Weapons of the Weak- Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance

Home > Other > Weapons of the Weak- Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance > Page 60
Weapons of the Weak- Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance Page 60

by James C Scott


  Wong Hin Soon. 1980. “Field Problems in Post-Production Handling of Padi.” Working Paper No. 19. Persidangan Padi Kebangsaan Malaysia (Malaysian national conference on paddy), Kuala Lumpur, February 26–28.

  Yamashita, Masanabu, Wong Hin Soon, and S. Jegatheesan. 1980. “MADA-TARC Cooperative Study, Pilot Project ACRBD 4, Muda Irrigation Scheme, Farm Management Studies.” Mimeo.

  Young, Kevin, William C. F. Bussink, and Parvez Hassan. 1980. Malaysia’s Growth and Equity in a Multiracial Society. A World Bank Country Economic Report. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press.

  Zakariah Ismail. 1980. “Economic and Social Aspects of Padi Production: Some Recent Trends.” Paper presented at Seminar on Economics, Development and the Consumer, Consumers’ Association of Penang. Penang.

  Zola, Emile. 1980. The Earth. Trans. Douglas Parmee. Harmondsworth: Penguin.

  Index

  [Page 375]

  Abdul Majid, 5, 159, 218, 221, 226, 233

  Abdul Rahim, 93, 198, 261n

  Abdul Rahman, 22, 93, 122, 141n, 161n, 164, 171, 173, 175, 207, 234, 244, 260, 281

  Abercrombie, Nicholas, 247n, 319n, 320

  Abu Hassan, 21, 94, 127, 135n, 144, 155, 195, 227, 267, 360

  Abu Saman, 206–08

  Accumulation, 181–82, 234–35; of capital, 181, 184; of land, 14–17, 96–97, 149

  Accusation: language of, 186–89; logic of, 160–62, 168–69, 181–83

  Afifuddin Haji Omar, 72n, 74n

  Agricultural labor, 51n, 113 and n, 306; gender-based division of, 117n, 119. See also Wage labor, paddy

  Agriculture, 51; capitalist, 27, 42, 44, 71, 80, 110, 167 and n, 181–83, 184, 234–35, 241, 349; commercialization of, 71, 74, 85, 106, 107, 123–24, 181–82, 189; plantation sector, 32, 51, 55, 124, 313. See also Double-cropping; Green Revolution; Rice cultivation

  Ahmad, Tok, 93, 165, 194–95, 208–09, 210

  Akil, 217–18

  Ali Abdul Rahman, 93, 132n

  Alier, Juan Martinez, 262n, 322n, 325n, 347

  Ali Husin, 190

  Alor Setar, 52, 62, 80, 170n, 275

  Althusser, Louis, 42, 43, 247n, 315, 317, 319

  Amin, 4, 5, 7, 94, 97, 114, 153–54 and n, 162, 228, 254, 263, 267; in village politics, 127, 128, 216–17, 221, 226, 232, 360

  Andalusia, rural labor of, 239, 322n, 325n, 326n, 347

  Anderson, Perry, 278n, 315n

  Ani, Haji, 13, 16, 20, 165

  Ariffin, 5, 89, 93, 132n, 250

  Arrests, political, 246, 274, 276

  Arrogance, charge of, 187, 199; against the poor, 197–98, 301; against the rich, 195–97, 239

  Arson, 29, 248, 249; absent in Sedaka, 273

  Asian Development Bank, 50

  Ayub, Haji (Haji Broom), 13–19, 21, 22–26, 188, 200n, 311

  Azaudin, Haji, 212

  Bakar “halus,” 200

  Bakri bin Haji Wahab, 92, 123, 132n, 161n, 171, 222, 229, 230n, 255, 281

  Barnard, Rosemary, 72n, 74n, 253

  Basir, 2, 4, 7, 11–12, 19, 89, 90, 94, 128, 131, 136, 159, 161n, 226, 234, 274, 277 and n, 278–79; in village politics, 127, 128, 131, 136, 169, 214–18, 221, 222–23, 227–33, 276–77, 360

  Behavior, 38, 46; onstage vs. backstage, 284–89. See also Compliance and conformity; Resistance

  Bell, Clive, 79n

  Bernstein, Richard J., 45n

  Blacks, American, 33–34, 279n, 329, 338

  Blame, assignment of, in Sedaka: to local neighbors, 160–62, 168–69, 182; to Malays, not Chinese, 168–69, 181–83

  Bloch, Marc, 332

  Blum, Jerome, 294n

  Bourdieu, Pierre, 283, 307 and n, 310, 323n, 345

  Boycotts, 290, 291; farm labor, 250–55

  [Page 376]

  Brecht, Bertolt, 346

  Broadcasting (dry sowing), 121–22, and n, 123 and n, 259, 260 and n, 242, 250n

  Buddhism, 331, 333

  Bukit Raya (district), 253, 276

  Burma, 44, 333

  Capitalism, 50, 51, 234–35, 307 and n, 311, 316, 318; agrarian, 27, 42, 44, 71, 80, 110, 167 and n, 181–83, 184, 241, 349; early vs. mature, 182n, 320–21, 346; ideological disaffection of labor, 339; resistance against, 235, 302, 347–48; revolutionary character of, 346–47

  Carlyle, Thomas, 347

  Census: decennial, 275; house-by-house, for government aid, 130, 131, 143, 221, 226–27

  Ceti, 21

  Character assassination. See Slander and character assassination

  Charity, 9–11, 135, 169–78, 185, 189–91; decline of, and increase in theft, 269, 271 and n, 291; as social lever, 11, 171–72, 175, 185, 194–95, 197; as tie between classes, 136–37, 144, 156, 306, 308–09; types of, 169–74. See also Zakat

  Chettiar moneylenders, 21, 44

  Chinese, the, 58 and n, 62–63, 86, 186n; as combine, tractor, truck owners, 109, 160, 162, 167, 169, 181–82, 214, 218–19, 249; as land tenants, 109–10, 167–69, 181–82; Malay relations with, 168–69, 181–82, 258; as moneylenders, 16, 151

  Christianity, 287n, 331

  Civil War (U.S.), 30–31

  Class consciousness, 38, 43, 288, 297, 340–45. See also False-consciousness

  Class experience, 41–47, 319n

  Class relations, 43, 140–41, 180–83, 290; analysis of, 42–47; balance of power, rich vs. poor, 22–27, 193–94, 212, 286 and n, 287–89, 305; blame assignment, intravillage intraethnic, 160–62, 168–69, 181–83; breakdown of social authority, 311–12 and n; conceptual equality, 192–95, 196, 218, 220; flow of money from poor to rich, 162, 194–95; interdependence severed, 76–77, 124, 136–37, 150–51, 180, 184, 243, 284, 305, 311, 312; landlord-tenant, in Sedaka, 104–05, 136–37, 153–54, 189, 193–94, 205–12, 306; moral context of, 184–85, 199; politics and, 134–35, 180, 220–33, 278–81, 314; rich-poor, 190–98, 305–14; rich-poor, in Sedaka, 24, 124, 129, 134–37, 141–82, 199–212, 241, 244, 282, 284, 288–89, 305, 336, 338, 345–48; rich-poor, widening of gulf, 57, 80, 84, 124, 182; and ritual ties, 169, 172, 180, 237–40, 308; role of charity in, 136–37, 144, 156, 169–78, 189–91, 194–95, 306, 308; shared values and norms, 184–98, 204, 207–12, 282–84, 305–10, 313, 337–38; symbols of, 44–45, 309; turned “topsy-turvy,” 162, 167–68, 178–83, 194–95

  Class structure, Sedaka, 91, 95–100, 199–204; complexity of, 244

  Class struggle, 42, 147–48, 243, 290, 296–97; common cause of, 338; objective vs. personal/social view of, 181–82 and n. See also Ideological conflict; Resistance Cloward, Richard A., 43, 323

  Cobb, R. C., 30, 37n

  Cobbett, William, 347

  Coles, Robert, 279n

  Collective resistance, 248–65, 292, 295, 297–99; obstacles to, 242–48, 273

  Colonial Malaya, 31–32, 62–63, 298, 313

  Combine-harvesters, 44, 72, 110; brokers, 161–62; effects in Sedaka, 8–9, 111–12, 114–21, 123, 125, 150, 154–64, 167–68; effects on pure [Page 377] wage labor, 116–18; justification by users of, 157–58, 161; peasant resistance to, 116, 160–64, 242–43, 246, 248–55; syndicates, 109, 110n, 160, 167 and n, 182, 249; views of rich vs. poor on, 154–64; wage labor displaced by, 9, 67, 74–76, 111–25, 150, 155–64

  Commercialization, 57, 71, 74, 85, 106, 107, 123–24, 181–82, 189

  Commodity fetishism, 39n, 307n

  Compliance and conformity, 24–26, 246–47, 273, 277, 289, 302, 304; false, 25, 29, 34, 37, 279–80, 284–86, 288–89; false-consciousness and, 39–40, 287, 316; interpretations of, 38–40, 284–89, 320; legitimation of hegemony lacking in, 324–25; as pragmatic resignation, 324–27; pressure for, on poor, 276–80, 312; protest within, 26 and n, 289; routine, 278–84, 320. See also Deference

  Concentration camps, 286, 287, 327–28

  Conformity. See Compliance and conformity; Deference

  Corruption and profiteering, 128–29, 143–44, 222–23, 225–29

  Corvée labor, 62, 63, 298, 307

  Counterappropriation, 34, 296, 301, 302–03

  Credit, 4
8, 64, 68, 84n, 136; delinquency and default, 84, 128–29; fraud, 128; government and quasigovernment, 56, 82–84, 126–29; interest rates, 15n, 44, 128; jual janji (mortgage) system, 16–17, 19, 21, 68, 73, 149, 311; padi kunca (paddy) system, 15 and n

  Cullam, Shelby, 296n

  Cultural resistance, 34, 287n, 300–01

  Cultural standing, 237–40

  Cutting of paddy, 75n, 115, 117, 119

  Daane, Jon R. V., 74n

  Datuk Asri, 224n

  Daud bin Haji Jafaar, 4, 89, 97, 127, 128, 131, 161n, 201, 216–17, 221, 360

  Death benefit societies, 3, 132, 134, 136, 238

  Deference, 24–25, 191, 197–98, 273; born of mortal fear, 286, 327–28; “false,” 25, 279–80, 285–86, 288–89, 327n

  Defiance behavior, 26, 32, 33, 243

  De Koninck, Rodolphe, 221n

  Demonstrations and riots, 52, 53–54 and n, 254, 334; absence in Sedaka, 273; in Alor Setar (1980), 80, 275–76

  Dependencies: rich-poor, 76, 180, 284–86, 305–06, 312; severed, 76–77, 124, 137, 150–51, 180, 184, 243, 284, 311, 312; on the state, of rich, 312–13

  Derma gifts, 169, 172 and n Desertion, 30–31, 32, 291, 293–94, 301

  Determinism, 317

  Dignity, loss of, of poor, 236–40

  Din, Haji, 165, 194–95, 208–09, 210

  Dissimulation, 25, 29, 200–04, 281, 284–85, 287, 288

  Double-cropping, 55, 186; effects of, 49, 66–68, 69, 75–85, 147; effects in Sedaka, 8, 42, 95–125, 137, 140, 148–51, 179–81, 238, 305; in Kedah, 65, 66–68, 148; views of poor vs. rich on, 148–51

  Drought of 1978, 67, 111

  Drought relief programs, 126, 129–30, 135

  Dry sowing. See Broadcasting Dulang (village), 216, 217

  Dullah, 11, 90, 92, 143, 149, 171, 174, 175, 186, 198, 228, 230n, 270–71

  “Dull compulsion of economic relations,” 252, 277–78, 304, 317, 336

  Dunn, John, 47

  Durkheim, Emile, 247

  [Page 378]

  Dzulkifli bin Haji Wahab, 93, 161n, 222, 230n, 281

  Economic system: and class relations, 42, 246, 252, 306–09, 336; “dull compulsion” of, 252, 277–78, 304, 317, 336. See also Production relations

  Economy, Malaysian, 50–51, 57, 246n

  Education, 50, 52n, 54, 57n, 65, 238

  Elections: of 1969, 53; of 1978, 57, 58n, 132; system of, 49, 52–53, 314 and n

  Elite, 38–40; class value imposition by, 40–41, 184–85, 287 and n, 304–05, 311–12 and n, 313–14, 315–17, 335, 336n, 341; political, Malaysia, 53; in political parties, 132, 135 and n; use of repression by, 246; village, 25–27, 129, 132, 137, 220, 283, 288–89. See also Rich, the

  Emigration, as form of resistance, 34, 35, 245. See also Flight; Migration

  Employment, 56, 67, 135; ties between classes, 136–37. See also Wage labor

  Engels, Friedrich, 265n, 315, 321

  England, 41, 347; peasant resistance, 35n, 249 and n, 265, 285; workingclass culture, 321, 322, 325n, 349

  Equality, conceptual, 192–95, 196, 218, 220

  Esman, Milton, 83n

  Euphemization, 205 and n; of socioeconomic power, 306–09, 314

  Evasion, 31, 35, 36, 301, 302, 329

  Exchange labor, 113n, 115, 300

  Exploitation, 39, 135, 180, 302, 307n; forms of, 328; to marginalization, 76–77, 243; rationalization of, 204–12; status, 240; vocabulary and examples of, 186–98

  Exports, 50–51, 54, 314

  Factionalism, 43, 140, 214–18, 224

  Fadzil, 11, 19, 93, 97, 109, 141n, 159, 166, 214–19 and n, 223, 267–68, 271n; in village politics, 127, 128, 132, 221, 231–32, 360

  False-consciousness, 39–40, 43, 49n, 139, 247n, 279, 287; institutional basis of, 315–17, 322; self-infliction, 322–24

  Farmers’ Association, 82–83, 125–26, 275; class character of, 126–28, 129; corruption and profiteering, 128–30; membership in, 83, 126–28, 136; nepotism, 130; partisan character of, 126–28, 129–30, 136; in Sedaka area, 12, 86, 87, 126–30, 131, 136, 159, 217

  Farm size: in Muda, 63, 64, 69, 70; in Sedaka, disparities, 91, 95, 98–99, 100–02 and n; structural favoring of large operators, 71–85, 99–100, 167n

  Feasts: Malay, 87, 149, 162, 169, 172–78, 237–39; reversal of social status in, 287n, 331

  Femia, Joseph, 316

  Feminism, 33n

  Fertilizer, 48, 55–56, 64, 66, 72, 82, 126, 128

  Feudalism, 287n, 328, 330–31, 340

  Field preparation, 74, 113–14

  Firth, Raymond, 190

  Fitrah (gifts), 10; peribadi, 171

  Flight, as form of resistance, 34, 35, 245, 298, 302, 329. See also Migration

  Flying letters (surat layang), 334, 362

  Food, 66, 148–49; meat, 174n; poor vs. well-to-do, 6

  Foot dragging, 29, 34, 35, 251, 255, 302

  France, 30–31; class relations, 147, 199n, 265, 284–85, 299n, 324, 332

  French Revolution, 344 and n Frontier society, 59, 62, 64, 266

  Fujimoto, Akimo, 72n, 74n, 192, 213n

  Funerals, 3, 7, 225n, 238

  Furnishings, house, 6, 66

  Gaafar, 217–18, 219

  Gaventa, John, 277n, 325n

  Geertz, Clifford, 45, 139

  [Page 379]

  Gelam Dua (village), 253

  Genovese, Eugene, 292, 293, 329, 338

  Germany, class relations, 34–35 and n, 239n, 342–43

  Ghandi, Indira, 283n

  Ghani Lebai Mat, 7, 94, 127, 128, 164, 166, 209, 267

  Ghazali, 5, 18, 94, 126n, 144, 156, 207n, 223, 228–29, 360

  Gibbons, D. S., 221n

  Giddens, Anthony, 318n, 319n, 32 n, 338n

  Gilmore, David, 239

  Gleaning, 9n, 256–57 and n; elimination of, 9, 76, 118–19, 154; behind combine-harvesters, 119, 156

  Goffman, Erving, 11n

  Gossip, 282, 284, 290. See also Reputation, politics of; Slander and character assassination

  Government policy, Malay, 54–57, 182, 275–77; Muda region, 65, 82–85, 313–14. See also Land policy; Rice policy

  Government services and subsidies, 4, 12, 50, 52n, 220–21, 314; rural development, 54–56, 65, 131; in Sedaka, 131–32, 220–33

  Gramsci, Antonio, 39, 315–17, 322, 331, 336–37 and n, 340–41, 346

  Greed, 17, 22, 187–88. See also Stinginess Green paddy, selling of, 110n, 162n, 165n

  Green revolution, 41–42, 56, 186; and farm commercialization, 71; in Muda, 64–68, 74–85, 180; in Sedaka, 86, 95–125, 140, 179–80. See also Double-cropping; Rice

  Griffin, Keith, 80, 84

  Gross national product, Malaysia, 50

  Guar Cempedak (town), 131, 276

  Gullick, John M., 62

  Habermas, Jurgen, 247n, 286, 315

  Haji, title and status, 18–22, 44–45, 107, 181

  Haji Broom. See Ayub, Haji Hamid, 93, 141n, 160

  Hamzah, 1–3, 7, 24, 89, 92, 113, 145–46, 150, 155, 160, 176–77, 178, 198, 222, 252, 263, 277n; and Haji Kadir, 21, 271–72, 279–81, 309; the zakat champ, 11, 171

  Harun bin Haji Jaafar, 127

  Harun Din, 93, 132n

  Harvesting, 75, 117–18, 121 and n; hand, 117–18, 121 and n, 155–56, 253–54; mechanized, 114–16, 118–19, 155–57. See also Combine-harvesters

  Hasnah, 92, 97

  Hassan, Haji, 167

  Hauling of paddy, 124n, 213 and n, 214–20

  Health services, 50, 52n, 54, 57n, 65, 87

  Hearn, Francis, 178n, 299n-300n

  Hegel, G. W. E, 12n, 139n, 179, 289

  Hegemony, ideological, 247n, 287 and n, 304–05, 311–12 and n, 313–14, 326; conflict within, 335–40; Gramsci’s analysis of, 315–17; inevitability of disputed, 322–24, 327–28, 330–31, 334, 347; legitimacy of questioned, 322–24 and n, 330, 334; not present in Sedaka, 318, 321–22, 336, 345; penetration of, by poor, 318–22, 346; questioning of concept, 317–18, 335. See also Ideology />
  Herring, Ronald, 312n

  Hinduism, 40 and n, 287n, 327, 331

  Hobsbawm, E. J., 36n, 273, 301, 344

  Hoggart, Richard, 322, 323n

  Horii, Kenzo, 90n-91n, 98, 101, 103 and n, 104n, 108, 113, 189

  Housing, 66, 89; government grants for, 89, 132, 143, 221–23, 226–33

  Humiliation of poor, 117n, 176, 194, 237–40; avoidance, 193, 197, 283

  Hyden, Goran, 302

  Identification with oppressor, 327–28

  [Page 380]

  Ideological conflict, 233–40, 297, 304–14, 335–46; caused by violation of promises, 338–40, 342–47; in Sedaka, 192–94, 234–39, 308–09, 336, 338, 340, 345–48; village gate issue, 212–20; in Village Improvement Scheme allocations, 220–33

  Ideology: of class relations, 188–98, 199, 204, 304–14; demystification of, 40–41, 316, 317, 346; elite control and imposition of, 39–41, 184–85, 287 and n, 304–05, 311–12 and n, 313–17, 335, 336n, 341; millennial and utopian, 332–33, 334, 335n, 336; penetration and deviant interpretation by poor, 318–22, 346; shared values, 184–98, 204, 207–12, 282–84, 305–10, 313, 337–38; subordinate classes and, 38–41, 316, 317, 340–45, 346–47

  Idleness, humiliation of, 117n, 239

  Idris, 87, 94, 127, 267

  Ignorance, feigned, 29, 33–34, 37

  Income: average, growth of, 55–56, 77–79; average, recent retreat, 78–79; farm, in Muda, 63, 65, 77–81, 355; farm wage labor in Sedaka, 112–13, 116–24; Malay vs. Chinese, 53; maldistribution of, 51–52, 53, 56, 57; maldistribution in Muda, 77–80; maldistribution in Sedaka, 91, 95, 96, 124; poverty-level, 9, 51–52, 81, and n, 82, 91; understatement strategies, 199–203

  India, 147, 283n; caste system in, 33, 39–40, 289n, 324, 327, 329, 330–31

  Indonesia, 147, 332. See also Java Inevitability, concept of, 322–24, 327–28, 330–31, 334, 347

  Inheritance, 211; land fragmentation by, 68n, 71, 99–100

  Institutional access, 82–85, 297–99; in Sedaka, 126–30, 135–37, 142, 220–33

  Insubordination, 31, 36, 294

  Interest rates, 15n, 44; subsidized, 128

  Intermediaries, use of, 207 and n, 250

  Internal Security Act, 53, 274

  Intimidation, 246, 274–75, 286

  Invasion of land, 32, 302–03

  Invisibles, 12 and n, 239

  Irrigation, 50, 66; canceled season of 1978, 66–67, 111; timed by state, 48, 56, 82. See also Double-cropping; Muda Irrigation Project Ishak, 25, 93, 227, 229n, 255

 

‹ Prev