Also by Matt McAllester
Beyond the Mountains of the Damned: The War Inside Kosovo
Blinded by the Sunlight: Surviving Abu Ghraib and Saddam's Iraq
For Pernilla
1
MY MOTHER SAT IN HER ARMCHAIR BY THE WINDOW AND asked me if I thought I was a good cook.
“Yeah,” I said. “Not bad.”
“Do you always leave the book open?”
“Yes,” I said.
“Then you can't cook.” She laughed, but she wasn't joking. “If you need to keep the book open, you're not really cooking.”
We had had this conversation before. It had a companion piece that went like this:
“Have you read Elizabeth David yet?”
“No, Mum.”
“If you want to know how to cook, read Elizabeth David. She'll tell you everything. Read French Provincial Cooking. They're marvelous books. We all learned to cook from Elizabeth David.”
This conversation I had with my mother was our shared doorway into talking about food. There was so little we could share, so few topics I could introduce without risking her anger and delusions—my father, certain former friends, certain relatives, places we had lived, most of the past, politics, foreign affairs—or without wading into the oceans of forgetfulness and obliviousness that had built up around things she once cared about and I still did—books, movies, the news. But if I told her what I was cooking for friends over the weekend, we would fall into a safe place together, one where past, present, and future were full of afternoons in the kitchen with the radio on and with chocolate-smeared mixing bowls in the sink, desserts cooling in the refrigerator, sauces simmering on the stove, a slowly crisping, caramelizing roast in the oven, and the house full of mingling, delicious smells.
It was the lovely afternoon of May 4, 2005. The pink bunched flowers of the horse-chestnut tree outside her window in Swiss Cottage swayed gently in a spring breeze. She had not cooked for a long time, having moved from a studio apartment where she would at best fry some bacon, to a locked mental ward in an industrial corner of Northwest London, and then to this charming, sunlit room on the top floor of an old folks' home (called Rathmore House), where she was a teenager compared to the dying bodies who sat immobile in the hallway. She was closer in age to some of the staff than to the other residents, and she didn't socialize with the bent-over old ladies who stared into their ever-dimming memories. Unlike them, she would walk along the street to the local stores and cafés, sitting with a cup of coffee and making friends with the local misfits who also spent their days over coffee. She kept to her room when in the home. She read the occasional novel, watched television, and waited for phone calls and visits from my sister and me.
She hated the food there, that was the only thing, and loved to be taken out. A few days earlier, on a walk to the shops of nearby Primrose Hill with my sister, she had bought me a present. It was a zester, and she handed it to me now without wrapping paper or reason. She knew I would like it. I had another zester already, but immediately I liked this one more. It had a solid ball of steel for a handle. She had bought an identical one for my sister.
She stood up from her armchair and we kissed and I hugged her, smiling. It was an unplanned visit, an hour snatched because I happened to be at home in London rather than in a war zone and I was passing by. It had been an hour without my getting irritated, one in which I asked for and received rare maternal advice about things I have already forgotten because it was the unwonted feeling of being looked after by my mother that mattered. The zester, bought by chance in a shop on the same street as the apartment where a young Elizabeth David, my mother's cooking guru, first began to cook for herself, was in my hand as I hugged her.
I put it into my pocket and left.
She died two days later, in the morning, in that room. She fell forward onto the floor in front of her armchair, her heart stopping without warning.
2
BY THE TIME I WAS EIGHTEEN YEARS OLD, I WANTED MY mother, who had brought me into the world and deluged me with love, to die. And I said so, out loud.
I stood in the kitchen of my aunt's apartment in Newport, Rhode Island, where I was staying for the summer, saving my tips and paychecks from the job I'd gotten as a busboy so that I could spend the fall and winter traveling around the United States on Greyhound buses. It was the summer of 1988. My aunt Jennifer was two years older than my mother. They were the oldest of four siblings and had been extremely close when they were children. My aunt emigrated from Scotland to the United States, to Boston, the year John Kennedy was assassinated. I had just graduated from high school in Scotland, and when I joined my aunt in this fresh, exciting country, I found in her something that I had not known for years. She was like my mother in so many ways—her voice, her eyes, her sporadic disdain for decorum. When she had met me fresh off the bus in Providence on my first day in the States, she had parked illegally, and when we rushed back to her car she began an argument with the meek-looking uniformed attendant who must have been pulling in just over minimum wage in his middle years and whom my lovely aunt loudly called “a Nazi.” My mother would have done that. But they were different in other ways. Unlike my mother, Jennifer did actually come to pick me up from the bus station; she would do my laundry, watch movies with me, make me coffee, share my jokes, treat me to dinner out. She did not fight with me. I could talk with her without constantly censoring myself. When my cousin Christian pierced my ear with a needle and thread and a block of ice, my aunt handed me a brandy from her freezer.
And now, in the afternoon before my evening shift at the wharfside restaurant in Newport where I worked, as illegal as my Salvadoran buddies, we were talking about my mother.
“I don't think I've ever told anyone this,” I said, “but I think she'd be better off dead.”
“So do I,” she said.
There was a moment of quiet.
“Matthew,” she said, reaching for the freezer, “would you like a brandy?”
“I think she'd be happier dead,” I said, taking the glass. “She's never going to get better. She just suffers. Her life is worthless.”
And it was unspoken, but understood, that it would be easier and better for me, and for everyone else in the family.
“You shouldn't feel guilty for feeling that, you know,” Jennifer said.
“I don't,” I said.
My mother did not die then. But many years later she said to me: “I'm ready to die now, Matty. I've been married, I've had my children. I'm ready to die.”
She was not depressed when she said this. She wasn't drunk or ranting. We were having a cup of tea in her small basement studio flat in Kilburn, in Northwest London, a five-minute amble from my sister's place, the last place she would live without full-time caregivers on hand. She repeated it to me at other times, in moments of calm and relative serenity. My sister, Jane, told me she had heard the same. “I've read enough books,” she said. “I've planted enough flowers and cooked enough meals. I'm not interested in that stuff anymore.”
By then I no longer considered her life worthless, but I respected her readiness to die. She had reached an end, I supposed. So it was fine with me.
And then she died on a Friday morning, while I was having breakfast alone in a café, reading the newspaper. I walked home and Jane called, her voice afraid and small. “Mum's dead,” she said. And after I called my father, who had not spoken with my mother for many years, and her siblings, and a funeral director I plucked from the yellow pages, and the coroner's office to ask where my mother actually was—an ambulance and police officers had come to the home to take her away—and when her body
would be available for collection by the funeral director, I sat at the table in my flat and my body began to shake. It was absolutely not fine for my mother to be dead. The feeling began at the base of my torso, to the rear, and moved up like nausea through my chest. When it hit my head, it distorted my face and contracted my throat into wails and squeezed my eyes. And it stayed there for about two hours, the waves of its storm growing taller each time, so that I had to drink glasses of water to compensate for the stuff pouring out of my eyes and nose. It left me exhausted and staring at nothing, until I began to feel I was recovering, and then it came back up from the base of my spine, again and again and again. For days. For weeks. For months.
3
IN THE FIRST DAYS AFTER MY MOTHERS DEATH, BEFORE HER funeral, much of my brain seemed to close down, my thoughts reduced to two simple sentences, which repeated themselves over and over. “Where are you? Please come back.”
I ran through the parks of Northwest London, through the long grass of May, and one morning, midway through a lap of the nearby Queen's Park, I found myself repeating a third sentence, an unexpected mantra of panic, speaking it aloud through my tears as I ran. “Dad, please don't die.”
The last defense I had left in the world. I needed someone, after all, to look after me. It was inconceivable, unimaginable, that I could be left to fend for myself. I was surprised at my terror. I had been self-sufficient, in a relatively intense way, for many years. And I had been in some alarming places and situations. But I had never been so afraid as now.
I ran back home and stood in my living room, sweating in my T-shirt and shorts, trying to keep my voice under control, dialing my father's number.
“Hi, Matt,” he said, his voice at its gentlest. “How are you doing?”
“Dad,” I said, “I don't want you to die.”
I was thirty-five years old and I felt like a very small boy. My mother had not looked after me, had not protected me, for about a quarter of a century. She had been worse than useless for nearly as long as I could recall. And yet I knew with a terrifying certainty that half of the protective field that some part of me relied on instinctively to keep me safe and to make sense of the world had been wiped out forever. At the age of seven I had sat with her on a rock overlooking the sea near our house on the West Coast of Scotland. The gray waves heaved in from the Atlantic, whitening on the barnacle-studded shelf of rock along the coast, an outcrop that would rip apart any boat that came close to it, any sailor who fell in. The place still scares me, the hidden depths of kelp and power churning unseen beneath the rock shelf. I leaned against the green canvas coat my mother wore. “What would you do if I fell in?” I asked.
“I'd go in after you,” she said, without hesitating.
“But you'd die,” I said, not entirely believing her because it simply didn't make sense. “You would drown too.”
“Maybe. But I'd still go in after you.” She squeezed me in her arms. I stared at the waves for a little longer and then held open her hands, comparing their size to mine, liking the grit under her fingernails and the chafing and cuts and toughness she picked up when we were in Ardnamurchan for several weeks.
“I wouldn't go in after you,” I said, looking back at the impossible walls of water whose spray reached our Wellington boots.
That woman had been long gone. By the time my mother died, she had not been in a position to jump in after me for many years. But her love was just as furious and unremitting. Without it, it seemed, I was useless. The initial burst of phone calls I made after hearing about my mother's death was followed by paralysis.
Jane had to call the lawyer and the priest. She had to design and print the order of service for the funeral and choose the hymns. She had to get movers to take away my mother's possessions from the home and put them in storage somewhere. She had to return calls to the coroner, who was making sure our mother hadn't been murdered in her old folks' home; indeed, she had died only of a heart attack, my sister reported. My sister had to fetch some clothes—a denim dress—for my mother to wear in her coffin. My sister was dynamic; I was stuck. I couldn't call people back. I couldn't write thank-you notes when letters of condolence arrived. I couldn't look after my girlfriend, who was in the hospital recovering from an operation when my mother died. I could go to the pub and embarrass myself in public with my tears. I could choose a song for the end of the funeral. I could write a eulogy. That was about it.
Jane and me on the rocks at Port an Droighionn, our country house in Scotland
“It's like walking along the road and someone walking up to you and punching you in the face, really hard, for no reason,” I told friends who had not had a parent die. “I'm telling you, I just want you to know, when it happens it'll take you by surprise. It will totally shock you.” They nodded, but I knew they had no idea of what lay ahead, for the death of a parent is an event for which there is no preparation. You can't lose your mother or father twice.
But the punch analogy was slightly off. It was more like a scene from a Robin Hood movie. You're trotting along through the forest on your horse when a swinging sack of wheat sweeps silently through the trees and broadsides you. And then you are utterly winded, motionless, undefended, staring at the insects and the pinecones on the forest floor. All the life and breath gone from you.
On the Saturday morning after my mother died, I went with my sister to the funeral director's in Notting Hill. The man, John, was kind in a studied fashion: Like his coworker on the phone the night before, he referred to my mother, a woman he had never met, as “Mum.” As in: “We'll get Mum from the coroner on Monday.” And: “What sort of coffin would you like for Mum?” And: “Did Mum want to be buried or cremated?”
As we walked home, my sister and I passed the stalls selling falafel and chorizo on Golborne Road and we came to one of the eclectic antique shops there. I went in and saw a huge stuffed wildebeest head mounted on the wall.
“How much is the wildebeest?” I asked the man in the shop. The stuffed wildebeest bust was enormous. It would protrude far into any room I was likely to live in as if craning over a stable door. I could already see it in place in my flat.
“Six hundred pounds.”
I turned to my sister. “I lost my mother; I'm going to get a consolation wildebeest.”
“Why don't you give that a bit more thought,” she said, and steered me out of the shop.
4
THE CORONER RELEASED MY MOTHER'S BODY TO THE FUNERAL director. The paramedics had taken her from her room to the coroner. People I had never met were passing my mother around from fridge to fridge, from gurney to gurney I felt like taking her home and laying her out on my dining table, for an old-fashioned peasant wake. She would still be in my possession. I could invite everyone round and serve them glasses of undiluted whisky. But it doesn't work that way. You have to go to what is, essentially, a store to see your dead. So on the evening before the funeral, my sister, my girlfriend—back home from the hospital—and I sat for a few moments in the wood-paneled anteroom of the funeral home I had randomly chosen, on Ladbroke Grove, waiting to see my mother's body. I thought: “She must have had her chest sliced open and poked around in by the coroner. She must have the most enormous slice down her torso, all sewn up in perhaps not the most cosmetically careful way.”
“Have you ever seen a dead body before?” I asked my sister and girlfriend, while John made sure that “Mum” was ready for us.
“No,” they said.
I thought of saying something comforting. I had some experience of death and dead bodies. I thought of my first encounter with violent death. I was standing on a subway station platform in Boston, on the Red Line, in late 1993 as I made my way to teach an introductory writing course to undergraduates at the college I was attending as a graduate student in Worcester, Massachusetts. It was very early in the morning. The train came into the station. The unshaven man ten feet to my left stumbled toward the edge of the platform. Just before the train got to him, he fell in front
of it and disappeared from sight. The train cut him in half, I learned later. That was just chance; then the observation of dead bodies became part of my job. My first actual view of a dead body was the following year, 1994. I was a summer intern at Newsday, the Long Island newspaper. The news editor sent me to a strip named Sunrise Highway. A motorcyclist had been showing off to his friends on the highway. He was balancing his helmet on his forehead, the police explained to me; it slipped onto his nose and, suddenly blinded, he rode into the back of a parked truck. “That's what we call a cleansing-the-gene-pool story, Matty,” said Lucinda, a reporter on the police beat, when I came back to the office after staring transfixed at the man's brains drooping onto the highway. From early 1999 onward, I saw a lot of dead people in war zones. Some of them, in Kosovo and Iraq, had been dug up from mass graves and were in various states of decomposition. Others were the brand-new dead, their bullet holes fresh on their sallow skin. I particularly remembered a Palestinian boy in a morgue in Nablus, in the West Bank; some of his bones poked out from his skin, white and obscene. He was about ten and had been playing outside the local Hamas political offices when a couple of Israeli rockets showed up to decapitate the Hamas leaders—whom I knew—inside the building. He wore white underpants and nothing else. Then there were the ambulances and morgues of Baghdad, full up with what remained of the latest group of civilians who had been hit by a suicide bomb.
But none of the dead I had seen had been my mother. They did not help me, nor did they qualify me to be reassuring to anyone else. I said nothing.
John appeared from the viewing room in the back.
“Would Mum have been wearing lipstick?” he asked.
“Er, no,” Jane said.
“I didn't think so,” John said. “I don't know how it got there. I'll just remove it.”
Bittersweet: Lessons from My Mother's Kitchen Page 1
