'Have You Seen...?'

Home > Other > 'Have You Seen...?' > Page 160
'Have You Seen...?' Page 160

by David Thomson


  The confusions and pretensions surely derived from the awe with which the studio regarded their Michelangelo, but it is evident in the array of screenwriters—Antonioni himself, Tonino Guerra (his regular), plus Fred Gardner, Sam Shepard, and Clare Peploe. Then you have to deal with the dumb Adam-and-Eve-like beauty of the raw leads—Mark Frechette and Daria Halprin—who simply could not act. And so the preparation became a weird mixture of consultations with Black Panthers and the creation of superb and insane Ozymandian houses in the desert, with sets by the very skilled Dean Tavoularis.

  Two kids go on the lam from student politics and the very vague oppression of Americana and head for the desert. In fact, the vestiges of plot and narrative dialogue are so embarrassing that you train your sensibility to gaze past them at the distance, the shapes, and light. And that is where the film is. It would have been so much more coherent if Antonioni had been free of script or actors, and if he and cameraman Alfio Contini had just been let loose in the Southwest.

  There is an orgy at Zabriskie Point itself, though orgy is a generous word for a director who closed his eyes in despair at the thought of sexual congress. Perhaps he did it to please his desperate studio who were just eager to get a bunch of kids out of their clothes and into the dust. Still, there are moments in that sequence in which the lovers begin to resemble the ashen ecstasies from Pompeii—I think of Rossellini’s Journey to Italy, and the dogged resistance in American melodrama to what you might call novelistic cinema.

  I would not include the film here—despite my attachment to Antonioni—but for the ending. With Pink Floyd’s music, we see the repeated explosion of one of the desert mansions—and not just the blooming fire and smoke but also the prolonged, distended scattering of all the interior things in the house—clothes fluttering from closets, provisions bursting out of refrigerators, the pages of books riffling in the breeze (or in the water where these scenes were filmed). This rhapsody could stand alone—it should—as a magnificent short film, and a single denunciation of the collected television commercials of fifty years. In the montage of American movie, there have to be moments from this aria on disruption. Metro got their money’s worth—even if their innocence remained intact.

  Chronology

  1895

  L’Arrosseur Arrossé

  1903

  The Great Train Robbery

  1913

  Fantômas

  1914

  Tillie’s Punctured Romance

  1915

  The Birth of a Nation

  1916

  Intolerance

  1917

  Thomas Graal’s Best Film

  1918

  The Outlaw and His Wife

  1919

  Broken Blossoms

  J’Accuse

  Male and Female

  1920

  The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari

  Erotikon

  Way Down East

  1921

  The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse

  Tol’able David

  The Wild Cat

  1922

  Dr. Mabuse the Gambler

  Foolish Wives

  Nosferatu

  Orphans of the Storm

  Robin Hood

  1923

  The Covered Wagon

  The Hunchback of Notre Dame

  Safety Last!

  The Ten Commandments

  A Woman of Paris

  1924

  Greed

  He Who Gets Slapped

  The Iron Horse

  The Last Laugh

  The Navigator

  Die Nibelungen

  Sherlock Jr.

  The Thief of Bagdad

  Wild Oranges

  1925

  Battleship Potemkin

  Ben-Hur

  The Big Parade

  The Gold Rush

  The Joyless Street

  Lady of the Night

  Master of the House

  The Merry Widow

  The Phantom of the Opera

  Seven Chances

  Strike

  1926

  Faust

  Flesh and the Devil

  Mare Nostrum

  The Son of the Sheik

  Sparrows

  The Temptress

  What Price Glory?

  The Winning of Barbara Worth

  1927

  The General

  It

  The Italian Straw Hat

  London After Midnight

  The Man with a Movie Camera

  Metropolis

  Napoleon

  7th Heaven

  Sunrise

  Underworld

  The Unknown

  Wings

  1928

  Un Chien Andalou

  The Crowd

  Lonesome

  La Passion de Jeanne d’Arc

  Queen Kelly

  Sadie Thompson

  Show People

  The Wind

  1929

  Applause

  Blackmail

  The Love Parade

  Pandora’s Box

  People on Sunday

  1930

  L’ge d’Or

  All Quiet on the Western Front

  Anna Christie

  The Blue Angel

  Earth

  Hell’s Angel’s

  Morocco

  1931

  The Champ

  La Chienne

  City Lights

  City Streets

  Dracula

  Frankenstein

  Kameradschaft

  M

  Le Million

  Platinum Blonde

  Public Enemy

  Que Viva Mexico

  Street Scene

  Tabu

  The Threepenny Opera

  Waterloo Bridge

  1932

  Boudu Sauvé des Eaux

  Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde

  Freaks

  I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang

  I Was Born But…

  Liebelei

  Love Me Tonight

  The Music Box

  Red Dust

  Red-Headed Woman

  Scarface

  Shanghai Express

  The Sign of the Cross

  The Testament of Dr. Mabuse

  Trouble in Paradise

  Vampyr

  What Price Hollywood?

  1933

  Baby Face

  The Bitter Tea of General Yen

  Dancing Lady

  Dinner at Eight

  Duck Soup

  Exstase

  42nd Street

  The Gold Diggers of 1933

  King Kong

  Little Women

  Outskirts

  1934

  L’Atalante

  Imitation of Life

  It Happened One Night

  Judge Priest

  The Merry Widow

  Of Human Bondage

  Our Daily Bread

  The Scarlet Empress

  La Signora di Tutti

  Tarzan and His Mate

  The Thin Man

  Toni

  Treasure Island

  Twentieth Century

  1935

  Alice Adams

  Bride of Frankenstein

  David Copperfield

  The Devil Is a Woman

  The Informer

  A Midsummer Night’s Dream

  Mutiny on the Bounty

  A Night at the Opera

  Peter Ibbetson

  Ruggles of Red Gap

  Steamboat Round the Bend

  Sylvia Scarlett

  A Tale of Two Cities

  The 39 Steps

  Top Hat

  1936

  Camille

  Come and Get It

  Le Crime de Monsieur Lange

  Desire

  Dodsworth

  Fury

  The Great Ziegfeld

  Modern Times

  Mr. Deeds
Goes to Town

  My Man Godfrey

  Une Partie de Campagne

  The Petrified Forest

  San Francisco

  Show Boat

  Swing Time

  1937

  The Awful Truth

  Black Legion

  Un Carnet de Bal

  Easy Living

  The Good Earth

  La Grande Illusion

  History Is Made at Night

  The Life of Emile Zola

  Make Way for Tomorrow

  Mannequin

  Nothing Sacred

  Pépé le Moko

  The Prisoner of Zenda

  Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

  Stage Door

  A Star Is Born

  Stella Dallas

  Swing High, Swing Low

  You Only Live Once

  1938

  The Adventures of Robin Hood

  Alexander Nevsky

  Angels with Dirty Faces

  The Baker’s Wife

  Bringing Up Baby

  Carefree

  Holiday

  Jezebel

  The Lady Vanishes

  La Marseillaise

  Pygmalion

  Quai des Brumes

  Three Comrades

  You Can’t Take It with You

  1939

  Dark Victory

  Destry Rides Again

  Gone With the Wind

  Gunga Din

  Le Jour Se Lève

  Love Affair

  Midnight

  Mr. Smith Goes to Washington

  Ninotchka

  Only Angels Have Wings

  The Rules of the Game

  Stagecoach

  The Stars Look Down

  The Story of the Late Chrysanthemums

  The Wizard of Oz

  The Women

  Wuthering Heights

  Young Mr. Lincoln

  1940

  The Bank Dick

  Broadway Melody of 1940

  Fantasia

  The Grapes of Wrath

  The Great Dictator

  The Great McGinty

  His Girl Friday

  The Letter

  The Mortal Storm

  The Philadelphia Story

  Rebecca

  The Shop Around the Corner

  They Drive by Night

  The Thief of Bagdad

  1941

  Ball of Fire

  Citizen Kane

  High Sierra

  Hold Back the Dawn

  How Green Was My Valley

  The Lady Eve

  The Little Foxes

  The Maltese Falcon

  Man Hunt

  Meet John Doe

  Penny Serenade

  That Hamilton Woman

  Two-Faced Woman

  1942

  Bambi

  Casablanca

  Cat People

  Gentleman Jim

  The Hard Way

  The Magnificent Ambersons

  Now, Voyager

  Ossessione

  The Palm Beach Story

  Sullivan’s Travels

  To Be or Not To Be

  Went the Day Well?

  Woman of the Year

  Yankee Doodle Dandy

  1943

  Air Force

  Cabin in the Sky

  Day of Wrath

  For Whom the Bell Tolls

  Hail the Conquering Hero

  Hangmen Also Die!

  I Walked with a Zombie

  The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp

  Lumière d’Été

  The More the Merrier

  The Ox-Bow Incident

  The Seventh Victim

  Shadow of a Doubt

  1944

  An American Romance

  Cover Girl

  Double Indemnity

  Frenzy

  Gaslight

  Going My Way

  Henry V

  Laura

  Meet me in St. Louis

  Ministry of Fear

  The Miracle of Morgan’s Creek

  Mr. Skeffington

  Phantom Lady

  Since You Went Away

  To Have and Have Not

  The Woman in the Window

  1945

  Brief Encounter

  The Clock

  Les Dames du Bois de Boulogne

  Detour

  Les Enfants du Paradis

  I Know Where I’m Going

  Ivan the Terrible

  Leave Her to Heaven

  The Lost Weekend

  Mildred Pierce

  Open City

  The Picture of Dorian Gray

  Scarlet Street

  Spellbound

  The Strange Affair of Uncle Harry

  They Were Expendable

  1946

  La Belle et la Bête

  The Best Years of Our Lives

  The Big Sleep

  The Chase

  Diary of a Chambermaid

  Duel in the Sun

  Gilda

  Great Expectations

  Humoresque

  It’s a Wonderful Life

  The Killers

  A Matter of Life and Death

  My Darling Clementine

  Notorious

  The Outlaw

  Paisan

  The Postman Always Rings Twice

  Shoeshine

  1947

  Body and Soul

  Brighton Rock

  The Cat Concerto

  Crossfire

  Daisy Kenyon

  Le Diable au Corps

  It Always Rains on Sunday

  Kiss of Death

  The Lost Moment

  Monsieur Verdoux

  Odd Man Out

  Out of the Past

  Pursued

  Quai des Orfèvres

  La Terra Trema

  They Made Me a Fugitive

  1948

  Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein

  Act of Violence

  L’Amore

  Bicycle Thieves

  The Boy with Green Hair

  Drunken Angel

  The Fallen Idol

  Force of Evil

  Fort Apache

  Germany Year Zero

  Hamlet

  Key Largo

  The Lady from Shanghai

  Letter from an Unknown Woman

  Maclovia

  The Naked City

  Oliver Twist

  Raw Deal

  Red River

  The Red Shoes

  Rope

  The Snake Pit

  The Treasure of the Sierra Madre

  Unfaithfully Yours

  1949

  Adam’s Rib

  All the King’s Men

  Caught

  Colorado Territory

  Criss Cross

  The Fountainhead

  The Heiress

  I Was a Male War Bride

  Kind Hearts and Coronets

  Late Spring

  Portrait of Jennie

  The Queen of Spades

  The Reckless Moment

  Samson and Delilah

  She Wore a Yellow Ribbon

  Une Si Jolie Petite Plage

  Le Silence de la Mer

  The Small Back Room

  Stromboli

  They Live by Night

  The Third Man

  Twelve O’Clock High

  Under Capricorn

  Whisky Galore!

  White Heat

  1950

  All About Eve

  The Asphalt Jungle

  Born Yesterday

  D.O.A.

  The Elusive Pimpernel

  Les Enfants Terribles

  Gone to Earth

  Gun Crazy

  In a Lonely Place

  Miss Julie

  Night and the City

  No Man of Her Own

  Los Olvidados

  Orphée

  Outcast
of the Islands

  Rashomon

  La Ronde

  Sunset Blvd.

  Wagon Master

  Winchester ’73

  1951

  Ace in the Hole

  The African Queen

  An American in Paris

  Diary of a Country Priest

  M

  A Place in the Sun

  The Prowler

  The River

  Strangers on a Train

  A Streetcar Named Desire

  The Tales of Hoffmann

  Der Verlorene

  1952

  Angel Face

  The Bad and the Beautiful

  Carrie

  Casque d’Or

  Europa ’51

  Forbidden Games

  High Noon

  Julius Caesar

  The Lavender Hill Mob

  The Life of Oharu

  Limelight

  Living

  The Lusty Men

  Monkey Business

  Othello

  The Quiet Man

  Rancho Notorious

  Robinson Crusoe

  Singin’ in the Rain

  Umberto D.

  Viva Zapata!

  1953

  The Band Wagon

  The Big Heat

  From Here to Eternity

  Gentlemen Prefer Blondes

  The Golden Coach

  Journey to Italy

  Madame de…

  M. Hulot’s Holiday

  Pickup on South Street

  Roman Holiday

  Sawdust and Tinsel

  Shane

  Thérèse Raquin

  Tokyo Story

  Ugetsu Monogatari

  I Vitelloni

  The Wages of Fear

  1954

  Anatahan

  Apache

  Bad Day at Black Rock

  The Barefoot Contessa

  Beat the Devil

  Carmen Jones

  Dial M for Murder

  The Glenn Miller Story

  Johnny Guitar

  Knave of Hearts

  On the Waterfront

  La Paura

  Rear Window

  Sansho the Bailiff

 

‹ Prev