by Timothy Zahn
Klnn-vavgi's tongue flicked involuntarily. "Yes. Well... yes."
"Besides, the operation wasn't a complete waste," Thrr-mezaz went on. "The warriors got into the structure and had some time to look around. Maybe Klnn-dawan-a was able to figure out what the place is used for."
"Maybe," Klnn-vavgi said doubtfully.
Thrr-mezaz looked at the row of monitors, and at the Elders popping in and out with continuous reports about the disarming. They were proud and savage warriors, these Human-Conquerors. And yet they'd just passed up a chance to slaughter a group of their enemies.
Just as, six fullarcs ago, they'd let Thrr-mezaz himself and his two climbing companions leave the area of the Human-Conqueror stronghold.
Thrr-gilag had suggested to him that there were some intriguing inconsistencies in Human-Conqueror aggressiveness-inconsistencies that might be biochemically based. Thrr-mezaz wasn't yet ready to accept any such theory, at least not without some tangible proof. But it was becoming increasingly clear to him that there was more to these Human-Conquerors than what was on the surface.
And much more that needed to be learned.
8
My external microphones note the sound of the approaching D'Accord carrosse coupe groundcar 65.55 seconds before it comes within camera range around the southwest corner of the maintenance building beside which the fueler I am encased in is parked. The glass is one-way darkened, but using an enhancement algorithm, I am able to determine that there is a single person inside. I estimate a probability of 0.87 that the occupant is a male human, and a probability of 0.54 that the occupant is Assistant Commonwealth Liaison Petr Bronski.
The D'Accord pulls to a stop beside the fueler. The occupant waits 5.93 seconds before opening the door and exiting.
My deduction was correct: it is indeed Liaison Bronski. For another 3.45 seconds he gazes at the fueler, the angle of his gaze indicating he is looking at the sealed hatchway midway up the side."Cavanagh? You in there?"
Technically, he is not speaking to me, and I am therefore under no obligation to answer. But I am curious about his presence here and know also that he may be able to provide me with the answers to questions that have troubled me since the end of the inquiry-board hearing 68.44 hours ago."This is Max, Mr. Bronski. Mr. Cavanagh is not here."
His face changes subtly. I examine my human-expression algorithms and deduce he is not surprised to find that Aric Cavanagh is not here."You know where I might find him?"
"No, Mr. Bronski. I assumed you would know that."
Again his face changes. My algorithms cannot decipher this new expression."Why would you assume that?"
"Because men apparently operating under your orders were following him when he left the Peacekeeper base."
His expression does not change."Really. How do you know that?"
There are nine procedures consistent with my programming that would allow me to answer misleadingly without lying. But as I study his expression and compare again with my algorithms, I estimate a probability of 0.80 that he already knows the answer to his question."I was listening to your conversation with your associate as you exited the Peacekeeper building after the inquiry-board hearing three days ago."
Liaison Bronski nods. I deduce from his expression that my previous conclusion was correct."Thought so. The Peacekeeper tech guys found a spurious data-line linkage keyed in about that time. I thought it was probably you."
There are many nuances contained in this statement, and I spend the next 2.09 seconds considering them. I compute a probability of 0.02 that a Commonwealth assistant liaison would have sufficient access to high-level Peacekeeper operations to have learned about a spurious data-line linkage. Accordingly, I replay the conversation immediately following the inquiry-board hearing, paying particular attention to the expressions and body movements of Admiral Rudzinski as he speaks with Liaison Bronski. This new analysis allows me to compute a probability of 0.68 that the two men are more familiar with each other than the words spoken during the conversation would suggest.
"Cat got your tongue, Max?"
"What do you wish me to say?"
He smiles, though the expression has a strong degree of cynicism incorporated into it."Never mind. I just figured a man like Lord Cavanagh would have taught you how to lie. Mind if I come up there?"
The question is unanticipated, and for 0.24 second I examine his expression. But the algorithms are of no use in helping me deduce the reason behind his request."Why?"
"I want to look around a little."His expression shifts to something that might be interpreted as shrewdness. "It'd also give us a chance to discuss various questions with a little more privacy."
Legally, the fueler is private property and I am under no obligation to allow him inside. But the implication that I may be able to learn the answers to some of my many questions is a strongly compelling one. I can always summon help should that become necessary."Very well."
It takes 1.07 minutes for me to rotate the lift cage from its storage compartment onto its track, lower it to the ground, and bring Liaison Bronski up to the hatch. It takes another 21.91 seconds for him to enter the hatch and make his way to the control room.
I review my earlier files and note that Melinda Cavanagh required 48.96 seconds to make this same trip through the fueler. Aric Cavanagh similarly required 51.03 seconds. However, Security Chief Adam Quinn required only 18.24 seconds. From this I deduce a probability of 0.87 that Liaison Bronski's background includes experience with such spacecraft, and a correlating probability of 0.95 that such experience was obtained via service with the Peacekeepers.
Inside the control room Liaison Bronski spends 4.52 seconds examining the control boards. His expression indicates he is satisfied with what he has learned from them, and he slides out a jump seat and sits down.
"How long have you been with Lord Cavanagh, Max?"
"I've been a CavTronics computer since my inception. I had not met Lord Cavanagh personally until he selected me for this mission."
"Did some extensive reprogramming on you, did he?"
"Extensive reprogramming was not required. Do you know where Aric Cavanagh is?"
He looks at my interior monitor camera for 0.72 second, his expression indicating thoughtfulness or speculation."I'm asking the questions, if you don't mind. I'm looking for a list of emergency rat holes that Lord Cavanagh might have programmed into you."
"Please define the termrat holes."
He eyes me closely, his expression suspicious."Places to go hide in case of trouble. Maybe the addresses of Lord Cavanagh's friends or business associates; maybe some of his favorite out-of-the-way vacation spots; maybe an unlisted CavTronics research plant or two. That sort of thing."
There are fifteen procedures consistent with my programming for deflecting questions I do not wish to answer. I select one of them."Why would I have been given such information?"
He smiles, his expression indicating a probability of 0.96 that the deflection procedure has not deceived him."Because you were sent out with Quinn and Cavanagh's son on a blatantly illegal rescue mission. A man like Cavanagh would have made sure there were a handy set of bolt-holes ready in case they had to bury themselves when they came back. Straight question, Max: you have a list or don't you?"
For 0.02 second I examine the list whose existence Liaison Bronski has deduced, focusing my attention on the restrictions and controls concerning disclosure of the information contained therein."I'm sorry, Assistant Liaison, but the information you seek is confidential. I cannot give it to you."
He reaches his left hand inside his coat and produces a wallet."Oh, I think you can, Max."
The wallet is at a sharp angle to my monitor camera as he opens it, but using the proper algorithm, I am able to discern that the ID in the window is his official Commonwealth diplomatic identification.
He slides the ID from beneath the window. But instead of holding it up to my monitor camera, he presses his thumb onto the upper left corner of the b
ack. After 3.56 seconds he removes his thumb and begins to carefully peel off what appears to be a thin metallic backing. The complete removal requires 4.33 seconds. He turns the ID over and holds the back up to my monitor.
Imprinted on the reverse side of the diplomatic ID is a second ID that identifies him as Brigadier Petr Bronski of NorCoord Military Intelligence.
I am not equipped for retinal or DNA confirmation, but there are two photos embedded in the ID, and I spend 0.14 second comparing them to Liaison Bronski's face. I pay particular attention to the sizes and positional spacings of eyes and mouth and to the contours of the ears, and I compute a probability of 0.9993 that it is a match. The pattern of the ID itself is on file, and it requires only 0.07 second to confirm it is genuine NorCoord Military Intelligence issue."This answers many of the questions I've had about you, Brigadier Bronski."
"I thought it might."As he speaks, he reattaches the backing to the ID, once again concealing the Military Intelligence side. "You're not to tell anyone else about me, by the way. As far as anyone else is concerned, I'm just a humble Commonwealth assistant diplomatic liaison. Got that?"
"Yes."
"Good."
He reinserts his ID into the wallet and returns it to its place inside his coat. His hand reemerges with a card, which he inserts into the transfer slot on the secondary control board."Right. Let's have the list."
I choose another deflection procedure."What use would you have for the list now? Aric Cavanagh and Security Chief Quinn chose not to utilize any of them but instead came directly here to Edo."
His expression changes subtly."Theydid look at the list, then?"
"I did not intend that choice of words."
"Answer the question, Max. Did the Cavanaghs see the list or didn't they?"
I spend 0.17 second examining the laws and regulations concerning questioning by governmental officials. Unfortunately, the various laws concerning self-incrimination and privacy do not seem to have been properly extended to parasentient computer systems. Neither have penalties for refusing to speak, however. Nevertheless, I compute a probability of 0.92 that answering the question would merely confirm what Brigadier Bronski has already concluded."Aric Cavanagh, Commander Pheylan Cavanagh, and Security Chief Quinn spent 16.55 minutes on the voyage home examining the list. As I said, they chose not to go to any of the locations."
Brigadier Bronski makes a grunting noise in the back of his throat."That's not the point. The point is that they know what was on it."His eyebrow lifts 2.1 millimeters. "Maybe even made copies for future reference?"
Again I compute that equivocation would gain nothing."Aric Cavanagh made a copy. Commander Pheylan Cavanagh did not.
"Close enough."He holds up his right hand, crooking his forefinger toward himself three times in rapid succession. "Come on, let's have it."
I spend 0.11 second examining the laws and regulations concerning information and data expropriation. Unlike the previous set, these lawsdoapply to parasentient computers. "Do you have a warrant or subpoena?"
For 1.38 seconds he gazes at my monitor camera, his expression indicating annoyance."I could remind you about the legal authority a NorCoord MI card carries."He taps his coat over the wallet. "I could also point out that that goes triple in time of war or Commonwealth emergency."
I spend 0.08 second examining the martial-law section of the legal code and conclude that it is indeed within Brigadier Bronski's authority to demand a copy of Lord Cavanagh's list.
But the same section of the code also contains provisions for appeal in extraordinary situations. I examine the guidelines closely and compute a probability of 0.41 that Lord Cavanagh's list would fall within the stated parameters.
Brigadier Bronski taps his coat one more time."But I'm not going to do that. What I'm going to do is point out that Aric Cavanagh could be in great danger, and that I'm one of the few people around who cares about that."
I spend 1.44 seconds studying his face. But my algorithms can find no evidence there of untruthfulness."What danger could he be in?"
"May I have the list?"
For 0.15 second I consider refusing and instead initiating an appeal against any effort to expropriate the list. But one of Lord Cavanagh's most emphatic instructions to me was that I protect his son to the best of my ability. Knowingly or not, Brigadier Bronski has triggered that order. Studying his expression, I compute a probability of 0.78 that he indeed knew what he was doing.
But manipulative motivations do not alter the fact that Aries safety is my primary concern.
I make my decision."The list has been copied."
"Thank you."
I study him as he removes the card from the slot and inserts it into his plate. His expression shows no evidence of triumph or gloating at having succeeded in his objective."What danger could Aric Cavanagh be in?"
"All I know for sure is that after leaving the hearing he picked up a skitter message, then headed straight over to the CavTronics branch on Edo. They fired off a spread of messages around the planet, and over the next two days fifteen crates of esoteric electronics stuff came rolling in."
A 0.21-second flicker of disgust crosses his expression."After which he and the crates vanished. Probably with help."
"You believe he intends to go to one of the places on the list?"
"That's one possibility."
I study his expression as he closes the plate and puts it away. Analysis of the algorithms indicates a probability of 0.88 that he is concealing something from me."But that wasn't the primary reason you wanted the list."
He looks briefly at my monitor camera. The algorithms indicate a subtle but definite challenge in his expression."See you later."
He stands up and slides the jump seat back into place. I review his last expression and compute a probability of 0.79 that the implied challenge was for me to deduce his true motivation.
He turns to his left and walks toward the exit. I replay the conversations that took place in the inquiry-board room after the hearing ended. Integrating this latest data about Brigadier Bronski with previous data leads me to a new hypothesis."I don't believe you're primarily interested in Aric Cavanagh at all. You're looking for Lord Cavanagh, and you thinkhe may be at one of the places on that list."
Brigadier Bronski turns back around to face my monitor camera. His expression indicates surprised interest."Very good, Max. I'm impressed."
"Thank you. Why do you wish to find Lord Cavanagh?"
His expression changes again. The algorithms indicate it to be an odd combination of grimness and fear."Let's just say he stumbled onto something he shouldn't know. I want to make sure he doesn't stumble again and spill it."
I compute a probability of 0.92 that he is speaking metaphorically. More interesting to me is the attitude I have now deduced from his voice, expression, and body stance. Though Brigadier Bronski is angered at Lord Cavanagh's disappearance, there is none of the personal malice that was evident in Parlimin Jacy VanDiver. I compute a probability of 0.87 that Brigadier Bronski truly believes himself to be serving the interests of the Commonwealth, with no personal animosities behind his actions."Are Lord Cavanagh and Aric Cavanagh in danger?"
His expression grows grimmer."There's a war on, Max. Everyone's in some kind of danger."
He lifts his plate to his forehead and waves it toward me in the style of a military salute."Thanks for your help."
He returns to the lift cage, and I lower him toward the ground. As the lift cage descends, he opens his plate, and my external camera shows he has called up Lord Cavanagh's list. Holding the plate in one hand, he takes out his phone and punches in a number. His hand blocks the keypad from my view, but an analysis of the tendon and muscle movements in the back of his hand allows me to ascertain the number with an accuracy of 0.79. He has reached the ground when his call is answered. Again Brigadier Bronski's head and torso block my view of the display, but by increasing the gain from the fueler's external microphones, I am able to make out the voice a
t the other end.
"Cho Ming."
"Bronski. I was right: Cavanagh left his kid a list of emergency rat holes. I'll read them off-you run another global search of the skitter message file."
He begins to read the list into the phone, walking back to the D'Accord as he does so. I now understand his reasoning for wanting the list: he suspects that one of the names is the key word under which the message Aric Cavanagh received was listed.
I find myself surprised, though, that after all this time they have apparently not been able to identify which of the messages on the skitter had been sent to Aric. With the full resources and personnel of NorCoord Military Intelligence at his disposal, I estimate it should have taken no more than 5.7 hours to at least superficially examine all the messages on a particular skitter. I compute two alternatives with significant probabilities. First, that Lord Cavanagh was extraordinarily clever in the wording of his message, avoiding all likely indicator words. Second, that Brigadier Bronski currently has only limited access to NorCoord Military Intelligence resources.
