Makers of Ancient Strategy: From the Persian Wars to the Fall of Rome

Home > Other > Makers of Ancient Strategy: From the Persian Wars to the Fall of Rome > Page 42
Makers of Ancient Strategy: From the Persian Wars to the Fall of Rome Page 42

by Victor Davis Hanson


  psychological strategy, 28; Alexander and,

  85n41, 95–96, 105, 108–12, 114n5, 116n21,

  119–20, 123, 129–30, 133; battle of Leuctra

  138–47, 151–53, 157; pacification and, 6; per-

  and, 103–4; counterinsurgency and, 167–68;

  sonal power vs. power of state and, 174–75;

  Cyrus and, 14–16

  Popular Assembly and, 211; preemption

  Ptolemy I, 126, 128

  and, 5–6 ( see also preemption); religion

  Ptolemy II, 131

  and, 131–32; republican system and, 207–8;

  Ptolemy IV, 131

  Roman Senate and, 175, 206–13, 223; satrap

  Publius Rupilius, 197

  system and, 41, 69, 119–21, 124–29, 133–34;

  Punic Wars, 67–68, 109, 177, 189

  self-promotion and, 18–19; slave wars and,

  Pylos, 188

  196; soft power and, 70, 88n53; Thucydides

  Pyrrhus of Epiros, 151

  and, 45–47; tribalism and, 7, 93, 156, 169,

  Pythagoreans, 112, 117n28

  178, 214–15; unilateralism and, 5–6; use of

  Pythia, 60

  force abroad and, 8; voting and, 32–33,

  85n41, 87n47, 209, 211, 213, 220, 223; war

  quality of life, 38–39

  and, 209–11

  Quintilius Varus, 165

  Politics (Aristotle), 74

  Quintus, 219

  Polybius, 3, 167

  quisligs, 23

  260 Index

  Radagaisus, 239, 246n33

  defense and, 4, 8–9, 227–42; genocide and,

  rape, 148

  167; governors and, 209; Herod Agrippa

  Realpolitik, 36

  II and, 173, 176; Herod the Great and, 173,

  Red Army, 202

  175–76; imperial collapse and, 241–42; Jew-

  religion, 46; Ahura Mazda and, 17–18; Alexan-

  ish revolt of 66 CE and, 168; Julius Caesar

  der and, 120, 124, 131–32; Athenians and,

  and, 163–64, 206–24; Late Roman Republic

  32–33, 85n41, 87n47, 209, 211, 213, 220, 223;

  and, 185, 189–90, 198–201; magistrates

  Christians and, 166, 191, 238; cosmic order

  and, 209; mass deportation and, 167;

  and, 17–19; cultural practices and, 131–32;

  multiculturalism of, 7; mutilation and, 167;

  desecrations and, 60–61; divine sanction

  occupational tactics and, 171–72, 214–15;

  and, 18–19; empire building and, 36; fire

  perceived ability to punish and, 167–68;

  concept and, 17; fourth philosophy and,

  personal power vs. power of state and,

  168; fusion, 131–32; Great Panathenaic

  174–75; political networking of, 164; Popu-

  Festival and, 41; Hellenization and, 130–31;

  lar Assembly and, 211, 223; private armies

  Marduk and, 12, 14; Oracle of Zeus-

  and, 217–20; provincial governors and,

  Ammon and, 120, 131; politics and, 131–32;

  209; public labor force and, 163; republican

  priests and, 15–17, 59, 168, 175; propaganda

  system of, 207–8; reputation of Epami-

  and, 17–19; proskynesis and, 129; revolts

  nondas and, 93; resource issues and, 163;

  and, 7–8; slavery and, 191–95; temple burn-

  ruling hierarchy of, 163–64; Senate and,

  ings and, 27–28, 44; Temple of Jerusalem

  175, 206–13, 223; Severan era and, 227; size

  and, 12, 15; Yahweh and, 15

  of military, 163; slave wars and, 185–202;

  republican system, 207–8

  Spartacus and, 8, 185, 189–90, 198–201;

  revolts, 82n22, 142; Alexander and, 119, 122–26,

  status of citizenship in, 172–75; superiority

  134; counterinsurgency and, 165–73, 182n31

  of, 7; taxes and, 163–65, 176–77; Tetrarchic

  ( see also counterinsurgency); ethnic, 7–8;

  emperors and, 229–30, 234; Third Punic

  Greco-Persian Wars and, 12, 23–24; Greek

  War and, 109; voter approval and, 209

  empire building and, 33–35; Ionian, 23–28;

  Roxane, 121, 123, 128–29

  religious, 7–8; slave wars and, 8, 185–88,

  RPGs, 155

  200–202

  Rubicon, 206, 208, 220

  Rhine: counterinsurgency strategy and, 167;

  Russia, 123

  frontier defense and, 227–35, 238–39, 244n5;

  Julius Caesar and, 207, 212, 227

  Sacred Band, 119

  Roman army: bandits and, 168–71; citizenship

  Sacrovir, 166

  and, 172; counterinsurgency and, 163–79;

  Salamis, 27–28, 60

  legionaries, 165, 172–73, 185, 218, 222; multi-

  Sallust, 210

  cultural composition of, 172–73, 183n33;

  Salvius, 194, 201

  occupational challenges of, 171–77, 182n31

  Samarkand, 122

  Rome, 3; absorption of Mediterranean by,

  Sambre, 218

  4; Augustus and, 163, 165, 170, 200, 207, 223–

  Samos, 19, 33

  24; banditry and, 168–71; Bar-Kokhba and,

  Sardis, 16, 23

  165–67, 169, 172; brutality of, 167, 213–14,

  Sarmatians, 172, 231–32, 237

  216, 222; centurions and, 219–20, 222,

  Satibarzanes, 121, 124

  226n20, 226n22; Christians and, 238; civil

  satrap system: Alexander and, 124–29, 134;

  war and, 206; colonies of, 163–64; corona

  autonomy and, 125–26; founding cities

  civica and, 209; counterinsurgency and,

  and, 127–28; logic of, 125; Persia and, 41,

  163–69; cursus honorum and, 209; dangers

  69, 119–21, 124–29, 133–34; power structure

  of public life in, 208; demographics of, 163;

  of, 125; taxes and, 125–26

  economy of, 163; empire building and, 2,

  Saudi Arabia, 77

  8, 118, 163–69, 174–79; fall of, 8–9; frontier

  Saudi Wall, 77

  Index 261

  Saxons, 227, 229

  increased cost of, 200; Julius Caesar and,

  Schlieffen, 10

  212, 218; manumission and, 185, 200–201;

  Scione, 55

  Marxism and, 189, 191; mass exploitation

  Scyros, 33

  of, 190; messianic idealism and, 6, 193,

  Scythians, 131

  204n15; modern concept of, 186; offers

  Sea of Marmora, 32

  of freedom to, 188–89, 192; Pericles and,

  Second Athenian League, 72–73

  49; pirates and, 190, 200; precautions of

  Second Punic War, 189

  masters and, 186; religion and, 191–95;

  Second Sicilian Slave War, 189, 191–92, 194, 198

  serfs and, 21, 93, 98, 105, 186–88; as shock

  sectarianism, 156

  troops, 177; skills of, 191; urban fight-

  security zones, 76–77

  ing and, 138–39, 152–53; utopia and, 192;

  Segesta, 177

  weapons for, 191

  segregation, 131

  slave wars: Bulla Felix and, 200; crucifixion

  Selecuid rulers, 128, 194

  and, 200; Damophilus and, 191–92; Diony-

  Sellasia, 67

  sus and, 195; divine direction and, 193–95;

  Selouros, 200

  Drimacus and, 193, 197, 201; economic

  Senate: governor appointments and, 209;

  issues and, 196; Eunus and, 194–95, 201;


  Julius Caesar and, 206, 210–11, 213, 223;

  Hollywood version of, 185; importance of,

  Lepidus and, 210; Pompey and, 210;

  189–90; location of, 190; maroons and, 197,

  rivalries in, 208

  200; Metallis and, 191–92; military experi-

  Sequani, 211, 214

  ence and, 196; modern, 202; offers of

  serfs, 21, 93, 98, 105, 186–88

  freedom and, 192; phalanx and, 185–86; pi-

  Seriphos, 33

  rates and, 198–99; pitched battles and, 196,

  Sertorius, 166

  199; repression of, 200–201; resettlement

  Severn era, 227

  and, 197; revenge and, 195, 201; Salvius

  Sextus Pompey, 200

  and, 194, 201; Second Punic War and, 189;

  shields, 149–50

  Selouros and, 200; Sicily and, 189–90, 192,

  Shiva, 131

  195–200; sieges and, 197; skills of, 196; soft

  sicarii (assassins), 168–70

  targets and, 195; Spartacus and, 8, 185,

  Sicilian Expedition, 97, 100, 111, 117n27

  189–90, 198–201; tactics of, 196, 196–200;

  Sicily, 175; empire building and, 53–54; Helleni-

  timing of, 190; treatment of masters and,

  zation and, 177; preemption and, 97, 100,

  195; un worthy nature of, 196–97; weapons

  110; slave wars and, 189–90, 192, 195–200;

  and, 195–96

  urban fighting and, 147–48; Verres and, 177

  Slavs, 242

  Silarus River, 199

  sling bullets, 141, 148

  Siwah, 120, 131–32

  Socrates, 94

  Six-Day War, 101–2

  soft power, 70, 88n53

  Skyros, 70, 72

  Sogdiana, 121–26, 134

  slavery: abolitionism and, 191; agriculture and,

  Solon, 64

  190; ancient documentation of, 185, 187;

  Sophocles, 94

  banditry and, 191; central role of, 185; chat-

  Sosistratus, 189

  tel, 186–89; communal servitude and, 186;

  Soviet Union, 101

  concentration of nationalities of, 190–91;

  Spain, 166, 171–72, 198, 210, 221

  cruel treatment of, 191–92; demographics

  Spartacus, 2; al ies of, 198; Crassus and, 199;

  of, 190; Dionysus and, 194–95; double stan-

  death of, 199–200; imposing figure of, 194–

  dard for, 36–37; Epaminondas’s freeing of

  95; Julius Caesar and, 209; lessons from, 201;

  helots and, 6, 93–94, 98, 104–8, 112, 114n9,

  pirates and, 198–99; religion and, 194–95; as

  115n11, 116n19, 188; fortification building

  Roman auxiliary, 191; slave wars and, 8, 185,

  and, 58; Greece and, 36–37; ideology and,

  189–90, 198–201; strategies of, 198–200; tacti-

  191–93; inadequate policing of, 190–91;

  cal skil of, 196; weapons and, 195–96

  262 Index

  Spartans, 6, 20, 42; Agesilaus and, 90n64, 95–97,

  27–28; counterinsurgency, 163–69; Cyrus

  100, 105, 142; Argives and, 66; Athenians

  and, 13–16; Darius and, 18–19; Delian

  and, 21, 35, 48, 63, 67–69, 72–73; attempted

  League and, 31–34, 43, 45; democracy and,

  annihilation of, 104; Attica and, 68; battle

  5–6, 21–23; diplomacy and, 215; divine

  of Leuctra and, 97, 103, 109; battle of

  sanction and, 18–19; empire building and,

  Thermopylae and, 27–28; bipolar state

  13–14 ( see also empire building); Epami-

  system and, 63, 69, 86n43; blockade of

  nondas and, 93–112; espionage and, 17,

  Piraeus and, 65, 67; Boeotia and, 94–99,

  24, 28; famine and, 96; fortifications and,

  103–12; Boeotian League and, 71; circuit

  58–78; frontier defense and, 4, 8–9, 227–42;

  wal s and, 152; Conon and, 70; Corinthians

  genocide and, 167; geopolitics and, 23;

  and, 53–54, 70–71; Delian League and, 32;

  guerrilla, 121, 124, 169–70, 196; idealism

  destruction of Long Wal s and, 67–68;

  and, 6, 93, 134; implicit expression of, 10;

  empire building and, 67–70, 97; Epaminon-

  importance of historical perspective on,

  das’s humiliation of, 83n25, 93–99, 103–12;

  2–10; intelligence gathering and, 7, 24, 53,

  equal sharing of loot and, 192; helots and,

  156, 232; Julius Caesar and, 206–24; keeping

  98, 104–8, 112, 114n9, 115n11, 116n19; homoioi

  the initiative and, 221; King’s Peace and,

  (equal class) concept and, 21; invasion of

  70–73, 86n43, 88n56, 89nn59,63; legitimiza-

  370–69 and, 96–99; King’s Peace and, 70–73,

  tion and, 18; occupational, 6, 9–10, 15–16;

  86n43, 88n56, 89nn59,63; Kleombrotos and,

  Pericles and, 31, 36, 38, 40–55; preemption

  97; Laconia and, 104, 106–8; Leontiades

  and, 5–6, 96–100, 103–12; preventative,

  and, 95; Lysander and, 67–68; Mantineia

  100–104; psychological, 14–16, 28, 103–4,

  and, 104; Messenian helots and, 93–94, 98,

  119–20, 123, 129–30, 133, 167–68; self-promo-

  104–8, 112, 114n9, 115n11, 116n19; multipolar

  tion and, 18–19; slave wars and, 196–200;

  state system and, 69, 73, 86n43; naval power

  Spartacus and, 196, 198–200; Spartans

  and, 86n43; The Peace of Antalcidas and,

  and, 21; transpopulation policy and, 127;

  71; Peloponessian League and, 32; Pericles

  unilateralism and, 5–6; urban fighting and,

  and, 42–45, 48; phalanx and, 95, 104; pitched

  138–57; voting and, 32–33, 85n41, 87n47, 209,

  battles and, 95–97, 139; preemption and,

  211, 213, 220, 223; world opinion and, 157

  102–3; slavery and, 186–88; tearless battle

  Strauss, Barry, ix, 7–8, 185–205

  and, 105; Thebes and, 95; urban fighting

  street layouts, 146–49, 155

  and, 139, 141–50, 153–55; view of fortifica-

  Strymon River, 119

  tions, 63, 66, 81n16, 82n24, 83n25

  Sueves, 239

  spears, 150, 155

  Sulla, 198, 208, 210, 223

  Speyer, 232

  Susa, 120, 125, 128, 129

  Sphodrias, 72, 73

  Switzerland, 211

  spice trade, 133

  swords, 150, 155

  Spitamanes, 121, 124

  synods, 32–33

  Stalingrad, 140

  Syracuse: counterinsurgency and, 177; pre-

  stasis (civil strife), 141–42

  emption and, 111; slavery and, 189; urban

  state power, 174–75

  fighting and, 142, 144, 148, 154–55, 157

  stationes (detachments), 170

  Syria, 128, 166, 171, 172, 175, 194

  stele of Aristoteles, 72

  Sthenius of Thermae, 177

  Tacitus, 167, 171, 235

  stone throwers, 155

  Tanagra, 96

  Strabo, 200

  Tarkontidmotos, 171

  strategy: Aeneas the Tactician and, 75; Alex-

  taxes, 16, 163–65, 176–77

  ander and, 118–35; ancient parameters of,

  Taxiles, 127

  2–10; assassinations and, 18, 119, 141, 168,

  tearless battle, 105

  175, 182n22, 222
, 234; battle of Marathon

  technology: fortifications and, 5, 76–77; instant

  and, 24–26; battle of Thermopylae and,

  communications and, 140; Internet and, 2;

  Index 263

  technology ( continued)

  Thrasyboulos, 153

  precision weapons and, 2; telecommuni-

  Thrasydaios, 145

  cations and, 2; urban fighting and, 7, 140,

  Thriasian plain, 72

  155–56; Western military superiority and,

  Thucydides, 3, 9, 111; Athenian fortifications

  7; world opinion and, 157

  and, 61–63; democracy and, 94; Long

  Tegea, 144, 146

  Walls and, 84n30; Melian Dialogue and,

  Tegyra, battle of, 96

  36; naval power and, 81n16; ostracism of,

  telecommunications, 2

  46–47; Pericles and, 45–47, 51, 55; Persian

  Temple of Aphrodite, 177

  threat and, 33; preemption and, 102; The-

  Temple of Jerusalem, 12, 15

  mistoclean walls and, 61–62, 61–63; urban

  Temple of Solomon, 12

  fighting and, 139

  Temple of the Tyndaridae, 149

  Tiberius, 167, 170

  Tenth Legion, 219

  Tiberius Julius Alexander, 173

  terrorism, 2; Baathists and, 102; Freedom

  Trajan, 166

  Tower and, 80n13; insurgents and, 168;

  transpopulation policy, 127

  Internet and, 2; Ionians and, 23; urban

  tribalism, 7, 93, 156, 169, 178, 214–15

  fighting and, 7

  tribute, 34, 35, 38, 45

  Tervingi, 233–34, 236, 238–39

  Trier, 231

  Tetrarchic emperors, 229–30, 234, 244n8

  triremes, 60, 64, 67, 85n37

  Teutoburg Forest, 165

  Truth, 17–19

  Thasos, 34

  Tryphon, 194

  theaters, 145

  tsar, 207

  Theban Sacred Band, 119

  Turkey, 166

  Thebes, 6, 68–69, 73–74, 90n68, 106; ascen-

  twentieth century, 7

  sion of, 95; backwardness of, 94; battle of

  tyrannos, 21–22

  Leuctra and, 97; democracy and, 94–99;

  tyrants, 33, 40; bandits and, 171; Julius Caesar

  Epaminondas and, 93–112; famine and,

  and, 207; Pericles on, 46; Thirty Tyrants

  96; hegemony of, 93–94, 106, 113, 114n4,

  and, 67, 139, 151

  117nn28,29,30, 139; Pagondas and, 103;

  Tyre, 120, 130, 132

  Peloponnesian Wars and, 95; slavery and,

  188; Spartans and, 95; street layouts and,

  Ukraine, 32

  146; urban fighting and, 138–39, 141–42, 144,

  undertakers, 131

  147, 149, 156–57

  unilateralism, 5–6

  Themistocles: as archon, 64; Attica defenses

  United States, 3; Bush administration and, 102,

  and, 59–60; Conon and, 75–76; decrees of

  112; Civil War and, 191; coercive democra-

 

‹ Prev