by Harper West
“Yeah, you like that?” I asked her. “You like me grabbing you and fucking you like this?”
“This is how I want you to fuck me in class,” she said. “I want you to just grab me and fuck me in front of everyone.”
“Oh God,” I felt the knot in my cock start to loosen. “Oh God, you are going to make me cum.”
“That’s what I want,” she moaned. “I want you to fuck me and make me cum in front of everyone.”
“Anytime you want,” I groaned, and then felt the knot of pleasure release. I exploded into her, and I felt her pussy spasm around my cock. I had never been with a girl who could cum in tandem with me so often, but she seemed to be able to do it every single time. “Anytime you want, baby. Oh God, Oh God, Oh God.”
I came so hard that I saw spots in front of my face. I sank down on the bed as soon as I finished cumming, and I closed my eyes. I seriously thought I was going to pass out, it was so good.
Natalie was still spasming and she was still moaning. Her legs were shaking, and I felt a sense of pride that I had made her cum that strongly.
“Hey,” I traced her shoulder. “Was that good?”
“Yes,” she managed. She still couldn’t get up and she rolled closer to me. “That was amazing.”
“What made you come here?” I asked. “Tonight?”
She didn’t answer for so long that I thought she might have fallen asleep. But when I looked down at her, her eyes were wide open. She was thinking, but she couldn’t seem to get the words out.
“It’s OK if you don’t want to tell me,” I said softly. “I know things are complicated.”
“Yeah,” she said at last. “They are. Thank you for understanding.”
“Do you want to stay the night?” I asked her. I was hoping that she would say yes, and she seemed like she was thinking about it. But then, at the last second, she got up, and pushed her long pink hair back from her face.
“No,” she said. “I mean, I’ll stay in the house, but I’m not going to stay in your bed.”
“Oh,” I said, slightly disappointed. “OK I mean, if you are sure.”
“I’m sure,” she said. “But I appreciate the offer.”
I didn’t know what to say, so I just leaned forward and kissed her cheek.
“I’m here if you need anything, Natalie,” I said. “Including... you know, round 2.”
“Thank you,” she said, and then slowly crawled out of my bed. She looked a little wobbly and I steadied her until she was standing up straight. “That was really good though.”
I chuckled at that.
“Glad I could help,” I said. She laughed that and then left the room. I took a moment to take a deep breath and then ran my hands through my hair and then took a sip of water from the glass beside me. I should probably take a shower, and then I should go to bed. I was supposed to go to work tomorrow, but I didn’t actually know if I was going to go in. I knew that Natalie was having a rough time, but I felt like my heart was also in turmoil. Was that goodbye sex and it was the last time I ever saw her? Would she sneak out of the house without saying goodbye?
I realized quickly that this wasn’t normal. I was falling in love with this girl, and I didn’t know what to do about it. I didn’t think I had ever been in love before and certainly not with a TA that I really should be staying away from.
I wanted to go talk to her, but I resisted the urge.
I needed to sleep. Everything would be clearer in the morning.
Chapter 17
John
I had actually been sleeping for quite awhile when I heard a noise at my door. It wasn’t like me to sleep so lightly, but I had been dreaming of Natalie as I was tossing and turning. My cock was hard when I woke up, and I thought that’s what woke me up. Instead, it was Natalie herself standing at my bedroom door.
“Natalie?” I asked, confused. “Am I dreaming?”
“No, you aren’t dreaming,” she said with a soft smile. “I’m surprised that you were asleep. Aren’t you normally a crazy night owl?”
“Only some days,” I said. “Some days, I’m an old man.”
“I don’t think you are old,” she said and advanced forward a few steps. Even though it was dark in the room, I knew she would see my rock-hard cock under the blankets if she got any closer. “I wanted to talk to you.”
“You did?” I said, surprised. “About what?”
“Well... actually…” she said, and then crawled onto the edge of my bed. “I don’t think talking is exactly what I want to do.”
“What do you want to do?” I asked, even though I knew that was a stupid question. She reached her hand out and touched my cock and I moaned. “Oh.”
“Are you game?” she asked.
“Of course, I’m game,” I said, and then she pulled the blanket off. I had been sleeping in the nude and so my cock just sprung free. Before I could stop her, Natalie fell on my cock like she was starving for it. She started sucking me with such vigor that I thought I was going to cum then and there.
“Oh god,” I moaned and fell back onto the pillows. “This is the nicest way to wake up. Oh God.”
“I want to get you to the brink,” she said. “I want to get you right to the brink and then I want you to fuck me.”
“OK,” I said. This was too good to speak coherently She was sucking me and flicking my cock with her tongue and I was starting to see spots from the waves of pleasure that were running though my body. She worked on my cock like a pro and after a few minutes, I started to thrust into her mouth. “Yes. Yes! Oh God, yes.”
She licked me, and pulled up for a minute, looking into my eyes.
“What do you want?” she asked. “Do you want to cum?”
“Yes,” I said through gritted teeth. “Yes. Make me cum baby.”
“You are only going to cum inside me, do you understand?” she asked. “I want you to cum in my pussy. Now, do you need me to keep sucking you or are you too close?”
I liked the dominant side of Natalie, and I reached to tangle my fingers in her hair.
“I can take a little more,” I said, and guided her lips to my cock. “Just a little more.”
She went back to sucking my cock, and she started to lick just around the base. It felt amazing, and I didn’t think that I could hold on much longer, and then I started to squeeze her hair even harder.
“Mm, I think I’m going to stop,” she said, devilishly. She didn’t seem to care that I was right on the brink of the biggest orgasm of my life.
“No,” I cried. “No, baby, don’t stop. Please, just let me cum this way. Please.”
“No,” she said and sat up completely. “No. I’m going to ride you now.”
I hadn’t realized until right then that all she was wearing was a tee-shirt. She took it off with one swift move of her arms. Her milky white breasts glistened in the moonlight and she looked like an Amazon queen. I couldn’t believe that this gorgeous creature was going to ride me. I had lots of sex in my life, but there was no woman who was as beautiful as Natalie was.
“Oh God,” I moaned as she lowered herself onto my cock. “Oh baby, you are so wet.”
“Do you like that?” she asked, in a low husky voice.
“Yes,” I breathed. “Yes, I like that. I like it when you are dripping wet for me.”
“I need to cum,” she said. “So, you can’t cum until I cum.”
I gave a low laugh.
“I don’t think I can wait that long,” I replied. “I don’t think I can…”
“I said I need to cum,” she replied, and glared at me. “And you aren’t cumming until I cum.”
“Yes, ma’am,” I grinned. I liked this side of her. Every time she gave me an order, my cock got harder.
“Good,” she said, and then started to ride me. Her breasts began to slowly bounce, and her hips came closer to my face, and then farther away. I wanted to bury my face in her perfect curvy body and lick every inch of her. I put my hands on her waist and pulled h
er forward, and then back.
“Oh God, yes,” I moaned. “Yes, that’s it. That’s it.”
“You like that?” she asked.
“Yes,” I moaned. “That is so good. Oh God.”
“You better not cum until I do,” she warned me, but I couldn’t hold it in any longer. One more thrust sent me over the edge and I exploded into her pussy.
“Oh God, oh God, oh God!” I cried out. I couldn’t even stop myself from screaming; it was that good.
Natalie, to her credit, did not ruin my orgasm. She let me ride it out, grinding her hips up and down to push it past its natural end. When it was done though, she leaned into my face.
“You weren’t supposed to do that,” she said, softly.
“I know,” I replied, half dazed “I just…”
“You better make me cum good,” she said. “You better make this the best cum of my life.”
She slipped off me, and lay down beside me, spreading her legs. I was still lost in pleasure, and I planned to take a moment to recuperate, but Natalie was impatient, and reached over to grab my hand.
“John,” she said in a voice that I couldn’t believe belonged to her, “Make me cum. NOW.”
“Yes, ma’am,” I felt compelled to roll over and I stuck my fingers into her pussy. It was dripping wet, of course, but it was somehow still tight. I started to thrust my fingers in and out, and soon, we built up the traction that she needed to start feeling shock waves of pleasure.
“Oh yes,” she moaned, throwing her head back. “Oh yes. Oh yes, that’s it.”
“Yeah, you like that?” I asked her. “You like me fucking you like that?”
“Yes,” she moaned. “Don’t stop. Please don’t stop. Keeping going. Harder. Faster.”
Her words became more garbled as I pumped in and out of her. Her hips launched off the bed and she thrashed and cried out, all while begging me for me.
“Cum for me, baby,” I whispered to her. “Give me that cum that you have been saving all night.”
“I’m going to... I’m cumming,” she moaned. “Oh God, I’m cumming.”
I felt her pussy start to spasm around my fingers, and I pumped into her just a little harder. That seemed to be what she needed to push herself over the edge. Natalie came so furiously that I was pretty sure that neighbors heard her. She thrashed and moaned, and her thighs shook for a solid two minutes after that. She looked to be in heaven, and I felt smug that I had put her there.
“Oh God,” she moaned. “Oh God. Thank you. That was amazing. Thank you. Oh God.”
“I’m glad I could make you happy,” I said, as I snuggled up beside her “Maybe we should do this more often?”
“Mm.” She was still lost in the throes of her orgasm, and she closed her eyes. I thought she was headed to sleep until she sat up.
“Natalie?” I asked. “Is everything alright?”
“Yes,” she said. “I should go.”
“You don’t want to stay?” I asked, confused.
“I don’t think it would be a good idea right now, to stay,” she said. “But thank you.”
“Did I do something wrong?” I asked, confused. “You keep doing this.”
“No, John,” she said. “You didn’t do anything wrong. You were great.”
“Then why are you…”
“Please,” she said. “Don't ask anymore questions.”
“OK.” I respected her wishes. She gave me a kiss on the cheek and then headed out the door.
I was confused, of course, but my foremost thought was that I should take a shower and head to bed. In the morning, things always looked clearer. I waited until I heard her bedroom door close before I pulled on a pair of pants and headed for the shower.
To my surprise, Reed was doing the exact same thing.
“Hey?” I asked him, confused.
“Hey,” he said. “I was just going to shower.”
“Yeah me too,” I said. “I can go somewhere else, if you like?”
“No, I can use the other bathroom,” I said. “But ... why do you need a shower?”
“Because…” he said. “It doesn’t matter.”
“Well, because Natalie just fucked my brains out,” I bragged to him. “So, I feel like I should go first.”
“Oh,” he said, plainly. “You too.”
“What?” I asked, confused.
Both of us stared at each other for a moment, as it dawned on us.
“What do you think she’s up to?” I asked at last.
“I don’t know,” Reed said. “If I’m honest with you... I was feeling special. I thought she had chosen me, and I was worried about how I was going to break it to you.”
“Yeah, I said. “I was kind of feeling the same way.”
“Great,” Reed replied and we both glanced at Natalie’s bedroom door. “So... what now?”
I didn’t know. I had always been the more protective one in our friendship; the one that cheered him on and also made sure that everything was OK. Reed was always the one who needed a boost of self-confidence and a chat. But now, it seemed like we were both tangled in the same mess, which was light years away from normal.
What was this girl doing to us?
“I think we should both take showers,” I said at last. “And head to bed. Things will look clearer in the morning.”
‘Frankly, I think they will be murkier in the morning,” Reed said. “But it’s alright. We’ll figure it out.”
“We will,” I said. “Don’t worry about it.”
“Goodnight,” he said.
“Goodnight,” I replied, and headed to the other bathroom. It was odd, because usually when we had a problem, we talked to each other about it. Now, we were stuck.
As the hot water washed over my muscles, I tried to figure out what was going through Natalie’s head. Was she going to choose one of us in the morning? Were we going to finally put an end to this?
What if she chose neither of us? What if she chose both of us?
It was far too late to have these thoughts. I finished with the shower and toweled off. Once I was dry, I wrapped the towel around me and headed to bed. Whatever happened, I needed to sleep. I hoped in the morning, she would explain herself to both of us.
Chapter 18
Natalie
I couldn’t believe that last night had happened. I felt surprisingly awake, given all that had transpired. It was true, my muscles hurt and I felt sore in places that I didn’t know were sore, but I couldn’t stop smiling at the same time. I was happy that I had made the choice I had made. I was happy that both of the boys had been receptive, but there was one last thing that I had to do, and I knew it was necessary
“Good morning,” Reed said to me when I walked into the kitchen the next morning.
“Good morning,” I said. He gave me a smirk and I returned it. “It certainly is a good morning.”
“I agree,” he replied. “And I was really hoping that you would still be here in the morning.”
“Of course I’m still here,” I feigned pain. “Why would you say that?”
“Just because I know that things are... tricky in your mind,” he said. “And you’re going through a lot.”
“You’re right,” I said. “I am going through a lot. And I think I still need time to think.”
“You still need time to think?” John responded, as he came into the kitchen. “After last night?”
I assumed that they had talked, given the look that they exchanged. I was so surprised that they were both so cool about it, given the situation. But I suppose as best friends, they truly shared everything.
“Yep,” I said. “I do. Sorry, guys, I just... needed to be absolutely sure about what is happening in my head.”
“Were we not good enough?” John blurted out.
“It’s not about that,” I said and took a deep breath. “Let’s say we did this. The three of us. What would that look like?”
“What do you mean?” Reed asked.
“I mean... like... what does that look like for all of us, in a relationship?”
Reed looked to John and I realized that they did not think it was complicated at all. For them, it was the simplest thing in the world.
“It’s just... it’s just the way it would be,” Reed said at last. “I would date you, he would date you... and if it got more serious, we would figure it out.”
“Isn’t it already serious?” I asked. I honestly expected Reed to answer, because he was the one who was usually more serious. The fact that John answered surprised me.
“Yes,” John said. “It is already serious.”
I met his eyes.
“And they say tigers never change their stripes,” I answered. John smiled.
“And where would we live?”
“I think that answer would be obvious,” Reed said, and looked between the two of us. “You’d live here, unless you don’t want to? I have all the space, and then if Ricky wakes up…”
“When Ricky wakes up,” I corrected him.
“When Ricky wakes up,” he replied. “Then he can be here too. I mean, it just makes sense.”
“It actually does,” John said. “And you know I’ve been complaining about my condo fees forever. I wouldn’t mind living in a mansion and pretending I’m a billionaire.”
“You’re pretty damn close to being a millionaire already,” Reed said, and John smiled.
“Well, maybe I’ll just sell the condo and push myself over the edge,” he said and then turned back to me. “What do you think, Natalie?”
I had no answer at the moment. The offer was so tempting. I knew if I chose them, life would be more complicated than it ever had been. I would have two boyfriends to entertain, and it wouldn’t be easy. But at the same time, I would want for nothing. There would never be anything in my life that I would need and couldn’t have. I knew that they would take care of me, and they would make sure that I was satisfied, sexually, to my heart’s content.
“What is holding you back?” Reed asked and I raised my eyebrows. He realized what it was, and his mouth opened in shock.
