by Cathy Gohlke
Much of the distance between Maureen and Katie Rose is initially due to assumptions they’ve made about each other. What other conflicts and misunderstanding arise as the story progresses to drive them further apart? As the elder sister, should Maureen have handled these situations differently? Do you think it would have made a difference?
In the midst of her conflict with Katie Rose, Maureen thinks, You’ve made a god of your fear and jealousy, Sister. For what is a god but what we go to again and again? Do you agree that Katie Rose has made a god of her negative feelings? Have you ever found yourself returning again and again to a similar “god”—whether a person, achievement, emotion, etc.?
When Olivia expresses doubts about using her love of writing, Curtis asks her, “Why would God gift you with a love of something—and an ability, I have no doubt—unless He intended for you to use it?” Do you agree with his perspective? Have you seen God bring connections between your abilities and His purposes for your life? Are there passions you possess that haven’t yet found an outlet?
Do you think most of the women in the Ladies’ Circle grasped Olivia’s early challenge to ask, “What would Jesus do?” in every situation? If not, what initiated the change, and what factors influenced their decisions about what to do? What do you think about accepting the same challenge? How would it change your life?
Many characters in Band of Sisters struggle with issues of social justice and how to personally address them. Do you? How do you think the Lord looks at issues of social justice, and why? Are there Scriptures, Bible stories or principles, or other factors that help you draw your conclusion?
It has been reported that the number of humans trafficked in its many forms today is greater by far than the number trafficked at the height of the transatlantic slave trade. Does that surprise you? Discuss the various forms of modern-day slavery and human trafficking of which you are aware.
The characters in Band of Sisters operated within the legal and (sometimes) social restrictions of their time and within the opportunities they perceived as theirs. In what ways did they use their influence and opportunities to create change? (Consider the women in the circle, the immigrants, the women working at Darcy’s, Curtis, Joshua.) What opportunities do we have that the characters didn’t? In what ways can we influence change on a local, national, or global level to end slavery?
Among some of the women in the circle there was an attitude that the poor bring their poverty, abuse, and exploitation on themselves and that they should be grateful for whatever they receive from benefactors. The women also expressed fears or reservations about bringing the poor into their lives and homes. Have you ever shared feelings like these? If so, why? After reading and discussing Band of Sisters, have your views changed?
How did Jesus respond to women who were caught in forms of bondage or were hurting or broken? Consider the woman with the issue of blood (Mark 5); the Samaritan woman at the well (John 4); the woman accused of wasting valuable spikenard to anoint Jesus rather than selling it to give to the poor (Matthew 26); Martha and Mary at the death of Lazarus (John 11); Mary Magdalene, from whom seven devils were cast (Mark 16, John 20). Can you think of other examples that display God’s heart toward women?
Once men, women, or children are freed from slavery, they often need help to heal and adjust to society. What organizations do you know of in your community to help support these individuals? What needs continue? How can you personally contribute?
Do you believe the church has a responsibility in working to end modern-day slavery? Why or why not?
How did the men in Band of Sisters reflect the worth of the women around them—both positively and negatively? What are some examples you’ve witnessed of the ways men value or demean women? How can we (men and women) help to encourage the boys in our lives and communities toward healthy perspectives on women?
The great ship returned late from her sea trials beyond the shores of Carrickfergus, needing only her sea papers, a last-minute load of supplies, and the Belfast mail before racing to Southampton.
But in that rush to ferry supplies, a dockworker’s hand was crushed beneath two heavy crates carelessly dropped. The fury and swearing that followed reddened the neck of the toughest man aboard the sturdy supply boat.
Michael Dunnagan’s eyes and ears spread wide with all the fascination of his fifteen years.
“You there! Lad! Do you want to make a shilling?”
Michael, who’d stolen the last two hours of the day from his sweep’s work to run home and scrub before seeing Titanic off, turned at the gruff offer, certain he’d not heard with both ears.
“Are you deaf, lad? Do you want to make a shilling, I say!” the mate aboard the supply craft called again.
“I do, sir! I do!” Michael vowed, propelled by wonder and a fear the man might change his mind.
“Give us a hand, then. My man’s smashed his paw, and we’ve got to get these supplies aboard Titanic. She’s late from her trials and wants to be under way!”
Michael could not move his feet from the splintered dock. For months he’d slipped from work to steal glimpses of the lady’s growing. He’d spied three years ago as her magnificent keel was laid and had checked week by week as ribs grew into skeleton, as metal plates formed sinew and muscle to strengthen her frame, as decks and funnels fleshed her out. He’d speculated on her finishing, the sure beauty and mystery of her insides. He had cheered, with most of Belfast, as she’d been gently pulled from her berth that morning by tugboats so small with names so mighty that the contrast was laughable.
To stand on the dock and see her sitting low in the water, her sleek lines lit by electric lights against the cold spring twilight, was a wonder of its own. The idea of stepping onto her polished deck—and being paid to do it—was joyous beyond anything in Michael’s ken.
But his uncle Tom was aboard Titanic in the stoker hole, shoveling coal for her mighty engines. Michael had snuck to the docks to celebrate the parting from his uncle’s angry fists and lashing belt as much as he’d come to see Titanic herself. He’d never dared to defend himself against the hateful man twice his size, but Michael surely meant to spit a final good-bye.
“Are you coming or not?” the dockhand barked.
“Aye!” Michael dared the risk and jumped aboard the supply boat, trying for the nimble footing of a sailor rather than the clunky feet of a sweep. Orders were shouted from every direction. Fancy chairs, crates of food, and kitchen supplies were stowed in every conceivable space. Mailbags flew from hands on dock to hands on deck. As soon as the lines were tossed aboard, the supply craft fairly flew through the harbor.
Staff of Harland and Wolff—the ship’s designers and builders—firemen, and yard workers not sailing to Southampton stood on Titanic’s deck, ready to be lightered ashore. The supply boat pulled alongside her.
Michael bent his head, just in case Uncle Tom was among those sent ashore, though he figured it unlikely. He hefted the low end of a kitchen crate and followed it aboard Titanic, repeating in his mind the two words of the only prayer he remembered: Sweet Jesus. Sweet Jesus. Sweet Jesus.
“Don’t be leaving them there!” An authoritarian sort in blue uniform bellowed at the load of chairs set squarely on the deck. “Bring those along to the first-class reception room!”
Michael dropped the kitchen crate where he stood. Sweeping a wicker chair clumsily beneath each arm, he followed the corridor-winding trail blazed by the man ahead of him.
He clamped his mouth to keep it from trailing his toes. Golden oak, carved and scrolled, waxed to a high sheen, swept past him. Fancy patterned carpeting in colors he would have wagered grew only in flowers along the River Shannon made him whistle low. Mahogany steps, grand beyond words, swept up, up to he didn’t know where.
He caught his breath at the domed skylight above it all.
Lights, so high he had to crane his neck to see, and spread wider than a man could stretch, looked for all the world to Michael like layers of icicles
and stars, twinkling, dangling one set upon the other.
But Michael gasped as his eyes traveled downward again. He turned away from the center railing, feeling heat creep up his neck. Why the masters of Titanic wanted a statue of a winged and naked child to hold a lamp was more than he could imagine.
“Oy! Mind what you’re about, lad!” A deckhand wheeled a skid of crates, barely missing Michael’s back. “If we scrape these bulkheads, we’re done for. I’ll not be wanting my pay docked because a gutter rat can’t keep his head.”
“I’ll mind, sir. I will, sir.” Michael took no offense. He considered himself a class of vermin somewhat lower than a gutter rat. He swallowed and thought, But the luckiest vermin that ever lived!
“Set them round here,” the fussy man ordered. Immediately the first-class reception room was filled with men and chairs and confounding directions. A disagreement over the placement of chairs broke out between two argumentative types in crisp uniforms.
The man who’d followed close on Michael’s heels stepped back, muttering beneath his breath, “Young bucks busting their britches.” A minute passed before he shook his head and spoke from the side of his mouth. “Come, me boyo. We’ll fetch another load. Blathering still, they’ll be.”
But as they turned, the men in uniform forged an agreement and called for Michael to rearrange the chairs. Michael stepped lively, moved each one willingly, deliberately, and moved a couple again, only to stay longer in the wondrous room.
But as quickly as the cavernous room had filled, it emptied. The last of the uniformed men was summoned to the dining room next door, and Michael stood alone in the vast hall.
He started for the passageway, then stopped. He knew he should return to the deck with the other hands and finish loading supplies. But what if he didn’t? What if he just sat down and took his ease? What if he dared stay in the fine room until Titanic reached Southampton? What if he then walked off the ship—simply walked into England?
Michael’s brow creased in consternation. He sucked in his breath, nearly giddy at the notion: to leave Belfast and Ireland for good and all, never again to feel Uncle Tom’s belt or buckle lashed across his face or shoulders.
And there was Jack Deegan to consider. When Deegan had injured his back aboard his last ship, he’d struck a bargain with Uncle Tom. Deegan had eagerly traded his discharge book—a stoker’s ticket aboard one of the big liners—for Uncle Tom’s flat and Michael’s sweep wages for twelve months. As cruel as his uncle had always been, experience made Michael fear being left alone with Jack Deegan even more.
To walk away from Uncle Tom, from Jack Deegan, from the memory of these miserable six years past, and even from the guilt and shame of failing Megan Marie—it was a dream, complex and startling. And it flashed through Michael’s mind in a moment.
He swallowed. Uncle Tom would be in the stoker hole or firemen’s quarters while aboard ship. Once in Southampton he would surely spend his shore leave at the pubs. Michael could avoid him for this short voyage.
“Sweet Jesus,” Michael whispered again, his heart drumming a beat until it pounded the walls of his chest. He had begged for years, never believing his prayers had been heard or would be answered.
Michael waited half a minute. When no one came, he crept cautiously across the room, far from the main entry, and slid, the back side of a whisper, beneath the table nearest the wall.
What’s the worst they could do to me? he wondered. Send me back? Throw me to the sharks? He winced. It was a fair trade.
Minutes passed and still no one came. Shrill whistle blasts signaled Titanic’s departure from the harbor. Michael wondered if the mate who’d hired him had missed him, or if he’d counted himself lucky to be saved the bargained shilling. He wondered if Uncle Tom or Jack Deegan would figure out what he’d done, hunt him down, and drag him back. He wondered if it was possible the Sweet Jesus listened to the prayers of creatures lower than gutter rats after all.
“I simply cannot keep the child alone with me any longer,” Eleanor Hargrave insisted, stabbing her silver-handled cane into the pile of the Persian carpet spread across her drawing room floor. “While I am yet able to travel, I am determined to tour the Continent. My dear cousins in Berlin have been so very patient, awaiting my visit while I served my father, then raised your father’s orphaned child.”
It was the story of martyrdom Owen had heard from his spinster aunt month after month, year after year, designed and never failing to induce guilt. It was the story of her life of sacrifice and grueling servitude, first to her widowed and demanding father, whom her younger sister had selfishly deserted, and then to the orphaned children of that sister and her husband. His aunt constantly referred to that sacrifice as her gift to his poor departed father, though no mention was ever made of her own sister, Owen and Annie’s mother. Owen tried to listen patiently.
“It is unfair of either of you to presume upon me any longer. You simply must take the girl and provide for her or return here to help me look after her. If you do not, I shall be forced to send her away to school—Scotland, I should think.”
“I agree, Aunt. I’ll see to it immediately.”
“You cannot know the worry and vexation caused me by—” His aunt stopped her litany midsentence. “What did you say?”
“I said that I agree. You’ve been most patient and generous with Annie and with me—a saint.” What Owen did not say was that he, too, was aware that his sister grew each day to look more like their beautiful mother—the sister Aunt Eleanor despised. It was little wonder she wanted Annie out of her sight.
“You will return here, then?”
He heard the hope in his aunt’s voice.
“I’ve made arrangements for Annie to begin boarding school in Southampton.”
“Southampton? You mean you will not . . .” She stopped, folded her hands, and lifted her chin. “No one of consequence attends school in Southampton.”
“We are not people of financial consequence, Aunt. We are hardworking people of substantial character, as were our parents.” Owen had yearned to say that to his aunt for years.
Her eyes flashed. “Your pride is up, young man. My father would say, ‘Your Allen Irish is showing.’”
Owen felt his jaw tighten.
And then his aunt smiled—a thing so rare that Owen’s eyebrows rose in return.
She leaned forward to stroke his cheek. “Impetuous. So like Mackenzie. You grow more like him—in looks and demeanor—each time I see you.”
Owen pulled back. He’d never liked the possessiveness of his aunt’s touch, nor the way she constantly likened him to his father. And now that he’d set his sights on the beautiful, widowed Lucy Snape, whose toddler needed a financially stable father, it was essential that he establish his independence.
Eleanor sniffed and sat back. “It is impossible. Elisabeth Anne must remain in London. It is the only suitable society for a young lady. You will return to Hargrave House.” She took a sip of tea, then replaced her teacup firmly in its saucer. “Your room stands ready.”
“Not this time, Aunt.” Owen spoke quietly, leaning forward to replace his own cup, willing it not to rattle. “I will support Annie from now on.”
“On gardener’s wages. And send her to a boarding school—in a shipping town!” She laughed.
“A convenient location for those going to sea.” Owen paused, debating how to proceed. “Or those crossing the sea.”
“The sea?” His aunt’s voice took on the suspicion, even the menace, that Owen feared. But he would do this, afraid or not.
Owen leaned forward again, breathing the prayer that never failed him. “Do you remember Uncle Sean Allen, in America?”
She stiffened.
“He and Aunt Maggie offered Father half of their landscaping business in New Jersey after Mother died.”
“A foolish proposition—a child’s dream! The idea of whisking two motherless children to a godforsaken—”
“It was a proposition that
might have saved him from the grief that took his life—if you hadn’t interfered!” Owen stopped, horrified that he’d spoken aloud the words harbored in his heart these four years but delighted that at last he’d mustered the courage.
She drew herself up. “If it was not an accident that sent him to his grave, it was his own ridiculous pining for a woman too silly to help him manage his business! I offered your father everything—this home, my inheritance, introduction to the finest families. He needn’t have worked at all, and if he had insisted, I could have procured any business connections he dreamed of in England. I can do all of that for you, Owen. I offer all of that to you.”
And it would be the death of all my hopes for Lucy—or even someone like her—just as you were the death of Father’s hopes and dreams. “I’m grateful for the roof you’ve given Annie and me these four years, Aunt. But it’s time for us to go. Uncle Sean has made to me the same offer he made to Father, and I’ve accepted. I sail Easter week.”
“Easter!” she gasped.
“As soon as we turn a profit, I’ll send for Annie.”
“He has been in that business these many years and not succeeded?” She snorted scornfully, but the fear that he meant to go did not leave her eyes.
He leaned forward. “Do you not see, Aunt? Do you not see this is a chance of a lifetime—for Annie and for me?”
“What I see is that you are foolish and ungrateful, with no more common sense than your father! I see that you are willing to throw away your life on a silly scheme that will come to nothing and that you intend to drag the child down beside you!” Her voice rose with each word, piercing the air.
Owen drew back. He’d not hurt Annie for the world. At fourteen, she was not a child in his eyes; that she remained so in Aunt Eleanor’s estimation was reason enough to get her away from Hargrave House.
