But she didn’t put her mouth to it yet. She wanted to take in the sight of Lori getting ready to fuck her. She saw her put on the leather panty-shaped straps and insert the shortest side of he strap-on into her own pussy. Sally felt eager to know how that felt like. But Lori walked up behind her, and held the other end close to her cunt.
“Ready when you are,” Lori said.
Only then did Sally take Todd’s cock into her mouth. She let herself taste his salty flavor first before fully committing to the blowjob. She didn’t know how hard Lori was going to fuck her, and the last thing she wanted was to bite Todd’s cock off from being startled by a strong strap-on stroke.
But Lori went in smoothly, and Sally felt herself ease her in. Her pussy was pretty wet, so there was no lube required. Lori’s thrusts were gentle at first, and Sally found herself taking Todd in and out of her mouth at the same pace. As the thrusts increased speed, so did Sally’s sucking.
The strap-on itself felt pretty great. No, it wasn’t as good as a real live cock (like the one she could taste right then, and God, the feeling of the shaft passing her lips and the precum coating her tongue was even better than usual), but it was certainly better than a dildo. Because there was someone else attached to it, someone she cared deeply about. Someone she once loved. And who was clearly getting off on it too.
“Oh, God,” said Lori. “This is so awesome. I wish this was my real cock, I want to feel your pussy tighten around me so much!”
“You fuck me so good,” Sally said. “Don’t stop. Just fuck me, keep fucking me!”
“God, you two are driving me—Ghh—”
Todd’s cock twitched in Sally’s mouth. She felt his whole body tighten. He was coming. For a moment she feared he was going to lose control and ejaculate, so she stopped the blowjob. She wanted him to enjoy himself, and them, for a while yet. So the last thing she needed was for him to get spent already.
“Did he do it?” Lori stopped moving, her fake cock still inside Sally. “Did he come or not?”
Sally took Todd’s cock from her mouth while his whole body relaxed into the bed, and proudly showed it to her friend.
“He came,” she said. “But there’s no come. See?”
“Oh, wow. He really does it. That is amazing.”
“Yeah…”
“Want me to do it to you?” Todd said, apparently recovered from his dry orgasm.
Lori grinned, and pulled out of Sally, much to her dismay.
“Yeah. Yeah, I do. But not in my cunt.”
“Aw, but I was blowing him…” Sally lamented. Lori hugged her from behind.
“Sorry, lover, but we have other stuff to do. Don’t worry, you’ll still have fun. Go on, take your stud’s place in bed. I’m sure he left it warm for you.”
Todd left the bed eagerly, his cock still as stiff as ever. Sally took his place as instructed, but she felt reluctant. She really was enjoying giving that blowjob. Also, getting fucked.
Fortunately, as soon as Sally got on the bed, Lori climbed on top of her, so at least one of the two things weren’t over yet.
“So what do you want me to do?” Todd asked as Lori positioned herself to fuck Sally missionary style.
“I want you to go to that drawer, take out the lube, and lube yourself up as thoroughly as you can.” She looked at Sally and winked. “And then I want you to do the same to my ass.”
“Ohhh.” Todd was clearly enjoying the plan.
“Do you need further instructions, Mr. Fireman?”
“No ma’am,” he answered, already spreading lube all over his erection.
Lori turned to Sally again. “We’re gonna have to take it slow now, lover. I’m gonna let your guy set the pace, so this’ll take a bit to get going.”
“I like it slow too,” Sally said.
“I know you do.” They kissed, but were interrupted by Todd.
“Tell me if I hurt you, ok?”
“No, I’m just going to bite my lips and suffer in silence. Of course, I’ll tell you, fireman. Don’t worry, just do your thing.”
He shrugged, applied lube to his fingers, and proceeded to place the tip of his index finger on Lori’s anus, and then pushed it in slowly.
“Ooooh, God. that feels nice,” she said. Be careful, though, it’s been a while since anyone’s been in there.”
“How long is a while?” asked Sally.
“At least two weeks.”
Todd and Sally laughed. And then they fell silent. The only sounds in the room were the soft squelching of Todd’s fingers lubing up Lori’s asshole. He took his time and did it with care. His index finger went in very slowly. When it was completely in, he spread the lube around, being careful not to move it too much yet. He repeated the procedure a couple of times. Only when he felt her less tight did he start to move the finger in and out gradually faster.
Lori cooed, her eyes closed.
“He’s doing a good job?” Sally asked.
“He’s doing an amazing job. If he’s as good with his cock as he is with his finger, my butt is in for a treat.”
“I aim to please,” Todd said.
“Then it’s time to aim it in and please me.”
Todd grabbed his hard cock, put its tip up against Lori’s asshole, and stopped.
“You ready?”
“Just about.” Lori mirrored Todd’s move by putting the head of her strap-on up against Sally’s pussy. “Are you ready?”
Sally nodded vigorously.
“Yeah. Yeah, I am.”
Lori kissed her, and then penetrated her. Seeing it, Todd entered her asshole a moment later. All three of them moaned with pleasure, their sounds and sensations merging.
Todd moved himself in and out of Lori’s ass, and she followed him, fucking Sally at the same exact speed.
Sally’s whole body was alight. She wanted to scream and laugh, and hell, she even wanted to sing. This was all beyond her wildest dreams. The two people she loved the most were sharing her, and sharing themselves with each other. And it was amazing for all of them.
If Sally ever had a better moment in her life, she couldn’t remember it. Then again, in her current state, she couldn’t remember much of anything.
Todd’s thrusts were increasing by the second. Lori matched him with her own all the way. From what Sally felt in her pussy, she was starting to worry if Todd wasn’t hurting Lori’s butt.
“Are you okay? Is he being too rough on you, honey?”
“Okay? God… This is… This is… This is all I ever wanted, Sally. This is you and me, happy.” She looked over her shoulder, and grinned at Todd. “And the more the merrier, stud.”
“Oh yeah…” he said, not breaking stride for a moment.
Then Lori broke their synch, fucking Sally harder. The strap-on hit her on her spot just right. Waves of pleasure flowed within her. She managed to open her eyes, and the look on Lori’s face told her she was feeling the same.
Todd tried to keep up, and in response Lori pumped into Sally even harder. Sally had no idea how Lori’s ass could take it, but Todd kept catching up to her thrusting speed. Sally had no idea, true, but she couldn’t be happier about it, because she never wanted this to end. Never never nev—
The feeling took her by surprise. The pleasure was intense, but she didn’t feel the heat rising up inside her first like she always did. Instead, this time she felt an explosion, a warm energy taking over her body, sending her into convulsions and flooding her with delight.
And to her surprise, Lori was convulsing too.
“Ah, jeez!” Lori shouted. “Yeah! Yes! Fuck yes…”
Sally couldn’t shout anything. The orgasm was still reverberating inside her, and she could barely keep her eyes open.
Then two thrusts later, it was Todd’s turn. He tipped forward as he grunted, and Sally was afraid he was going to fall over. Lori must’ve felt it, and moving to the side she took him out of her, but she moved too fast and lost balance. And without Lori there, Todd found his cente
r of gravity shifting too suddenly and mid-orgasm.
They all collapsed into each other. Sally was the first to laugh. The others joined in soon after. They hugged each other, with Sally in the middle, and just laid there catching their breaths. The only one who seemed able to move was Lori, who wriggled her strap-on off, but even her just dropped it to the side and then laid there.
“Wow,” said Todd. “That was amazing.”
“’Was’?” Sally said.
“Well, yeah. You want more?”
“Yes, honey. I do.”
Lori had her mischievous grin on, but said nothing.
“Okay, well, give me a moment to recover, I’ll—”
“No no. Honey. Remember our deal?”
“Yes.”
“Remember what I said I was going to do?”
Todd looked both puzzled and worried.
“You said you were going to ask me to do something for you. A fantasy.”
“Yeah. And I’m going to ask you now. Are you ready?”
“Shoot.”
“I want to fuck you.”
“That’s what I was thinking.”
Sally put her hand on his cheek. “No, honey. I want to fuck you. Like Lori fucked me.”
“Oh. Oh!” Todd jumped back with a jolt, and Lori couldn’t keep herself from laughing.
“Sorry. I’m sorry, I’m keeping out of this part, I just… I’m sorry.”
“It’s okay,” said Todd, visibly perturbed. “Honey… Are you sure you want this?”
“Yes, I’m sure. Why wouldn’t I be?”
“Well… I don’t know, I mean, this is something that… Well…”
“I think the question here, stud,” said Lori finally, “is are you man enough to keep your promise.”
Todd looked from Lori to Sally and back again.
“She’s a bit blunt, Todd, but yeah. Will you do this for me? I’ve had this image in my head of me fucking a man in the ass ever since I was a young girl. And I gotta tell you, very few things turn me on more. I’ve just never had the guts to tell you because I always thought you’d say no, or that I was crazy, or something.” She took his hands in hers, and spoke softly. “I won’t hold you to the promise. I think tonight was pretty great for you, but to me it was amazing, and I don’t want anything to spoil it, I really don’t. But I do have to ask. Will you be able to do this for me? Even if it’s not today?”
Todd sighed. He looked exactly the same as when Sally told him about her and Lori.
“Yeah. We can try it. We’ll try it tonight, why not.” Sally was so giddy she actually clapped.
“Way to go, stud,” Lori said. “I knew you wouldn’t disappoint us.”
“Yeah.” Todd let out another sigh, more resigned than anxious. To Sally’s surprise, he turned to Lori, not to her. “Okay, how do we do this?”
“Todd, it’s butt fucking. Man or woman, strap-on or cock, if you don’t do it the same, meaning very lubed up and very carefully, then you’re doing it wrong. That’s basically it.”
“Okay.” He turned to Sally then. “So how do you want me? Where?”
“Well… I don’t know, bend over the bed?”
“No, no,” Lori said. “That won’t work. You’re smaller than him, you couldn’t fuck his ass even on your toes. Todd, lie face down on the bed, please.”
He complied.
“Now lift your ass just a bit, ok?”
Todd did so, and Lori placed both head pillows under his belly, leaving him in a comfortable position but with his ass in the air, his butthole exposed.
“Oh God, this is looking awesome,” Sally said.
“Now it’s your turn,” said Sally. “Get in there and lube him up.”
Sally squeezed some lube onto Todd’s buttcrack, and with her finger tried to insert it into his hole rim. But despite the relative thinness of her fingers, she found she couldn’t insert them.
“Okay, I’m having a little trouble here,” she said.
“Sorry…” He sounded almost embarrassed.
“I have an idea,” said Lori. “Give me a towel from that closet.”
Sally handed her a hand towel, which she used to wipe Todd’s buttcrack of all lube.
“Won’t it be harder that way?”
“Yeah, but I don’t like the taste of lube.”
Todd looked over his shoulder. “What do you mean you don’t—Ohhhhhhhh!”
Lori’s tongue connected with his rim. She licked around his asshole, and he squirmed.
“Honey, are you okay?” asked Sally while she put on Lori’s discarded strap-on. The feeling of the smaller end inside her was strange, but it was good, and as soon as she put it on, she knew it would be very good later.
“Oh. Oh, yeah. This is nice. Very nice, actually.”
“You like that, stud? Never been rimmed before?”
“Nope. First time.”
Lori threw Sally a look of mock anger.
“Naughty Sally. Seems you aren’t naughty enough with our big guy here.”
“I’ll make it up to him,” Sally said.
“I think you won’t have to wait long.” Lori pressed her finger against the entrance of Todd’s asshole, and the tip went in. He moaned.
“Here’s a tip for both of you. Nothing relaxes more than tongue.”
“Duly noted,” said Sally, who proceeded to give Todd a few licks more. His moans were getting louder.
Lori handed Sally the lube bottle, and once again she squirted it onto Todd’s ass. This time, however, when she tried lubing him inside, her finger went in much easier.
“Honey, tell me if I hurt you, okay?” she said as she spread the lube inside his asshole.
“Yeah. Yeah… Don’t worry, it’s, it’s good.”
“You’re enjoying it?”
“Yeah, I am. That was the point, right?”
“Oh yeah,” she said, her last doubts gone.
“Try to put in the middle finger too, but do it slowly,” Lori told her. “Your fingers are thin, and he needs to be looser to take in the strap-on.”
Sally did so, and found that her middle finger met with little resistance. Todd moved like he wanted to fuck the pillow under him, which Sally took as a sign of encouragement.
“Okay. Are you ready, honey?”
“I think so…”
“Yeah, he’s ready.” Lori lubed up the strap-on, and then slapped Sally’s ass. “Go get him, lover.”
Sally placed herself in buttfucking position. She was so turned on she could barely steady herself up, but Lori held her by the arms.
“You can do this,” Lori said. “It’ll be okay.”
Sally nodded, and put the tip of the strap-on against his butthole. The pressure was minimal, but it was enough to feel the other end of the strap-on inside her already stimulating her.
She took in the sight of the man of her life exposed in front of her. Waiting to be fucked by her.
That was the sexiest thing Sally had ever seen.
She pushed in.
He grunted. She didn’t go far, only the tip went in. But it was more than he was used to, and no matter how lubed up he was, she knew it wouldn’t be comfortable right off the bat.
“Slow. Take it slow, lover.” Lori let go of her. Sally steadied herself on Todd’s hips, and moved forward very slowly, pushing the strap-on both into him and into her.
They moaned at the same time. Sally giggled.
She pushed again, and met with less resistance. Again. More resistance, but still doable.
She kept going in, all the while checking to see how he was doing, until the whole strap-on was inside his ass.
“Oh my God, stud,” said Lori. “You actually took it all in. Like a man.”
“Yeah,” he said, with more than a hint of irony. “I’m really proud of myself.”
“Oh, that one deserves some punishment. Sally… do your thing.”
Faster than she’d gone in, Sally pulled out. He moaned, the same moan he’d given when Lori r
immed him. Then Sally went in again, and found that it was much easier to penetrate him all the way. Then out again, then in, then out.
Pretty soon she was full-on fucking him in the ass.
Sally was loving it. The mere act was as much a turn-on as she dreamed. And fucking herself with the double-sided strap-on as she did it was the cherry on top. The strap-on was better than some of her old lovers!
For his part, Todd seemed to be taking it well. More than well, actually. His moans had dropped any hint of pain and discomfort. He was enjoying it. Hell, Sally could almost swear he was loving it.
She looked at Lori. Sally expected to find her touching herself, but instead Lori was just watching, almost clinically.
“Okay, stop.” That was the last thing Sally expected Lori to say.
“What? What’s the matter?” She didn’t expect Todd to sound so disappointed either.
“I feel like I’m being left out here. I know this is your thing, it’s something between the two of you. But I think I can make it better for both of you, and have some fun in the process as well.”
Sally smiled, and pulled herself out of Todd. “I’m open to anything. You know that.”
“I’m open too,” said Todd. “But I think I’m closing up.”
Lori laughed. “Don’t worry, we won’t let you. Turn around, stud.”
Taking the pillows from under himself, Todd did as Lori told him.
“Okay, good. Now get in the missionary position, but spread wide and try to scoot your asshole a bit upwards. Can you do that?”
Todd smiled, and then did it.
“Now you can fuck him again, lover. Just like he fucks you.”
Sally placed herself in position, and after lubing up her strap-on, entered his ass again. He had closed up a bit, but not a lot, and nothing that a couple of gentle thrusts couldn’t solve.
Lori let them get into it. They were both clearly enjoying it.
“How about you?” Sally managed to say between moans.
“I’m going to do this.”
Taking advantage of Sally not being completely on top of Todd, Lori put her head between both of their bodies, and took Todd’s hard cock into her mouth.
Sally's Surprises Page 3
