“We’re good?”
“Of course we are.”
He flashes me a wide smile. “Hunter’s idea to unwind in the hot pool is a brilliant one, but I thought we might add a fun element to up the stakes.”
“What do you mean?”
“Yeah, buddy, what are you talking about?”
“Since one of us will have the honor of claiming Allison’s ass tonight, I thought that instead of tossing a coin, we might let her decide who she wants. But of course, it wouldn’t be nearly as thrilling for her to pick one of us as it would be for one of us to win the honors.”
“Oh.” I blush. It’s true the steam is rising above the water inside the pool, but I’d be fooling myself if I blamed the temperature for the warmth against my cheeks.
“You almost sound surprised,” he teases. “You didn’t think we had forgotten? Yesterday was a warm-up. Tonight you’ll discover what it’s like to be dominated by two men who worship you.” Jake’s gaze is so intense I bring the back of my hand up and wipe a few pearls of sweat running down my forehand.
“You want us to duel over who takes her virginity?”
“You’re funny, Hunter. I have something a little more civilized in mind,” he says, pulling a blindfold from the pocket of his terrycloth robe.
Oh, my God. First he shackles me with a rope in a remote barn and now he wants to blindfold me? Is there no end to this man’s kinkiness?
“I don’t know what you have in mind, but what’s dangling from your hands is making me nervous.”
“There’s nothing to be worried about,” Jake responds, taking a few steps towards me.
“If we’re going to blindfold her, should I run out and grab a collar or handcuffs?”
“Hunter,” I say, scandalized.
“Well, if Jake wants us to battle it out, I want to make sure I have a chance of winning.” Hunter grins from ear to ear.
“Ali has already been with both of us separately and we shared her last night. Let’s see how well she knows her lovers.”
My lovers? I like the sound of that.
“I still don’t follow.” Hunter is as perplexed as I am.
“Yeah, I don’t think it’s fair for me to have to choose between the two of you blindfolded.” I don’t know what he has in mind, but knowing Jake his naughty experiment will leave me panting.
“Once you can no longer see, your other senses will kick in. The more you allow your senses to guide you, the more this game will turn you on… and it should do the same to us as well.”
“My cock’s already fully aroused.” Hunter is grabbing his crotch with a devilish smile.
I doubt either of them will spare me tonight.
“Hold your horses. I need to lay down some ground rules.”
“Good idea. I can already see Hunter cheating.” I wink.
“How can you assume I’d cheat to have a chance at fucking your ass?” Hunter’s fake innocence is endearing, but I know first-hand the kind of passion this man is capable of.
“Here’s how it’s going to work. We’re all going to get into the pool and I’m going to blindfold Ali. Ali, your job is to enjoy the warmth of the water and to be a willing participant in my little game. You need to guess which one of us is touching you. The one you recognize by touch the most often is the one who will have the honor of claiming your ass.”
“That sounds easy enough, I guess.”
“Oh, there’s one more thing.”
“What?” I ask nervously.
“Every time you’re right, we drink. If you’re wrong, you’ll have to take a little sip of your wine. I won’t let you get drunk, but if you can’t figure out who’s who, you’ll surely be a little tipsy by the end of this game.”
“I’m loving the idea,” Hunter cheers.
“It’s easy for you to say. You’re not the one who’s losing their virginity tonight.” I frown at him.
“You want this, don’t you?” Jake reaches out for my cheek and I press my face against his strong hand. “We’re not forcing you to do anything against your will?”
“No,” I respond without hesitation. I know what I agreed to when I accepted the butt plug Hunter bought for me. I want both men and I’m not about to run away now.
“Good,” he says holding my gaze while he pulls at the sash around my waist. “Loose the robe so I can cast my eyes over your heavenly body.” It’s not a suggestion. Jake pushes open the robe, exposing my nakedness, before I can even respond. He leans in and takes my lips with his. I close my eyes, savoring his lingering kiss, and I extend my hand behind me, calling my brown-eyed lover to join in the action.
When Hunter presses his muscular body against my ass and I realize I’m sandwiched between my guys, my clit swells and chafes against my lower lips as I anticipate both men putting their hands all over me and pleasuring me.
After a few minutes of kissing, Jake whispers close to my ear. “Come on, let’s start this game. My cock is hungry.” Hunter pulls away and lets Jake guide me to the pool.
I climb down the stairs and squat to dip my whole body into the warm and soothing water. I look up and both men are standing side by side, eating me up with their gazes, as they remove their robes, revealing the two very big cocks I’ll be riding tonight. Sweet mother of Lord have mercy. The scalding heat emanating from both of them makes the temperature of the pool seem icy. I will never be able to walk again after tonight.
Hunter jumps in first, followed by Jake, who approaches me holding the blindfold over his head to prevent it from getting wet. When he gets close enough, he pulls it down over my eyes.
“Remember, no touching,” he says, securing the blindfold so I can’t see a thing. “No cheating.” He places my left hand on the edge of the pool, forcing me to lift my boobs higher. “No talking.” He trails his finger over my lips. “No hesitating. You blurt out the first name that comes to mind.”
Once everything is pitch black around me, it hits me. How on earth am I going to tell which one of them just touched me? I thought this would be easy, but now I’m not so sure.
The water ripples, lapping around my exposed breasts, teasing them remorselessly. Without having to look, I know my nipples peek above the waterline because the contrast between the ambient air flirting with my rock-hard peaks and the warmth of the water sends shivers down my back. Thankfully the pool is shallow.
“When you said no talking, did you mean I can’t ask questions? What if—”
A pair of lips silence me. Who is it? I don’t know how, but this lover isn’t touching me anywhere but on my mouth. The touch is so delicate, I barely feel it, but it’s still incredibly sensual. Shit. A tongue brushes against my lower lip and just when I reach out to touch the face of the man taunting me, he eludes me. Damn. Whoever it is moves, licking the corner of my mouth and sending me into a passionate whirlwind. I lean forward, hoping to capture his lips, but he laughs softly before moving away.
Gosh, I haven’t got a clue who it is. “Hunter?”
One of my lovers grabs the hand that’s on the edge of the pool and places a glass in it. I take a sip. Okay, so it was Jake.
“I don’t think it’s fair. The two of you are plotting to get me tipsy and have your way with me.”
Instead of an answer, the water shifts again and I feel a body moving behind me. Focus. I breathe deeply and try to take in the cologne of the man behind me. I’m out of luck because everything around me smells like pool water and the scented candles surrounding me.
“Jesus,” I sigh.
One of them flicks my left nipple with his tongue. I raise my boobs out of the water, breathing heavily when lips, a tongue and teeth pull at my swollen nipple before moving on to the left. As much as I try, I’m still stumped and I can’t tell if it’s Jake or Hunter assaulting my boobs. I’m still convinced they’re trying to trick me and I flash back to one of our passionate interludes and for a moment I’m certain I know who’s latching at my boob, but when I whisper the name of the stud I think
is responsible for leaving my legs feeling like Jell-O, my wineglass returns.
Two for them and zero for me. I’m losing in a big way and they’ll both still be sober by the end of this. I brace myself for the next touch, fully prepared to ace it, but I lose all my resolve when a hard cock brushes against my back under the water. Not fair. “Jake?”
Both men chuckle and my wine glass returns. This time, instead of wetting my lips, I take a big gulp.
“There’s no way I can win this,” I say, aggravated, fully aware I’m breaking one of Jake’s cardinal rules. The two of them are so different, so how can I be failing so badly at this game?
A pair of hands wrap around my boobs. I know those hands. I open my mouth to blurt a name, but a finger slides against my sensitive clit. I’m about to complain about the fact Jake never said anything about both of them touching me at the same time when the man behind me grabs my hips, lifting me and placing my body against the edge of the pool.
Fuck. I reach out with both hands and I hold on tight to the towel laid out in front of me. Where did the other one go? I don’t have time to wonder because the man holding me pushes me forward, bending me over and exposing my ass to the open air. Oh, God. I’m still unable to predict their next move.
Then one of them spreads my ass cheek open with his hands and his mouth closes in, tonguing me from behind.
“Holy Christ,” I cry out, shocked. He grips me firmly, preventing me from escaping. He’s incredibly strong, but then again both of them are strapping demigods. “Holy Jesus.” The tongue sweeps me from my asshole to my eager clit, lapping ravenously. There’s no way I can tell if it’s Jake or Hunter, but who the hell cares at this point because that tongue against my pussy is threatening to make me lose my mind.
The man behind me moves away and I grunt in frustration. “No. You can’t get me all worked up and leave me like this.” I’ve barely finished protesting when he returns. I steady myself against my hands and I yank up my ass higher, but instead of a tongue, a man’s cock butts up against my slick pussy, teasing and torturing me.
“Oh.” I’m so consumed by the cock gliding against my wetness that I don’t notice when the other lover lies down on the towel I’m still clutching with both hands. He slides his long legs between my arms and fists my hair possessively. He pulls my head towards him and punishes me with an urgent kiss before pushing me along his lean, athletic body until my lips brush against his dick.
This game is getting dirtier by the minute.
“There will be no winners because you two are going to kill me tonight and neither of you will get to fuck me,” I bark.
The man in front of me pushes my head down until my lips touch his shaft as if to silence me. I stick out my tongue and I graze the tip of his cock, licking his moisture while the other man slides the tip of his shaft against my impatient clit.
“Hmmm,” I moan against the cock inside my mouth as I gyrate my hips to encourage whoever is behind me to never stop what he’s doing.
Jake was right. The fact that I can’t tell who’s doing what to me heightens my arousal to no end.
Both of them grunt at the same time and it drives me fucking insane. Since I’ve already broken the rules by talking, I reach for the man in front of me and caress his thighs, hoping to be able to put a face to the body. When it becomes clear I’m enjoying this moment way too much to care about naming the man fucking my mouth, I grab the base of his cock while I bob my head up and down along his length, matching the rhythm of the man now plunging his tongue in and out of my ass. I raise my head, still gripping the big cock in front of me, and I let out a raw, throaty moan when the man behind me plunges two fingers inside my pussy while still lapping at my ass.
“Aaaah.” This game is maddening.
Frustrated by being unable to see the two guys assaulting my body in the sweetest possible way, I rip the blindfold off and fling it in the water. I blink a few times at the man in front of me and I gasp.
“Hunter?”
“Damn, Allison, why did you have to stop sucking my cock? I’m nearly there. Come on, baby, wrap your pouty lips around me again,” he says, yanking his hips up towards my mouth, holding his dick as an offering. His deep brown eyes are heavy-lidded and provocative. I can read the desperation in them.
I turn to the lover behind me, but I know exactly who it is before I meet his dangerously seductive blue eyes.
“Jake?”
He lifts his head and smiles without removing the fingers inside my pussy. “Who else did you expect?”
“Are you going to be the one to claim me?” I’m surprised by my own forwardness. I realize I willingly gave myself to him with my question.
“Why don’t we take this to Hunter’s place? His house is the closest to the cabin. We can continue what we started in a much more comfortable setting. Your first time shouldn’t be in a pool. We should take you on a bed.”
“You didn’t answer my question,” I press boldly.
“No, I didn’t,” he says, holding my gaze. “Hunter and I decided his girth might be too much to handle for your first time, so I’ll do the honors.” He stands up behind me and presses his cock against my back as he grabs hold of my boobs. I close my eyes, feeling his hands all over me as I grind my bum into him.
“I’ll take you from the front while Jake introduces you to the dark side, but don’t worry, we have all night… there’s plenty of time for you to get accustomed to my size.” My eyes pop open when Hunter speaks and I can tell from his cocky grin my two lover boys decided a long time ago who was going to take my virginity. I never had any say in the matter and this little naughty game was purely for their enjoyment—and mine.
“Buddy, help her out of the pool.” Jake has barely finished his sentence before Hunter stands up and pulls me out of the water. Once my feet are firmly planted on the ground, he picks me up and flings me over his shoulder.
I squeal with delight. In their arms, I’m as light as a feather. “What are you doing?”
“You heard the man. He said we needed to finish you off at my place.” Hunter chuckles and slaps my ass for good measure.
CHAPTER FOUR
HUNTER
Luckily my house is only a few steps away from the cabin and all three of us are able to make the short journey butt naked without having to worry about being accused of indecent exposure. I climb the stairs all the way to my bedroom, kick open the door with a carnal grunt and turn on the lights. I walk decisively to my bed and throw the sexy blonde’s body against my mattress, impatient to ravish her.
I take a few steps backward to admire Allison’s glistening body under the soft lights. When she falls backward, her long hair fans out like a crown around her face. Her arms are raised above her head, letting us appreciate her best assets. Her heavy tits fall toward the sides of her exquisite body and the only thing I want to do is reach down and cup them. In a shy attempt to conceal her nakedness from our eyes, she folds her legs closer to her body and plants her feet against the mattress as she wiggles her painted toes. She’s absolutely beautiful. It doesn’t take long for Jake to come join me and we stand shoulder to shoulder looking at the woman we’re about to brand.
“Fuck, your beautiful curves are glimmering under these dim lights.” I’m unable to peel my eyes away from her.
“Hunter is right, you’re absolutely glowing, Ali.”
“I’m going to enjoy watching you get taken by both of us, Allison.” My thick and swollen cock jerks when she bites her bottom lip, bouncing her eyes from my hungry dick to Jake’s.
“And I’m going to take a lot of pleasure from seeing you climax with both our cocks buried deep inside you while you scream your head off.”
“I want this, I really do, but there’s a part of me that’s scared shitless because I’ve never had two men inside me at the same time.” Allison blows out a tense breath and I can tell she’s still a bit nervous, although we’ve been preparing her for this moment for a few days now.
&n
bsp; “Don’t worry, we’ll be very gentle and we’ll use a lot of lube.”
“Promise?”
“Remember what we’ve said to you from the beginning. This is supposed to be as enjoyable for you as it is for us.”
She swallows and nods jerkily as she soaks in Jake’s words.
“I’ll prepare your ass while Hunter has a little fun with you. We’ll make sure to ease you into it so you don’t have to worry about a thing.”
“O-okay.”
Jake walks to my night table and grabs the bottle of lube and a couple condoms from the box I pulled out before going to get Allison to take her to the cabin. The truth is, we’ve both been planning this moment with a great deal of anticipation. My best friend strides back towards me with a huge grin on his face as he throws a packet my way, which I catch with one hand. Greedy bastard. I already know he’s going to come like an animal up her ass while I pump her pussy hard. This is a night our gorgeous little blonde is unlikely to forget for a very long time.
Jake climbs onto the mattress next to Allison before leaning in and kissing her lips. I watch as he licks her face until he reaches her earlobe, which he sucks into his mouth until she squeals with contentment. As much as Jake loves watching me take Allison as he masturbates, I derive as much pleasure if not more from watching her succumb to him. I fist my cock and choke it, stroking up and down as my friend feasts on her supple skin. He nibbles along her neck until sweet shivers travel through her body. When he draws away, Allison reaches out for him, already begging for more.
“I’m not going too far, baby, but I can’t wait any longer. I need to find out how tight you are,” he growls. “Get on all fours, Ali.”
She sucks in a breath, glancing in my direction for support, but she quickly realizes I’m as eager as Jake is when she sees me taking pleasure. She smiles at me and obeys, turning her body around until her round ass is pointing at me.
Christ, how sinful. The sight of her pussy and asshole only adds to my enjoyment and I stroke my cock harder, grunting with every thrust. Jake turns in my direction and casts me a complicit stare before positioning himself right behind Allison’s rear, ready to claim her. His half grin lets me know he sympathizes with me and he understands it’s impossible for me to contain myself any longer.
Craving More Page 3
