‘But you were attacked?’
‘Footpads ambushed us at a river. They caught my companion and murdered him. They tried to kill me, but I escaped them, and defended myself against the man there in the bed. He fought well, and almost knocked me from my horse while his comrades fled. Then he too ran, trying to take a path through a stand of low trees where I could not follow on horseback. I left him, and went to my friend, but poor Tom was dead and his package was stolen. It was a disaster, the failure of our embassy.
‘So I continued alone. A short way beyond the little wood, I found this man. I would have killed him, but I needed to find the relic, and I thought he could tell me of its whereabouts. He agreed to tell me all he knew in return for my parole. If I protected him and brought him here, he would answer my questions.
‘This man told me that a companion of his had tried to kill him. For that he felt that he owed his erstwhile colleagues no loyalty. So he told me of the girl Annie. He loved her, and he wanted her to know he was alive. I found her and told her about the attack on her man, and she was enraged. She helped me, telling me of the whore Moll, and telling me where Adam and Will lived so that I could ambush them and find the relic. So this I tried to do.
‘The first night I went to the tavern and saw the men there. I tried to return to catch Will, but he escaped me in the dark. I remained up in Moll’s room. In the middle of the night, the brother of this man appeared, horrified. He had found Will’s body. I left then, determined to find the man and search his body.’
‘This was the middle of the night?’ Baldwin queried.
‘Yes. Moll persuaded him that it would be better to leave Will there and report the murder in the morning. Will had had his throat cut, and I went through his clothes but could find nothing on him. No relic. In a rage, I slashed at his corpse. He’d killed my friend Tom and robbed him, and now I couldn’t find Tom’s goods. I was enraged.’
‘You would have killed him.’
‘No. I wanted the relic, and I wanted to question him to learn where it was. I have no taste for murder. In the same way I tried to capture Adam. He was stronger than I expected, though, and didn’t fall when I struck him. In the fight, I had to kill him…and I think he has killed me.’
‘So we still don’t know who killed Will,’ Simon said. ‘Nor Moll, either.’
‘I killed neither,’ the injured knight said. ‘Who would kill Moll?’
Baldwin was silent for a moment. Then he bowed over the dying man. ‘You have done well, poor fellow soldier.’ He drew his sword, and showed the man the blade. There, outlined in gold, was the Templar cross. He had asked for it to be carved there when he had the sword made, and never had he been more proud.
Sir John de Mantravers peered closely, and then looked up at Baldwin. ‘Thank you, comrade.’ He kissed the cross and sank back with a grunt of pain.
‘Come on, then, Baldwin. Who would have killed Moll?’ Simon asked.
‘I have little doubt that it was Rob,’ Baldwin said. ‘I think he feared that she saw something on the day that Will was killed.’
‘So you think that Will was murdered by Rob?’ Jonathan asked.
They were near the Broad Gate, the great main entranceway to the cathedral, and Baldwin stopped here. ‘We may never know, of course, but I think that for our report we should assume that he was responsible for that as well. Clearly we may not enquire of him any longer, but who else would have had the motive? His brother had been leader of the band, and when his brother was stabbed, perhaps he thought that Will would take over. Maybe he thought the gang was his own inheritance? For whatever reason, he killed Will and then stabbed Moll in case she had seen something. Perhaps he thought she was a witness and couldn’t take the risk that she might report him?’
‘I see.’ Jonathan nodded. He gave the two men his thanks for their company, and walked in under the great gates. In a moment he was lost to sight.
Baldwin nodded to himself. ‘A pleasant enough fellow.’
‘And about as gullible as you could hope,’ Simon said more caustically. ‘So now, Baldwin, what really happened?’
‘Think of it this way, Simon. What reason was there for someone to kill Will? He was no real threat to anyone in the band. He had the others under control. When Adam wanted to get the relic, he didn’t fight with Will, but picked a fight with Tad instead. Adam himself recognized Will’s leadership.’
‘Rob could have killed him.’
‘True enough. He was a weak, ineffectual man, yet he still managed to attempt to kill his own brother when he thought that Andrew might take his woman. He could have tried to kill Will–but was there the desire? I think that someone else had more of a desire to see him dead.’
‘Who?’
‘Annie, Andrew’s woman. She loved him, from what Andrew said to Mantravers, and surely she would not have expected Andrew’s own brother to murder him; when she heard that Andrew was attacked and presumed dead, who would she have blamed? I think the first person would be Will. So she laid a trap for him, waiting in the alley. When he came near, she pulled his neck back and cut his throat.’
‘You think that she went back to kill Moll?’
‘Moll was sure she knew who had killed Will. She told you she was safe, didn’t she? That was because she felt sure that the killer was Robert or Adam, and she didn’t feel threatened by either of them. But she was wrong. One of them was quite prepared to kill her.’
‘Adam was a violent, dangerous man,’ Simon said thoughtfully. Then he shook his head. ‘Yet he didn’t kill anyone. He wouldn’t rise to fight Will when Will prevented him looking at the box, and we know that Robert was capable of murdering his own brother to keep his woman. It must have been him.’
‘Yes. He thought Annie could have been seen, so he went back to Moll’s house and killed her.’
‘What would make him think that she was a threat to him?’ Simon wondered.
Baldwin said nothing. His friend the bailiff was too dear to him for Baldwin to talk about the time when they had both been questioning Rob on that first day they had seen him, when Baldwin studied the pool of vomit and Simon went to the whore and spoke to her quietly. Baldwin could see the two of them now, young Moll looking at Simon with that saucy smile, every bit the practised wench; Simon himself grinning back and asking her who she might have seen or heard. A man as anxious as Rob would be sure to wonder whether that quiet conversation could have led to information being shared. No, Baldwin wouldn’t tell his friend.
But Simon’s mind was already on another matter. ‘So if this woman Annie killed Will, do you think we should have her arrested?’
Baldwin grimaced and shook his head. ‘What good would it do? She has managed to remove a felon from the streets. In fact her act of revenge for the stabbing of her man had the beneficial result that it removed four footpads from the roads about here. I think she deserves to be left to her own conscience.’
Exeter, January, 1324
The little graves were a sad reminder of those days, he thought, as he looked down at them. On one side was the plain, simple cross of a monk; on the other was the more showy affair with the special sign etched into it.
Joseph rose from his prayers for the two men with a grunt as his knee seemed to lock. The cold wintry weather always had this result: the right knee would freeze, like a rusted hinge, and he would find it difficult to get up from his devotions. Now he must use a stick to hobble from here back to his hospital.
The two men were bold enough, he supposed. It was good of the knight from Furnshill to pay for their gravestones, but perhaps it was the sort of charitable gift a man like him would be expected to donate. Looking after those who had been on a journey and were assaulted on their way. It was a little disturbing to see that cross symbol, though, the mark of the Templars. Their Order had been disbanded because they were heretical and recusants. To have their Order’s cross carved upon the gravestone felt almost sacrilegious–and yet Joseph couldn’t begrudge it. The man him
self had seemed a good man. He had saved Andrew’s life, too, and that itself meant he deserved being remembered in a kindly light.
‘Come in, Brother.’
‘Thank you, thank you.’
Joseph hobbled inside and glanced about him at the beds. ‘No customers, thank God.’
Andrew smiled. He was still a little bent from the after-effects of his wound, and the pain, and the reserved inward-looking expression, would never leave him, but he was content. ‘No. No more strays, Brother.’
Joseph watched him from narrowed eyes. Yes, the lad would make a good lay brother. It was a shame that his woman would have to find a new lover, but that was the way of things. Those whom God called, and so on.
And what more clear call could there be, than that he should make a man touch a cursed relic and never be able to leave it behind? The relic was still in its box in Andrew’s custody, secure. There had been a time when Joseph wondered whether it should be given to the bishop, but something made him hesitate. He had spoken to Sir Baldwin at length, and both thought that it would be best to keep the thing secret.
In any case, Andrew had touched the thing once, so he was cursed to keep it. If he relinquished it, he would die.
That was why he was here. He could have left the hospital to marry Annie, but the weight of this burden was too much to lay upon her.
No, rather than blight her life too, he would live here for the rest of his life. Because he knew that if he left the hospital and gave up the relic, he would die. As surely as Will and Adam had died.
At least here he was safe.
ACT FOUR
Cambridge, late July 1353
The old friar closed his eyes and muttered a prayer of relief when he saw the cluster of towers and rooftops jutting above the distant line of trees. His legs ached with weariness, and there was a bitter, gnawing pain in his back that had been growing steadily worse since Christmas. The summer had been unpleasant for travelling, starting with unseasonable gales and heavy rain, and now there was the exhausting, searing heat that drained his meagre supplies of energy. The sun blazed high in cloudless skies, and even farmers, who usually delighted in dry summers, complained that their crops burned and that the soil was baked too dry and hard. The friar glanced at his companion, an eager, doggedly loyal novice who had agreed to postpone his studies and go with him on his long pilgrimage from their priory in Exeter.
‘It is not much farther now, Father Andrew,’ said the youngster kindly, seeing his master’s exhaustion. ‘We will find a small, quiet hostel, where you can regain your strength. And while you do, I shall attend the public lectures given by the scholars here–if any survived the plague, that is. I heard the Death struck the universities very hard.’
‘It did, Urban,’ replied Andrew, recalling the bleak months some three years before, when a foul contagion had swept across the civilized world, claiming more victims than could be properly buried. ‘It took every one of the Cambridge Dominicans, God rest their souls.’
‘Is this our final destination?’ asked Urban keenly, sensing in his elder a rare willingness to talk, and determined to make the most of it. ‘Is this the end of our quest? Surely I have earned your trust by now, and you can tell me why we left Exeter in the depths of night and have been travelling on little-used pathways for months?’
‘I trust you, Urban,’ replied Andrew, knowing it was time he was honest, but unwilling to impose such a dreary burden on his youthful companion. ‘That is why I asked you to accompany me–you were the novice who best suited my needs. I had intended to end my journey in Norwich, but I grow weaker with each passing day, and I am not sure whether I possess the strength to finish what I began. I may have to ask you to do it.’
‘I will, Father,’ said Urban, supposing the old man was paying him a compliment of sorts. Andrew was not an easy master, and there were times when he felt as though nothing he did was satisfactory. He was always compared unfavourably with another student, who had been everything a novice should be, and Urban often wondered whether he would ever meet Andrew’s exacting standards. ‘I promised obedience, and I will do what is necessary.’
‘It will mean your death,’ said Andrew, watching alarm and then puzzlement flash in the young man’s hazel eyes. ‘Do you remember the rumours about our Holy Blood relic–the one under the high altar? It is said to carry a curse.’
Urban was startled by the mention of so odd a topic, but struggled to mask his reaction: he could not bear Andrew to think him stupid or unworldly. ‘We–the novices–tease each other about it. We take a splinter of wood and thrust it into someone’s hands, telling him he will die now that his bare skin has touched a piece of the True Cross stained with Christ’s blood. It is all nonsense, of course. None of us really believes the story about it being cursed.’
As soon the words were out, Urban regretted them; Andrew was humourless, and would certainly disapprove of jokes about a relic, even one that was tainted with such a dubious reputation. He was unable to suppress the thought that Andrew’s saintly former student would not have made light of such a subject, and that once again he, Urban, would be found lacking. To his surprise, Andrew did not issue a stream of reprimands.
‘I am sure you heard about the Exeter murders,’ Andrew said after a few moments. ‘About how a Keeper of the King’s Peace called Baldwin de Furnshill and his friend Simon Puttock discovered that four robbers had taken hold of the relic? They turned on each other, and three died in horrible ways. Eventually, it came to our priory in Exeter, which was chosen because it lies within the city walls, where it will be safe from thieves.’
Urban nodded slowly, wary now and unwilling to commit himself. He did not want to be accused of listening to the gossip of laymen who said bad things about their priory’s only relic. ‘But I do not believe them.’
Andrew gave the kind of grimace that passed for a smile on his pinched, lined face. ‘I was the fourth thief, the one who survived,’ he said softly. ‘I saw it all. Indeed, the vile events in Devonshire all those years ago were why I gave up my secular life and took the cowl. My brother Rob and I were felons–God save my soul from the shameful iniquities of my youth–and I was rough and feckless. But I came to know the relic’s power, and I wanted to be near it, to ensure it stayed where it was put, and that no one ever tried to steal it for dark purposes.’
Urban gazed at him. Here was part of the story he had not heard before. He had known his master had once been wild–some of the novices even claimed he had been an outlaw–but he had not realized that Andrew had played such an active role in the relic’s history. It certainly explained why he had always spent so much time near the high altar, where the relic was hidden.
‘I see,’ he said, knowing his response was inadequate, but unable to find better words to express himself.
‘And you know what happened next. Prior William de Regny sent me away as a minor envoy to distant places–Hungary and the land of the Bohemian kings–and I even studied in foreign universities.’ Andrew gave a short bark of humourless laughter. ‘My dim-witted brother would not have credited that I–his uncouth, loutish sibling–would become a scholar and an emissary! I was a teacher, too, grooming my best student to take my place in the university’s hierarchy, before he…well, you know what happened with him. I took the relic with me, but I was never easy about its safety in such distant places, and after some years I brought it back to Devonshire again, to our little priory.’
‘Yes, Father,’ said Urban dutifully, wondering where the discussion was leading.
Andrew’s expression was distant. ‘It is powerful–more powerful than you can imagine–and it is genuine. Besides what I witnessed thirty years ago, there are two ancient parchments that carry its seal of authenticity.’
‘I heard there were documents, but I did not think it was true.’
‘It is true,’ said Andrew with a conviction that surprised his novice. ‘The fragment of the True Cross is in a vial, and the parchments are wrapped aroun
d it. Anyone can hold the glass, but to touch the stained splinter inside is certain death.’
Urban swallowed, and the bright sun seemed to lose some of its warmth. When a magpie chattered in a tree above his head, he jumped and found that his hands were shaking. Slowly, a nasty, unworthy suspicion began to form in his mind. ‘Our priory has been the relic’s guardian for years now. It is still there…’
Andrew rummaged under his habit and removed the purse he carried around his neck. The cord that held it was old and frayed, while the bag itself was sewn from cheap purple cloth, stained and worn from the actions of restless fingers. ‘It is here.’
Urban was almost speechless, and fought hard against the urge to back away, appalled by what Andrew had done. ‘You took it? You stole it?’ All manner of questions suddenly found answers: the reason for their moonlit flight, the secrecy and orders to tell no one they were leaving, Andrew’s refusal to say where they were going, the preference for little-travelled paths when the highways would have been faster and safer.
‘It was for the best. My days are coming to an end, and the relic would not have been safe with our new prior. My duty was clear: I must convey it to Norwich, where there is another Holy Blood relic, and where the Benedictine monks will know how to keep this one from harming others.’
Urban was not convinced. Stealing was a mortal sin, but stealing a relic from a priory was an unimaginably wicked crime, and now he, Urban, was implicated in it. And Father Andrew, whom he had idolized and whose grim piety he had sought to emulate, was no more than a common thief. His thoughts whirled in confusion, and he felt betrayed. Andrew read the unhappiness and bewilderment on his face and touched his arm gently.
‘I did what was right. Do not ask me how I know–perhaps God planted the knowledge there, because I assure you I would rather have spent my last days at home than traipsing across England–but I feel it with my whole being. Prior John de Burgo is not a believer in the power of blood relics–few men in our Order are–and I was afraid one of the tasks he would perform as he took up his new office would be to rid his priory of the anathema the relic has become.’
The Tainted Relic Page 25
