CRITICAL ACCLAIM FOR TRAVELERS’ TALES PARIS
“To experience Paris is to smell it, taste it, hear it and, most important, to feel it. Travelers’ Tales Paris is a guidebook for the senses — the real Paris experience.”
—Mark Eversman, Paris Notes
“The book is a must for all those who relish the delights of new discoveries, those who enjoy getting lost, those who marvel at each encounter as it arises, those whose ultimate test of good-value travel is not in how much they spend but in how much they experience and savor.”
—International Travel News
“The newest installment of this now well-known collection is probably the most enchanting.”
—France Today
“...Paris by the Travelers’ Tales bunch...is a whole bouquet of stories in, about, and encompassing Paris and environs. My own favorite is about a Versailles alternative but there are great excursions toward food, fashion, and folly as well.”
—Marilis Hornidge, The Courier-Gazette
“This latest addition...proves that these are books you can count on; the editors of this series gather together some of the wiliest writers today, many of whom make their rather dubious livings on the road. The tales are current, accessible, often funny, infinitely digestible and not just peripherally about place. Destination aside, the writing in this book makes it an excellent value.
—Linda Watanabe McFerrin, San Francisco Examiner
TRAVELERS’ TALES BOOKS
Country and Regional Guides
America, Australia, Brazil, Central America, Cuba, France, Greece, India, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Mexico, Nepal, Spain, Thailand, Tibet, Turkey; American Southwest, Grand Canyon, Hawai‘i, Hong Kong, Paris, San Francisco, Tuscany
Women’s Travel
Her Fork in the Road, A Woman’s Path, A Woman’s Passion for Travel, A Woman’s World, Women in the Wild, A Mother’s World, Safety and Security for Women Who Travel, Gutsy Women, Gutsy Mamas
Body & Soul
The Spiritual Gifts of Travel, The Road Within, Love & Romance, Food, The Fearless Diner, The Adventure of Food, The Ultimate Journey, Pilgrimage
Special Interest
Not So Funny When It Happened, The Gift of Rivers, Shitting Pretty, Testosterone Planet, Danger!, The Fearless Shopper, The Penny Pincher’s Passport to Luxury Travel, The Gift of Birds, Family Travel, A Dog’s World, There’s No Toilet Paper on the Road Less Traveled, The Gift of Travel, 365 Travel, Adventures in Wine
Footsteps
Kite Strings of the Southern Cross, The Sword of Heaven, Storm, Take Me With You, Last Trout in Venice, The Way of the Wanderer, One Year Off, The Fire Never Dies
Classics
The Royal Road to Romance, Unbeaten Tracks in Japan, The Rivers Ran East, Coast to Coast, Trader Horn
TRAVELERS’ TALES
PARIS
TRUE STORIES
TRAVELERS’ TALES
PARIS
TRUE STORIES
Edited by
JAMES O’REILLY LARRY HABEGGER
SEAN O’REILLY
TRAVELERS’ TALES
SAN FRANCISCO
Copyright © 2002, 1997 Travelers’ Tales, Inc. All rights reserved.
Travelers’ Tales and Travelers’ Tales Guides are trademarks of Travelers’ Tales, Inc.
Credits and copyright notices for the individual articles in this collection are given starting on page 314.
We have made every effort to trace the ownership of all copyrighted material and to secure permission from copyright holders. In the event of any question arising as to the ownership of any material, we will be pleased to make the necessary correction in future printings. Contact Travelers’ Tales, Inc., 330 Townsend Street, Suite 208, San Francisco, California 94107. www.travelerstales.com
Art Direction: Michele Wetherbee
Interior design: Kathryn Heflin and Susan Bailey
Cover photograph:© Martine Mouchy/Getty Images. Eiffel Tower at night.
Maps: Keith Granger
Page layout: Cynthia Lamb using the fonts Bembo and Boulevard
Distributed by: Publishers Group West, 1700 Fourth Street, Berkeley, California 94710.
Library of Congress Cataloguing-in-Publication Data
Paris: true stories / edited by James O’Reilly, Larry Habegger, and Sean O’Reilly
p. cm. — (Travelers’ Tales)
Includes bibliographical references and index
ISBN 978-1-60952-074-8
1. Paris (France)—Description and travel. 2. Paris (France)—Civilization.
I. O’Reilly, James, 1953- II. Habegger, Larry. III. O’Reilly, Sean.
IV. Travelers’ Tales guides.
DC707.P2548 2002
914.3'36104—dc 21
2002010183
First Edition
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Take those two words, gold and pleasure, for a lantern, and explore the great cage of Paris.
—HONORÉ DE BALZAC
Table of Contents
Preface
Map
Introduction
Part One
ESSENCE OF PARIS
Vive l’Argument
THOM ELKJER
Behind the Wheel
JOHN GREGORY DUNNE
The Gift
JOSEPH DIEDRICH
On the Left Bank
HERBERT GOLD
The Mystical Scarf-Tying Gene
LYNN SCHNURNBERGER
Le Paris Profond
JACK E. BRONSTON
St-Germain-des-Prés
SHUSHA GUPPY
The Concierge
EDMUND WHITE
The Hungry Museum
HELEN DUDAR
Excusez-Moi, Je Suis Sick as a Dog
MARYALICIA POST
Within the Périphérique
JAN MORRIS
Part Two
SOME THINGS TO DO
The Empire of Death
LOREN RHOADS
Paris Rapture
MICHELE ANNA JORDAN
Illumined in Sainte-Chapelle
TIM O’REILLY
On Ile St-Louis
HERBERT GOLD
Bonjour, Chaos
DAVID ROBERTS
Monsieur Fix-It
COLEMAN LOLLAR
The Source
MORT ROSENBLUM
In Notre Dame
DONALD W. GEORGE
Real Life House of Horrors
TARAS GRESCOE
The Fairy Palace
INA CARO
Part Three
GOING YOUR OWN WAY
My Idea of Paris
MAXINE ROSE SCHUR
Hair Pierre
CAILIN BOYLE
A Night in Gay Paree
HANNS EBENSTEN
Air Château
BOB BRADFIELD
Sacred Hill of the North
IRENE-MARIE SPENCER
Turkish Baths
LAWRENCE OSBORNE
Wounded and Healed
GEORGE VINCENT WRIGHT
Montreuil-sous-Bois
DAVID APPLEFIELD
The Frog and the Periscope
TISH CARNES BROWN
Part Four
IN THE SHADOWS
Destination Paris
MARCEL F. LAVENTURIER
Bearing Witness
THÉRÈSE LUNG
Monsieur de Paris
ROBERT DALEY
La Photo
CORI KENICER
Fleeing the Splendor
INA CARO
Part Five
THE LAST WORD
St-Julian the Poor
JULIAN GREEN
Recommended Reading
Glossary
Index
Index of Contributors
Acknowledgments
Preface
TRAVELERS’ TALES
We are all outsiders when we travel. Whether we go abroad or roam about our own city or country, we often enter territory so unfamiliar that our frames of reference become inadequate. We need advice not just to avoid offense and danger, but to make our experiences richer, deeper, and more fun.
Traditionally, travel guides have answered the basic questions: what, when, where, how, and how much. A good guidebook is indispensable for all the practical matters that demand attention. More recently, many guidebooks have added bits of experiential insight to their standard fare, but something important is still missing: guidebooks don’t really prepare you, the individual with feelings and fears, hopes and dreams, goals.
This kind of preparation is best achieved through travelers’ tales, for we get our inner landmarks more from anecdote than information. Nothing can replace listening to the experience of others, to the war stories that come out after a few drinks, to the memories that linger and beguile. For millennia it’s been this way: at watering holes and wayside inns, the experienced traveler tells those nearby what lies ahead on the ever-mysterious road. Stories stoke the imagination, inspire, frighten, and teach. In stories we see more clearly the urges that bring us to wander, whether it’s hunger for change, adventure, self-knowledge, love, curiosity, sorrow, or even something as prosaic as a job assignment or two weeks off.
But travelers’ accounts, while profuse, can be hard to track down. Many are simply doomed in a throwaway publishing world. And few of us have the time anyway to read more than one or two books, or the odd pearl found by chance in the Sunday travel section. Wanderers for years, we’ve often faced this issue. We’ve always told ourselves when we got home that we would prepare better for the next trip—read more, study more, talk to more people—but life always seems to interfere and we’ve rarely managed to do so to our satisfaction. That is one reason for this series. We needed a kind of experiential primer that guidebooks don’t offer.
Another path that led us to Travelers’ Tales has been seeing the enormous changes in travel and communications over the last two decades. It is no longer unusual to have ridden a pony across Mongolia, to have celebrated an auspicious birthday on Mt. Kilimanjaro, or honeymooned on the Loire. The one-world monoculture has risen with daunting swiftness, weaving a new cross-cultural rug: no longer is it surprising to encounter former head-hunters watching All-Star Wrestling on their satellite feed, no longer is it shocking to find the last guy at the end of the earth wearing a Harvard t-shirt and asking if you know Michael Jordan. The global village exists in a rudimentary fashion, but it is real.
In 1980, Paul Fussell wrote in Abroad: British Literary Traveling Between the Wars a cranky but wonderful epitaph for travel as it was once known, in which he concluded that “we are all tourists now, and there is no escape.” Tourism is one of the world’s largest industries; which is horrifying indeed—hordes of us hunting for places that have not been trod on by the rest of us!
Fussell’s words have the painful ring of truth, but this is still our world, and it is worth seeing and will be worth seeing next year, or in 50 years, simply because it will always be worth meeting others who continue to see life in different terms than we do despite the best efforts of telecommunication and advertising talents. No amount of creeping homogeneity can quell the endless variation of humanity, and travel in the end is about people, not places. Places only provide different venues, as it were, for life, in which we are all pilgrims who need to talk to each other.
There are also many places around the world where intercultural friction and outright xenophobia is increasing. And the very fact that travel endangers cultures and pristine places more quickly than it used to calls for extraordinary care on the part of today’s traveler, a keener sense of personal responsibility. The world is not our private zoo or theme park; we need to be better prepared before we go, so that we might become honored guests and not vilified intruders.
In Travelers’ Tales, we collect useful and memorable anecdotes to produce the kind of sampler we’ve always wanted to read before setting out. These stories will show you some of the spectrum of experiences to be had or avoided in each country. The authors come from many walks of life: some are teachers, some are musicians, some are entrepreneurs, all are wanderers with a story to tell. Their stories won’t help you be an insider as so many travel books promise—but they will help you to deepen and enrich the experience that you will have as an outsider. Where we’ve excerpted books, we urge you to go out and read the full work, because no selection can ever do an author justice.
Our selection of stories in each Travelers’ Tales is by no means comprehensive, but we are confident it will prime your pump, and make your use of regular guidebooks much more meaningful. No longer do you have to go to dozens of sources to map the personal side of your journey. You can reach for Travelers’ Tales, and truly prepare yourself before you go.
JAMES O’REILLY AND LARRY HABEGGER
Series Editors
Paris: An Introduction
Imagine leaving this world without ever having seen Paris. For those who have been there, the thought is unthinkable. For those who haven’t yet had the chance, the thought is a reminder that their lives will be impoverished until they go, for Paris is the center of the civilized universe, the capital of the Western world, a city of transcendent beauty which belongs to everyone.
It is one of a handful of cities on earth one should endeavor to know over the course of a lifetime, not just in one or two or even a half-dozen visits. Paris—or Parisians—may rebuff you from time to time, but then, that is one of its duties, one of its perverse pleasures. Paris is not lightly seduced, not to be trifled with.
There are those who say darkly that Paris isn’t what it used to be; that hordes of visitors have irrevocably changed it for the worse; that in pandering to the needs of tourism the city has become a parody of itself, nothing more than a cultural amusement park. And of course, there is truth to the lament of the cynical, to those weary of slack-jawed foreigners who spout a kind of French which bears more resemblance to the gibberings of the Neolithic than it does the language of Molière and Victor Hugo. But Paris is such a mighty archetype that these things ultimately do not matter.
The images of Paris are familiar to all: barges on the Seine; the Eiffel Tower poking into a summer sunset; the Cathedral of Notre Dame standing stoutly on its island in the middle of the river; the Pei Pyramid glowing before the classical lines of the Louvre; the Basilica of Sacré-Couer stark white above the streets of Montmartre; the Arc de Triomphe dominating the chaotic roundabout of Le Étoile, an architectural key to the Champs Elysées and the grand obelisk at Place de la Concorde, site of the horrors of the French Revolution; lovers embracing in the Tuileries; the famed headstones of Père-Lachaise cemetery; the ubiquitous cafés and well-dressed Parisians and coiffed dogs; arresting new architecture and the fabulous Métro; the list goes on and on.
There may be no city more uplifting to the human spirit. It is a place to explore the dimensions of yourself or those of someone you love—to walk and talk, to argue about life, to sit and contemplate the events of human history which have played themselves out here on these streets, on the banks of this river.
And yet as heavy with tradition and culture as it is, the City of Light has bestowed on countless millions the gift of the incandescent present, an image, an experience or moment into which all life is condensed, to be reflected upon for years to come. Paris is a place to feel especially alive, and it’s here now, waiting for you to come, sample its treasures, and make it yours.
A Note on Currency
The French franc, along with most other European currencies, was replaced by the euro in January, 2002.
PART ONE
ESSENCE OF PARIS
THOM ELKJER
Vive l’Argument
The sec
rets of Paris are the secrets of love.
IN PARIS, MEN AND WOMEN LOVE WITH THEIR INTELLECT AS MUCH as their emotions. This is in fact a deeply romantic approach to love, one that sees the lover as the most worthy adversary in the world, worthy even of trying to persuade. Of course we are talking about Paris, so the persuasion involves panache, aplomb, and attitude—plenty of attitude.
A young couple enters the Café St-Germain on a November afternoon. His leather jacket is open over a white t-shirt; her heavy gold sweater sets off a mane of black hair. They are beautiful to look at, and clearly in love. They sit, smoke, and drink coffee in a room of spidery mirrored walls and brown marble tables. In fact they sit at the next table and the café is not crowded, so their discussion quickly becomes more interesting than the afternoon newspaper. Love in public is public love, n’est-ce pas?
It turns out the young woman is attempting to convince the young man that their relationship should proceed to the ultimate intimacy more or less immediately. Not tomorrow, not tonight, but today, now. The young man sits back in his chair and listens, which means he is resting, marshaling his own arguments for the rebuttal to come. It is a tender scene of young love, in Paris.
There is a famous photo of Simone de Beauvoir and Jean-Paul Sartre, who shared one of the great romances of this century, in Paris or anywhere else. They are sitting at the table in La Coupole where they dined daily for many years. She looks off to the side with a half smile on her lips, he looks down reflectively. What discussions they must have had, I always thought. One day it dawned on me that they didn’t go to the same café for 40 years to agree with each other. They went to discuss, to disagree, to argue. In fact, their lifelong agreement on where to go for dinner saved invaluable energy for what happened when they got there.
Never have I felt so forcefully that our lives have no meaning outside of our love, and that nothing changes that, neither separation, nor passions, nor the war. You said it was a victory for our morality, but it is just as much a victory for our love.
Travelers' Tales Paris Page 1
