by Amy DeMeritt
“I thought you love her?”
“I do. And I know I hold Kayla’s heart. I know she would never cheat on me or do anything I didn’t give my approval to.”
“Are you ok with just being their plaything, knowing they love each other and probably would never love you the same?” Candi smiles at Sam and shrugs a shoulder. “I’ve only been with one person before and it only happened once and it was terrible. Even just dancing with these two is better than my first sex experience was. I’m ok with not being their number one. I don’t need that deep romantic relationship right now. I’m only eighteen. I’m not trying to settle down and have children yet.”
“Are you going to be loyal to them or sleep around and end up giving them something?”
“If I only have one previous experience, do I really seem like that kind of girl to you?”
“Well, you were only in a bra and skimpy shorts at that party. And you did go home with them and have a threesome and then a foursome this morning. You’ve now had sex with three women in less than twenty-four hours.” Candi laughs and shakes her head. “No, I had sex with one woman and made out with two others. Kayla is the only one that touched me down there, so I don’t count that as sex with you and Madison. And just because I’m confident and comfortable with my body doesn’t mean I put out.”
I can’t stop grinning like a fool. Candi made a really good point. Technically, I’m the only one that had sex with all of them. Everything they did with each other could have been done just making out. I made love to each one of them and then they worked together to make love to me, but none of them made love to each other. Sam looks over at me and smiles and shakes her head.
“Damn, what the hell did they wake up inside you?” I cheese bigger and she leans across the table and kisses me a moment. With her face in front of mine, she looks in my eyes and whispers, “I’m going to miss you even more now. Why did you have to get even sexier?” She kisses me again and then sits back down.
“Uh, here are your drinks.”
I look up at Carmen and she looks really confused. She places our drinks down and then holds her tray under her arm, looking between me, Madison, and Sam. She looks like she wants to keep the question in, but its burning her tongue and she just can’t keep it in.
“I thought you two were together?” She points between me and Madison and we smile at her. “We are. Kayla is mine and all of us are Kayla’s.”
My cocky confidence grows hot in my chest and I inhale deeply as my arousal kicks up higher. I love the way Madison just said that. I really want to go down on her right now.
Carmen stares at Madison in disbelief. She looks between all of us and I look around the table as well. Candi and Sam are watching Carmen with a small amused smile. Sam squeezes my leg under the table with hers and it makes me release a small laugh. Carmen looks at me and her mouth hangs open a moment and then she clears her throat. Her cheeks blush a deep red as she looks in my eyes and her confused dumbfounded look transforms into a shy smile.
“You are the kind of girl my mother warned me about. You are dangerous.”
I laugh really hard and she smiles really big. She fixes my hair that had fallen in my face from laughing, brushing her fingers through my hair, and then walks away.
“Are you going to add her when I leave?” I look at Sam and I shrug my shoulders. “I don’t make those calls. That’s Maddi’s department.”
Madison squeezes my thigh and I look over at her. She’s smiling in such a loving way that it makes my throat tighten. Madison brushes her fingers through my hair and then pulls me into a short kiss. We look back at Sam and she looks like she wants to ask another question, but she looks nervous. She picks at the paper placemat in front of herself and glances up at us.
“Speak your mind, Sam. What’s burning in that head of yours?” She looks at me and smiles affectionately. “What happens to us when I leave? I don’t want anyone else. I never wanted to break up with you. I let my mom get inside my head and I ruined everything because of it. I know you’re with Madison and that won’t change, but can I still fit in somehow?”
She looks at Madison and waits for her answer, understanding that I’ve given that power to Madison and I have no say in the matter. Madison rubs my thigh and squeezes it, leaning in closer to me.
“You going home for Thanksgiving?” Sam nods. “Then we’ll see you at Thanksgiving, unless you decide to come visit again sooner.”
“Seriously?” She smiles really big and leans across the table, kissing Madison on the lips. “Thank you.”
Madison smiles, but before she can say anything, Carmen is back with our food. She sets a large tray down on a stand and starts placing giant plates loaded with amazing looking food down in front of each of us. She places mine down last and I release a small moan.
“This looks so good.”
“I put a little extra hot fudge on it for you. Do you need anything else?”
She lifts the tray and it’s stand and tucks them under her arm. I glance down and notice a brown drip on her bare thigh. Without thinking, I reach forward and grab her thigh, tugging her a little closer. Carmen releases a small surprised moan.
“I think you dripped some fudge on yourself.” She lifts her leg some and looks down. “Oh, you’re right.” I rub my thumb over the drip, wiping it up off her leg and then suck it off my thumb. I see her swallow hard and her cheeks blush. She chokes out, “Thanks. Do you need anything else?”
I shake my head and she nods and walks away with a shy smile. After she walks away, I get an idea that makes me smile really big and Madison nudges me in the ribs.
“What’s that grin about?” I laugh and lick my lips, savoring the delicious thought. “We should buy chocolate syrup.” Madison licks her own lips and laughs a little. “What are we doing with the chocolate syrup?”
“I’m going to paint your body with it and then feast.”
“Ok, Daddy, we’ll buy some chocolate syrup.”
I smile really big and kiss her lips. She grips the inside of my thigh, just below my fun zone, making me release a small moan and she giggles.
Breakfast is delicious and the conversation is actually really nice. Sam ends up relaxing and doesn’t question or fight our “family” situation anymore and we’re able to talk without any awkwardness or tension. Carmen comes over several times to refill drinks and ask if we need anything and to steal a few moments to just chat.
I hate leaving food on my plate, but I’m so stuffed that I end up leaving about a quarter of my plate untouched. I’m leaning back in the booth holding my stomach when Carmen comes back again. She giggles and places her hands on her hips to look at me.
“Didn’t you like it?” I laugh and rub my stomach. “Yes, it was fucking amazing. But I’m stuffed. I can’t eat another bite.”
“How about a drop?”
Her eyes scan to her own leg and I follow her gaze and laugh. She has a drip of chocolate syrup just below the hem of her uniform skirt on the inside of her thigh. I glance at Madison and she giggles and nods once in approval for me to retrieve the drop.
Carmen moves closer to the booth to attempt to hide what I’m about to do. I slowly bring my hand under her skirt and grip her thigh above the chocolate drip, making Carmen inhale and lean in closer. I trail my fingers down the back of her thigh. I rub the drip off with my thumb and then continue my fingers gentle trail down her leg till I reach her knee. Instead of sucking the chocolate off my thumb like before, I offer it to Madison and she sucks it off in a very slow and sexy way. Carmen releases a small sound of arousal and then clears her throat and giggles.
“This table is dangerous. You girls are going to get me fired.” We laugh a little and she starts picking up plates to clear the table. “I’ll be back in a few.” She pulls her phone out and sets it down in front of me. “Add yourselves before I get back. I don’t know if I’m brave enough to get in the middle of this crazy sexy thing you have going on, but I’d like to hang out with all
of you at least.”
After she walks away, I look to Madison and she grins and picks up the phone. She goes to the contacts and adds her number, listing herself as “Mommy” and then hands me the phone. I enter mine as “Daddy” and then she takes the phone and hands it to Candi. After Candi finishes adding herself, she hands it to Sam. As Sam is finishing, Carmen returns with a smile. Sam hands her the phone and Carmen looks through her contacts with a confused look.
“Kayla, I don’t see you in here. Wait, I don’t see any of you.” I laugh a little. “Look in the D’s.” She scrolls up and smiles and looks at me with blushing cheeks. “Hey, Daddy. Ok, if you are Daddy, then Madison must be…” She smiles and giggles. “Mommy. Ok, Candi, you must be Baby Girl.”
“Yup.” Carmen scrunches her brow and looks down at Sam. “Why did you put yourself in here as The Black Sheep?” I laugh and shake my head. “Give me that.” Carmen hands me the phone and I open the contact to edit her name. I hand it back to Carmen and she giggles. Sam sits up craning her neck to see the screen. “What? What did she say?”
“Daddy’s little cup of milk and honey.”
Sam smiles and her cheeks blush. She looks down in a shy way before looking in my eyes with love and affection. Carmen looks at me with a curious grin and then her fingers start moving on her phone. My phone vibrates in my pocket. It’s a text from an unnamed number reading, “What’s my name going to be, Daddy?” I laugh and Madison leans over to read it and giggles. She looks at me with a cute mischievous grin and I sit back and think with a cocky grin on my face.
I add the number to my contacts and type in her name and show Madison for her approval and she nods and kisses my cheek. I show Carmen my phone and she smiles really big.
“Spicy Hot Chocolate, I like that. I should probably get back to work before my boss comes and asks why I’ve been over here for so long. You can hang out if you’re not ready to leave, but if I don’t see you before you leave, I guess I have your numbers now so I’ll talk to you soon.”
She starts to turn, but I grab the pocket of her apron.
“Carmen, you’re forgetting something.” She looks at me with a cute smirk and waits. “The bill?” She laughs and shakes her head. “I got it this time.” I shake my head. “Bring Daddy the check. This is not a pay to play kind of deal here.” She giggles and leans forward. “Exactly, you played, so you don’t pay.”
“I meant, you don’t pay to be played with. Now, listen to Daddy and bring me the check.”
“What if I want to disobey?” Sam laughs and leans forward on her elbows. “Can you handle two disobedient girls in your family, Daddy?”
Madison slips her hand between my legs and cups my center, making me release a small gasp and heat instantly flares up my chest and face. I swallow hard and my clit starts ticking.
Madison sucks my earlobe and whispers, “You are so damn sexy. I can’t wait to go down on you later. Are you going to punish Carmen for not listening to you, Daddy?”
I inhale at the hot coo and feel my cockiness grow even stronger.
“Carmen, when is your break?” She smiles and looks at her watch. “In ten minutes. Why? What do you have in mind, Daddy?”
“Your punishment for being disobedient.”
“Oh, then you definitely are not receiving that check, Daddy. I’ll come get you when I’m able to go on break.”
Carmen walks away and Madison loops her arm in mine. Sam looks at me with a grin and shake her head.
“I should have known that little baby-dom beast inside you would just blossom into something wild if I uncuffed you. I could see it fighting to be released when you would dance with other girls. Madison, you sure you can keep her on a leash?”
Madison places a hand on my cheek and turns my face to look at her. As soon as our eyes meet, my face spreads into a huge smile and she giggles.
“Who do you belong to, Kayla?”
“To you.” She smiles wider and kisses my lips. “Who do you want to please above all else?”
“You, my queen.” Madison sucks my bottom lip and gently pats my cheek a few times. “I love you too, baby.”
We look back at Sam and she just shrugs her shoulders and leans back. Candi looks over at her thoughtfully and asks, “When do you go home? Or I guess, back to school.”
“My friends want to leave tonight and drive through the night, so they’re trying to sleep pretty much all day today.”
“Who are those brutes and how did you get them to come out here with you?” Sam laughs and blushes a little bit. “They live in my dorm building. Our building had a huge party one night, but I wasn’t in the mood to party. I was sitting in a windowsill staring at the stars sipping on a big bottle of vodka just trying to ignore everyone and drink away my loneliness. They sensed my pathetic lovesick mood and came over to talk to me. They are really nice girls and actually offered to drive me out here to try to win Kayla back.”
“How did you know I was at that party?”
“You don’t want to know.” I look at her confused and she blushes bright red. “Sam, tell me.”
“Ok, well, I’m sorry. It wasn’t my idea. Jody is a computer genius and she was able to track your cellphone with GPS. We got there shortly after you and I watched you dance with Madison and Candi while we came up with the plan to blindfold you.”
I laugh and shake my head. “I love your crazy jealous ass. I can’t believe you lojacked me. That’s a higher level of crazy than you’ve ever been.” Sam smiles and laughs a little bit. “I know. It was fun though. It was so hard not to run over and hug you when we actually found you. I was skeptical it was going to work.”
Carmen quickly walks up and grabs my hand resting on the table, pulling me up from the booth.
“Come on, Daddy. Its break time.”
With Carmen guiding me with one hand in hers, Madison is holding my other, and Sam and Candi are closely following behind. She leads us outside and behind the restaurant. We are completely concealed back here, but I’ve never done something in such an open public place. It makes me nervous and excited.
Carmen releases my hand and faces me with her hands on her hips and a challenging smile. Madison wraps her arms around me from behind and leans her chin on my shoulder.
“What are you going to do to her, Daddy?”
“What does my queen say I should do to her?” Madison licks up the side of my neck and whispers in my ear, “Be rough and turn me on. Teach me something new.” I moan and she bites my ear. “Unleash that baby-dom inside you, Daddy.”
Madison releases me and pats my ass, urging me forward. Carmen’s smile widens as I take a step closer to her.
“Calmly approaching me with that cute grin is not intimidating, Daddy. Are you coming to punish me or are you coming to swaddle me?”
“Any limits?” She smiles and shakes her head. “Better make your move soon before… Oh!”
Before she can finish her sentence, I slide up right in front of her so our bodies are pressed tightly together and my nose is touching hers.
“Are you going to accept your punishment like a good girl?” Carmen smiles and shakes her head. “No.”
She pushes her hands into my shoulders, trying to push me back, but I’m solid and don’t budge. I lean into her and wrap an arm around her waist, holding her close to me. She inhales deeply, and then releases a surprised gasp as I land a firm smack on her ass.
I quickly turn us so her back is facing Madison so she can see better. Madison, Sam, and Candi are standing against the wall of the diner watching. Madison is in the middle and Sam and Candi have their arms looped through hers, standing close together. Seeing this makes my pride and confidence increase.
Carmen’s hands wrap around my back and slide down over my ass and squeeze. My clit starts hammering. I firmly grab her ass and squeeze her left cheek before delivering another firm smack, slightly harder than the last. Carmen moans and leans against me. I rub my hands up the backs of her thighs, slowly going under her sk
irt. She inhales deeply and lays in my neck. Her hands tighten on my ass as my hands lift her skirt, revealing her ass to my girls. They’re all smiling really big. I grip her cheeks and loop my thumbs in the waist of her panties and slowly pull them down a couple inches and wait to see if she objects. She inhales and kisses my neck, so I continue to pull her panties down off of her cheeks. All of my girls are staring hard at Carmen’s ass and they look very aroused.
I rub my palm over her left cheek and pull back to deliver a firm stinging slap to her bare ass. She gasps and arches her ass up some, inviting me back. I deliver a few good firm slaps to both cheeks and then pull back. I’m wearing a loose fitted tank top over a tighter one. I quickly pull my top layer off and grab her hands. She obediently crosses her hands in front of herself and I tie her hands together with my tank top. I quickly twist her around to face my girls and pull her arms above her head to wrap her tied hands behind my head. I slap the inside of her thigh and she gasps and slightly parts her legs. I repeat on the other leg and she spreads her legs a little further. I bend into her neck and rake my teeth up the side of her neck and firmly bite her earlobe.
“Have you had enough punishment?” She shakes her head and inhales. “Spank me, Daddy.” I trail my fingers up the sides of her thighs, loop my fingers in her panties and pull them down further. I look up at my girls and Madison’s watching with her thighs tightly pinched together and she’s biting her thumb. Our eyes meet and she grins. I lift Carmen’s skirt and hold it up with my left hand and deliver a gentle smack right between her legs. Carmen moans and presses in harder against me. I increase the firmness of the smack several times. Carmen is breathing hard and her moans and gasps are getting louder with each smack against her wet lips and clit.
There’s a pipe sticking out of the wall close to where my girls are standing that’s just a few inches higher than their heads. I smile and coax Carmen over to the wall and hook her tied hands up on the pipe. We’re now standing only a few inches in front of my girls. I lift the back of Carmen’s skirt off her ass and deliver a hard smack to her perfect round cheek. Carmen arches her back, spreads her legs, and opens her hips up to me. I grab her left cheek and pull it out as I slide my right hand between her legs and penetrate her. I thrust in deep and hard and she gasps and pumps back against me.
