I want you to go, ballad, to seek out Love
and present yourself with him before my lady,
so that my exculpation, which you sing
may be explained to her by Love, my lord.
Ballad, you move along so gracefully,
you need no company
to venture boldly anywhere you like,
but if you want to go with full assurance,
first make a friend of Love;
perhaps to go alone would not be wise,
because the lady you are meant to speak to
is angry with me now (or so I think),
and if you were to go your way without him,
she might, perhaps, refuse to take you in.
But sweetly singing, in Love’s company,
start with these words (but only
after you have begged her for compassion):
“My lady, the one who sends me here to you
hopes it will be your pleasure
to hear me out and judge if he is guilty.
I come with Love who, through your beauty’s power,
can make your lover’s whole appearance change;
now can you see why Love made him look elsewhere?
Remember, though, his heart has never strayed.”
And say to her: “That heart of his, my lady,
has been so firmly faithful
that every thought keeps him a slave to you;
it was early yours, and never changed allegiance.”
If she should not believe you,
tell her to question Love, who knows the truth;
and end by offering this humble prayer:
if granting me forgiveness would offend her,
then may her answer sentence me to death,
and she will see a faithful slave’s obedience.
And tell Love, who is all compassion’s key,
before you take your leave,
tell Love, who will know how to plead my case,
thanks to the strains of my sweet melody:
“Stay here awhile with her,
talk to her of your servant as you will;
and if your prayer should win for him reprieve,
let her clear smile announce that peace is made.”
My gracious ballad, when it please you, go,
win yourself honor when the time is ripe.
Ballata, i’ voi che tu ritrovi Amore,
e con lui vade a madonna davante,
sì che la scusa mia, la qual tu cante,
ragioni poi con lei lo mio segnore.
Tu vai, ballata, sì cortesemente,
che sanza compagnia
dovresti avere in tutte parti ardire;
ma se tu vuoli andar sicuramente,
retrova l’Amor pria,
ché forse non è bon sanza lui gire;
però che quella che ti dèe audire,
sì con’io credo, è ver di me adirata:
se tu di lui non fossi accompagnata,
leggeramente ti faria disnore.
Con dolze sono, quando se’ con lui,
comincia este parole,
appresso che averai chesta pietate:
“Madonna, quelli che mi manda a vui,
quando vi piaccia, vole,
sed elli ha scusa, che la m’intendiate.
Amore è qui, che per vostra bieltate
lo face, come vol, vista cangiare:
dunque perché li fece altra guardare
pensatel voi, da che non mutò ’l core.”
Dille: “Madonna, lo suo core è stato
con sì fermata fede,
che ’n voi servir l’ha ’mpronto onne pensero:
tosto fu vostro, e mai non s’è smagato”
Sed ella non ti crede,
di’ che domandi Amor, che sa lo vero:
ed a la fine falle umil preghero,
lo perdonare se le fosse a noia,
che mi comandi per messo ch’eo moia,
e vedrassi ubidir ben servidore.
E di’ a colui ch’è d’ogni pietà chiave,
avante che sdonnei,
che le saprà contar mia ragion bona,
per grazia de la mia nota soave:
“Reman tu qui con lei,
e del tuo servo ciò che vuoi ragiona;
e s’ella per tuo prego li perdona,
fa che li annunzi un bel sembiante pace”
Gentil ballata mia, quando ti piace,
movi in quel punto che tu n’aggie onore.
This ballad is divided into three parts. In the first I tell it where to go and encourage it so that it will go with more assurance, and I tell it whom it should have for company if it wishes to go securely and free from any danger; in the second I tell it what it is supposed to make known; in the third I give it permission to depart whenever it pleases, commending its journey to the arms of fortune. The second part begins: But sweetly singing, the third: My gracious ballad.
Here one might make the objection that no one can know to whom my words in the second person are addressed, since the ballad is nothing more than the words I myself speak; and so let me say that I intend to explain and discuss this uncertainty in an even more difficult section of this little book; and if anyone may have been in doubt here, perhaps wishing to offer the objection mentioned above, let him understand, there, the explanation to apply here as well.
XIII
After this last vision, when I had already written what Love commanded me to write, many and diverse thoughts began to assail and try me, against which I was defenseless; among these thoughts were four that seemed to disturb most my peace of mind. The first was this: the lordship of Love is good since he keeps the mind of his faithful servant away from all evil things. The next was this: the lordship of Love is not good because the more fidelity his faithful one shows him, the heavier and more painful are the moments he must live through. Another was this: the name of Love is so sweet to hear that it seems impossible to me that the effect itself should be in most things other than sweet, since, as has often been said, names are the consequences of the things they name: Nomina sunt consequentia rerum. The fourth was this: the lady through whom Love makes you suffer so is not like other ladies, whose hearts can be easily moved to change their attitudes.
And each one of these thoughts attacked me so forcefully that it made me feel like one who does not know what direction to take, who wants to start and does not know which way to go. And as for the idea of trying to find a common road for all of them, that is, one where all might come together, this was completely alien to me: namely, appealing to Pity and throwing myself into her arms. While I was in this mood, the desire to write some poetry about it came to me, and so I wrote this sonnet which begins: All my thoughts.
All my thoughts speak to me concerning Love;
they have in them such great diversity
that one thought makes me welcome all Love’s power,
another judges such a lordship folly,
another, with its hope, brings me delight,
another very often makes me weep;
only in craving pity all agree
as they tremble with the fear that grips my heart.
I do not know from which to take my theme;
I want to speak, but what is there to say?
Thus do I wander in a maze of Love!
And if I want to harmonize them all,
I am forced to call upon my enemy,
Lady Pity, to come to my defense.
Tutti li miei penser parlan d’Amore;
a hanno in lor sì gran varietate,
ch’altro mi fa voler sua potestate,
altro folle ragiona il suo valore,
altro sperando m’apporta dolzore,
altro pianger mi fa spesse fiate;
e sol s’accordano in cherer pietate,
tremando di paura che è nel core.
Ond’io non so da qual matera prenda;
e vorrei dire, e non so ch’io mi dica.
/>
Così mi trovo in amorosa erranza!
E se con tutti voi fare accordanza,
convenemi chiamar la mia nemica,
madonna la Pietà, che mi difenda.
This sonnet can be divided into four parts. In the first I say and submit that all my thoughts are about Love; in the second I say that they are different, and I talk about their differences; in the third I tell what they all seem to have in common; in the fourth I say that, wishing to speak of Love, I do not know where to begin, and if I wish to take my theme from all my thoughts, I would be forced to call upon my enemy, my Lady Pity—and I use the term “my lady” rather scornfully. The second part begins: they have in them; the third: only in craving; the fourth: I do not know.
XIV
After the battle of the conflicting thoughts it happened that my most gracious lady was present where many gentlewomen were gathered. I was taken there by a friend who thought I would be delighted to go to a place where so many beautiful ladies were. I was not sure why I was being taken there but, trusting in the person who had led his friend to the threshold of death, I asked him: “Why have we come to see these ladies?” He answered: “So that they may be fittingly attended.” The fact is that they were gathered there to be with a certain lovely lady who had been married that day, for according to the custom of the afore-mentioned city they were supposed to keep her company during the first meal at the home of her bridegroom. So I, thinking to please my friend, decided to remain with him in attendance upon the ladies. No sooner had I reached this decision than I seemed to feel a strange throbbing which began in the left side of my breast and immediately spread to all parts of my body. Then, pretending to act naturally, I leaned for support against a painted surface that extended along the walls of the house and, fearing that people might have become aware of my trembling, I raised my eyes and, looking at the ladies, I saw among them the most gracious Beatrice. Then my spirits were so disrupted by the strength Love acquired when he saw himself this close to the most gracious lady, that none survived except the spirits of sight; and even these were driven forth, because Love desired to occupy their enviable post in order to behold the marvelous lady. And even though I was not quite myself, I was still very sorry for these little spirits who bitterly protested, saying: “If this one had not thrust us from our place like a bolt of lightning, we could have stayed to see the wonders of this lady as all our peers are doing.” Now many of the ladies present, noticing the transformation I had undergone, were amazed and began to talk about it, joking about me with that most gracious one. My friend, who had made a mistake in good faith, took me by the hand and, leading me out of the sight of the ladies, asked me what was wrong. Then I, somewhat restored, for my dead spirits were coming back to life, and the ones ejected were returning to their rightful domain, said these words to my friend: “I have just set foot on that boundary of life beyond which no one can go, hoping to return.” And leaving him, I went back to my room of tears where, weeping in humiliation, I said to myself: “If this lady were aware of my condition, I do not believe she would ridicule my appearance but, on the contrary, would feel pity.” In the midst of my tears I thought of writing a few words addressed to her, explaining the reason for the change in my appearance and saying that I was well aware that no one knew the reason and that, if it were known, I believed it would arouse everyone’s compassion; I decided to write this in the hope that my words by chance would reach her. Then I composed this sonnet which begins: You join with other ladies.
You join with other ladies to make sport
of the way I look, my lady, and do not ask
what makes me cut so laughable a figure
when I am in the presence of your beauty.
If only you knew why, I am sure that Pity
would drop her arms and make her peace with me;
for Love, when he discovers me near you,
takes on a cruel, bold new confidence
and puts my frightened senses to the sword,
by slaying this one, driving that one out,
till only he is left to look at you.
Thus, by the changeling Love, I have been changed,
but not so much that I cannot still hear
my outcast senses mourning in their pain.
Con l’altre donne mia vista gabbate,
e non pensate, donna, onde si mova
ch’io vi rassembri sì figura nova
quando riguardo la vostra beltate.
Se lo saveste, non poria Pietate
tener più contra me l’usata prova,
ché Amor, quando sì presso a voi mi trova,
prende baldanza e tanta securtate,
che fere tra’ miei spiriti paurosi,
e quale ancide, e qual pinge di fore,
sì che solo remane a veder vui.
Ond’io mi cangio in figura d’altrui,
ma non sì ch’io non senta bene allore
li guai de li scacciati tormentosi.
I do not divide this sonnet into parts, since this is done only to help reveal the meaning of the thing divided; and since what has been said about its occasion is sufficiently clear, there is no need for division. True, among the words with which I relate the occasion for this sonnet, there occur certain expressions difficult to understand, as when I say that Love slays all my spirits and the spirits of sight remain alive, though driven outside their organs. But it is impossible to make this clear to anyone who is not as faithful a follower of Love as I; to those who are, the solution to the difficulty is already obvious. Therefore, there is no need for me to clear up such difficulties, for my words of clarification would be either meaningless or superfluous.
XV
After that strange transformation a certain thought began to oppress my mind; it seldom left me but rather continually nagged at me, and it took form in this way: “Since you become so ridiculous-looking whenever you are near this lady, why do you keep trying to see her? Now assume that she were to ask you this, and that all your faculties were free to answer her, what would your answer be?” And to this another thought replied, saying modestly, “If I did not lose my wits and felt able to answer her, I would tell her that as soon as I call to mind the miraculous image of her beauty, then the desire to see her overcomes me, a desire so powerful that it kills, it destroys anything in my memory that might have been able to restrain it; and that is why what I have suffered in the past does not keep me from trying to see her.” Moved by such thoughts, I decided to write a few words in which I would acquit myself of the accusation suggested by the first thought, and also describe what happens to me whenever I am near her. Then I wrote this sonnet which begins: Whatever might restrain me.
Whatever might restrain me when I feel drawn
to see you, my heart’s bliss, dies from my mind.
When I come close to you, I hear Love’s warning:
“Unless you want to die, run away now!”
My blanching face reveals my fainting heart
which weakly seeks support from where it may,
and as I tremble in this drunken state
the stones in the wall I lean on shout back: “Die!”
He sins who witnesses my transformation
and will not comfort my tormented soul,
at least by showing that he shares my grief
for pity’s sake—which by your mocking dies,
Dante’s Vita Nuova, New Edition: A Translation and an Essay Page 3
