by Rose Nickol
When Gavin and Shelby arrived at the garage, Mike held his arms open and Shelby ran into them—a very good sign. Mike looked at Gavin over the top of her head and nodded. Gavin walked up until he was right behind Shelby.
“Honey, we want to talk to you,” Mike told her.
“Okay.” Shelby nodded and stepped back, running into Gavin. “I’m sorry. I didn’t know you were so close,” she told him, flustered. She was worried. They wanted to talk to her. Maybe she wasn’t only being fired, but maybe Gavin was throwing her out, too. She didn’t know why he would, but anything was possible.
Gavin held his hand out to her and she placed her small hand is his much larger one. Touching him made her feel more secure. Mike came up on her other side and took her other hand, then led them out the door and across the street. He unlocked the door and led them into his sitting room, and after grabbing beers for him and Gavin and water for Shelby, he sat on one end of the couch opposite Gavin with Shelby between them. They each laid a hand on one of Shelby’s thighs, and as they decided earlier, Mike started the conversation.
“Shelby, we have something we want to talk to you about.”
Shelby didn’t say anything. She just nodded. Crap here it comes.
“Shelby, I know you’re in a relationship with Gavin, but the thing is…Gavin and I like to share women. I’ve been attracted to you since I first saw you in Gavin’s garage, and we would both like you to be our woman.”
Shelby was so prepared for the words “I’m letting you go” that she wasn’t sure she heard Mike right. “Wait…what?” she stammered, looking at Gavin.
“Yes, baby. Mike and I want you to belong to both of us. We are both dominants and we want to have a Dom/sub relationship with you.” Gavin also wanted to tell her they wanted to marry her, but he knew she wasn’t ready for that yet.
Mike couldn’t wait any longer and slipped his arms around Shelby and pulled her into his lap. Gavin moved closer to the middle of the couch and pulled her feet into his lap, he needed to touch her, too. Mike tilted her face to his and brushed her mouth in a chaste kiss. He wanted more but didn’t want to scare her.
Shelby wrapped her hand around Mike’s neck and pulled his head closer to hers. She put her lips on his and, using her tongue, traced the seam of his lips, showing him with her mouth she was ready for what he wanted.
Mike didn’t need to be told twice and slid his tongue into her mouth, claiming her as his. While he was kissing her, he moved his hand down her side to where her shirt was tucked into her jeans and pulled it loose. He moved his hand underneath it and walked his fingers up the smooth skin of her stomach to her bra-covered breast. Cupping the small firm globe in his hand, he ran his thumb over her cloth-covered nipple, never losing contact with her mouth. Pulling back for breath, he sat her up in his lap, where both he and Gavin could see her face.
Shelby looked at both of them wide-eyed and took a deep breath. “You both want me, together at the same time?” she asked, full of wonder.
She couldn’t believe she was lucky enough to have one man, let alone two, want her. She hadn’t really thought about it until now, but the day she found out about her parents, Mike had shown how much he cared for her. He had held her and made sure she was taken care of until Gavin arrived. Gavin, how did he feel about all of this?
Shelby looked at Gavin and took his face in her hands. “Do you want this, too?” She watched his face carefully.
Gavin smiled and leaning over took her mouth with a kiss, showing her how much he wanted it. When Gavin broke the kiss Shelby leaned back and looked at both men.
“Both of you at the same time. You’ll both be okay with that? You won’t be jealous of each other?”
“No, honey. Gavin’s my best bud. We’ve been friends forever and have been talking about sharing a woman for years. We just never found the right woman until you came along,” Mike said, settling her more comfortably on his lap.
Gavin still had her feet across his legs and started removing her shoes and socks. “Baby, this is something Mike and I have wanted for a long time. We both care deeply for you. Mike just held back until he knew I was willing to share you. This is up to you, though. This won’t work unless we all try.”
Mike broke in. “Shelby you have to be on board with all of it, and you need to know there are times that I will spend time with you without Gavin around, and he will spend time with you without me, and of course, we will both have you together.”
While he talked he lifted it up over her stomach, not quite exposing her bra and breasts, but close.
“So what do you think? Do you want to try this with us?” Gavin asked.
Shelby looked at both men and thought for a minute. Did she want this? She had read a few books about it but never thought she would find one man let alone two that wanted to be with her. Could she be with two dominant men? Gavin had shown her a little of his dominant side, but she hadn’t seen Mike’s yet. Could she be what both men needed and wanted?
Looking at both men again she asked, “What if I’m not enough? What if I can’t do this?”
Gavin was sure she was the one and that it wouldn’t be a problem. “Shelby, you will be enough, and if it doesn’t work out for some reason, we’ll deal with that then. But, baby, I’m sure you’re the one for us. Enough talk, time for us to show you.” He finished undoing her jeans.
“Yeah, enough talk,” Mike murmured, pulling her T-shirt over her head. “Time to play.”
Before Shelby realized what was going on, both men had her naked, and she was being carried toward the back of the house.
“Where are we going?” she asked, a little anxious about what was going to happen.
“I’m taking you back to my bedroom,” Mike answered.
Part of the reason Mike and Gavin had decided to begin this at his house was that Mike had a custom-made bed that was large enough not only for him but for several other people, too. Mike also had a playroom in his basement that he and Gavin had worked on together.
Mike sat on the side of the bed, and Gavin sat beside him. They looked at Shelby.
“Are you sure you want this, baby?” Gavin wanted to make sure they weren’t pushing her.
“Yes, I want both of you,” Shelby answered, putting one hand of each of their thighs.
“Okay,” Gavin said. “Before we start I’m going to give you two words, they are what we call in BDSM play safe words. The first one, yellow, is for you to use when you start to feel overwhelmed or it’s becoming too much. Yellow is also the word you use when you need something adjusted, a drink, or to go the bathroom. The word yellow tells us we need to slow down and talk. After we find out what the problem is we will fix it if we can and resume play.
“The next word is red. When you say, ‘Red,’ everything stops for a while. We will still stop and talk like we do with yellow, but we won’t resume play right away. You use the word red when it’s too much and you can’t take any more. I hope you never have to use it. You should say yellow before you get to that point, and your Doms should watch you close enough that you don’t have to use either word. If Mike and I are doing our job and paying attention to you we will be so in touch with your body that we know what you need. That’s our goal.”
Shelby listened carefully as he explained, then thought a minute. “Why can’t I just say, ‘Stop’? Why do I need special words, and why colors?”
“The reason you need special words is we need something you won’t say normally,” Mike answered. “You might say stop and not really mean it. If you say red or yellow, it’s not something you would usually say during play. The reason we use colors is because they are easy to remember. We will also be checking with you during the course of scenes and play to see how you are doing. You can answer green if everything is good.”
When Mike finished explaining, it made more sense to her. “Oh, like the stoplight—green for go, yellow to slow down, and red to stop. That makes sense now.”
Gavin stood and starte
d removing his clothes. “I think we’ve done enough talking for now,” he said, looking at Mike.
Mike nodded and stood to remove his clothes. As Mike took his clothes off Shelby could see more of his tattooed body. She had seen the tattoos on his arms at work and could now see that his chest and back were also covered. Sitting up, she reached for him to come closer so she could get a better look.
Sitting on the side of the bed where he could explain and show her in better detail he pointed to each tattoo and explained when, where and why he had gotten them. Some he had gotten because of his service in the army, and some were in memory of friends who didn’t come back with him. He explained each one and its reason. Shelby had tears in her eyes when he was done, so did Mike. Even Gavin was somber.
Both men were naked and laid her back on the bed so she was in the center. It was so roomy she felt like a little kid lying in Mommy and Daddy’s bed, but the men approaching her from either side of the bed were definitely not her parents.
Gavin approached from the far side of the bed and crawled across the bed until he was at her side. Mike did the same from his side. They each took the arm closest to them and gently pulled her arms over her head fastening a leather cuff around each wrist. Each cuff was attached to a chain that was attached the head of the bed. They then moved to the foot of the bed and did the same with her legs. Those cuffs were also attached to a chain at the foot of the bed.
“The reason for the chain is to adjust so you aren’t stretched too much.” Mike showed her how the cuffs could be attached to different places on the chains to adjust them.
Mike reached under the bed and pulled out a bolster to place under her back and raise her hips. Then he lay between her legs while Gavin crawled to the head of the bed. Gavin was kneeling beside her head, his erect penis inches from her mouth.
“Baby, I want you to suck my cock while Mike eats your pussy. If you get me off before Mike makes you come, you’ll get a reward. If not, a punishment,” Gavin told her, rubbing her lips with his penis.
Shelby’s eyes got wide, but she nodded. A challenge, she could do this.
What Shelby didn’t know was that they were setting her up to fail. There was no way she was going to get Gavin off before she came. Mike would make sure of that.
Mike lifted her thighs over his shoulders and licked from her pussy to her clit, circling the little nubbin, but not touching it. Shelby tried to arch her hips and push her clit closer to Mike’s tongue, but between the bolster under her and the fact that he held her thighs, she couldn’t.
“You better get started if you don’t want the punishment,” Gavin told her with an evil grin as he rubbed his cock over her lips again.
Shelby groaned as Mike slid his tongue into her pussy. She reached out her tongue and licked the drop of pre-cum from Gavin’s penis, just barely touching. She felt him jerk and wished her hands were free to touch him. Fisting the sheets in frustration all she could do was move her head and take more of him in her mouth. This was going to be harder than she thought. She could already feel herself starting to gather.
Pulling Gavin’s cock farther into her mouth, she ran her tongue round and round, sucking him for all she was worth. It was more difficult than she thought without the use of her hands, but she managed to pull him farther down her throat and get some good sucking motion. She felt him jerk several times and knew she was getting to him. Hollowing her cheeks, she sucked him as far down her throat as she could and felt him jerk again.
At the same time, she felt Mike lift her thighs, and his tongue was in her channel again. Using his thumbs he pulled back the hood over her clit and launched what could only be called a full-out assault on her pleasure center. While Mike was licking and sucking her clit, Gavin reached down and began to pinch and pull on her nipples. With both men playing with her, she was helpless. She had to come.
Giving one last push to make Gavin come before she did, she swallowed him down her throat as far as she could, licking and sucking for all she was worth. Mike started finger fucking her cunt, and she was lost. Feeling the surge within her, she came, screaming around Gavin’s cock unable to do anything but let the starburst come over her.
Gavin slowly pulled out of her mouth, his cock still hard and throbbing. “Oh honey, was that you coming I just felt.”
Shelby was so sated that she just lay there unable to speak. Mike was still between her legs, gently licking and sucking her clit, keeping her on the edge.
Once Shelby’s breathing evened out again, Mike lifted away from her and put her legs down. Scooting to the edge of the bed he looked at her. “How are you doing, honey? Do you need to get up or have anything adjusted?”
“No, I’m good.” Shelby wondered why they had stopped. Had she done something wrong?
“If you’re sure everything’s good I’m going to get us all some water. Gavin, why don’t you let her loose for a few while I do.”
Gavin released her from the chains but left the cuffs on her wrists and ankles. Then he helped her sit on the edge of the bed. “Honey, do you want to go to the bathroom?”
I might as well if they are done with me, Shelby thought. Standing and looking for the door to the bathroom, she felt a tear run down her face. No, I can’t cry, she thought, looking up in time to see Gavin open a door for her. She dashed in and shut the door quickly, not wanting him to see her cry.
She went to the sink and turned the water on, trying to muffle the sound of her sobbing. She had no idea what she had done wrong, but she was sure there was something. Why she ever thought she could be enough for not one but two men, two dominant men she didn’t know. She couldn’t go out and face them. What was she going to do?
She blew her nose, put the tissue in the toilet, and flushed it. She stood trying to decide what to do next. Shelby walked to the sink and splashed water on her face, looking around for an escape. There were no windows in the room, but there was another door. Shelby opened it hoping it led to a hallway or another means of escape. It was a walk-in closet, the perfect place to hide. Finding a corner under some hanging clothes Shelby sat on the floor and wrapped her arms around her knees, rocking herself and trying to think what to do next. She heard Gavin beating on the bathroom door and calling for her but just ignored it.
Mike came back in the room carrying several bottles of water. Looking at the empty bed, he turned to Gavin with a question on his face.
Gavin answered Mike’s unasked question. “She’s in the bathroom.”
“She’s perfect, isn’t she?” Mike asked Gavin . He couldn’t believe they had finally found the woman he and Gavin had spent years looking for.
He nodded. Taking a bottle of water from Mike, Gavin drank half of it before recapping it. They stood in silence for several minutes, waiting for Shelby to come out.
“Was she okay when she went in there?” Mike knew women could take what seemed like forever in the bath, but he was starting to get concerned.
Gavin nodded and knocked gently on the door. He listened for a minute before knocking again a little harder this time. After waiting another minute or so he really pounded on the door this time, calling out to her as he pounded. Turning the doorknob, he found it locked. He looked at Mike and put his shoulder to the door to knock it down.
Mike stopped him just before he could break the door down and motioned for Gavin to follow him. He led him out to the hall and a door just a few feet away from the bedroom door. Quietly opening the door, he motioned for Gavin to follow him and be quiet.
The two men walked into the closet and stood, listening for the sound of their girl. Mike heard the sobbing first and zeroed in on where Shelby sat crying. He walked up to where she was and squatted down in front of her. Pulling her hands loose from where she had clenched them around her knees, he took them both in his hands.
“What’s the matter, baby?” he asked quietly.
Gavin knelt on the other side of her and started rubbing her back. “Are you cold, baby?” he asked, grabbed one o
f Mike’s shirts, and put around her.
Shelby sobbed harder. Mike and Gavin exchanged looks of confusion, neither one of them knowing what to do next. Gavin sat on the floor Indian style and pulled Shelby onto his lap. Mike kept hold of her hands, not knowing what else to do.
“Did we hurt you, baby?” Gavin asked, scared that they might have. She had seemed okay before going to the bathroom, but something was obviously bothering her.
Shelby shook her head and took a deep breath. “No, you didn’t hurt me physically. Why don’t you want to play with me anymore?” She sobbed.
Gavin and Mike exchanged looks again and Mike asked, “Why do you think that, honey?”
“Because you stopped and Mike left the room. I know I’m not much, but I thought I had pleased both of you. I know I lost the challenge, but give me another chance. Don’t give up on me. I’ll try harder, and you can do anything to me that you want to me. I promise I won’t use my safe word no matter what you do. Please don’t make me leave.” She sobbed, turning her face into Gavin’s chest. She didn’t know what she’d do if she had to leave these men.
Gavin and Mike exchanged a look, and Mike scooted to sit on Shelby’s other side.
“Oh, baby, you didn’t do anything wrong,” Gavin said, taking her face between his hands so he could look into her eyes. “You were and are perfect.” He pulled her face to his for a kiss. “Absolutely perfect. Isn’t she, Mike?”
“Everything we’ve ever wanted in a woman, totally perfect.” Mike took a kiss of his own from Shelby.
Shelby looked at both men and the longing she felt for them was evident in her face. “Really, you think I’m perfect. Why did you stop?” She sniffled.
“Baby, we didn’t stop, we were just taking a little break. We all needed some water, and we wanted to make sure you were okay. We still want to play some more. I think you have a punishment coming. Mike and I have so much more we want to do to and with you.” Gavin wiggled his eyebrows. “Are you willing to play some more?”
