“Not yet.”
“When he does, tell him I’ll write him some sort of a letter. He’s a lunatic, but he has a wife and child to feed.”
“I’ll tell him.”
“How was your dinner last night?”
“I was glad that you finally chose to warn me that we were going to be at Baskerville Hall, but we sorted it out eventually. Thanks to Russell, actually, who gave an astonishingly realistic performance of a young wife fiercely protective of her eminent husband’s comfort and reputation. Ketteridge no doubt thinks her a fool.”
The sharp old eyes found me again across the room, and this time the twinkle in them was unmistakeable.
“That must have been quite an act,” he said.
“It was.”
Baring-Gould smiled gently to himself, and with that smile I had my first inkling of the nature of the hold this man had over Holmes.
“Russell and I will be away again tomorrow, but before we go, is there anything I can do for you?” Holmes asked him.
“Do you know,” Baring-Gould answered after a moment, “if it isn’t too much trouble, I should very much like some music.”
Without a word Holmes rose and left the room. I sat in the window and listened to the slow, laboured breathing of the man in the bed, and when Holmes came back in with his violin, I slipped out.
For two hours I sat, first in our rooms and then downstairs, trying to read Baring-Gould’s words concerning the Curious Myths of the Middle Ages and then his Legends of the Patriarchs and Prophets while the violin played the same sort of wistful, simple music I had first heard on the muddy road from Coryton station. It filled every corner of the house, and finally I took the current book, his recently published Early Reminiscences (which I had unearthed in the study between a tattered issue of the Transactions of the Devonshire Association and a pamphlet by Baring-Gould entitled “How to Save Fuel”) and escaped with it out of doors. Even the stables were not free of the music, I found. It was not until I closed the heavy door of the Lew Trenchard Church that silence finally enfolded me.
I had passed the building several times, a simple stone square with a proud tower, nestled into the tree-grown hillside and surrounded by gravestones and crosses. This was the first time I had been inside it, though, and I left the book of memoirs in my pocket while I looked around. It was an unsophisticated little stone building that straddled the centuries, with suggestions of thirteenth-century foundations rebuilt two and three hundred years later. The windows were not large, but the gloom cast was peaceful, not oppressive, and there was light enough to see. The air smelt of beeswax candles and wet wool from the morning services, but oddly enough, the feeling I received was not one of completion, but of preparation and waiting.
The single most dominating presence in the church was the screen framing the chancel. It was a magnificent thing, thick with niches and canopies, cornices and tracery, heavily encrusted with paint and gilt—far too elaborate for the crude little church but undeniably bearing the imprint of Sabine Baring-Gould’s hand. It was his idea of what a Tudor rood screen should look like, and once I had recovered from its first startling appearance, I found myself liking it for its sheer vehement assertion that God’s glory is to be found in a backwater parish on the skirts of Dartmoor.
There were other nice things in the church, somewhat overshadowed by the shiny new screen, and I spent some time admiring St. Michael and his dragon on one bench-end, a jester dated 1524 on another, the triptych in the side chapel, the old brass chandelier, and the carvings on the pulpit, before eventually taking the book from my pocket and settling onto one of the better-lit benches with it. I did not think God would object to my reading in His house, particularly not the memoirs of the man who had created this unlikely chapel in the wilderness.
AN HOUR OR so later, the door from the porch opened and Holmes came in. He removed his hat and slapped the light rain off of it, and came around through the church to sit on the other end of my pew. He leant forward, propping his outstretched arms on the back of the seat ahead of him and holding the brim of the dangling hat with the fingers of both hands. The prayerlike attitude of his position was deeply incongruous.
I closed the book of memoirs and looked up at the screen with its scenes from the life of Jesus. After a minute I spoke. “He’s dying isn’t he?”
“Yes.”
“Is that why you’ve come?”
“I would have come anyway, but yes, it makes the solution of the case that much more urgent.”
Other than the visual commotion around us, the church was utterly still. I thought I smelt incense as well as the beeswax, and I could picture Baring-Gould in his robes up in that pulpit, speaking a few well-chosen words that would have some of his parishioners squirming and others chuckling to themselves, and I felt a strong and unexpected bolt of sorrow to know that I would never witness that scene.
The case Holmes and I had just finished had begun with a debt to a dead woman. For several weeks over the summer I had lived with the fact that debts to the dead are heavier than those owed the living because there is no negotiation, no forgiveness, only the stark knowledge that failure can never be recompensed, that even success can only restore balance. That case was a hard one in a lot of ways, and I had only begun to think about the lessons it had driven into me when Holmes’ telegram had drawn me away from Oxford. Holmes, too, was still in the recovery stage, judging by the fact that he was still puffing on the black cigarettes he had taken up again in the most frustrating days of the Ruskin case. It had been a depressing affair whose solution only landed us in greater complexity, and now here we were, faced with another client who might not live to see the end of his case.
If working for the dead was hard, working for the dying looked to be harder yet: The already dead had eternity, after all. Baring-Gould did not.
“How long?” I asked.
“Weeks. Perhaps months. He will be gone before summer.”
“I am sorry.” Precisely what Baring-Gould meant to Holmes I still did not know, but I could readily see that there was depth to their relationship, and history.
He did not refuse my sympathy, did not say anything about Baring-Gould’s fullness of years. He just nodded.
After a while, we left the church. The flat ground surrounding the building was, inevitably, covered with gravestones new and ancient. One of the newer was at the foot of the church tower down a small slope, and I went over to look at it. As I had thought, the name on the stone was that of Grace Baring-Gould, the transplanted mill girl who had married the parson and ended up here, the squire’s wife. On her stone were carved the words DIMIDIUM ANIMAE MEAE. “Half my life,” Baring-Gould had placed there. I had no doubt that he waited now to join her.
We turned and went up the road to the village of Lew Down, where we took lunch in the Blue Lion, then walked around to the public bar to ask if Randolph Pethering had been seen that day. The barman knew immediately who we were talking about.
“You’ve missed’en, by abaut two hours. Gone aut auver th’ moor.”
“Out onto the moor? Why?”
“’Untin’ ’ounds,” he declared. “’S’ right, he’s gone a-hunting the ’Ound of the Baskervilles.” He peered at our faces, waiting for a reaction, and laughed aloud at what he saw there. Then he explained. “Mr Petherin’s one of they story fellas, writes down any rummage people tell’en. Ole Will’m Laddimer, ’e comes by while Mr Petherin’s tuckin’ into ’is eggs this morning, and ’e sits and ’e tells Mr Petherin’ abaut the goin’s-on up the moor. You heerd tell they been seein’ Lady ’Oward’s carriage, and them’s seed the ’ound’s footprints ’round abaut daid bodies?”
“We heard.”
Somewhat deflated, either by the loss of an opportunity to recount the story or because of Holmes’ flat inflection, the barman went on. “That’s all, really. Mr Petherin’ heerd the ’ound was seen near Watern Tor and went to looky. He’ll be back tomorry most likely. A pity you’ve already
beed aut along the tor—you could’ve meeted him there.”
As we carried our glasses to a table, I said to Holmes, “I don’t know why I imagined we might keep our business to ourselves here.”
“There’s no privacy in a village; for that you need either a truly remote setting or a city. No, everyone in this end of Devon will know who we are and what we’re about.”
“I did wonder why you made no attempt to conceal our identity up on the moor.”
“There’s no point in even trying, not unless you’re willing to sustain a complete disguise.”
I took a swallow of the dark beer in my glass and found it filled the mouth pleasingly, rich with yeast and hops. I took another, and put the glass on the table with respect.
“What next, Holmes?” I asked.
“For the next two or three days I think we need to divide forces. I will go north to finish quartering the ranges for Mycroft’s accursed spies and get that task out of the way. You can take the southwest. We need to find out how that carriage gets up onto the moor, and there are a limited number of routes it can take.”
I reached out and turned the glass around on the table, and with an effort pushed down the cold apprehension that wanted to rise up at the idea of walking alone onto the face of Dartmoor. When my voice was completely trustworthy, I asked him, “Why do you assume the carriage comes onto the moor? Isn’t it more likely that it is kept on the moor and brought out when needed?”
“It is of course possible, but in fact there are very few houses up there where a carriage and a pair of horses could be hidden, whereas there are a hundred places around the edges of the moor with considerably greater privacy. The northeastern edges particularly, which is why you on the south and west will be covering a greater amount of ground than I will.”
“Do we leave this afternoon?”
“In the morning. That will give you a chance to study your maps. And I think it might speed matters up if we arranged a horse for you. You’ll be making a circuit of half the moor; you would be a week on foot.”
Although normally I prefer to walk rather than be tied to the needs of a horse, I did not argue. Anything that would cut short the number of days I was to spend up on that bleak place had my approval.
I SPENT THE afternoon in Baring-Gould’s study, alone but for the fire, one somnolent cat, and a visit from Mrs Elliott with a tea tray. I was aware of movement in the house—footsteps in and out of the bedrooms overhead, kitchen noises from beyond the door, the arrival of a mud-caked cart that disgorged an old woman, wrapped in rugs and dignity—but I ignored them all.
Instead, I made a complete perusal of the shelves and their contents, climbing up on the back of a chair and hanging from my fingertips at the higher reaches like a rock climber. There was not a great number of books, considering that the man was supposed to be a scholar and had been in the same house for forty years, and the volumes on the upper reaches particularly were covered with a thick blanket of dust.
I did find quite a few books written by Baring-Gould. In fact, after the first dozen or so I only thumbed through them to get an idea of the topic, and then replaced most of them, not being particularly interested in A Book of the Rhine from Cleve to Mainz; The Tragedy of the Caesars; A History of Sarawak Under Its Two White Rajahs; Iceland, Its Scenes and Sagas; a biography of Nelson; or even Post-Mediaeval Preachers, although I did set aside monographs on “The Lost and Hostile Gospels: An Essay on the Toledoth Jeschu, and the Petrine and Pauline Gospels of the First Three Centuries of Which Fragments Remain” and “Village Conferences on the Creed,” plus a few books with irresistible titles: Freaks of Fanaticism and Other Strange Events; Devonshire Characters and Strange Events (Baring-Gould seemed to like strange and curious events); Virgin Saints and Martyrs; and two novels, one called Pabo, the Priest, the other Urith: A Tale of Dartmoor, the latter of which I could at least justify by calling it local research.
At the very end of the afternoon, when the grey light of the day had long turned to black at the windows and the smells of dinner were coming in under the door, I found what I had originally had in mind when I had entered the study five hours before and forgotten in the pleasure of prospecting the shelves for nuggets: a manuscript copy of Further Reminiscences, the Baring-Gould memoir for the second thirty years of his life. The clean copy was probably now with his publisher, as the first volume had only just come out, and this version was sprinkled with crosshatchings and corrections, but the small handwriting was surprisingly legible. I left it in place, as a loose sheaf of papers requires a sedentary reader, but I planned to return to it later. Of the third volume, 1894–1924, there seemed to be only thirty pages or so of manuscript in a manila folder inside the high writing desk, along with a pen with a worn nib, crusted with ink, and a dusty inkwell. I held the manuscript pages in my hand, wondering bleakly if he would ever finish the volume. It did not appear to have been worked on for some time.
The study door opened and Holmes walked in. “Dinner in ten minutes, Russell. You ought to have memorised those maps by this time.”
The maps. I had not even looked at the things, although Holmes could not know that for certain, as they had been shifted around in the course of the afternoon’s ransacking—I might, after all, have folded them up after having committed the pertinent sections to memory. I murmured something noncommittal and began to search earnestly for a pencil. Holmes picked one up and held it out to me, not a whit deceived. I thanked him and stuck it in my shirt pocket, noticing as I did so the state of my nails.
“I think I ought to go and tidy up,” I said. A fair percentage of the several cubic feet of dust I had set free seemed to have settled on my person. I picked up the tall stack of books I had set aside for reading and tucked them underneath my arm.
“Don’t forget these, Russell,” he said drily. I took the maps he was holding out, wedged them on top of the books, and made my way out of the crowded study and up the stairs.
AFTER DINNER WE climbed the stairs to Baring-Gould’s bedroom. We found him seated in a chair at the window, looking tired and ill and without strength. Looking what he in fact was: a man not far from his death.
Watching him, one could see the effort it cost him, but he succeeded in rallying his forces, his eyes coming to life, his mind focussing again on us and the problem he had given into our hands.
“We’re off tomorrow, Gould, for two days,” Holmes told him. “We need to find how Lady Howard’s carriage is coming up onto the moor, and I have to take a closer look at the army ranges for Mycroft.”
A smile tugged at Baring-Gould’s mouth. “Don’t let them blow you up, Holmes.”
“I shall endeavour to avoid becoming a target,” Holmes assured him.
“You don’t mean they’re actually firing up there?” I exclaimed.
“It is a firing range, Russell.”
“But—” I bit back the mouthful of protests and cautions, as there would be little point in voicing them. Besides which, I told myself, Holmes would never have reached his present age if he could not be trusted to dodge an artillery shell.
It was Gould who reassured me, or tried to. “I shouldn’t think they are practising this late in the season. They normally finish in September.”
“Before we go, Gould,” said Holmes, “just take a look at the map for us and tell Russell if there are any points a person could take a carriage onto the moor that aren’t obvious from the markings.”
“A ghostly carriage doesn’t need a road, Holmes,” Baring-Gould said in a stern whisper. Holmes did not deign to answer, merely took a folded smaller-scale map from his pocket and shook it out, holding it up by the corners directly in front of Baring-Gould. The old man had only to pull down his spectacles from his forehead to study the map, but instead he smiled and waved Holmes away.
“No need for that; I can see it better with my eyes closed.” He did actually close his eyes, and Holmes laid the map over a table for those of us whose eyes were better than our knowledge
of the moor. I took out a pencil.
“I think that, as the sightings have all been in the northern quarter, we need not bother with anything south of the Princetown Road. Is this reasonable?”
“For the present,” Holmes said, adding, “We may have to expand the search later.”
“Very well. From the south, we begin at the point where the Princetown Road enters Tavistock.” I dutifully made a small circle on the map. “From there up to Mary Tavy the gates are all on the east side of the Tavy, and will coincide with the lanes leading down to the river. Except,” he said, sitting forward and replacing his glasses onto his nose so he could take the pencil from me and circle an invisible fold in the contour lines, “except for here, a lane that appears to skirt the field. Since the map was made, however, the farmer took down a section of the old wall, and now drives his cattle up onto the moor along here.” The edge of his fingernail traced a dip in the contour lines. “Here is another place, but that should be obvious.” His eyes shifted sideways to take in my reaction. I nodded, and pointed to half a dozen other access points I could see. We both ignored the actual lanes and the labelled Moor Gates, looking only for the hidden places. “Along here,” he said, “there is an old miner’s trail. And this here; it used to be a railway line for bringing peat off the moor. And of course this path here, marginally negotiable if the driver were very good and the horses strong.”
It did not take long for Baring-Gould’s intimate knowledge of the moor to lay open the map to my eyes. I should begin by crossing the moor to the other side of Princetown, and from there work my way back to Lydford, while Holmes cut across the moor up to the northeastern portion and worked his way counterclockwise. We should either meet in the middle or, failing that, return here Wednesday night.
I took my leave of Baring-Gould with considerably greater warmth than I would have thought possible even a day or two earlier. Holmes played for him again that night, and although the music ended early, he did not return to our rooms until a very late hour.
The Mary Russell Series Books 1-4: The Beekeeper's Apprentice; A Monstrous Regiment of Women; A Letter of Mary; The Moor Page 100
