by Sam Bourne
‘Can you initial here, please? That means you understand that you have the right to remain silent. OK. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. Do you understand?’
‘This is a simple mistake—’
‘Do you understand? That’s all I’m asking right now. Do you understand the words I am saying? If you do, then initial the goddamn form.’
Will said no more as Fitzwalter got to the end of the form, telling him his rights. Once it was initialled, the detective pushed it to one side.
‘OK, now that you know your rights, do you wish to talk to us?’
‘Don’t I get to make a phone call?’
‘It’s the middle of the night. Who you gonna call?’
‘Do I have to tell you?’
‘No,’ said the detective, taking the phone from the back table and stretching its cord to place it on the desk between them. ‘Just tell me the number you want me to dial.’
Will knew there was only one person he could possibly call but the idea was appalling. How could he, with this news? He looked at his watch. 2.15am. Fitzwalter was getting impatient.
Will dictated the number. The detective dialled it, then handed him the phone — staying firmly in his seat. It was clear he was going to listen in on every word. Finally, Will heard the voice he was wanting and dreading to hear.
‘Hello? Dad?’
CHAPTER FIFTY-FOUR
Monday, 3.06am, Manhattan
‘I have good news and bad news for you, Mr Monroe.’ It was Fitzwaiter. ‘Which would you like first?’
Will lifted his eyes slowly. He had spent only forty minutes in this cell, but it felt like forty nights. His father had told him to invoke the first of the rights he had been read and to say nothing. Once Fitzwalter was certain Will was not going to crack, and that the interview was over, he had him locked up.
‘The good news is that His Honour Judge William Monroe Senior has telephoned to say he is on his way in from Sag Harbor.’
His father’s voice floated back into Will’s head now, as audible as it had been when he made that call. Sleepy, then shocked, then stern, then disappointed, then purposeful. Since Will had spent his youth three thousand miles away from his father, he had never gone through that teenage rite of passage: announcing’ to your father that you have in some way betrayed his trust. Dad, I trashed the car. Dad, I got caught smoking dope. These were sentences he had never had to utter. He had never heard his father say, as all his contemporaries had, ‘Son, you’ve let me down.’ So to hear it now — not the words, but that tone — was an extra ordeal, to be piled on top of all the others.
‘Mr Monroe, are you listening to me?’
‘Sorry?’
‘You’ve had the good news. Don’t you want to hear the bad news?’
‘Not really, no.’
‘The bad news is, I’ve just come off the phone with the duty lawyer at the Times. He’s made some calls and guess what? They don’t think you’re on assignment for them at all. In fact, what they say is that you’re taking a few days “rest”. By order of the editor himself. Sounds like you got yourself in a whole pile of trouble, my friend.’
Will cupped his hands over his eyes. What a basic error: to offer a lie that could so easily be disproved. His legal defence was already compromised. He had made that cardinal mistake of all guilty men: he had changed his story. As for his career, that was surely over. He would be suspended ‘in order to defend himself on these grave charges’ — and then quietly dropped.
The door slammed shut. In some strange way, Will almost felt grateful to be in this cell. Ever since Friday morning, he had been on the move, feverishly rushing from one place to another, from one new plan to the next. He had criss-crossed the city, in and out, either to Brooklyn or Long Island or back again, trying to think, to focus, to act. Even when sitting down, he had been willing the train or cab to go faster, to get there now, or praying for the phone to ring or an email to arrive.
Now there was nowhere he could go and nothing he could do. The scheming and thinking and frantic calculating were at an end. His jailers had not even allowed him a pencil and paper.
The pause let in the realization he had been resisting for days. Any time it had broken surface in the last nearly seventy two hours, Will had pushed it back down. But now he had no strength for the task.
Everything was falling apart. That was the conclusion he had refused to face, but which was now too strong to resist.
His wife was missing, a captive of men whose fanaticism ran deep. He was about to be charged with murder, facing a pile of circumstantial evidence that would be hard to refute.
Worse still, he had fallen for a classic set-up.
After all, who had sent him to that building in the middle of the night? Was he really meant to believe it was just a coincidence that a brutal murder was in progress the minute he appeared on the scene? And how strange that the killer should almost certainly have taken refuge in, of all places, a Hassidic synagogue.
All that guff about fearing for the end of the world. They were bringing it about themselves! Will and TC had cottoned onto their plot, so Freilich had had to come up with some bullshit about ‘whoever is behind this’ blah, blah. Will’s first instinct had been right. There was no ‘they’. The Hassidim had found the identities of these righteous men and now, for some warped reason of their own, they wanted them dead. Will was getting in the way. What better way to take him out of circulation than to have him picked up not by them, but by the police! Will had to hand it to them: it was masterful.
How funny to think that a matter of days ago the central force in his life had been his career. His career! It was now in shreds: he had been caught engaged in gross misconduct by the editor himself. And now he had lost all standing in the eyes of the only man whose opinion really mattered: his father. He saw that now with great clarity. Of course it was bound to have affected him, growing up all those years without a dad. He felt it every day. Cricket games, when other boys were getting cheered from the boundary. Sports days, when he had no one to cheer in the fathers’ race. People used to ask if his dad was dead.
He had gone through all the phases. He had been angry with his father; he had resented him; he had, on occasion, joined forces with his mother in hating him. But mainly he had missed him. He had missed the thing he had seen other boys get every day from their fathers: a hand on the shoulder, a tousle of the hair, a gesture that constituted male approval. Now, in this prison cell, unfogged by ambiguity and nuance, he saw more starkly than ever before why he had crossed the Atlantic and changed his life. He had come to seek his father’s approval. It was not going to find him sitting in London; he would have to come to America to get it for himself.
He had had a plan too. He would be the bright young man in a hurry, Will Monroe, Oxford star, come to make a splash in New York City. He had imagined the day, perhaps ten years from now, when he would wear black tie, lean into a microphone positioned a few inches too low for a man of his height, and thank the Pulitzer judges for their belief in him. This very week — on the front page, twice — it had even seemed within reach. Yet now he was an exhausted wreck. The woman he loved, and the future he dreamed of, had vanished.
Even as he engaged in this mental audit, he could feel a nagging intrusion — one more thought demanding to break the surface. Will had been pushing it below the waves more vigorously than the rest; he was hoping it would sink.
It forced itself up. What if the Hassidim are right? What if the moment the thirty-six men are killed, the world is no longer upheld? Everything about this wild theory had stacked up so far. The Chancellor really had performed an act of stunning goodness. So had Baxter. And they were disguised just as Mandelbaum said they would be. Could all the detail be right, but the idea itself be wrong?
Tonight he had witnessed, or just missed, the murder of a man who may well have been a tzaddik, one of thirty-six righteous ones. If that’s who this man was, then it would be
one more confirmation that the Hassidim were telling the truth — or at least part of it. It would also mean the killers of the lamad vav were getting very close to their goal. He looked at his watch: from what TC had told him, Yom Kippur would be over in about sixteen hours. They had so little time.
He had to know: was the man in that building a tzaddik, as the Hassidim had predicted? For the first time in hours, Will had an idea.
Some time later, the cell door opened again. Will braced himself to see his father. But it was Fitzwalter.
‘Come with me.’
‘Where am I going?’
‘You’ll see.’
Will was led downstairs, into a room with bright fluorescent lights. There were seven or eight other men there. At least three of them looked to be stoned; he guessed several were homeless. The door was slammed shut.
‘OK, gentlemen,’ said a voice over a loud-speaker. ‘If you can all take your places against the back wall.’ Two of the men in the group seemed to know exactly what to do, casually walking to the back, then standing and staring straight ahead. It was then Will saw the markings on the wall, indicating height. This was a line-up, an identity parade.
On the other side of the one-way mirror Mrs Tina Perez of the Greenstreet Mansions apartment building stared at the men arrayed before her.
‘I know it’s been a long night, Mrs Perez,’ Fitzwalter was saying. ‘So you just take your time. When you’re ready, I have two questions to ask.’
‘I’m ready.’
‘I want you to look really hard and tell me whether you’ve seen any of these men before and, if you have, where you’ve seen them. OK? Is that clear?’
‘The answer’s no. I haven’t seen any of these men before. The man I saw had eyes you couldn’t forget.’
‘You’re absolutely certain, Mrs Perez?’
‘I’m certain. He had his hands around poor Mr Bitensky’s neck and he looked up at me with those eyes. Those terrible eyes—’
‘It’s OK, Mrs Perez. Please don’t distress yourself. Jeannie, you can take Mrs Perez home now. Thank you.’
‘OK, show in Mrs Abdulla.’
***
Will was spared the encounter with his father he had feared. Twenty minutes after the line-up, Fitzwalter had come into the cell.
‘More good news and bad news. The bad news for me is that two witnesses say you were not the man they saw in Mr Bitensky’s apartment. One of them did recognize you in the line-up. She places you at the apartment building standing outside at the time of the killing. So the good news for you is that I’m going to have to let you go. For now.’
There were forms to fill in, so that Will’s things could be released. He pounced on his cell phone first, powering it up. Instantly it began vibrating: a voice message. TC.
‘Hi, guess what. As predicted, I am in police custody. They’re questioning me about the murder of Mr Pugachov. It seems he was shot, at point-blank range. Can you believe this? In my apartment? That sweet, gentle man. And I can’t bear to think it’s all because …What? Oh God, I’m sorry. Sorry, Will, that’s Joel Brookstein. Do you remember him? He was at Columbia. Anyway, he’s agreed to be my lawyer. He’s telling me to shut my mouth. Let me know where you are and what’s happening. Not sure if they’ll let me keep this phone on.’ Her voice faded, as if she needed to talk over her shoulder. ‘All right, I’m coming. One minute! Will, I’m going to have to go. Call me as soon as you can. We don’t have much time.’
As he listened to her voice — which now seemed to oscillate between TC and Tova Chaya — he heard a double beep.
A text message. He pressed the buttons.
Paul, sort the letters of no Christian! (1,7,29)
In the bombardment of the last few hours, Will had almost forgotten about the phantom texter. In his mind, he still associated these messages with Yosef Yitzhok, even though he knew, rationally, that was impossible. This latest text was definitive proof: someone else had been giving Will these coded clues all along. But who?
The meaning of this latest message seemed almost within reach. Forty-eight hours of communication with this man had given Will some sense of the workings of his mind. This must be how crossword addicts do it, Will thought: after a while, they insert themselves into the head of the crossword setter.
And this did indeed look like a crossword clue. Surely, the literal meaning was irrelevant. He knew how such clues worked, with instructions in one part relating to the rest. But who was Paul? And why did the solution include a word twenty-nine letters long?
He would start with the most obvious bit, following the instruction to ‘sort the letters’, to reorder, ‘no Christian’. With the recklessness of a newly free man, he grabbed a pen from the desk clerk’s table and scribbled on the back of the receipt she had just handed him.
On Ian Christ. That did not work. Con this rain. That was not much better.
And then he saw it, smiling his first smile in hours. How perfect that this message should arrive just as he was alone, without TC. The one area where he would have greater knowledge than her.
He picked up the phone to call his father. To tell him the good news that he had been released without charge and ask him to stop on his way, maybe at a hotel, and pick up the one thing that Will realized he would need: a bible.
CHAPTER FIFTY-FIVE
Monday, 4.40am, Manhattan
For a minute, he thought about asking the desk sergeant. Then he reconsidered. It would not look great, a dishevelled murder suspect, alternately ranting about the identity of the true killer — ‘He has piercing blue eyes!’ — and then demanding to read the bible. Fine if Will was guilty and pursuing a ‘diminished responsibility’ defence; not so great for a man who wanted to walk out of the seventh precinct having convinced the police he was both innocent and sane.
Instead he waited for his father pacing outside, desperate to get away. Finally William Monroe Sr, dressed in a battered sailing jacket, appeared. He looked exhausted, his eyes ringed in red. Will wondered if he had been crying.
‘Thank God, William,’ he said, hugging his son, his hand cupping the back of his head. ‘I wondered what on earth you’d done.’
‘Thanks for that vote of confidence, Dad,’ said Will, pulling away. ‘No time to talk. Do you have the thing I asked you to bring?’
His father nodded, a gesture of sad surrender, as if he was humouring a son who was babbling about the voices in his head or demanding a hundred bucks for another fix of crack. ‘Here.’
Will pounced on the bible. ‘OK, Dad. You know those text messages I’ve been getting? Well, here’s the latest.’ Will held up his cell phone.
Sort the letters of no Christian! (1,7,29)
‘What could that mean?’
Hurriedly, Will explained. ‘No Christian is an anagram for Corinthians. The figure I refers to Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians — and it must be Chapter 7, Verse 29. Which is why I wanted a bible. And here it is.’
What I mean, brothers, is that the time is short.
‘He’s getting desperate.’
‘Will—’
‘Hold on, Dad. I just want to prove something to you. Now, I know how bizarre this will sound, but at the heart of this whole, fucked-up business seems to be a Jewish religious theory. It centres on men of exceptional goodness.’ He could see his father’s face moving from pity to impatience.
‘Will, what on earth are you talking about? The police brought you here on suspicion of murder tonight. Do you have any idea of the trouble you’re in?’
‘Oh yes, Dad, believe me. I know that I am in the deepest shit imaginable. Deeper than you think. But please hear me out on this. The Hassidim who are holding Beth say that someone — it may even be one of them for all I know — is killing good people. Extraordinarily good people. Not just here, but all over the world. What happened tonight is that I came this close to witnessing one of those killings. If the Hassidim’s theory is right, the man who was murdered tonight will be a so-calle
d righteous man. Which is why I wanted you to see this.’
He took his BlackBerry out of the police zip-loc bag, clicked on the internet browser and selected Google. Then he punched in the words ‘Bitensky and Lower East Side’.
Google was searching, not fast on this handheld machine. Finally, a page of search results. A biomedical website, something about a classical pianist. And then a link to Downtown Express, ‘the weekly newspaper of lower Manhattan’. He clicked on it, waited an age for the page to load and then scrolled down. It was an archive item from a couple of years ago. He prayed for it to be something of substance, something which might prove to Monroe Sr that his son was not completely deranged.
Residents of the Greenstreet area endured a chilly start to the Passover season this week, when their apartment building was evacuated for a fire alert Tuesday.
It was after midnight when scores of residents filed together into the park, as fire crews examined the building before declaring it was safe to re-enter.
While most folks were clothed only in pyjamas and robes, one group were fully dressed — since they had been taking part in the traditional seder that often continues until the early hours.
They were guests ofJudah Bitensky, one of the the last Jewish residents of a building that was once a hub for the East Broadway Jewish community. It appears that Mr Bitensky, janitor at one of the area’s remaining synagogues, hosts an annual seder meal at his home — inviting all those who have no other home to go to.
‘It’s kind of a tradition,’ said Irving Tannenbaum, 66 and a regular. ‘Every year Judah opens his door to people like us.
Some of the crowd are elderly and live alone. Some are, you know, street people. It’s quite a scene in there.’
Riwy Gold, 51 and homeless, added, ‘It’s the best meal I get all year. This is the one night I feel like I have family.’
Downtown Express counted twenty-six people heading back into Mr Bitensky’s tiny apartment — including three in wheelchairs and two on crutches. Reluctant to give an interview to a reporter, Mr Bitensky was asked how he was able to feed so many, despite living on a meager income himself. ‘Somehow I manage,’ he said. I don’t quite know how.’
