by Chloe Lang
“Heath is here. I invited him.”
Seth’s face darkened, but he didn’t say a word.
“You can put the gun down, cowboy.”
“Not until I know for certain it is my brother and not yours.” His tone was sharp and made her uneasy. He stepped off the porch and went around the house to the front.
This plan of mine is doomed before it begins.
In no time, Seth and Heath returned, both looking at her with accusing eyes.
“Spill it, Charly,” Seth demanded.
She opened her mouth to say something pithy, but instead not a single word came out. What could she tell them that would change anything? Nothing. She’d been lost to the idea that getting them together might soften their anger at each other.
Heath frowned. “We’re waiting, Charly.”
Normally hearing these men say her name made her weak in the knees, but now her body was as rigid as an iceberg. Not just her body, her mouth, too. What could she say that would make them understand why she’d attempted this failed arbitration? She hated seeing them tear each other apart when it was clear they still cared for each other deep down. Her heart now had a hole that would never be filled again. She wasn’t just losing Seth and Heath. Drake, Dax, Nate, and Tobias would no longer be in her life. There was no way she could choose some over others, no matter the mix. One, two, three, or even five of the Strongs would not suffice. Plus, she could never do what Gabby had done to them. What kind of woman was she? Seth told her he still loved the woman.
Seth moved next to her. “I think she’s drifting.”
“You’re right about that, bro,” Heath said.
“Guys, I’m sorry. This was a terrible idea.”
“And she’s back.” Heath stepped to the other side of her.
“Not completely,” Seth added. “I know what she needs. You game, Heath?”
“Yes, I am.”
Was she hearing them correctly? They’d just agreed to work together to top her. And they sounded happy to do it. Had her plan actually worked?
Her hands shook as Seth tugged on her hair.
“You’ve been really bad, pet,” he said.
“I didn’t mean to trick you two.”
“But you did. You told me you were ready to move,” Heath said. “Was that a lie, too?”
The bitter taste of guilt filled her mouth. “I’m sorry.”
Even that confession wasn’t completely true. She wasn’t sorry. She was thrilled that her plan had worked and that these cowboys, who had been at each other’s throats ever since she’d arrived in Wilde, were actually about to work together. Strange. It didn’t really make sense, but the human psyche was a mysterious thing. What they were proposing—more like demanding—wasn’t what she’d planned for the evening. Still, perhaps this unorthodox therapy might open them up in ways she couldn’t have done on her own. She would willingly take whatever they dished out if it meant they might find common ground. It was a start, and hope sprang up inside her.
“Let’s take her inside.” Seth hoisted her up in his arms, and she leaned into his chest. “You’re going to be punished for lying to us, pet.”
“I know, Sir.”
He carried her into the house with Heath following close behind.
When they came to Seth’s bedroom, he placed her on the bed. He went to his closet and pulled out a large suitcase. He set it beside her on the mattress and opened it up. Inside the case were lots of sex toys.
Heath leaned over, looking into the suitcase. “Very nice, bro. I can see why you’re sought after by so many subs at the club.”
Jealously bubbled up inside her. She couldn’t bear thinking of Seth being with any other woman.
Charly watched as Seth pulled out two dangerous-looking paddles. “Is this only about punishment, Sirs?”
Seth leaned down and grabbed a fistful of her hair. “You need to be punished, baby.” His tone was gentle even if his actions were harsh. “Take your licks bravely and you will earn a reward.”
She watched him place a box of condoms and a tube of lube he’d pulled out from the suitcase next to the paddles.
“I will be brave. I promise.” Giddy beyond measure, she couldn’t stop smiling.
Heath touched her cheek. “God, you’re something else, sweetheart.”
Seth went back to his closet and disappeared. The space was larger than she’d imagined. When he came back out, he pulled an odd-looking piece of equipment that reminded her of a massage table, though it was bent in the middle into a kind of upside-down V. She’d seen one like it at The Masters’ Chambers. Her cowboys had restrained her on a bench like this before they’d spanked her.
In a flash, Seth positioned it by the bed. Her anxiety ground into her like a drill, but her excitement kept her worry in check, if only a bit.
“Let’s get started, bro,” Heath said.
“Absolutely.” Seth stared at her with the most commanding eyes she’d ever seen, and a shiver ran up her spine. “Stand up.”
She jumped to her feet fast, hoping to please him.
The corners of his mouth curled up. So did Heath’s. God, this is actually going to work.
Together, they stripped her roughly, and more than a few of her top’s buttons popped off. Even her bra and panties were destined for the trash bin after they tore them to bits. Their severe handling made her shiver violently. Though she actually craved the promised paddling, she also feared it in an odd way.
Shamelessly, her two cowboys looked her up and down. She braved a quick glance between their legs. The tents in both their jeans told her they were hungry and ready to devour her.
Seth pointed to the contraption he’d pulled out of his closet. “Lean over the horse.”
It’s called a horse. How appropriate for a cowboy Dom.
“Stay focused, sub,” Heath demanded. “Seth gave you an order and you’re making us wait.”
“Sorry, Sirs.” She complied and leaned over the upside-down V. “Like this?”
“Exactly.” Seth clamped the restraints on her wrists and ankles. “Perfect.” He voiced the last word with what sounded to her like awe, which vibrated down to her pussy, delivering a delicious ache.
In her current physical state, her ass was the highest part of her body, a vulnerable yet not uncomfortable position. The padding of the horse softened things a bit. She grinned, thinking how few therapists would go to such extremes to aid their patients. But these two weren’t her patients—they were two men she’d fallen completely in love with.
It pained her to see Seth and Heath so at odds. She couldn’t imagine how their parents felt having seen their once-loving sons clashing for so many years. She’d brought Seth and Heath together under pretense, but her intentions had been pure. Not entirely true. Yes, she wanted to aid in their healing so they could once again be in harmony with each other, but the selfish motive of getting Seth to agree to sharing her with Heath and the others was also the reason for the great risk.
With a feather-like touch, Heath rubbed her ass. “What a beautiful ass. It’s going to look amazing when it turns pink.”
“Same protocol, pet. Colors.”
“Yes, Sir.” She turned her head and looked at him out of the corner of her eyes. His intensity flowed from him to her like an overwhelming flood.
Seth looked at Heath. “Green. Yellow. Red. Got it?”
“I know it, bro. Shall we get started?”
“Absolutely. She’s been extremely naughty. I don’t tolerate lying, do you?”
“Never.”
Hearing them talk civilly with each other gave her a feeling of awe. She could imagine repeating this event with Seth and Heath, over and over, for years to come.
Seth caressed her neck and face with his fingers, increasing her temperature several notches. “You’ve earned what is about to come. You lied to us. We don’t want that to happen again, do we?”
“No, Sir.” She regretted her trickery of both of them. “I shouldn’t ha
ve lied.”
“I believe you mean it, pet.” Seth picked up one of the paddles. “Still, I want to make sure you won’t do it again. Ever. Understand?”
“Yes, Sir. I wish I hadn’t angered you. I really am sorry.”
Seth leaned down so that his face was next to hers. “Charly, I’m not angry. I was at first. I don’t like being lied to. But that’s gone now. I understand why you did this.”
“So do I,” Heath chimed in. “We can’t blame you, sweetheart.”
“But I can’t let you have a pass on this. Even though I will never punish you in anger, I will punish you. Trust me. Tonight, you will feel pain. More than you felt before. It’s for your own good, pet.”
“I know, Sir.”
“Time to spank that beautiful ass of hers, brother.”
Out of the corner of her eye, she saw Heath pick up the other paddle.
Seth stroked her hair. “Yes, it is time.” He kissed her cheek, and then he moved out of her sight. Heath remained in front of her, rubbing her back with his free hand.
She vibrated from head to toe.
Whack! Seth struck first, landing the paddle on the middle of her ass. Tears welled up in her eyes, but she didn’t cry out.
Whack! Whack! Her shame rocked her to the core and filled the sides of her face with heat. Still, the stinging in her ass sent a vibration through her, making her pussy clench and causing her clit to throb.
Staring down at Heath’s boots and knowing Seth stood behind her made her feel safe and secure, in an odd way. Then it hit her—this was the first time she’d been intimate with these two sex-on-sticks cowboys together. Sure, she’d had sex with them separately on more than one occasion, but never side by side. The realization astonished her and filled her with joy. Perhaps her approach had been wrong, but it was clearly working.
Seth continued slapping her ass, never landing the paddle on the same spot. She couldn’t hold back her tears, which were a mix of regret and satisfaction.
Whack! Whack! Whack!
Her thoughts softened as their punishment sent her closer toward a trancelike state.
Heath leaned down and placed the paddle in front of her eyes. “See this, sweetheart?”
“Yes, Sir.”
“I’m going to use this to teach you a lesson you won’t forget. Your lips are too beautiful to let lies slip past them.”
His boots disappeared from view, and Seth’s came into view. They’d switched positions.
“You want your punishment to end, right?” Heath asked.
“Yes, Sir.” Her heart thudded in her chest, and her throat tightened. Doubt shot up inside her. Did they plan on only spanking her tonight? Oh God, no. If they didn’t make love to her together then all she’d done to get them here was for naught.
“What state are you in?”
Her lips trembled. “Green, Sir. But I–I...” Her tongue suddenly wouldn’t cooperate as nerves got the better of her.
“What do you want to say to us, pet?” Seth asked.
“I’m so sorry for what I did. Really I am.”
“Don’t hold back, love.” Heath caressed her ass. “Tell us.”
She blurted out, “Are you going to share me tonight?”
Silence.
She closed her eyes as tight as possible as her heart began to shred into a million pieces.
“Where are you, pet?” Seth asked, his voice softer than before.
“Here, Sir.”
“I’m not asking about your physical state. Where is your head?”
“Away.”
“What state are you in?” he asked.
“I guess I’m yellow,” she confessed.
“Listen to me, Charly. Really listen.”
“Okay.”
“Heath and I didn’t react to your question correctly. That’s our fault.”
Heath said, “We should’ve read your tone and body language better.”
“You’re right about that,” Seth continued. “Sweetheart, you were jumping ahead to your reward before your punishment was complete. That was why I hesitated answering you. That’s all.”
“Can you answer me now? Please.”
“Yes, pet. We will make love to you once you’ve earned it.”
“That makes me so happy,” she whispered.
“Heath needs to deliver some slaps to your ass, pet. You lied to him, too. What state are you in now?”
“Green, Sir. All green.”
“Good girl,” Heath said. His spanks were softer than Seth’s had been. “Will you ever lie to us again?”
“No, Sir.”
“She’s learned her lesson, bro.”
Seth unfastened her wrist restraints, and Heath undid the ones on her ankles. Then Seth lifted her up in his arms and placed her gently back on the bed.
Heath placed his paddle into the suitcase.
Seth followed suit, putting his paddle into the case, too. He closed and latched the sex toy container. Then he pulled it off the bed and placed it on the floor out of the way.
“You really want us to make love to you, pet?” he asked.
She nodded.
He smiled, warming her from head to toe. Turning to Heath, he asked, “Shall we?”
“She’s earned it, bro.”
“Yes, she has.”
How long had she waited for this moment to be with these two warring brothers? Now, it had finally arrived. For the very first time, she saw the future she’d dreamt of as possible. This was the first step to it coming true. Seth and Heath were more alike than even they knew. She could see it. They were intense, powerful, and confident men. What could be sexier?
Watching them strip off their clothes made her heart pound faster in her chest. Their fixed stares made her tremble. Both her cowboys had muscles that would make any woman drool. Even their stomachs were ripped. As her eyes drifted to their massive cocks fully erect, her desire flamed higher.
The impatient Heath crawled next to her first. As his fingers played with her nipples, she held her breath for a moment. Her tiny bits tightened, and her pussy dampened.
Seth got on the bed on her other side. His lips feathered her neck. “Tell me what you want, pet?”
Dizzy with desire, she confessed, “I want you and Heath.”
Seth kissed a trail down her body. He started with her shoulder then moved down her arm. Each spot where his lips and tongue landed ignited a new sensation that shot through her entire body, and she got even wetter.
Heath licked her nipple and palmed her other breast, driving her mad with want. “Are you wet, sweetheart?”
His brazenness flooded into her, and more moisture seeped from her pussy. “Yes, I am.”
Seth kissed the soft spot under her arm, giving her a wonderful shiver.
Heath nipped at her breasts’ tips, sending her even higher and making her hazy with want.
As Seth positioned his head between her legs, sending a hot breath over her mound, and Heath sucked one of her nipples into his mouth, a sense of warmth and safety rolled over her. She needed them to fill her in every way. Being with them was what she’d craved for so long. She touched Heath’s face with one hand and the top of Seth’s head with the other to ensure this wasn’t a dream.
“This is really happening.” Her heart soared.
Heath kissed her into silence. His tongue swept into her mouth, filling her with even more heat. Her heart raced in her chest, and her toes curled.
Seth dotted her thighs with little kisses of his own, warming up her lower half. “Let’s give her a tongue bath she’ll never forget, Heath.”
“Excellent idea.”
The two rolled her on her side, and Seth remained a breath away from her pussy. Heath kissed his way down her back until his manly lips landed on her ass, still stinging slightly from their earlier joint paddling.
As Heath parted her ass cheeks with his large hands, Seth licked her swollen folds, drenching her with dizziness. When Heath’s tongue landed on the tight spo
t of her backside as Seth pressed gently on her clit, she slipped below the surface of steamy sensations. Her insides tingled and tightened.
“Are you enjoying our bath, love?” Heath asked.
“God, yes.” As they continued brushing her pussy and ass with their tongues, a massive pulse shot through her body.
“She’s close, Heath.” Seth’s voice seemed heavy with lust. “Drown me in your juices, pet.”
She closed her eyes and wiggled between them like a live wire.
“Come for us, love,” Heath commanded, then continued licking her most intimate spot on her ass.
When Seth captured her clit with his lips, tightening down on the throbbing flesh perfectly, her orgasm exploded deep inside her. Spasms shook her body, and her pussy clenched and unclenched and clenched again. She writhed between them, tugging on Seth’s head, pulling him in tighter between her thighs.
Their delicious torture continued on and on, keeping the ride of her life from ending.
As Heath began applying lubricant to her ass, even stronger desire—to have her two cowboys inside her body—consumed her.
“Take a deep breath, love,” Heath commanded from behind her.
She obeyed, and he sent a finger into her ass.
Seth donned a condom, adding to her excitement. This is really going to happen with Seth and Heath. Oh my God.
Heath added another finger, and the sting came and went quickly, leaving only agonizing urgency. “She’s ready, bro.”
Seth stood, leaned down, and lifted her off the bed. “Wrap your legs around my waist, pet.”
His hands remained on the back of her thighs.
“Yes, Sir.” She also placed her arms around his shoulders, steadying herself.
Out of the corner of her eye, she saw Heath roll a condom down his erect dick.
Seth smiled, and then he lowered her body down just a bit until the head of his cock pressed on her mound.
Heath came up behind her and placed his hands on the curves of her sides. “You know the drill, love. Keep breathing.”
She obeyed, feeling his cock slip between her ass cheeks until the tip of his dick hit the tight spot.
Needy shivers undulated through her. Her clit ached, and her pussy got even wetter.
“Time for your reward, pet.” Seth lowered her down until his thick dick pierced her sex.
