by Nicci French
I tried once more to reach back into my memory not my long memory, the memory of my life and my friends and my family, not the things that made me into who I am, the passage of time like rings in a tree trunk, not all of that, don't think of that. My recent memory, the memory that would tell me how I came to be here, now. There was nothing. A thick wall lay between me here and me there.
I recited tables inside my head. I could do the two times table, and the three, but after that I got muddled. Everything became jumbled up. I started to cry again. Silently.
I shuffled forward until I found the drop. I struggled into a sitting position. It couldn't be that high. He had stood beneath me and lifted me down. Four feet, maybe five. Not more, surely. I wriggled my feet in their bindings. I took a deep breath and shuffled forward a few inches more, so I was teetering on the edge. I would count to five, then I'd jump. One, two, three, four .. .
I heard a sound. A sound at the other end of the room. Wheezing laughter. He was watching me. Squatting in the dark like a toad, watching me writhing around pathetically on the platform. A sob rose in my chest.
"Go on, then. Jump."
I wriggled backwards.
"See what happens when you fall."
Back a bit more. Legs on the ledge now. I shifted myself back against the wall and lay slumped there. Tears rolled down my cheeks, under my hood.
"Sometimes I like watching you," he said. "You dunno, do you? When I'm here and when I'm not. I'm quiet, like."
Eyes in the darkness, watching me.
"What time is it?" "Drink your water."
"Please. Is it still morning? Or afternoon?" "That doesn't matter any more." "Can I .. . ?" "What?"
What? I didn't know. What should I ask for? "I'm just an ordinary person," I said. "I'm not good but I'm not bad either."
"Everyone has a breaking point," he said. "That's the thing."
Nobody knows what they would do, if it came to it. Nobody knows. I thought of the lake, and the river, and the yellow butterfly on the green leaf. I made myself a picture of a tree with silver bark and light green leaves. A silver birch. I put it on the top of a smooth green hill. I made a breeze to rustle through its leaves, turning them so that they glinted and shone as if there were lights among the branches. I put a small white cloud just above it. Had I ever seen a tree just like that? I couldn't remember.
"I'm very cold."
"Yes."
"Could I have a blanket? Something to cover me."
"Please."
"What?"
"You have to say please."
"Please. Please give me a blanket."
"No."
Once again I was filled with wild anger. It felt strong enough to suffocate me. I swallowed hard. Beneath the hood, I stared, blinked. I imagined him looking at me, sitting with my arms behind my back and my neck in a noose and my head in a hood. I was like one of those people you see in newspaper pictures, being led out into a square to be shot by a line of men with guns. But he couldn't see my expression beneath the hood. He didn't know what I was thinking. I made my voice expressionless.
"All right," I said.
When the time came, would he hurt me? Or was he just going to let me die bit by bit? I was no good with pain. If I was tortured, I would crack and give up any secret, I was sure of that. But this was much worse. He would be torturing me and there would be nothing I could do to stop him, no information to give. Or perhaps he would want sex. Lying on top of me in the dark, forcing me. Pull my hood off, naked face, the rag from my mouth, push in his tongue. Push in his ... I shook my head violently, and the pain in my head was almost a relief.
I had once read or heard or been told how soldiers who wanted to join the SAS were ordered to run a long distance with a heavy pack on their back. They ran and ran, and at last they arrived at the end, near to collapsing. And then they were ordered to turn round and run the distance back again. You think you can't bear any more, but you can.
There is always more in you than you think. Hidden depths. That's what I told myself. For what was my breaking point?
I was woken by slaps on my face. I didn't want to wake. What was the point? What was there to wake for? Just curl up and sleep. More slaps. Hood pulled up, the gag pulled out of my mouth.
"You awake?"
"Yes. Stop."
"I've got food. Open your mouth."
"What food?"
"What the fuck does that matter?"
"Drink first. Mouth dry."
There was muttering in the dark. Steps going away and down. That was good. A tiny victory. A minuscule bit of control. Steps came back up. The straw in my mouth. I was desperately thirsty but I also needed to rinse away the lint and fluff of the awful old rag I'd been choking on for so long.
"Open your mouth."
A metal spoon was pushed into my mouth with something soft on it. Suddenly the idea of eating something I couldn't see, pushed into my mouth by this man who was going to kill me, was so disgusting that I imagined chewing on raw human flesh. I started to retch and spit. More swearing.
"Fucking eat or I'll cut the water off for a day."
A day. That was good. He wasn't planning to kill me today.
"Wait," I said, and took several deep breaths. "All right."
The spoon scraped in a bowl. I felt it in my mouth. I licked the food and swallowed it. It was something porridgy, but blander and smoother and slightly sweet. It tasted like one of those powdery bland mushes for babies. Or it might have been one of those concoctions that is given to convalescents, the sort you buy in a chemist's. I thought of gibbering glassy-eyed people sitting in hospital beds being spoon-fed by bored nurses. I swallowed and more food was pushed into my mouth. Four spoonfuls altogether. I wasn't being fattened, just kept alive. When I was finished I sucked more water through a straw.
"Pudding?" I said.
"No."
I had an idea. An important idea.
"When did we meet?"
"What do you mean?"
"Since I woke up here, I've had the most terrible headache. Was it you? Did you hit me?"
"What are you on about? Are you fucking me around? Don't you fuck me around. I could do anything to you."
"I'm not. I don't mean anything like that. The last thing I remember .. . I'm not even sure. It's all so blurred. I can remember being at work, I can remember .. ." I was going to say 'my boyfriend' but I thought that making him jealous, if that's what it would do, might not be a good idea. "I remember my flat. Doing something in my flat. I woke up here and I've no idea how I got here or how we met. I wanted you to tell me."
There was a long pause. I almost wondered if he had gone but then there was a whinnying sound, which I realized with a shock was a wheezing laugh.
"What?" I said. "What did I say? What?"
Keep talking. Maintain communication. I was thinking all the time. Thinking, thinking. Thinking to stay alive, and thinking to stop feeling, because I knew dimly that if I allowed myself to feel I would be throwing myself off a cliff into darkness.
"I've got you," he said.
"Got me?"
"You're wearing a hood. You're not seeing my face. You're being clever. If you can make me think you never saw me, then maybe I'll let you go." Another wheezing laugh. "You think about that, do you, while you're lying there? Do you think about going back to the world?"
I felt a lurch of misery that almost made me howl. But it also made me think. So we did meet. He didn't just grab me from behind in a dark alley and hit me over the head. Do I know this man? If I saw him, would I know his face? If he spoke naturally, would I recognize his voice?
"If you don't believe me, then it doesn't matter if you tell me again, does it?"
The rag was jammed into my mouth. I was lifted down and led over to the bucket. Carried back. Dumped on the ledge. No wire. I took that to mean that he wasn't going out of the building. I felt his breath close on my face, that smell.
"You're lying in here trying to work things
out. I like that. You're thinking that if you can make me believe that you can't identify me, I'll play with you for a while, then I'll let you go. You don't understand. You don't see the point. But I like it." I listened to his scraping whisper, trying to recall if the voice was in any way familiar. "They're different. Like Kelly, for example. Take Kelly." He rolled the name round in his mouth as if it was a piece of toffee. "She just cried and fucking cried all the time. Wasn't a bloody plan. Just crying. It was a bloody relief just to shut her up."
Don't cry, Abbie. Don't get on his nerves. Don't bore him.
The thought came to me out of the darkness. He's been keeping me alive. I didn't mean that he hadn't killed me. I had been in this room now for two or three or four days. You can live for weeks without food but how long can a human being survive without water? If I had just been locked in this room, unattended, I would be dead or dying by now. The water I'd gulped down had been his water. The food in my gut was his food. I was like an animal on his farm. I was his. I knew nothing about him. Outside this room, out in the world, this man was probably stupid, ugly, repulsive, a failure.
He might be too shy to talk to women, work mates might bully him. He could be the silent, weird one in the corner.
But here I was his. He was my lover and my father and my God. If he wanted to come in and quietly strangle me, he could. I had to devote every single waking second to thinking of ways to deal with him. To make him love me, or like me, or be scared of me. If he wanted to break down a woman before killing her, then I had to remain strong. If he hated women for their hostility, then I had to reassure him. If he tortured women who rejected him, then I had to ... what? Accept him? Which was the right choice? I didn't know.
Always and above all I had to stop myself believing that it probably didn't matter what I did.
I didn't count the time without the wire. It didn't seem to matter. But after a time he came back in. I felt his presence. A hand on my shoulder made me start. Was he checking I was still alive?
Two choices. I could escape in my mind. The yellow butterfly. Cool water. Water to drink, water to plunge into. I tried to re-create my world in my head. The flat. I walked through the rooms, looked at pictures on the wall, touched the carpet, named the objects on shelves. I walked around my parents' house. There were odd blanks. My father's garden shed, the drawers in Terry's desk. But still. So much in my head. So many things. In there and out there. But sometimes as I was wandering through these imaginary rooms, the floor would disappear from beneath my feet and I would fall. These mind games might be keeping me sane but I mustn't just keep sane. I must also keep alive. I must make plans. I wanted to kill him, I wanted to hurt, gouge, mash him. All I needed was an opportunity but I couldn't see any possibility of an opportunity.
I tried to imagine that he hadn't really killed anybody. He might be lying to scare me. I couldn't make myself believe it. He wasn't just making an obscene phone call. I was here, in this room. He didn't need to make up stories. I knew nothing about this man but I knew he had done this before. He had practised. He was in control.
The odds against me were bad. They were as bad as they could be. So any plan I could come up with didn't have to have a particularly good chance of success. But I couldn't think of any plan at all that had any chance of success. My only plan was to stretch it out as long as I could. But I didn't even know if I was stretching it out. I had a horrible feeling another horrible feeling, all my feelings were horrible that this was all on his timetable. All talk, all my feeble plans and strategies, was just noise in his ear like a mosquito buzzing around his head. When he was ready, he would slap it.
"Why do you do this?" "What?"
"Why me? What have I done to you?" A wheezing laugh. A rag stuffed in my mouth.
More knee pull-ups. I couldn't do more than sixteen. I was getting worse. My legs hurt. My arms ached.
Why me? I tried to stop myself asking the question but I couldn't. I've seen pictures of murdered women, in newspapers and on TV. But not murdered. Hardly ever. No. I'd seen them when they thought their lives were going to be ordinary. I suppose that when the families give the photos to the TV companies they choose the prettiest, smiliest pictures. They're probably from high-school yearbooks most of the time. But they're blown up larger than they were meant to be. It gives them a slightly blurry, creepy feel. They don't know what's going to happen to them and we do. We're not like them.
I couldn't believe that I was going to be one of them. Terry would go through my stuff and find a picture. Probably that stupid one I got for my passport last year in which I look as if I've got something trapped in one of my eyes and I'm smelling a bad smell simultaneously. He'll give it to the police and they'll blow it up so it looks all blurry and I'll be famous for being dead and it's so unfair.
I went through the unlucky women I knew. There was Sadie, who was left a month before Christmas by her boyfriend when she was nearly eight months pregnant. Marie has been in and out of hospital for her chemotherapy and has been wearing a headscarf. Pauline and Liz were made redundant from the firm when Laurence did the belt-tightening the year before last. He told them on a Friday evening when everybody had left, and when we came in on Monday morning they were gone. Even six months later Liz was still crying about it. They're all luckier than me. And some time in the next few days they'll know it. They'll hear about it and they'll each become mini-celebrities in their own right. They'll be saying to acquaintances, colleagues at work, with excitement covered with a thin layer of deepest sympathy, "You know that woman, Abbie Devereaux, the one in the papers? I knew her. I can't believe it." And they'll all be shocked and they'll all tell themselves secretly that they might have had their problems but at least they weren't Abbie Devereaux. Thank God that the lightning had struck her and not them.
But I am Abbie Devereaux and it's not fair.
He came in and slipped the wire around my throat. I was going to count this time. I'd been thinking about this, planning it. How would I stop myself losing count? I worked out a plan. Sixty seconds in a minute, sixty minutes in an hour. That's 3,600 seconds. I would imagine walking up a hill in a town beginning with A. A hill with 3,600 houses and I would count the houses as I walked past them. I couldn't think of a town beginning with A, though. Yes, Aberdeen. I walked up the hill in Aberdeen. One, two, three, four .. . When I got to the top of the hill in Aberdeen, I began again in Bristol. Then Cardiff, then Dublin, Eastbourne, Folkestone and then, when I was half-way up the hill in Gillingham, he was back in the room, the wire was slipped off my neck. Six and a half hours.
If you are in a hole, stop digging. A stitch in time saves nine. Don't cross a bridge till you come to it. Don't burn your bridges. Was that right, two sets of bridges? What else? Think, think, think. No use crying over spilt milk. Look before you leap. Too many cooks spoil the broth and many hands make light work and don't put all your eggs in one basket and birds of a feather flock together and one swallow doesn't make a summer. Red sky at night, shepherd's delight. My delight. But red sky in the morning, shepherd's warning. How many roads must a man walk down, before .. . ? No, that was something else. A song. A song not a saying. What was the tune? I tried to remember, to put music in my brain and to hear the sound in this dense and silent dark. No use.
Pictures were easier. A yellow butterfly on a green leaf. Don't fly away. A river, with fish in it. A lake of clear, clean water. A silver tree on a smooth hill, with its leaves furling in the breeze. What else? Nothing else. Nothing. I was too cold.
"Hello. I was hoping you would come soon."
"You haven't finished your water."
"There's no hurry, is there? There are so many things I wanted to ask you."
He made a faint guttural sound. I was shaking, but perhaps that was because I was so chilled. I couldn't imagine ever being warm again, or clean. Or free.
"I mean, here we are, two people alone in this place. We should get to know each other. Talk to each other." He said nothing. I couldn't tell if he
was even listening. I drew a breath and continued: "After all, you must have chosen me for a reason. You seem like a man who has reasons, is that right? You're logical, I think. I like that. Logical' Was logical a word? It sounded all wrong.
"Go on," he said.
Go on. Good. What should I say next? There was a sore patch above my lip. I put out the tip of my tongue to touch it; it felt like a cold sore. Perhaps my whole body was breaking out in sores and blisters. "Yes. Logical. Purposely." No. Definitely the wrong word. Try again. "Purposeful. You're someone who is strong. Am I right?" There was a silence. I could hear him breathing hoarsely. "Yes. I think I'm right. Men should be strong, though many are weak. Many," I repeated. "But I think you're lonely as well. People don't recognize your hopes. No, your strengths, I meant strengths, not hopes. Are you lonely?" But it was like dropping stones into a deep well. I spoke the stupid words and they disappeared into the darkness. "Or do you like being alone?"
"Maybe."
"We all need someone to love us, though," I said. "No one can be all alone." I would do anything to survive, I thought. I'd let him hold me and fuck me and I'd even pretend I liked it. Anything, to live. "And there must have been a reason you chose me, rather than somebody else."
"Do you want to hear what I think? Eh? Do you?" He put a hand on my thigh. He rubbed his hand up and down.
"Yes. Tell me." Oh, don't let me be sick and don't let me scream out loud.
"I think you haven't got a clue what you look like at the moment." He gave his wheezy laugh. "You think you can flirt with me, eh? Trap me like that, as if I'm stupid? But you've no idea what you look like, sweetheart. You don't look like a person at all. You haven't even got a face. You look like a-a-a thing. Or an animal. And you smell, too. You smell of piss and shit." He laughed once more, and his hand on my thigh tightened until he was pinching me hard and I cried out in pain and humiliation.
"Abbie, who tried so hard," he whispered. "Kelly who cried and Abbie who tried. I can make you into a rhyme. Cried, tried, died. It's all the same to me, in the end."
Cried, tried, died. Rhymes in the dark again. Time was running out. I knew it was. I imagined an hourglass with the sand falling through it in a steady stream. If you looked at it, the sand always seemed to fall faster as it reached the end.
