it wasn’t something they readily accepted. It was only after a quiet word with Matilda that she realized it was all down to budget.
‘And you, Claire. I like your new haircut.’ Matilda smiled.
‘Thank you,’ she said, running her fingers through it. Claire looked at Matilda, clearly trying to return the compliment, but nothing had changed in the month or so since they’d last met. ‘So, shall we begin?’ was all she said.
Ryan Asher, still in a sealed and padlocked body bag, was lying on the bed of the scanner in the main section of the Digital Autopsy Suite. As a sign of respect, and the unspoken knowledge that a teenage boy was inside that bag, the atmosphere upon entering the room changed immediately. Yes, he was a two-time killer, but he was still just a teenager.
As Matilda, Adele, and Claire made their way to the control room, the two uniform police officers standing guard over the body followed them, making the cramped office seem even smaller.
‘At least you’ve got the air con on this time,’ Matilda said as an aside to Adele.
‘It can get very warm in here,’ she agreed.
‘Tell me about it. Last time I was in here I’m sure I lost five pounds through sweating alone.’
‘It doesn’t help when you have such burly coppers.’ Adele nodded to the two large uniform officers standing at the back of the narrow room.
‘I’m just waiting for us all to be ready before I begin,’ Claire said loudly.
Matilda and Adele exchanged glances.
Claire Alexander was an acutely professional woman. She was all for office banter and gossip but her body language told Matilda she thought there was a time and a place for that, and it was not in the Digital Autopsy Suite. She pressed a few keys
on the keyboard and the scanning of Ryan Asher began. It took minutes. Eventually, an X-ray image of the fifteen-year-old killer came up on the large computer screen. Claire looked at it briefly before selecting the trunk of the body and rescanned it to get a closer look at the areas where he was stabbed.
‘As I’m sure you know, Matilda, skin is the most resistant soft tissue to stab wounds in the body. It takes effort to penetrate it. Once you’re through very little force is needed to penetrate what lies beneath.’
‘So you’ll be able to see exactly what damage each stab wound did?’
‘Absolutely. Look at the heart—’
‘Can you point it out for me?’ Matilda said trying to make sense of the black-and-white X-ray.
Claire circled the heart with her index finger. ‘See that black blob? In layman’s terms, that is air. The edge of the heart, here … you can see a disruption. That is where the knife stabbed the heart.’
‘So he stabbed the heart, letting air in?’
‘That’s right. Obviously, you don’t want air in your heart. This darker shade of grey outside of the heart is blood. The heart is still pumping and blood is rapidly seeping out of the organ and into the chest cavity.’
‘Is that what killed him? A stab wound to the heart?’
‘There are twelve penetrating injuries on the body. I’ve no idea what order they came in. This one would definitely have done it but so would the ones to his lungs too. Look here.’ Again Claire pointed out the lungs for Matilda’s benefit and showed how the punctured lung had let in air and deflated. ‘This would have caused a pneumothorax and would almost certainly have killed him too.’
‘He could have been killed twelve times over,’ Adele said, leaning in to the screen.
‘If we look at the 3D image.’ Claire clicked with the mouse and a brilliantly clear image of Ryan Asher came up on-screen. It showed the ribs and organs perfectly. Matilda didn’t need anything pointed out this time. ‘You can see the deflation of the organs more clearly.’
