Death in Florence: the Medici, Savonarola and the Battle for the Soul of the Renaissance City

Home > Other > Death in Florence: the Medici, Savonarola and the Battle for the Soul of the Renaissance City > Page 53
Death in Florence: the Medici, Savonarola and the Battle for the Soul of the Renaissance City Page 53

by Paul Strathern


  culture of, 139 and n

  delegations sent to, 154–6

  Tuscan delegation in, 156, 158–9

  Giovanni’s life in, 156–7

  Giovanni’s departure from, 158

  Lombardy delegation in, 159–60

  and the French invasion, 205, 218–19, 220

  direct action against Savonarola urged in, 221

  Alexander VI’s Brief summons Savonarola to, 221

  Savonarola refuses to go to, 222, 233, 239

  opinion swings behind reinstatement of the Medici, 230

  Michelangelo in, 235–6

  Savonarola’s rhetoric against, 250–1, 263

  committee of theologians reports in, 253–4

  Bracci as Florentine envoy in, 264–5

  news of French treaty with Holy League reaches, 265

  Piero de’ Medici in, 271–3, 280

  increasing outrage against Savonarola in, 273

  delivery of papal Brief of Excommunication from, 276–7

  depiction on medal in Florence, 287

  Bonsi sent as second ambassador to, 292

  Bonsi’s despatch from, 294

  meeting of Alexander VI with Bracci and Bonsi, 295

  Signoria receives ultimatum demanding Savonarola’s despatch to, 300

  news about Savonarola’s intention to send circular letter reaches, 303

  Bonsi’s audience with Alexander VI about ordeal by fire, 311

  Alexander continues to ask for Savonarola to be sent to, 334

  Signoria reluctant to send Savonarola to, 335

  Alexander insists that three friars should be sent to, 347–8

  Pratica sends despatch to, 348

  Remolino delivers his official report in, 368

  brief references, 58, 59, 94, 132, 175, 226, 241, 243, 281, 315

  see also Vatican; names of popes

  Roover, Raymond de, 36, 63, 78, 131, 199

  Roscoe, William, 24, 128–9

  Rovere, Cardinal Giuliano della (later Pope Julius II), 75, 157, 158, 172, 218, 369

  Rovizzano, 253 and n

  Rucellai, Bernardo, 113, 138, 139, 140, 211, 216

  Rucellai, Girolamo, 309

  Rucellai family, 130 see also names of individuals

  Russia, 370

  St Martin, brotherhood of, 112

  Salone dei Cinquecento, Florence, 232

  Salviati, Francesco, Archbishop of Pisa, 32, 33–4

  Salviati, Giuliano, 288

  Salviati, Marcuccio, 316, 317, 320

  San Croce, Florence, 138, 240, 277, 304, 305, 306

  San Gallo Augustinian monastery, Florence, 107, 109 and n, 198

  San Gervasio, 129

  San Gimignano, 72, 73, 74, 95, 137, 155, 164, 226

  San Giorgio, convent of, Florence, 72

  San Lorenzo, Church of, Florence, 9, 71, 130, 132–3

  San Marco, Church of, Florence, 7, 101–2, 111, 248, 278, 291, 296, 297, 306, 312, 317, 323

  San Marco, monastery of, Florence

  Savonarola takes up post as lecturer at, 38, 53, 54

  foundation, 54

  renovation, 54–5

  lifestyle of monks in, 55–6, 145

  Pico visits Savonarola in, 69, 81, 99, 110

  success of Savonarola’s theological instruction in, 70, 71

  Savonarola recalled to, 94, 97

  Savonarola takes up post as teaching master at, 99

  monks warn Savonarola about his reckless preaching, 102

  Fra Mariano da Genazzano visits Savonarola in, 108

  Savonarola becomes prior of, 111

  Lorenzo the Magnificent sends gifts to, 112

  leading citizens meet Savonarola at, 113–14

  Lorenzo’s body taken to, 130

  travellers bring news to, 134

  Savonarola sees need for reform at, 145–6

  Savonarola wants to move community to new premises from, 146, 152

  visitors attracted to, 146–7

  Savonarola instructed to move friars into building adjoining, 153–4

  Florentine delegation sets out from, 155–6

  reforms at, 160, 163–4

  Giovanni de’ Medici gives rare books and manuscripts to, 195–6

  Pico leaves his possessions to, 209

  Pico buried in, 209

  Savonarola writes in his cell at, 224

  and Frateschi, 230

  so-called papal Brief arrives at, 240

  Savonarola’s boys recruited by friars of, 245

  distribution of food and clothing, 253

  crowds jeer outside, 279

  plague at, 285

  vigil in days before the planned ordeal by fire, 314

  stones hurled at Fra Mariano Ughi and his group outside, 322

  siege of, 324–9

  monks send letter to the pope, 345–7

  brief references, 60, 134, 242, 275, 286, 308, 311, 321, 331, 332, 335

  Sannazaro, Giacopo, 129

  Santa Caterina, monastery of, Pisa, 166

  Santa Maria del Sasso, hospice of, Casentino, 239

  Santa Maria Novella, Church of, Florence, 277

  Santo Agostino, Church of, Faenza, 46

  Santo Spirito, Church of, Florence, 109 and n, 267

  and n, 277

  Sarzanello, 185–6, 190

  Sarzano, 185, 186, 211

  Savonarola, Elena, 48, 72–3, 95, 96, 208

  her son’s letters to, 72–3, 95, 96–7

  Savonarola, Girolamo

  early years, 39–40, 41–2

  education, 42–3, 45, 48–9

  falls in love and is rejected, 43–4

  and civil war in Ferrara, 44–5

  reaches crisis point, 45–6

  becomes convinced that he will become a priest, 46

  asks to become novitiate monk at Dominican monastery in Bologna, 46

  letter to his father, 46–7

  early life in the monastery, 47–9

  takes up post as teaching master in monastery in Ferrara, 49

  at Chapter General of the Dominicans of Lombardy, 51, 52–3

  and Pico della Mirandola, 51, 52–3, 69–70, 81–2, 99, 100, 101, 106, 134, 147–8, 149, 150, 151, 163, 166, 180

  given post as lecturer at monastery of San Marco, 53

  walks to Florence, 53

  arrival in Florence, 38, 54

  first glimpse of Lorenzo the Magnificent, 55

  first period in Florence, 56, 60, 69–74

  becomes master of novices at San Marco, 70

  delivers 1484 Lenten sermons in Church of San Lorenzo, 71

  wishes to abandon public preaching, 71–2

  delivers 1485 Lenten sermons at San Gimignano, 72

  letters to his mother, 72–3, 95, 96–7

  delivers 1486 Lenten sermons at San Gimignano, 73–4

  appointed master of studies at Studium generale in Bologna, 74

  takes up post at Studium generale, 94

  posted back to Ferrara, 94–5

  travels and preaches throughout northern Italy, 95–6

  invited to return to Florence by Lorenzo the Magnificent, 8, 94

  ordered to take up residence as teaching master at monastery of San Marco, 97

  journey to Florence, 97–8

  takes up post at San Marco, 99

  philosophy, 100–1

  preaches sermon in San Marco in August 1490, 101–2

  chosen to deliver 1491 Lenten sermons, 102

  warned about content of his sermons, 102

  preparations for sermons, 102–3

  delivers 1491 Lenten sermons in Florence Cathedral, 103

  delivers private sermon for gonfaloniere and Signoria, 103–4

  Lorenzo the Magnificent decides against banishment of, 104

  Lorenzo plans to undermine, 105, 107

  and Poliziano, 106, 134, 147, 166, 181, 209, 210

  and Ficino, 106, 134, 217, 227, 237–8, 261, 299

  and Fra Mariano da Genazzano’s sermon, 108
–10

  elected as prior of monastery of San Marco, 111

  refuses to pay courtesy visit to Palazzo Medici, 111

  does not respond to Lorenzo’s conciliatory actions, 111–12

  visited by delegation of leading citizens, 113–14

  prediction of deaths of Lorenzo, Innocent III and King Ferrante, 114, 133–4, 176

  and Lorenzo’s appropriation from Dowry Fund, 118

  visions, 123–4, 126–7, 132–3 and n, 143–4, 146n, 224–8, 229

  face-to-face encounter with Lorenzo, 7–8, 124–7

  and Lorenzo’s lying in state at San Marco, 130

  1492 Lenten sermons at San Lorenzo, 132

  and Michelangelo, 134–5, 147, 236

  power of his preaching, 135–7

  1492 Advent sermons, 141–3, 144–5

  uncomfortable in his position as prior of San Marco, 145–6

  dream about friars of San Marco, 146 and n

  attracts visitors to San Marco, 146–7

  and Botticelli, 147, 166, 170, 171, 181, 217, 227, 236

  wants to build new monastery for friars of San Marco, 152–3

  not granted permission for new monastery, 153–4

  and the attempt to gain independence of Tuscan Congregation from Lombardy Congregation, 154–5, 155–6, 158, 159

  becomes Vicar General of newly independent Tuscan Congregation, 163

  reforms at San Marco, 160–1, 163–4

  makes plans for new community near Fiesole, 162

  sends friars out to preach in Tuscany, 164

  encounters hostility in role as Vicar General, 164–6

  preaches 1493 Advent sermons, 166

  sermon in September 1494, 179–80

  reports of sermon are made to Piero de’ Medici, 181

  sermon on All Saints Day 1494, 187–8

  sermons on the following days, 189

  as head of Florentine delegation ot Charles VIII, 190, 200–1

  and delivery of books and manuscripts from Medici library to San Marco, 195

  informs Florence of imminent arrival of French army, 201

  gives sermons before arrival of the French, 201–2

  and Villari’s account of atmosphere in the city, 202–3

  meeting with Charles VIII in Florence, 207–8

  learns of death of his mother, 208

  and death of Poliziano, 208–9

  and death of Pico, 209–10

  preaches 1494 Advent sermons, 213, 214, 216

  and the government of Florence, 214, 215, 217, 231, 268, 269

  misgivings about the power of, 217–18

  meeting with Commines, 220

  Alexander VI writes papal Brief exhorting him to come to Rome, 221

  response to Alexander VI, 222

  illness, 222

  a ‘last sermon’ in July 1495, 222–4

  retires to cell at San Marco, 224

  influence reaches a wider audience, 229

  as focus of division in Florence, 230–1, 267

  opposition to, 230–1, 233

  and the building of hall for Great Council, 231–2

  retires to the countryside, 239

  so-called papal Brief for, 239–41

  reply to so–called papal Brief, 241–2

  continues preaching in defiance of order in so-called papal Brief, 243

  ordered to stop preaching by papal Brief from Alexander VI, 243–4

  receives verbal permission to preach again, 244–5

  action against excesses of Carnival, 245–6, 247

  and gambling, 246

  and sodomy, 246–7

  as precursor of revolutionary tradition, 249

  delivers 1496 Lenten sermons, 249–52

  sermons anger rulers throughout Italy, 252

  Alexander VI appoints ecclesiastical committee to investigate, 252

  organises distribution of food and clothing, 253

  ecclesiastical committee finds no evidence of heresy in teachings of, 253–4

  and mission of Fra Ludovico da Ferrara, 254

  preaches sermon on 20 August 1496, 254–5

  and death of Charles VIII’s son, 256–7

  sermon of 28 October 1496, 257

  preaches 1497 Lenten sermons, 262–4, 265–6, 267

  reaction to sermons in Rome, 264–5

  growing public disillusion with his role as prophet, 265

  predicts death of Charles VIII, 266

  political situation in Florence shifts against, 267, 268–9

  increasing anger in Rome against, 273

  Ascension Day sermon 1497, 274–5

  excommunication, 276–7

  response to excommunication, 277–8

  public rejoicing about news of his excommunication, 279

  and the fate of citizens accused of being traitors, 283, 285–6

  consolidates his political power, 286

  popularity, 286–7

  period of creative output, 287–8, 289–90

  Salviati seeks advice from, 288–9

  political philosophy, 289–90

  asked if he is intending to resume preaching, 291–2

  lawyer despatched to Rome to seek absolution for, 292

  delivers sermon in February 1498, 292–3

  launches personal attack on Alexander VI, 293

  reaction to sermon, 293–4

  assassination plot against, 294

  Alexander VI expresses his anger about, 295

  Bonsi’s despatch from Rome concerning, 294, 295

  Alexander VI sends two papal Briefs to Florence about, 295

  discussion in Florence about papal Briefs, 296–7

  commanded not to preach by Signoria, 297

  supporters and opponents in Signoria, 298

  Vatican demands that he should be taken into custody and sent to Rome, 300

  writes circular letter to rulers, 300–2

  fate of his letters, 303–4

  letter passed on to Alexander VI, 304

  and the ordeal by fire episode, 304, 305–7, 308, 310–11, 311–12, 313, 314–15, 317, 318, 319, 320, 321

  incidents involving supporters and opponents of, 322

  and siege of San Marco, 325, 326, 328

  taken prisoner, 329–30

  trial and torture by judicial commission, 331–43

  Fra Silvestro Maruffi questioned about, 345

  friars of San Marco describe their feelings about, 346–7

  torture and confessions of supporters produce no convincing evidence against, 347

  Pratica decides on course of action with regard to, 347–8

  ambassador informs Alexander VI about decision, 348

  Alexander VI selects Papal Commission to examine, 349

  conditions in gaol, 350

  last tract written in gaol, 350–2

  trial before Papal Commissioners, 352–5, 356–7

  Pratica discusses sentence of, 355–6

  fate discussed by Papal Commissioners and Florentine authorities, 357

  Remolino’s report to Alexander VI about, 357

  sentenced, 357–8

  informed about death sentence, 359

  Niccolini spends time in cell with, 360

  meeting with Fra Silvestro and Fra Domenico, 360–1

  last hours in his cell, 361

  led into Piazza della Signoria, 362

  tribunals, 362–3

  death, 364–7

  celebration following death of, 368

  and events of later centuries, 370–1

  brief references, 115, 122, 182, 234, 282, 369

  Writings:

  ‘Compendium of Revelations’ (Compendio di Rivelazioni; Compendium Revalationum), 123, 144, 222 and n, 224–9, 239, 257, 351

  Compendium totius philosophae (A Brief Summary of All Philosophies), 70

  Contra sententiam excommunicationis (‘Against sententious excommunications’), 278

  Contro la escomunicazione surrettizia (‘Against surruptitious exc
ommunication’), 277–8

  Disputationes adversus astrologiam divinatricem (‘Against Astrological Prediction’) (written by Pico, but possibly co-authored by Savonarola), 149–50, 151, 287

  ‘Division of All the Sciences’, 100

  ‘An Exposition and Meditation on the Psalm Miserere’, 350–2 and n, 370

  ‘On the Ruin of the World’, 45, 49

  Riposta, 314

  ‘A Rule for Leading the Good Life’ (attributed to Savonarola), 350

  Trattato circa il reggimento e il govorno della città di Firenze (Treatise on the rule and government of the city of Florence), 289–90

  Triumphus Crucis (The Triumph of the Cross), 287–8

  Savonarola, Michele, 39, 40–1, 42, 53

  The Practice of Medicine from Head to Toe, 39

  Savonarola, Niccolò, 40, 42, 45, 46, 72

  Savonarola’s boys, 245–6, 247–8, 249, 260, 261, 262, 266, 276, 296

  Scholasticism, 68, 87

  Seward, Desmond, 226, 356

  Sforza, Cardinal Ascanio, 155, 158

  Sforza, Francesco, Duke of Milan, 15, 21

  Sforza, Galeazzo Maria, Duke of Milan, 21, 26–7, 35, 49

  Sforza, Gian Galeazzo, 167–8, 183, 184

  Sforza, Ippolita Maria, 15

  Sforza, Ludovico ‘il Moro’

  character, 2

  Leonardo da Vinci sent to win over, 2, 37

  becomes personal friend of Lorenzo the Magnificent, 2, 3

  attends conference of anti-Venetian allies at Cremona, 58

  secret agreement with Venetians, 59

  perceived as traitor by Sixtus IV, 59, 60

  allows Lorenzo the Magnificent to purchase post of Abbot of Miromanda for his son, 92

  sends physician to Lorenzo, 2, 122

  and delegation on behalf of Lombardy Congregation, 154–5, 159–60

  refuses to surrender power to his nephew Gian Galeazzo Sforza, 167–8

  appeals to Charles VIII, 168

  and French preparation for invasion, 171

  welcomes Charles VIII at Asti, 178

  has misgivings about the French, 183–4

  has himself proclaimed rightful Duke of Milan, 184

  the French have doubts about, 184–5

  joins alliance against the French, 219–20

  and Maximilian I, 255

  passes Savonarola’s letter on to the pope, 304

  Sforza family, 52 see also names of individuals

  Siena, 29, 116, 155, 165, 257, 270, 277, 280, 282

  Signa, 201

  Signoria

  and Florentine system of government, 4–5

  invites Cosimo de’ Medici to return to Florence, 11

  and Medici manipulation of government, 20–1, 27, 37

  informed about Lorenzo the Magnificent’s departure for Naples, 35

  Savonarola preaches private sermon to, 103–4

  Cardinal Giovanni de’ Medici visits, 119

 

‹ Prev