Was it possible for another man to enter the room while Mr. Thiroux was dozing and murder Anne? Of course it was. This is a house of ill repute, gentlemen. There are men of all station entering and exiting at all hours unencumbered. It is not without possibility that someone entered the house and was not seen or was seen and disregarded.
Mr. Thiroux had the misfortune to be in the wrong place and the wrong time, a victim of his own weakness and absinthism. He has been devastated by the death of Miss Donovan, burdened with guilt that he was incapable of helping her. Mr. Thiroux provided Miss Donovan with a proper Christian internment, which is not the act of a murderer.
Mr. Thiroux’s life rests in your hands, as does the future of our judicial system. There is no proof that beyond a reasonable doubt Mr. Thiroux committed this senseless crime, and it is your duty and responsibility to find him not guilty.
* * *
JURY SET TO DELIBERATE IN THIROUX TRIAL!
January 22, 1850- After instructions from the judge, the jury will go into seclusion to deliberate the verdict in the shocking and sometimes unbelievable trial of Mr. Jonathon Thiroux, accused of stabbing Anne Donovan seventeen times to her death. While it would seem the prosecution has a strong case, one can only speculate what a jury will decide. Mr. Thiroux is an attractive, quality member of our city’s society, a true peer to those sitting in the box, who has never displayed any violence in a public setting. It is hard for the mind to wrap itself around the concept that such a gentle artist could lift a bowie knife and strike with such ferocity and ill intent, especially when one looks into the frequently confused and sad eyes of the defendant.
If Mr. Thiroux is found guilty, anticipate the temperance and vigilance movements to gather steam and push their opposition to spirits, for if a man such as Jonathon Thiroux can kill under the influence, they would ask you to imagine it in the hands of the less gently bred. The prosecutor maintains that the question of the connection of alcohol to crime will be debated another day, and not through this case, but the majority will recognize that this is naïve. It is public outcry that forced the initial arrest, not justice for Miss Donovan, and from the beginning the question of the influence of alcohol on behavior has been indelibly wrapped around this case just as the oppressive heat of summer tendrils about our city.
* * *
Sara hung up the phone after purchasing her airline ticket and went to pack her suitcase, the unmistakable and irritating feeling of tears in her eyes yet again. She didn’t know why she felt like crying. She was angry, maybe irrationally so, given the length and depth of her relationship with Gabriel. She had no right to assume anything or to expect anything from him.
But she had. She did.
It made her angry at herself. She had wanted something from Gabriel, right from the beginning, without even being aware of it. She had thought he could provide it, only to discover that she really didn’t know him as well as she thought she did.
Tossing her suitcase on his bed, she started shoving random clothes into it, pulling her things out of his drawers. That upset her even more. She had actually unpacked her clothes into his drawers. Yet they’d never even had sex. How weird was that? She had allowed herself to get carried away by that friendship, that sense of comfort she felt with him. She’d made assumptions.
Now she felt like a fool.
Gabriel was tapping his absinthe spoons in the other room. She could hear the frantic, agitated rhythm of two spoons hitting the desk simultaneously. Absinthe. God. Why had he let her drink it when he knew exactly what it did? He’d admitted it had been his drink of choice prior to his sobriety.
It didn’t make sense. None of it made sense. Gabriel had withheld important information from her, had accused Rafe of murder, yet was perfectly willing to let her go to lunch and pal around with Rafe.
Sara leaned over Gabriel’s bed, which neither one of them had bothered to make after her marathon sleep session, to snag her pillow. She never traveled without her down pillow. Dragging it across the bed, she was irritated to see that one of Gabriel’s long caramel colored hairs was stuck to her white pillowcase. It was irrational, but seeing that made her absolutely furious. He wouldn’t have sex with her, but he could shed on her linens, depositing his DNA all over the place.
The random thought made her pause in the act of picking the hair off the pillow, her original intention to fling it down onto his pillow. Wait a minute. Tossing it defiantly back at him made no sense. It was his DNA. In her possession. Glancing towards the door, reassuring herself that he couldn’t see her, Sara took the hair and unzipped her makeup bag she had already slung into her suitcase. Wrapping the hair around a lipstick, she settled the tube and hair in the bottom of the bag and zipped the case back shut and jammed it in her purse. She could head down to Royal Street and mail it overnight to Jocelyn with the other samples so she could have the results sooner. Maybe Gabriel wasn’t curious to see what a comparison would show, but she was.
It wouldn’t change the past or the future, but she wanted to know if Jonathon Thiroux was a killer.
* * *
From the Court Records of the Willful Murder Trial of Anne Donovan, State of Louisiana vs. Jonathon Thiroux
January 23, 1850
Judge: We the jury find the defendant, Jonathon Thiroux, not guilty of murder in the first degree.
* * *
From the Court Records of the State of Florida vs. Dr. Rafe Marino
July 31, 2007
Judge: We the jury find the defendant, Rafe Marino, not guilty of murder in the first degree.
* * *
Gabriel pulled up to the terminal at the airport the next morning and put his car into park. When he glanced over to ask Sara what time her flight was supposed to arrive in Naples, she was already opening the passenger door and climbing out. Great. She was just going to grab her suitcase and leave without saying a word.
Turning his car off, he jumped out and beat her to the trunk of the car, pulling out her suitcase before she could. He set it on the ground and pulled the handle up, facing her. It had been a cold, quiet day and night with her avoiding speaking to him more than was absolutely necessary and he was frustrated. He missed her. Wanted to see her smile.
“Call me when you get in,” he said.
She just nodded. “Thanks for watching Angel.”
“Sure, no problem.”
The longing to touch her, to reassure, to make everything right again, was almost overwhelming. Gabriel clenched his fists and studied her, wanting her to see in his eyes what he couldn’t say in words. Wanted her to know that there was a million things he wanted to tell her but couldn’t. That she had stepped into his lonely life and made it better. Made him better. That he had met and known a lot of women, but that she was the only one who had ever made him feel such an acute longing, such true, deep love.
“You’re coming back, aren’t you?” he asked.
“Probably.”
“Probably? No, you need to come back.” He wanted a commitment, a promise. Needed to hear that she would be back, and soon. She wouldn’t leave her kitten with him permanently, he was positive of that, but he wanted her to return to be with him, not just to collect the cat.
“Why should I come back?” Her head tilted and she was asking so much more. She was asking for all the answers, for everything.
He gave her all he could. “Because I want you to.”
Sara sighed.
Gabriel ground his teeth together, desire, frustration, love all spilling up and over and making him want to kick her suitcase. Or more accurately, to pull Sara into his arms and kiss her senseless.
Instead he settled for a watered down nothing of a kiss that he brushed over her forehead and a muttered, “Be careful,” before he turned and walked away, afraid of what else he might say or do.
Afraid that if she asked again, he would tell. Touch.
But when he got in the car and looked in the rearview mirror, she was already walking through the airpor
t doors, without a single glance back, and he was regretful anyway.
Either way, he was going to lose, and he hated it.
* * *
Rafe wasn’t home. In fact, it looked like he had moved out. Sara stood on the front walk of his condo and glanced around. Everything was quiet. The blinds were partially open and there was no furniture in his dining room.
He had left. Without telling her.
Stunned and hurt, Sara felt more tears pricking her eyes. Damn it, she hated to cry, and she’d been on the verge for twenty-four hours.
She wouldn’t do it.
Taking a deep breath, she called Rafe, leaving a voicemail for him to call her back when he didn’t pick up.
She turned to head back to her rental car and to Jocelyn’s apartment where she was staying, when she almost collided with a woman with dark hair and big sunglasses. “Oh! Sorry.”
“It’s okay.” The woman smiled. “You’re Sara, aren’t you?”
Anyone knowing her name made her wary anymore, so Sara said cautiously, “Do I know you?” She didn’t recognize the woman, but the sunglasses make it harder to see her features. Sara would estimate the woman was in her late twenties, and that she had money, given her sundress and expensive handbag. She had a firm, curvy figure, and her dress was flattering, her demeanor confident and sensual.
“No. I’m Rafe’s girlfriend.”
Sara took an instinctive step back and said, “What?” Since when the hell did Rafe have a girlfriend? Her mother was his girlfriend.
“I’m Marguerite.” She stuck out her hand. “Rafe’s told me a lot about you.”
He’d told her jackshit about Marguerite. Sara took her hand and shook it lightly. “Where is he, by the way?” She couldn’t force a nice to meet you platitude because she really had no goddamn interest in meeting the woman who had replaced her mother in Rafe’s life.
She was angry. It had been a year already, and she understood that eventually he would move on, but it seemed too soon. She hadn’t moved on, not yet. How had he? Plus he’d been on trial for murder. When the hell had he been dating?
“He’s moved in with me. I just stopped over to pick up his mail. It’s not being forwarded correctly.”
“Oh, I see. Well.” Sara had no clue what the hell to say. “I just left him a voice mail, but tell him I said hello. I’ll only be in town for two days if he wants to give me a call.” She had wanted to see him, but now she wasn’t sure she did.
“I’m sure he’ll want to talk to you. Maybe we can go out to dinner.”
So the three of them could discuss how he’d been tried for her mother’s murder? Yeah, that sounded like good times. “Sure. Lovely.” She was such a bad liar and she wanted away from whoever the hell her name was. “Nice meeting you. I have an appointment I have to run to.”
Sara waved and started towards her car.
The woman called after her, “I’ll see you soon. And say hi to Gabriel for me.”
That brought Sara to a grinding halt. Heart pounding, she turned around, wondering if she could have possibly just heard that. The woman was already walking in the opposite direction across the parking lot, her back to Sara, too far away to question.
But she’d heard that name, coming from that strange woman’s lips. No question about it.
The real question was how in the hell could Rafe’s new girlfriend know Gabriel St. John?
Chapter Seventeen
Gabriel picked his way down the narrow alley next to the house on Dauphine Street, tromping through brush and over a random pile of bricks. Ending up behind the house, he assessed windows and the door. Unlike some of the neighboring houses, this one still had the original wooden pane windows and no evidence of a deadbolt on the door. While not dilapidated, it was easily one of the shabbier houses on the block, paint peeling, and various rusted out pieces of furniture and car parts strewn across the small back courtyard.
Deciding the easiest approach was the door, Gabriel went up the brick step, turned the knob, and shoved, using his immortal strength. The lock gave and the door swung open with a slight squeak. Stepping in, Gabriel paused to get his bearings. This room was a kitchen now. Gabriel couldn’t remember how it had been used in The House of Rest, but it looked like it had been modernized in the eighties. The cabinets were dark, the walls a ruddy yellow, a red fruit themed wallpaper border hung above the cabinets.
The overall affect was tired and gloomy, the original charm of the transom over the door, the thick moldings, and the wood floor lost under the influence of the drop ceiling and the muted yellow countertops. But someone was obviously in residence, since there was a dirty coffee mug in the sink, and a sticky spoon on the countertop.
Moving forward through the kitchen door into the next room, Gabriel saw a half bathroom had been added in the corner, and the room was being used as an office, a desk and bookcase prominent in the small room. The house was shotgun style, with the rooms leading off of each other, and no central hallways. When he moved into the front room, he recognized it as the original parlor, where he had entered so many nights all those years ago from the street. At some point it had been painted a mauve color, which offended his artistic sensibilities in the extreme, and the floor was carpeted in a periwinkle blue, but beyond that, the room was unchanged. The fireplace and moldings were intact, and the front windows still had traditional shutters.
He could see it, the way it had looked then, with its scarlet sofas and peeling wallpaper, smoke hanging in the air, the woman spilling out of their gowns, perched on the laps of men as they watched them play cards, waiting for the moment when the wine and the winning would cease, and the gentlemen would seek comfort upstairs. Gabriel could still hear the random and sour notes being pounded out on an out-of-tune piano that Madame had won in a game of keno, and could only marvel now how the level of his tolerance for depravity and disgusting surroundings had increased in conjunction with his addiction.
While it wasn’t as crass as it had been as a cheap bordello, it wasn’t a well-loved house either. Most of the structure and decor looked like it hadn’t been bothered with in a good twenty years. The stairs had also been carpeted in the offensive blue, and the railings a dirty white that begged for fresh paint. Gabriel jogged quickly up the stairs, knowing that what he was looking for was waiting for him.
The succession of little rooms seemed to have been consolidated into two larger bedrooms and a bathroom. But oddly enough, or maybe appropriately so, Anne’s little room at the end of the hallway had been left untouched, serving as a minute guest room with a daybed.
* * *
“John, isn’t my room just lovely?” Anne asked him, quite serious, a smile on her face as she spun around and fell backwards onto her bed. She gave a contented sigh, surveying her tiny domain.
He thought the room was a stuffy little hole in the wall, the plaster crumbling, the sheets yellow with age, the dressing table chipped and wobbly, the shutters missing slats. It had the odor of damp and a thick layer of dust on the baseboards and there was absolutely nothing lovely about it.
Madame was charging him too much for it, but he didn’t really care if he was being fleeced. Money was only money, and Anne had his absinthe. It didn’t matter where he drank it and the room was enough to please Anne.
“Not as lovely as you,” he said. “Pour my drink then let me sketch you.” He wanted to capture that smile, that satisfaction on her face.
Maybe if he captured it, he could figure out how to create it for himself.
* * *
Raphael was sitting on the daybed, cross-legged, a stack of papers in his hand, more on the mattress next to him. “Hello, Gabriel,” he said without looking up. “I figured I would see you sooner or later.”
Gabriel stepped into the room, the floor creaking beneath his boots. “Raphael. I assume you know why I’m here.”
Setting his papers aside, Raphael sighed and looked up, his expression calm. Gabriel had been expecting anger, disdain, sarcasm, maybe
a sick satisfaction. But he saw none of that on the demon’s face. “I think you are planning to tell me to stay away from Sara Michaels.”
“To start with.” Gabriel had other thoughts as well, but first he wanted to hear what Raphael had to say. “Are you going to agree quietly or do I have to convince you?”
There was nothing but a shrug. Raphael’s passivity was unnerving. Gabriel had arrived expecting, anticipating a battle. He had a sheath knife in his back pocket, prepared to kill Raphael if he had to, knowing full well only an immortal could kill another immortal.
But the man he had come to think of as his nemesis, the one who had taken Anne’s life, making him doubt his own innocence, his soul, his very self, and had hurt Sara in ways that could never be repaired by killing her mother, just sat there hunched over in khaki cargo shorts and a red golf shirt.
“I’ll stay away from Sara because I don’t want her to get hurt,” Raphael said. “I never wanted to hurt her, and I’m sorry that she has been affected by all of this… by me. I came here to watch her, to protect her. I admit I was surprised that she was with you… I didn’t anticipate that, but I figured it was a good thing. With both of us watching out for her, she should be safe, right? She is safe, isn’t she? Where is she?”
Confused, Gabriel just stared at Raphael. What the hell was he talking about? Safe from who? It didn’t sound like the words of a man who had sent her pictures of her mother’s crime scene, but Gabriel was wary of drawing any conclusions. “She’s safe. Why do you care?”
Raphael propped his chin up with his hand. “I care about Sara… she’s a wonderful person. Kind, giving, and she loved her mother even though Jessie had her fair share of problems. I should have stayed away from both of them.”
Dark Secrets: A Paranormal Romance Anthology Page 54
