“Well it did hurt, Daddy,” said Stevie. “They never told me anything.”
“It was a secret,” said one of the boys.
“I told him I’d never never tell so he wouldn’t . . .” The boy’s voice trailed off, growing weak.
“Don’t leave!” said Stevie. “You said if we did Christmas!”
“It’s hard,” said another of the boys.
Stevie turned to Step. “Dad, you got to call Mr. Douglas. If he sees them all, he’ll have to believe it, won’t he?”
“Yes,” said Step.
“I knew he wouldn’t believe just me telling him, because if you didn’t believe me then why should he?”
“We believed you, Stevie,” said DeAnne, struggling not to cry. “We really did.”
“I mean you didn’t believe in them,” he said. “I thought you could see them like I could, but then you couldn’t, and not even Robbie except once for a second.”
Step thought: Robbie saw, but I couldn’t, and DeAnne couldn’t.
“And I tried to figure out how to show them. They told me they were all buried under the house and so I—”
Again a gasp from DeAnne, and Step felt a wrenching in his gut. It wasn’t just some disturbance in the fabric of the universe that Stevie had felt, it wasn’t just some nameless evil somewhere in the city. It was here. It was under the house. The place from which spiders and crickets had fled. The place where the bodies of seven little boys had been concealed, where no one could find them no matter how hard they searched.
But someone had been under the house since they moved there, yes, more than once, more than once. Bappy has been under this house. And Bappy lived here before us, before his son made him move out so he could rent the place to us. Bappy lived here when the first of the boys were taken, and Bappy has been here so often, ever since.
Stevie went on. “So I crawled under there and buried myself up but it didn’t help, I still couldn’t do it, and anyway you got mad at me for getting so dirty and going outside and so I didn’t try that again.”
My son was under there, Step thought. He wanted to scream the way he had screamed after the Fourth of July picnic. But he held it in.
“I didn’t know what to do anymore,” said Stevie, “and so I gave up, I thought nobody could ever see them. But I couldn’t just let him go on doing it, could I, Dad? That wouldn’t be right. They didn’t like it, I knew that, even if they didn’t tell me how much it hurt.”
He looked at the other boys, and some of them looked away, perhaps ashamed.
“So I remembered what you said about how bad people hate the truth, it scares them, so I broke the rules and I went outside when he was doing the lights and I said, I know what you’re doing, and he said, I don’t know what you’re talking about, and I said, They told me about you, and he said, Who told you? and I said, They told me about Boy, and I said, Mr. Douglas is a friend of mine, I met him, and he said so. And I said, You got to stop, and he said, I already did. He said, Boy don’t do that no more. But I knew he was lying, because I could see that Boy wasn’t like they told me, Boy wasn’t somebody else, he was Boy, Boy was his own self, and then I ran to get back in the house but I wasn’t fast enough.”
DeAnne was crying now, her face covered in her hands, and Step could feel tears on his own cheeks, because now he knew, beyond all doubt, beyond all hope, that there were eight lost boys, not seven, sharing Christmas in their house tonight. Eight lost boys, not seven, buried in the crawlspace.
“And I thought I wrecked everything,” said Stevie. “But then I knew that I didn’t at all. Because I did know how to make you see me. It was really hard the first night and I think a couple of times you didn’t see me when you were supposed to, but I got better and better at it and then I really could show them how because I was like them now, and so Daddy, here we are, and you got to call Mr. Douglas because Boy is still there and he’s got to stop.”
“Yes,” said Step. “Will you stay, boys? Till Mr. Douglas comes?”
They didn’t answer; they looked at each other, some of them, and others looked at the floor.
“They’re afraid of seeing him again,” said Stevie. “The old guy.”
“Boy,” whispered one of Stevie’s friends.
“Boy,” echoed several others.
“I know what we should do,” said DeAnne. She was trying to sound cheerful, despite her tears. “You’ve all sat here and seen what our family does for Christmas Eve. Why don’t you each tell the rest of us what your family does. You don’t have to if you don’t want to, but I’d really like to know, because I don’t think any two families in the world do Christmas exactly alike. What about you, Jack?”
DeAnne led them in sharing tales of Christmases past as Step went to the kitchen and called the police station. “Call Mr. Douglas and tell him that Step Fletcher has to see him tonight. I know it’s Christmas Eve, but tell him that the answers are all here but only if he comes now to see them with his own eyes.”
Step worried for a moment that this policeman might be too fearful of offending someone, of losing his job or a promotion, to dare to call his boss on Christmas Eve.
“I promise you, my friend,” said Step, “that if you make this call, you’ll be giving Doug Douglas the best Christmas present he ever had.”
“Easy for you to say,” said the man. “But I’ll give it a shot and see if he wants to talk to you.”
It seemed less than a minute—yet such a long time—before the phone rang. Step picked it up so fast it barely had time to echo.
“What have you got on Christmas Eve, Mr. Fletcher?”
“I had the list before, Mr. Douglas, and that wasn’t a fake, right? I told you the truth, right?”
“Right.”
“Come now, come quickly. I have all the answers here. But no lights, no sirens. Because you’ll frighten them and they might go.”
“Them? Who?”
“The boys, Mr. Douglas.” Step hung up, trusting that Douglas would have faith enough in him to come.
He got there before the boys had finished telling all their memories. He came in quietly, and when he saw them gathered there. Step could see the hope in his eyes, the wonderment that they were not dead after all. But then he saw Step’s face, and Step knew that it was no secret that he had been grieving, and then Douglas began to understand. “Your boy really did see them,” said Douglas.
“All along,” said Step.
“But why is it that we can see them now?”
“Because Stevie showed them how. And he kept them here so you could see them.”
Douglas walked slowly, carefully, to the center of the room. “Ah, boys. If only I could have found him sooner. If only I could have stopped him before . . . But I can stop him now. Just tell me who it is.”
So Stevie told it all again, and this time with more details. The deep place under the house. How he didn’t really understand what had happened to his friends until he saw that place and then he made them tell him, and he made them tell him who it was, too. “Bappy,” he said.
“Boy,” said a couple of the others.
“Baptize Waters,” said Step. “Our landlord’s father. He used to live here. I wrote down his address and phone number for you while you were on the way.”
“Boys,” said Douglas. “I’ll tell you something. I don’t think you should ever see that man again. I don’t think any children should ever have to see him again.”
They nodded.
“So I promise you that if you stay right here in this room for just a little while longer, you won’t ever see him again. And if you wait, I’d like to call your parents. I’d like your parents to have a chance to see you.”
“They’ll be mad,” said one of the boys. “I didn’t stay where I was supposed to.”
“No,” said Douglas. “I’ve talked to all of them and I can promise you that not one of them will be mad. Not one. Can you stay just that much longer?”
“It’s hard,” said one o
f the boys.
“Then I’ll hurry.”
Douglas left the room, went into the kitchen. Step could hear him phoning, speaking quietly. Later he would learn how the phone calls went. We have found where the bodies are hidden, and your son is one of them. But there’s also something else, a chance of something else, to say good-bye to your son, if you hurry. “Tell no one. Come quickly. They didn’t understand, of course, but they came. And soon they had spread out through the house, the grieving parents, the boys, shy at first, and softspoken, for none of them was as strong as Stevie.
And while they talked inside the house, the policemen worked beneath it and outside it, and the bodies were brought out one by one on pallets and were laid under the bright lights on the lawn. Bappy was brought to the house on Chinqua Penn, he and his son and his son’s lawyer, furious at first about being dragged out here on Christmas Eve. But then they saw the bodies on the lawn, and the son turned to the father, and in a voice rising steadily to a shout, to a scream, he said, “You told me you stopped. You told me you were too old to want it anymore. But you didn’t stop, you old son-of-a-bitch, you went on doing it only now you killed them!” Weeping in shame and rage and terrible memories of his own, the son shoved his father to the ground and then he kicked him until the police grabbed him and held him, and he stood there sobbing. “He said he stopped. I would have told you about him if I’d known he was still doing it, if I’d known he’d do this, I would have told you.”
“So why didn’t you tell us anyway?” asked Douglas.
For a moment he couldn’t think of how to say it. And then he could. “He’s my father.”
“It wasn’t me,” said Bappy.
“Yes it was,” said Douglas.
“It was Boy,” said Bappy. “I never wanted to. What do you think I am, anyway? I’d never do anything like this. It’s always that Boy.”
All of it was on videotape. The son. The father. The grim-faced lawyer urging them both, far too late now, to be quiet, to say no more. All on tape, and so there was no need for any of the men outside the house to see or even know about what was happening inside.
As Bappy was led away, as the bodies were brought out of their hidden graves and under the police lights of that bitter cold Christmas Eve, one by one the boys inside the house no longer had the strength or the need to keep trying anymore, and they said good-bye, and they were gone. One moment there, the next moment not there. Then their parents left, weeping, clinging to each other, with just a whispered word or two from Douglas. Tell no one,” he said. “You don’t want your boy’s name in the press. Just go home and thank God you had a chance to say good-bye. One small mercy in this whole cruel business.” And the parents nodded and agreed and went home to the loneliest Christmas of their lives, the Christmas in which questions were answered at last, and love was remembered and wept for, and God was thanked and blamed for not having done more.
Inside the house, Stevie was the last to linger; he had been the strongest all along. Robbie and Betsy were both asleep, and Zap also was asleep in DeAnne’s arms. So Stevie was alone with his parents at last, as he had been alone with them when their family was just beginning.
“Ah, Stevie,” said Step. “Why did you face him by yourself? Why didn’t you make us believe you? Why didn’t you explain?”
“I was the one they came to,” said Stevie. “It was my job. Isn’t that why we moved here?”
“Not to lose you,” said DeAnne.
“I just did what you taught me,” said Stevie. “I didn’t mean to die. But I didn’t know how to do it until then. Did I do wrong?”
“Oh, Stevie,” said DeAnne, “what you did was noble and good and brave. We knew that’s the kind of man you would be, we knew it all along.”
“We just thought we’d have a chance to know you longer,” said Step. “We thought we’d the long before you. That’s how the world is supposed to be.”
“Nothing was how it was supposed to be,” said Stevie. “Nothing was right, but now it’s better, isn’t it? I made it better, didn’t I?”
“For all the mothers and fathers who won’t have to grieve,” said Step, “because you stopped that man before he found their sons, yes, you made it better.”
“And you’re not mad at me for breaking the rules?” asked Stevie.
“No, we’re not,” said DeAnne. “But we’re sad.”
“Stevie, will you forgive us?” said Step. “For not understanding? For not knowing that what you said to us was true?”
“Sure,” he said. “I could see them and you couldn’t. I was only mad at you until I figured that out.” Then Stevie sighed. “It’s so hard, staying here like this.”
“I don’t want you to go,” said DeAnne.
“It’s so hard,” he said again.
“I love you, Stephen Bolivar Fletcher,” said Step. “I love you more than life. I’ll miss you so much.”
“I’ll miss you too, Daddy. I’ll miss you too, Mommy. Tell Robbie and Betsy bye for me. And tell Zap about me when he’s bigger, because I’m still his biggest brother.”
“I love you,” said DeAnne. She wanted to tell him what that meant. What he meant to her, how it felt to carry him for all those awful months of sickness and how it all was worth it when she held him in her arms, and more than worth it as she watched him grow and saw what a fine boy he was, so much better than she could have hoped for. She wanted to tell him of all her dreams for him, of all the children she wanted him to have, children lucky enough to have him for a father. She wanted to tell him how she had once dreamed of lying on her own deathbed, knowing that it would be all right to die because Stevie was sitting there beside her, holding her hand, and she dreamed that he said, Good-bye, Mother. And then: Be there waiting for me when I come.
“Good-bye, Mother,” said Stevie. “Good-bye, Father.”
“Good-bye, Door Man,” whispered Step.
And DeAnne said, “Oh, Stevie, be there waiting for us when we come.”
15
NEW YEAR
This is how the Fletchers found their way to the end of 1983: They called the Lowes, who only had to hear two sentences before they came rushing to the house on Chinqua Penn. Mary Anne helped them pack what they’d need for the next few days while Harv telephoned the bishop and Sister Bigelow, who also came. Long after the Fletchers had been taken to the Lowes’ house to spend the rest of that long Christmas Eve, the bishop and Sister Bigelow remained, gathering up all the presents that Step had pointed out to them, wrapping those that were still unwrapped, filling the stockings with the candy and gifts that Step and DeAnne had prepared, and then carrying it all to the Lowes’ house before any of the little ones awoke. Step and DeAnne watched quietly as Harv and Mary Anne made the Fletcher children’s Christmas a bright and happy time.
While they stayed home from church, the rest of the two Steuben wards gathered, and the much-fought-over Christmas program was scrapped on the spot. Instead the bishop, sleepless as he was, told the story of the innocents of Bethlehem, and then the story of Alma and Amulek as they watched the deaths of other innocents. And he said, “Such children of God will soon forget all pain and death, as they are greeted with rejoicing. It’s those who are left behind who need our help and comfort now.”
Help and comfort took many forms in the next few days. A new but empty condominium was found, and the landlord, hearing a little of their story, let the Fletchers have it for the first month free. While the police line still barred most people from the house on Chinqua Penn, the elders quorum crossed the line to carry all the Fletchers’ worldly goods to a U-Haul truck, which was shuttled back and forth until everything was in place in the Fletchers’ new home. They never had to set foot again in the house where Stevie died.
Sister Bigelow stayed after all the others who helped with the move had left. “I found something,” she said. “I thought you should be alone when you got it.” She set a brown paper sack on the table. “It was in the back of the closet.” Then she h
ugged DeAnne and left.
They opened the bag. Inside were two odd-shaped Christmas presents, wrapped. DeAnne’s was heavy. She opened it to find two stones glued together and painted to be a rabbit. One stone was the body, the little one was the head, and there were two construction-paper ears glued on. On a 3 x 5 card Stevie had written, “The Yard Bunny.” Step’s present was much lighter, and harder to figure out at a glance. Stevie had taken a Cool Whip tub, glued a used-up plastic tape dispenser to the lid, and painted the whole thing bright red. On the card was a careful diagram showing a watch dangling from the arm of the tape dispenser, several pens sticking through the hole in the dispenser, and loose change in the Cool Whip tub. There were fifteen pennies in the tub to help him get started. It was a dresser caddy to hold the stuff he kept in his pockets.
They held hands across the table for a long time, the presents framed by their arms.
None of the parents broke the silence about what happened on that Christmas Eve, and Doug Douglas made sure that the journalists heard only the story of Bappy and his son, and a family that had kept the dark secret of the old molester until it was far too late. So it was only pictures of Bappy and his son that ran on the evening news and on the front pages. Doug Douglas would keep in touch with all the families over the years, even after he retired from the Steuben Police Department, but he never brought up the subject of that night or of the year that led to it; they all knew the nature of the threads that bound them together. They shared with him the friendship of people who have been on a long journey together, a journey that is now behind them but can never be forgotten for a single hour.
Doug Douglas called the Fletchers only once. In going back over the records of the case, just for his own peace of mind, he had come up with a correlation between the times their house had been strangely infested by insects or spiders and the nights that boys had died. They confirmed the dates for him. Stevie hadn’t been the only one to sense how the world was being torn.
Step and DeAnne buried their oldest boy in a cemetery on the western edge of Steuben, surrounded by thick woods full of birds and animals, a living place. They both knew as they stood beside the grave that their days of wandering were through. They had been anchored now in Steuben, both by the living and by the dead. Little Jeremy would enter Open Doors when the time came; flowers would be tended on this grave.
Lost Boys: A Novel Page 50
