Renee leaned over and kissed Jesse. “There will always be jerks in the world. Let it go.” AJ set down his drink and focused on the food. “I’m starving.” They ate and chatted with others at their table. Nothing bad happened. AJ felt foolish for building it up in his mind, but Steve certainly had tried to rip him down in front of everyone.
As the dancing started, a tall, slightly familiar-looking woman with glasses approached and smiled at Jesse.
“How about a dance for your old prom date?” she asked.
Jesse hugged her. “Sure, but I better dance with him first, or I’ll never hear the end of it.” Jesse pointed to AJ.
“Of course, how silly of me. You just did that whole big speech, and here I am trying to steal your date. Go on, I’ll catch up with Renee.” Linda nodded.
AJ and Jess joined the other couples on the floor and barely got a few looks.
“Okay?” Jesse asked.
AJ nodded. “We’ve danced together plenty. That prom date of yours is interesting.”
“Renee set that up, as friends. Mom paid; she wanted the picture. Linda didn’t have a boyfriend, and neither did I. She’s actually entertaining.”
“A friend of Renee’s? Probably trying to help us out by adding another girl to the mix and diffusing the three-way rumors.” AJ nodded.
“That stuff is no one’s business. We don’t ever have to share that in public.” Suddenly, the women were tapping them on the shoulder and demanding to cut in. Jesse danced with Linda, and AJ led Renee.
“Your friend is sweet.” AJ smiled.
“She is. Don’t worry; she won’t steal your man. Are you sorry you came to the reunion?” she asked.
“Hell no. It’s good to get it all out.” He held her close.
“We get much closer, and you’ll be in the dress.” She took a half-step back.
“You don’t care what people think,” he reminded her.
“No, but it’s a weekend of fun. You don’t need to explain or justify that to anyone.” She nodded at Jesse who was coming toward them. “I think you’re trading girls.” AJ didn’t argue and danced with Linda. She was light on her feet, if a bit timid; she kept their space very appropriate.
“You were inspiring up there. Jesse felt like a million bucks.” She smiled. “Isn’t it funny how things change, but not really?”
“Meaning?” AJ shrugged.
“Well, in high school I was good friends with Renee and she was popular and pretty. She and Jesse were fast friends, and some people thought they were dating, but I knew the truth.
Then the summer before our junior year in high school, she shocked me when she and Jesse had sex. She’s still full of surprises.” Linda took a step closer, relaxing a bit.
It was AJ’s turn to tense. “Jesse and Renee? You’re saying they had sex in high school?”
“Well, yes. You knew that. Right.” Her face went from happy to confused. “Right? I mean, you’ve been dating Jesse for ten years. You know everything about each other by now.”
“I thought so.” AJ forced his jaw to relax. He scanned the dance floor for Jesse and Renee.
“Oh God, you didn’t know. I’m so sorry. I didn’t mean to…” She stepped back from the dance.
“It’s okay. Not your fault. Excuse me.” He walked way to find Jesse talking with an ex-girlfriend of AJ’s from sophomore year.
“Hi, AJ. I knew there was something special about you. You really cared.” She smiled at him.
“Hello, Mary. Thanks, I think. How are you?” He tried to be polite as he seethed with a secret.
“Fine. Married with twins. Boys. I used to be in real estate, but when the market fell apart in Vegas, I just went to being a stay-at-home mommy.”
“It’s good to have options.” He turned to Jesse. “I’m going up to the room. I forgot something. Do you have the key?”
Jesse handed it over. “You okay?”
“Sure. Just need some aspirin.” AJ faked a smile, not ready to confront Jesse on this matter yet. But once they were alone, they’d have to talk it out. “Nice to see you again, Mary.”
“You, too! I have pictures.” She grabbed her phone.
AJ didn’t wait. He headed for the bank elevators. Aspirin, a drink and a reality check about his relationship were in order. Adding Renee to the mix? No wonder Jesse had agreed so fast. What was AJ thinking?
Chapter Seven
Jesse was tired of chasing AJ at this reunion, but something was wrong. “Renee?” AJ
asked in the elevator.
“I thought you’d be happy. Relieved she was the only girl.” Jesse’s only regret remained that he hadn’t told AJ about it. But Jesse had thought AJ would laugh, that it’d all come full circle and that they’d gotten what they all wanted.
“I don’t know what to think. It makes those pictures you took even weirder. You didn’t sleep with her while I was dating her?” AJ asked as the doors opened.
People milled in, and Jesse kept quiet until they were safely in their hotel room. “No, of course not. We never screwed around while you were dating. It was that one time. One.”
“Details,” AJ prompted.
Jesse sat on the bed. “It’s nothing impressive. I was struggling with my sexuality, men or women. Renee didn’t want to go into junior year as a virgin. I wanted to see what a girl was like.
So we tried it on her sixteenth birthday.”
“How was it?” AJ sat next to him on the made-up bed.
“We were sixteen and virgins. How good could it be? I didn’t last very long. She was pretty tight. The oral we tried afterward worked much better. I’d only been fooling around with a couple of guys at that point so nothing to compete with you.” Jesse nudged.
“It’s not a competition. We both had partners before each other, but you never told me it was Renee.” AJ looked Jesse in the eye. “When we started dating, you never thought to mention it?”
Jesse saw the hurt in AJ’s furrowed brow. “I’m sorry. No, I never thought about it. It was one foolish night between friends. She didn’t want to regret her first time. We trusted each other, so it wouldn’t have been embarrassing if it hadn’t gone perfectly. We never tried it again. I was deep into a guy, and that worked.” How could he make AJ understand? “She was the only girl I ever wanted.”
“So that’s why you were okay when I suggested her?” AJ asked.
Jesse shrugged. “Sure. No one else would fit. I loved her, and that never changed. She let me be me. I fell for you in high school and after. Hard. I’m sorry I didn’t tell you about all my sexual history, but I wanted you, to show you how good it could be. I was your first guy; lots of pressure.” He kissed AJ’s tense mouth.
“Pressure. You were an expert. My one and only man ever. I’ve slept with more girls than guys.” AJ’s face contorted into an amused smile with a dose of confusion.
“But none of those girls lasted ten years. That long and you’re still addicted to me.” Jesse kissed AJ’s cheek gently, trying to diffuse the tension and replace it with affection.
“And when we talked about the threesome and trying to seduce and keep her, you didn’t want to share the truth then?” AJ punched Jesse’s chest and pinned him to the bed.
Jesse groaned, the feel of AJ’s muscles holding him down, the outline of AJ’s growing cock against his thigh, turned their tiff to foreplay. “At first, I didn’t even know if you were serious. Then you seemed nervous about it. I didn’t want to freak you out and have it all get called off.”
“You knew it would bug me,” AJ said against his neck.
“Not bug, I figured once we’d done the deed in a three-way, it’d be a funny story. We were sharing a girl we’d both screwed before. The reunion drama got in the way. And we still need to tell Renee.”
AJ adjusted the angle and thrust harder against Jesse’s cock. “She already knows she slept with you.”
“I mean about what we want with her. If you’re pissed about something that happened before we eve
n dated, imagine what she’ll think. We’ve been screwing her, and she thinks it’s just great sex, but we want more.” Jesse lifted up to meet AJ. The hottest sex was angry fight makeup sex.
“I can’t believe she doesn’t suspect anything weird.” AJ moved back and freed Jesse’s cock, sucking him off fast with the experience of ten years.
Jesse came hard. The wave of release, emotional and physical, made him tremble and pull AJ’s hair. “We’re so lucky,” he said in the afterglow.
“What?” AJ pulled out his erection and straddled Jesse’s head.
Jesse sucked in his lover’s cock fully, knowing every curve and ridge and which ones trigged AJ’s climax. Teasing and tasting AJ for a moment, Jesse squeezed his sac and let go.
AJ’s strong hand dug into Jesse’s hair. Jesse groaned, sucking and fucking until AJ came deep in Jesse’s throat.
When AJ slid down Jesse’s body so they could kiss, Jesse smiled. “We’re lucky.” AJ kissed him harder. “Hell, yes.”
“So few people have what we do. Even if Renee says no, we’re still fine. We’ll get over it. Luckier than most.” Jesse didn’t want AJ to be disappointed. Renee had always been a girl with goals. Settling down might never be her thing.
“So we’re ready to find her and tell her?” AJ zipped Jesse’s fly.
Jesse returned the favor on AJ’s pants. “Sure.” AJ grabbed his phone and texted Renee to come and join them. They got a fast text back that she’d be right there. Lying back on the bed, they waited for her. Nothing was going to happen without her now.
AJ opened the door and Renee walked in and kicked off her heels before she sat on the bed like it was a slumber party. “You guys okay?”
“We’re good. AJ found out about our time before junior year. He was a bit shocked I was your first.” Jesse shrugged.
“Oh yeah. I got to be his first girl.” She rolled onto Jesse’s chest. “Didn’t hurt much and the first time weirdness was over with then. Of course, he went running to men. But apparently, he found his way back to liking me in bed.”
AJ stretched out next to them. “You’re the only girl he ever did.”
“Oh, that’s sweet. So you two don’t do this three-way thing with other girls?” She leaned over and kissed AJ then did the same to Jesse.
AJ ran a hand over her curves and took in the view of her pressed to Jesse. Clothed or not, the chemistry still crackled between them.
“No, just for you. It’s not just sex. It’s you.” AJ didn’t exactly know how to steer the conversation to the emotional side.
“You two are so sweet. I never would’ve imagined this weekend turning out so great.”
“You made the reunion wild. Our little group is now the talk of the reunion. I’ll bet it gets in the newsletter.” AJ pinched her firm ass playfully.
She batted his hand away. “I’m not ashamed of what I do. People are too boring and afraid all the time. I fly planes with hundreds of people’s lives in my hands, and weather that can be unpredictable. If that doesn’t scare me, nothing does. It’s something to enjoy.” She wiggled on Jesse.
“And you made a stand while getting an award.” AJ tugged her skirt up. Just as he’d suspected: no panties of any kind. “I’m amazed you didn’t moon them.”
“They don’t deserve it.”
Jesse tugged her strapless dress down and massaged her breasts.
AJ took the hint, seduce her first and tell her the truth in the sexual afterglow. He dipped his fingers between her thighs and teased the tender skin.
Renee spread her legs and inched forward until Jess could satisfy her breast with his mouth. She belonged there, with them. AJ leaned in and ran his tongue along her pussy lips, flicking them until her hips lifted.
“Your boyfriend is a fucking tease,” Renee said to Jesse.
Working his tongue into her core, AJ found her wet. He smiled to himself and pressed a thumb to open her.
Renee eased up onto her knees so he had better access. Immediately, AJ took full advantage, licking her clit and pushing his other thumb to her core and opening her with both, massaging and teasing her from both sides.
Grinding, Renee pushed back. “Fuck me.”
“Sorry, babe, you’re not directing right now. Relax. But you’ll get off.” He sucked on her clit until Renee moaned in a constant need.
Her body quivered between them. AJ nipped at her clit, and her hips snapped to him, insisting on more attention.
Trailing his tongue along her inner pussy lips, he tormented the opening his thumbs held.
Renee had only grown wetter. “Like my thumbs?”
“I like your cock better. Two of them in me are better. Why is that so hard to get?” She gasped as AJ thrust three fingers deep in her, stopping only when he hit his third knuckle.
“You love two cocks, don’t you?” Jesse egged her on.
“Yes. Two mouths, two cocks. You two are a hell of a team!” She gasped in release.
AJ curled his fingers down to hit her g-spot, and her body tightened around his like a vise. “One man would never be enough for you, would it, Renee?” AJ wanted her to admit her needs first.
“No, never enough. More!” She arched her back. “How could I pick one of you?” AJ sensed her need. “We didn’t ask you to pick. Are we the best you’ve ever had?” He massaged her inner lips down to her clit with those three slick fingers.
Her body froze as though she feared he’d stop or not give her what she needed. He waited, not touching her until she answered.
“Yes, you’re the best. I love it. Make me come again, you bastards, or I’ll drag you out in the hall and ride you there.”
AJ suppressed a chuckle and rubbed hard on her clit, rotating it. It was firm and rebounded as her body jerked. He increased the pace until she trembled and shouted.
“Thank you,” she gasped for breath.
He kissed her ass. “We love you, too. And I don’t think one weekend will be enough.” AJ
sucked her juices off his fingers.
“Yeah, we’ll have to make her stay with us.” Jesse rolled over and pressed her beneath him.
“What are you two talking about?” she asked.
“You just kick back and enjoy.” The truth was about to come out. AJ wanted more of her first.
Chapter Eight
The men had pinned her, very willingly, under their weight as they each sucked and teased one of her breasts. The duel pleasure had her arching and wet. It didn’t hurt that each had a hand playing in her pussy.
AJ lifted his head. “We must be maturing to realize we might want more, might be able to handle more then go for it.”
“I guess we’re mature enough to share. I’m still waiting for you two to fulfill my fantasy of watching two men.” Renee ran her nails up their backs.
“You’ve seen us do stuff.” Jesse pinched her clit.
Renee hummed in enjoyment. “True but that’s not really watching. I want to just sit back and see you two alone. Forget I’m even here. Ignore me. Enjoy each other, and go at it for as long as you want.”
“But you’re the new flavor here.” AJ bit her nipple.
She groaned as she lifted for more. “So you get your fantasies, but I don’t get mine?”
“If you want to get into fantasy fulfillment, we’ve got a list with you in the mix,” Jesse said. “We’d need more than a weekend.”
“A lot more.” AJ smiled.
“But we can give Renee her fantasy.” Jesse got up and pulled the old heavy chair near the desk to face the bed dead center. He pulled Renee up and guided her into the chair.
“What are you doing?” she asked.
“No, you’re not here.” Jesse grabbed the scarf she’d worn and tied it around her head as a gag. “You want the fantasy.”
Renee didn’t remember a gag in her fantasy, but if it helped them forget about her, that’s what she wanted.
Jesse crawled under the desk and unplugged the phone line from the wall and the other end f
rom the phone itself. He wound the cord around her right ankle, holding it to the chair leg.
He tied her left arm to the chair as well. Unless she wanted to drag the chair with her, she was stuck.
“Watch all you want.” Jesse winked at her.
Renee moaned against the expensive scarf. They’d heated her up then set her aside. But they were giving her what she wanted, only without full use of both hands and her toys.
But when Jesse lined up with AJ for a sixty-nine, she didn’t care about anything except watching. Their muscled bodies, one leaner than the other but both so hot any girl would appreciate them, strained to hold each other as they sucked each other’s cocks.
Renee understood the appeal of gladiators. Two men willing to do anything to come out on top. Even if it wasn’t sexual then, Renee’d bet money those women had squirmed in their seats.
AJ flipped them so he was on top, and Renee found her tied hand could still reach her breast. She massaged it, trying not to rush her pleasure as the men performed for her.
Watching AJ thrust his thick member in Jesse’s mouth made Renee’s cunt tighten. Her fingers rubbed her outer pussy lips to satisfy the momentary need. She lifted her left leg, propped her foot up on the seat and spread her legs to open herself more.
They didn’t glance over, not at all. She had to give them credit; they went all the way for a fantasy.
“Mine,” AJ said.
Renee watched him suck Jesse to his base and squeeze his balls tight. Jesse trembled and released AJ’s cock to scream his lover’s name. The muscles on AJ’s throat moved, and she could tell he was swallowing Jesse’s cum.
Her clit suddenly ached to join the party in a very constant way. Tapping her clit, Renee strummed along her pussy to avoid early orgasm.
AJ and Jess kissed for a few minutes, but AJ’s long cock still strained for relief. Without any warning, AJ pushed Jesse onto his hands and knees.
Renee had a side view of the men. Licking her lips, she dipped her finger to her entrance, testing her wetness as AJ licked Jesse’s ass. She saw him slid the condom on, and he was ready.
It was true; men didn’t talk a lot. They seemed so at ease and satisfied with the silence.
Renee's High School Reunion Page 6
