by Emily Giffin
“How about a hug?”
She shakes her head and says, “Later, Mommy. I’m very busy now.”
They are clearly words she’s heard many times before, and I feel a stab of guilt knowing she is quoting me.
“What are you making?” I ask, sitting at the table beside her, and wondering why my mother didn’t put down a drop cloth or newspaper, glitter already working its way into the crevices of her rustic wooden table. I resist the urge to clean, waiting for her answer.
“A castle. And that’s you,” she says, pointing to an oval-faced brunette peering out of a half-moon third-floor window. I’m not quite frowning, but certainly not smiling, my mouth a straight, smudged line of red crayon.
“What’s Mommy doing up there?” Nolan asks, sitting on the other side of Harper.
“Just looking out,” Harper says. “At this tree. And this blue bird.” She points to each as I notice that her fingers are beginning to lose their chubbiness, becoming little-girl slender.
Nolan and I exchange a glance, as I wonder if he’s trying to psychoanalyze her art project as much as I am.
“And where are you?” I ask, even though it is clearly her standing in the front yard, wearing a pink A-line frock. Beside her is a strapping, smiling man that has to be Nolan.
“Right here,” she says, pointing to herself. “With Daddy.”
“That’s a mighty happy pair,” I say under my breath, but Harper hears me and quotes me back.
“A happy pair,” she says, smiling, nodding.
“So did you and Nana have fun?” I ask, changing the subject.
“Yeah,” she says.
“You mean ‘yes’?” I say, gently correcting her.
“Yes,” she says, shaking more purple glitter into the flower bed in front of the castle.
“We had a marvelous time,” Mom says, gazing at Harper adoringly. “And how was your anniversary weekend?”
“It was great,” I say, forcing a cheerful tone. “Very relaxing…It’s such a beautiful place.”
Nolan quickly echoes my comments.
Mom looks pleased. “I’m so glad you had a good time,” she says.
“So what else did you two do?” I ask, glancing from Mom to Harper.
“Let’s see. We watched movies….Right, Harper?”
Harper nods and says, “Lady and the Tramp…and 101 Dalmatians. And Lassie Come Home.”
“Oh, a little dog theme, I see,” Nolan says pointedly, glancing my way.
In addition to a second child, he has been trying to get Harper a puppy for months now, but I have held out, knowing that I will be the one taking it out every morning, feeding it, and scooping up its poop from the yard.
“And speaking of dogs,” Mom says. “Aunt Josie came over with Revis for a late breakfast. You actually just missed her.”
“Drats,” I say, my voice completely flat.
Mom says my name as a warning.
“What?” I ask, feigning innocence.
“Be nice,” she says. And then—“Have you still not talked to her?”
“No,” I say, positive that this fact was discussed, and knowing how adept Josie is at making me out to be the bad guy.
“You really need to talk to her.”
“And why’s that?”
I know her answer before she says it: Because she’s your sister. She clears her throat, then adds, “And because she’s going to have this baby, and we need to support her decision.”
“Do you think she’ll really go through with it?” Nolan asks.
Mom nods and says, “Yes. In fact, she picked her donor.”
I flinch, but remain silent, determined not to ask any questions and indirectly validate what Josie’s doing. Of course Nolan doesn’t get this nuance and eagerly asks for the scoop.
Mom takes a deep breath, then starts rattling off the detailed bio of a complete stranger. “His name is Peter. He’s from the Midwest—Wisconsin, I think she said…but he currently lives in Atlanta. He’s forty-one. I think she said he’s five-ten or five-eleven….He has brown hair and hazel eyes.”
She takes a deep breath, Nolan looking rapt while I pretend to be completely disinterested. “And let’s see….He’s Irish and German by descent….He was raised Catholic, but isn’t very religious. He is spiritual, though. He believes in God. He likes outdoorsy things—camping and biking and skiing. He’s very fit. Very healthy. He went to college, then got a graduate degree in physical therapy, which he practices now. He’s very smart, especially in math and science….”
“If he does say so himself?” I say.
Mom ignores my snide comment and says, “Oh—and she says he has a cleft in his chin. Which Josie has always liked.”
“Well, super,” I say.
“Meredith,” she says sternly. “You really need to change your attitude.”
“Why? She never changes her attitude,” I say, knowing how immature I sound. “She never resists a single impulse.”
“Actually,” Mom says, her voice gentle. “That’s not true. She’s really trying lately.”
I cross my arms and raise my eyebrows. “Oh? How so?”
“Well, for one—she has agreed to go to New York with us. In December.”
“We’ll see about that. I bet you a hundred bucks she backs out,” I say, thinking that’s one of Josie’s signature tactics—bow to pressure, then come up with an excuse later.
Mom shakes her head. “No. She’s really come around on the idea,” she says so earnestly that it breaks my heart. “And I think it will be good for her. For all of us, but maybe especially for her.”
“Why’s that?”
“She needs to face her grief,” Mom says. “She never really has. I think seeing Sophie might help with that….So anyway, we should all probably book our tickets and hotel soon….New York is so busy around the holidays….” Her voice trails off and her eyes grow glassy, as she is obviously thinking about Daniel, that time of the year, trees and decorations and Christmas carols, all completely synonymous with death in our family.
I look away, watching Harper add another large tree to the castle grounds, this one an evergreen. Nobody speaks for a long stretch, the only sounds those of Harper’s crayon pressing against the paper and Nolan tapping the table with his thumbs. Annoyed by the monotonous rhythm, I reach over and put my hand on his, silencing him.
He glares at me, then clears his throat. “Speaking of New York,” he says. “Meredith might go up there sooner than December….”
I look at him, confused. Ellen and I have recently discussed going to the city for a girls’ weekend, but I don’t recall mentioning this to him, probably because I knew it was a long shot given my workload at the firm.
“Oh?” Mom says, glancing at me. “For work?”
“No,” Nolan quickly replies. “She just needs a break. A little getaway.”
“Wasn’t that the point of this weekend?” Mom asks, clearly as confused as I am.
“Oh, she needs a longer break than that,” he says. “A real break. From her job. And Harper. And me.” He flashes a fake smile, then forces a chuckle. “Don’t you think that would be good for her?”
Mom nods, but remains pensive. “Well, I guess time away can be good for all of us….How long of a break do you need, sweetie?”
“I don’t need a break,” I say, feeling both agitated and defensive.
Nolan musses my hair, feigning lightheartedness, and says, “Oh, yeah you do. A couple weeks will do you good.”
“A couple of weeks?” Mom and I reply in unison.
“What about Harper?” she asks as I glare at my husband.
“Oh, I have that covered. Hell. Josie’s going to be a single parent. Surely I can handle a couple of weeks on my own,” he says, as I stare at him, wondering when all of this came to him. On his run yesterday? Last night after we had sex? On the virtually silent drive back this morning?
He whistles a few bars of an unrecognizable song, then says, “Maybe I’ll take some time off, too
. Do a little father-daughter bonding. Wouldn’t that be fun, Harper?”
“Uh-huh,” she says, without looking up.
“And I’m sure Nana can help a little…and Gran and Pop,” he says, referring to his parents. “And Josie, of course. Good ol’ Aunt Josie.”
Mom frowns, looking confused by the contradiction between his maniacal mood and the undertones of his message. Deep lines appear on her forehead as she asks her standard question. “Should I be worried here?”
“No,” I say.
“Oh, no,” Nolan says. “Not one bit. Meredith just needs to do some thinking. Right, Mere?”
I bite my lip and mumble a noncommittal yeah, as Mom asks what sort of thinking.
“Deep thinking,” he chirps. “Soullll searching.”
“About?” Mom asks.
At this point, I’m in damage control mode, so I simply say, “About my job.”
“So you’re seriously thinking about leaving?” she asks, her frown lines easing a bit.
I start to reply with a watered-down statement about feeling burned out, but Nolan once again answers for me. “Yes,” he says decisively, a word he almost never uses, which is why Harper continues to say yeah and uh-huh. Then he turns and looks into my eyes. “She’s seriously thinking about leaving.”
—
“WHAT THE HELL was that about?” I ask Nolan as soon as we’re back at the house and alone—as alone as you can be with Harper in the next room. My voice is measured and low, but inside I’m enraged.
“What?” he says with a passive-aggressive shrug. “I think it’s a great idea. You need some time to think.”
“Any reason you didn’t mention this idea to me first?” I ask, using my fingernail to scrape a piece of hardened shredded wheat from a cereal bowl Nolan left in the sink two mornings ago. It’s now as hard as superglue. I finally give up and put it in the dishwasher.
“Any reason you didn’t mention that you think our marriage is a joke?” he asks.
“I never said that. Nor do I think that.”
“Okay. Any reason you didn’t mention that you think our marriage was a big mistake?”
“I didn’t say that, either, Nolan,” I say, spinning around and staring at him.
He stares back at me with defiance and disdain. “What did you say, then?”
“I don’t know, Nolan….I’m just…confused.”
“Well, as I said, I think you need to go away and figure it out.”
“I can’t just go away, Nolan,” I say, my hands on my hips. “What about Harper?”
“I told you. I can handle things here.”
I look at him, thinking that he doesn’t have the first clue about how to run the washing machine, let alone handle the myriad details of Harper’s daily routine. I think about the last time I went on a work trip and how he didn’t even get the mail for three days. “What about my job? Can you handle my job, too?” I say.
He shrugs. “Take a leave of absence. People do it all the time. Or just quit. You hate it. What’s the point of doing something you hate?”
“I don’t hate it,” I say, thinking that his oversimplification of everything is part of the problem.
“Yes, you do,” he says. “You despise it. You wish you had stayed in New York and become a famous actress.”
I open my mouth to correct him, as I never desired fame. I just wanted to be a working stage actress. At most I dreamed about a Tony—and how many Tony Award–winning actresses are household names? But this seems rather beside the point.
“Instead you’re an attorney in Atlanta. Married to me. Huge, huge mistake,” he says.
“Nolan,” I say, my voice beginning to rise. “Would you please stop with this crap? I didn’t say that.”
“Oh, but you think it,” he says. “Don’t you?”
My mind races for a response, as I realize that he is partially right. And maybe, but for Harper, completely right.
“And you know what?” he continues. “There’s nothing stopping you from getting a do-over.”
I pretend we’re both talking about my job, and not a divorce, wondering how long it will be before one of us utters the word aloud. “I’m too old to change careers,” I say.
“No, you’re not,” he says. “Isn’t acting like riding a bike? Surely it’s all still there….Just…go to some auditions….”
I swallow, a huge lump in my throat. “It’s not that easy,” I say. “And besides. We can’t leave Atlanta.”
“Yes, you can,” he says. “You can do anything you want to do, Meredith.”
I turn away from him, looking out the window over the kitchen sink, just like in Harper’s drawing, and I feel myself tremble with the tantalizing, terrifying thought that he might be right.
chapter nineteen
JOSIE
On Monday morning, I take a giant leap forward and call the office of Dr. Susan Lazarus. According to my research, Dr. Lazarus is the leading fertility specialist in Atlanta, known for both in vitro fertilization and intrauterine insemination. My heart sinks when her receptionist briskly informs me that her first available appointment is nearly two months away. I tell her that I’ll take it, then ask if she can please put me on a waiting list.
“If there’s any cancellation…I’ll drop everything and come in at a moment’s notice. I’m pushing forty and a little bit panicked here….”
“I feel you,” she says with a little chuckle, dropping her professional persona. “I turn forty next week. Ugh.”
“Do you have kids?” I ask.
“Yes. Ten-month twins, thanks to Dr. Lazarus.”
“Wow. Congrats,” I say, feeling bolstered by the anecdote, though the mere thought that I could somehow end up with twins fills me with pure terror. “Boys or girls?”
“One of each,” she says.
I congratulate her again as she suddenly informs me that I’m in luck, she just noticed a cancellation on the calendar for this coming Friday at eleven, confirming my belief that sometimes small talk can really pay off.
“I’ll take it,” I say.
—
I GIVE SYDNEY my entire update at recess that day, the two of us taking our usual supervisory spots on a bench overlooking the playground. As I watch Edie hanging upside down on the monkey bars, her arms dangling, her tiny torso swinging, and her face turning red, I fill Sydney in on Pete, as well as my upcoming appointment with Dr. Lazarus.
“I’m so proud of you, Josie,” she says, turning to give me a sideways hug. “And a little jealous.”
“Hey, why don’t you do it with me?” I say excitedly.
She laughs. “Matching cars and kids?”
“I’m serious! Would you ever consider it?” I ask, as I hear Meredith scoffing in my head, proffering my suggestion as further proof that I’m not taking motherhood seriously.
Sydney shakes her head and gives me an adamant, animated hell no. “I’m seriously impressed that you’re doing this…but personally? If I had to choose just one, I’d rather have a husband than a baby. But definitely in that order.”
I nod, thinking that although I want both, too, the baby part of the equation has always been more important to me—at least since Will and I broke up. And if I’m honest, I think I might have even felt that way then. I loved him, yes, but he also felt like a prerequisite for motherhood. The means to an end.
She gives me a thoughtful look, then says, “Are you scared?”
“A little,” I say. “Mostly just about logistics.”
She murmurs her agreement, then asks if I will still live with Gabe or move into my own place.
I frown and tell her I haven’t figured that out yet, as I hear Meredith’s voice again, mumbling that this is par for the course.
“Gabe knows your overall plan, though? That you want to have a baby?”
I nod and say of course, Gabe knows everything.
“And?” she asks. “What does he think?”
“He’s supportive….Unlike my sister, who is
her usual judgmental self.” I pause, then say, “But he’s not really down with the idea of Pete as my donor.”
Sydney raises her eyebrows. “That’s ’cause he’s jealous.”
“Stop it right there,” I say, knowing exactly what she’s getting at. “How many times do I have to tell you men and women can be friends?”
She smirks. “Yeah. That’s what Harry and Sally said.”
“I’m not Sally,” I say.
“Maybe not. But he’s definitely Harry,” she says.
“No, he’s not, Syd….Didn’t I tell you about his new girlfriend?”
“Yeah, yeah. Whatever,” she says, rolling her eyes.
“I’m serious….He really likes her.”
“Yeah. But only because he can’t have you.”
I shake my head. “No. His objection to Pete is purely a practical one. He thinks I should use an anonymous donor rather than someone I know. He’s worried that it would get too…weird. Messy.”
“And you say…?”
“I say I’ll take that chance. Pete’s smart, attractive, and really sweet. It just feels…right.”
“Oh, reeally, now?” she says, her voice dripping with innuendo of the sexual kind.
“The right donor,” I say. “I have no interest in dating him, either.”
“Well, then,” she says, sitting up straighter. “Introduce us.”
I laugh and say not a chance.
“Why not? He could be my soul mate. You’d deprive me of that?”
“Yes. Because that would be too weird,” I say, feeling oddly possessive, if not of Pete, then at least of his sperm.
—
THAT EVENING, I find Gabe out back, grilling three hot dogs while listening to Bob Marley.
“Hey,” I say, leaning against the deck.
“What’s up?” he says, without looking my way.
“Is Leslie coming for dinner?”
He shakes his head. “Nope. And she’s a vegetarian. Remember?”
“Oh, right. How could I forget?” I say, only a little snidely.
He either misses or ignores my tone, and asks if I’m hungry. “I threw an extra dog on just in case.”
“Sure. Thanks,” I say, then ask about his day. Gabe’s worked for the same company for nearly a decade, but I’m still not exactly sure what he does for a living—other than that it involves graphic design, computers, and a lot of high-maintenance clients.
