by Tim Maltin
“Steamer Rhein reports passing wreckage and bodies 42.1 north, 49.13 west, eight miles west of three big icebergs. Now making for that position. Expect to arrive 8 o’clock to-night.
(Signed)“MACKAY-BENNETT.”
The second message read:
“Received further information from Bremen (presumably steamship Bremen) and arrived on ground at 8 o’clock p.m. Start on operation to-morrow. Have been considerably delayed on passage by dense fog.
(Signed)“MACKAY-BENNETT.”
After receiving these messages Mr. Ismay issued the following statement:
“The cable ship Mackay-Bennett has been chartered by the White Star Line and ordered to proceed to the scene of the disaster and do all she could to recover the bodies and glean all information possible.
“Every effort will be made to identify bodies recovered, and any news will be sent through immediately by wireless. In addition to any such message as these, the Mackay-Bennett will make a report of its activities each morning by wireless, and such reports will be made public at the offices of the White Star Line.
“The cable ship has orders to remain on the scene of the wreck for at least a week, but should a large number of bodies be recovered before that time she will return to Halifax with them. The search for bodies will not be abandoned until not a vestige of hope remains for any more recoveries.
“The Mackay-Bennett will not make any soundings, as they would not serve any useful purpose, because the depth where the Titanic sank is more than 2,000 fathoms.”
On April 22d the first list of twenty-seven names of bodies recovered was made public. It contained that of Frederick Sutton, a well-known member of the Union League of Philadelphia. It did not contain the name of any other prominent man who perished, although it was thought that the name “George W. Widen” might refer to George D. Widener, son of P. A. B. Widener, of Philadelphia. The original passenger lists of the Titanic did not mention “Widen,” which apparently established the identity of the body as that of Mr. Widener, who, together with his son, Harry, was lost.
The wireless message, after listing the names, concluded, “All preserved,” presumably referring to the condition of the bodies.
A number of the names in the list did not check up with the Titanic’s passenger list, which led to the belief that a number of the bodies recovered were members of the Titanic’s crew.
MINIA SENT TO ASSIST
At noon, April 23d, there was posted on the bulletin in the White Star office this message from the Mackay-Bennett dated Sunday, April 21st:
“Latitude, 41.58; longitude, 49.21. Heavy southwest swell has interfered with operations. Seventy-seven bodies recovered. All not embalmed will be buried at sea at 8 o’clock to-night with divine service. Can bring only embalmed bodies to port.”
To Captain Lardner, master of the Mackay-Bennett, P. A. S. Franklin, vice-president of the White Star Line, sent an urgent message asking that the company be advised at once of all particulars concerning the bodies identified, and also given any information that might lead to the identification of others. He said it was very important that every effort be made to bring all of the bodies possible to port.
Mr. Franklin then directed A. G. Jones, the Halifax agent of the White Star Line, to charter the Minia and send her to the assistance of the Mackay-Bennett. Mr. Jones answered this telegram, and said that the Minia was ready to proceed to sea, but that a southeast gale, which generally brings fog, might delay her departure. She left for Halifax.
NAMES BADLY GARBLED
On April 24th no wireless message was received from the Mackay-Bennett, but the White Star Line officials and telegraphers familiar with the wireless alphabet were busy trying to reconcile some of the names received with those of persons who went down on the Titanic. That the body of William T. Stead, the English journalist and author, had been recovered by the Mackay-Bennett, but through a freakish error in wireless transmission the name of another was reported instead, was one of the theories advanced by persons familiar with the Morse code.
BREMEN SIGHTED MORE THAN A HUNDRED BODIES
When the German liner Bremen reached New York the account of its having sighted bodies of the Titanic victims was obtained.
From the bridge, officers of the ship saw more than a hundred bodies floating on the sea, a boat upside down, together with a number of small pieces of wood, steamer chairs and other wreckage. As the cable ship Mackay-Bennett was in sight, and having word that her mission was to look for bodies, no attempt was made by the Bremen’s crew to pick up the corpses.
In the vicinity was seen an iceberg which answered the description of the one the Titanic struck. Smaller bergs were sighted the same day, but at some distance from where the Titanic sank.
The officers of the Bremen did not care to talk about the tragic spectacle, but among the passengers several were found who gave accounts of the dismal panorama through which their ship steamed.
Mrs. Johanna Stunke, a first-cabin passenger, described the scene from the liner’s rail.
“It was between 4 and 5 o’clock, Saturday, April 20th,” she said, “when our ship sighted an iceberg off the bow to the starboard. As we drew nearer, and could make out small dots floating around in the sea, a feeling of awe and sadness crept over everyone on the ship.
“We passed within a hundred feet of the southernmost drift of the wreckage, and looking down over the rail we distinctly saw a number of bodies so clearly that we could make out what they were wearing and whether they were men or women.
“We saw one woman in her night dress, with a baby clasped closely to her breast. Several women passengers screamed and left the rail in a fainting condition. There was another woman, fully dressed, with her arms tight around the body of a shaggy dog.
“The bodies of three men in a group, all clinging to one steamship chair, floated near by, and just beyond them were a dozen bodies of men, all of them encased in life-preservers, clinging together as though in a last desperate struggle for life. We couldn’t see, but imagined that under them was some bit of wreckage to which they all clung when the ship went down, and which didn’t have buoyancy enough to support them.
“Those were the only bodies we passed near enough to distinguish, but we could see the white life-preservers of many more dotting the sea, all the way to the iceberg. The officers told us that was probably the berg hit by the Titanic, and that the bodies and ice had drifted along together.”
Mrs. Stunke said a number of the passengers demanded that the Bremen stop and pick up the bodies, but the officers assured them that they had just received a wireless message saying the cable ship Mackay-Bennett was only two hours away from the spot, and was coming for that express purpose.
Other passengers corroborated Mrs. Stunke.
THE IDENTIFED DEAD
On April 25th the White Star Line officials issued a corrected list of the identified dead. While the corrected list cleared up two or more of the wireless confusions that caused so much speculation in the original list, there still remained a few names that so far as the record of the Titanic showed were not on board that ship when she foundered.
The new list, however, established the fact that the body of George D. Widener, of Philadelphia, was among those on the Mackay-Bennett, and two of the bodies were identified as those of men named Butt.
THE MACKAY-BENNETT RETURNS TO PORT
After completing her search the Mackay-Bennett steamed for Halifax, reaching that port on Tuesday, April 30th. With her flag at half mast, the death ship docked slowly. Her crew manned the rails with bared heads, and on the aft deck were stacked the caskets with the dead. The vessel carried on board 190 bodies, and announcement was made that 113 other bodies had been buried at sea.
Everybody picked up had been in a life-belt and there were no bullet holes in any. Among those brought to port were the
bodies of two women.
THE MINIA GIVES UP THE SEARCH
When at last the Minia turned her bow toward shore only thirteen additional bodies had been recovered, making a total of 316 bodies found by the two ships.
Further search seemed futile. Not only had the two vessels gone thoroughly over as wide a field as might likely prove fruitful, but, in addition, the time elapsed made it improbable that other bodies, if found, could be brought to shore. Thus did the waves completely enforce the payment of their terrible toll.
LIST OF IDENTIFIED DEAD
Following is a list of those whose identity was wholly or partially established:
Astor, John Jacob.
Adonts, J.
Ale, William.
Artagaveytia, Ramon.
Ashe, H. W.
Adahl, Mauritz.
Anderson, Thomas.
Adams, J.
Aspalande, Carl.
Allen, H.
Anderson, W. Y.
Allison, H. J.
Butt, W. (seaman).
Butt, W. (may be Major Butt).
Butterworth, Abelj.
Bailey, G. F.
Barker, E. T.
Butler, Reginald.
Birnbaum, Jacob.
Bristow, R. C.
Buckley, Katherine.
Chapman, John H.
Chapman, Charles.
Connors, P.
Clong, Milton.
Cox, Denton.
Cavendish, Tyrrell W.
Carbines, W.
Dutton, F.
Dashwood, William.
Dulles, W. C.
Douglas, W. D.
Drazenoui, Yosip (referring probably to Joseph Draznovic).
Donati, Italo (waiter).
Engineer, A. H. F.
Elliott, Edward.
Farrell, James.
Faunthorpe, H.
Gill, J. H.
Greenberg, H.
Gilinski, Leslie.
Graham, George.
Giles, Ralph.
Givard, Hans C.
Hansen, Henry D.
Haytor, A.
Hays, Chales M.
Hodges, H. P.
Hell, J. C.
Hewitt, T.
Harrison, H. H.
Hale, Reg.
Hendekeric, Toznai.
Hinton, W.
Harbeck, W. H.
Holverdon, A. O. (probably A. M. Halverson of Troy).
Hoffman, Louis M.
Hinckley, G.
Hospital Attendant, no name given.
Johansen, Malcolm.
Johansen, Eric.
Johansson, Gustaf J.
Johansen, A. F.
Jones, C. C.
Kelly, James.
Laurence, A.
Louch, Charles.
Long, Milton C.
Lilly, A.
Linhart, Wenzell.
Marriortt, W. H. (no such name appears on the list of passengers or crew).
Mangin, Mary.
McNamee, Mrs. N. (probably Miss Elleen McNamee.)
Mack, Mrs.
Monros, Jean.
McCaffry, Thomas.
Morgan, Thomas.
Moen, Segurd H.
Newell, T. H.
Nasser, Nicolas.
Norman, Robert D.
Petty, Edwin H.
Partner, Austin.
Penny, Olsen F.
Poggi,—.
Ragozzi, A. Boothby.
Rice, J. R.
Robins, A.
Robinson, J. M.
Rosenshine, George.
Stone, J.
Steward, 76.
Stokes, Philip J.
Stanton, W.
Straus, Isidor.
Sage, William.
Shea,—.
Sutton, Frederick.
Sother, Simon.
Schedid, Nihil.
Swane, George.
Sebastiano, Del Carlo.
Stanbrocke, A.
Tomlin, Etnest P.
Talbot, G.
Villner, Hendrick K.
Vassilios, Catalevas (thought to be a confusion of two surnames).
Vear, W. (may be W. J. Ware or W. T. Stead).
Widener, George W.
Williams, Leslie.
Wirz, Albert.
Wiklund, Jacob A.
Wailens, Achille.
White, F. F.
Woody, O. S.
Wersz, Leopold.
Zacarian, Mauri Der.
1912–2012
A Survivor and the Centennial
Lawrence Beesley,
New York Times,
APRIL 29, 1912
I have been asked by the editor of The Times to review the whole circumstances of the sinking of the Titanic from the point of view of a survivor as well as from that of the ordinary reader who has followed the evidence given before the Senate Committee. The only reason that makes me think I am fitted to accede to the request is that I have absolutely no bias in the matter. I was alone on board and have lost no friends by the disaster; the few belongings I had were of no value beyond their immediate utility, with the exception of money locked in the purser’s safe, and this, by the way, the White Star Line has mostly refunded on my bare statement as to the amount. I knew no officer on board the Titanic, and the only official of the line I spoke to was Second Officer Lightoller on the Carpathia, and under the following circumstances:
While on board the Carpathia I had written a letter to The London Times, urging the taking of immediate steps to insure safety of passengers and pointing out as dispassionately as possible the reasons for the disaster, without seeking to apportion the blame for it. This letter appeared in The London Times on Saturday last, and I understand they were glad to have it as the opinion of a survivor. It became known on the Carpathia that such a letter was in preparation, and Lightoller came to me with Mr. Ismay’s compliments to ask if he could take the letter to Mr. Ismay. I have never seen Mr. Ismay.
I hesitated, knowing that while it did not seek to affix blame, the deduction would be that there was blame attachable somewhere—where I did not know and I did not wish Mr. Ismay to think we were planning to criticize either his officers or his company. However, I knew every statement in the letter was absolutely justifiable and likely to help forward the question of passenger safety, and so I sent the letter to Mr. Ismay. He returned it without raising the slightest objection to it. I asked Lightoller to read it. He did so, and said it was calculated to help all concerned—the officers and crew no less than the passengers.
I mention these details only to make it quite clear that my connection with officials of the line is limited to a few moments’ conversation, and that I know no motive that induces me to either criticize or defend their actions.
Now, the facts of the disaster are briefly these: The Titanic, with a lifeboat provision for saving less than one in three of its passengers, proceeded at full speed through an iceberg region, in which, moreover, it was definitely known that icebergs had been seen and might be expected. An awful indictment! An unbelievable accusation, were it not that we know every detail is attested to by scores of responsible witnesses.
But let us analyze the whole circumstances in a just manner. Let us not form hasty judgments or make rash statements. The power of correct analysis is unfortunately sadly lacking in the average man and woman, and most people are prone to rush to rapid conclusions on totally insufficient evidence. Now, I take it what the editor of The Times wishes me to do is analyze as closely as pos
sible the reasons, motives, and aims of those concerned in the disaster, and as far as in me lies I will do so.
I take it there are two main questions to be considered: (1) At whose door should the blame for this overwhelming disaster be placed, and, (2) What are the precautions to be adopted in the future against the repetition of such a disaster?
Now, I think the first of these questions is not by any means the more important; in fact, it should be considered only as a means to aid the efficiency of the methods suggested in the second question. Our motive in fixing responsibility should not be that some person or corporation shall be pilloried and punished; that helps neither them nor the public safety. No one dreams that the ship was lost with deliberate intent. If it be proved that any one has been guilty of criminal negligence, let it be brought home to him or to them and let punishment be meted out if it is thought well; but criminal negligence will be found a difficult thing to prove, and the traveling public that denounces the officials concerned may find the charge a possible boomerang that returns to wound themselves.
It will, therefore, be better to take the second question first and consider what are the precautions to be adopted in the future against the repetition of such a disaster. The general public cannot attempt to discuss such technical questions as bulkhead compartments and double bottoms: they are for the expert in ship construction: but is not the main question after all one of ordinary common sense which the general public is quite as capable of using as the trained official? Perhaps by his very ignorance of technical construction details the average man is not so apt to lose sight of the simpler precautions. The following points will, I think, occur to everyone as being eminently sane and rational. The fact that they have not been attended to in the past seems unbelievable, but several factors, some of which I hope to discuss shortly, have tended to eliminate these safeguards from the policy of sailing mail passenger vessels.
The route fixed by agreement among the steamship lines is normally a safe one, but apparently we are faced this year with an exceptionally large icefield, extending much further south than is usual. It is normally safe, however, only with due precautions: it can never be safe at full speed in the dark when icebergs are a possibility.
