by Sarah Graves
All of which she’d also had. And Roger Dodd wasn’t the first barefaced liar she’d ever dealt with.
Not by a long shot. “Tell him I know he’s mixed up in this,” she whispered. “And if Sam doesn’t come home—”
A sob blocked her throat. She swallowed it angrily and went on, feeling the bad old days pulling her back. And not caring.
Like in the old days. “Tell Roger that if that happens, his lawyers won’t save him. Nothing will. You tell him from me.”
Startled, Bob hesitated. Then, “You got it,” he said.
Then he went out. But when he was gone, she sank into a chair again, because if vengeance for Sam was the only thing left to her, she could get it. She hadn’t been bluffing about it.
But she wouldn’t want it; not that, or anything else.
Ever.
“HOW’S THE ANKLE?” WADE ASKED HALF AN HOUR LATER when she’d retreated to her third-floor workroom and the insulation project.
“Fine.” It hurt like hell, actually. They’d given her pills for it at the clinic.
But she didn’t want to take any. “Wade, I was this close. I could practically touch him. But I gave up.”
Furious, Jake flung old floorboards toward the holes they’d been pried out of. Her father had been keeping his hands occupied while he awaited word that morning, and had gotten a helper to run the insulation blower, too.
The result was that the floor up here had been insulated, although at the moment she wouldn’t have cared if the whole place froze solid, maybe even forever.
Wade stood by the door watching. “I gave up and ran away,” she fumed, seizing a claw hammer and some nails.
“Jake, you didn’t. Where you were, you had maybe another minute. After that, the tide would’ve washed you off your feet.”
She fit one of the boards back into the floor, realized she had it upside down and backward, flipped it angrily, and slammed it down again.
“You don’t know that. We might’ve made it. I just got too scared, that’s all.”
Refitting floorboards was about the last thing she felt like doing. But she had to do something or her feet would find their way downtown, straight to the Artful Dodger, and then without any delay her hands would find their way around Roger Dodd’s neck.
“So, what if we’d had to swim a little?” she went on. “We were both already wet. Maybe we could’ve …”
“Drowned,” Wade said flatly. “And we’d be searching for the two of you now, too. For,” he added quietly, “your bodies, yours and Bella’s.”
Silence. Then: “Yeah. I’m just mad, that’s all. And scared.” She looked up. “Wade, what the hell is Randy Dodd doing out there? Why didn’t he just take the money and run? He doesn’t know it’s fake.”
Wade shook his head. “I don’t know. Maybe there’s something else he wants. Something he didn’t know he wanted, until—”
Which was when it hit her. She put the hammer down. “That’s it, isn’t it? There’s something else now, there must be. Randy must have thought he’d just show up, get his cash from Roger, and vanish again. But then Chip Hahn and Carolyn Rathbone stuck their oar in, and he had to do something about that. Because Carolyn suspected that Randy was still alive, and if she said so publicly she might be listened to. And Randy couldn’t have that.”
“And then,” Wade agreed, “Sam showed up unexpectedly on the breakwater and maybe recognized him. Talk about bad luck.”
Right, she thought. For both of them, Randy and Sam.
Wade continued, “Which still doesn’t explain why Randy didn’t …”
Kill them all right off the bat, he would have finished, but instead he stopped short, not wanting to voice the thought.
He’d changed his clothes, she noticed suddenly; now he was dressed for boating, in heavy cargo pants and layers of shirts. An oilskin slicker topped the bright red sweatshirt she’d given him for his birthday.
“Right.” She said what he hadn’t wanted to: “Grab Carolyn, kill her, get rid of the body. Simple, right? But when he grabbed her, he must not have realized Chip Hahn was with her, that he’s her partner. So, why not?”
She put a nail into one of the repositioned floorboard’s old nail holes, grabbed another one, and slammed it home with the hammer. Hitting something felt good. She placed two more nails, positioning them carefully.
Wade crouched by her, put a hand on her shoulder. “Don’t hit your thumb.”
She managed a smile. “Right. But seriously, Wade, he should be out of the country by now.”
She placed another board, hammered it down. “But maybe he’s onto the fact that the money is no good? Or maybe—”
He’s got a taste for it, Roger Dodd had said of his brother. And … missing girls, Chip had reported of Randy’s time in another state.
Jake voiced her worst thought. “Maybe he just wants to kill them his way. His own time and place. Maybe it’s worth the risk to him, waiting until he can—”
But this time she was the one who stopped before finishing the thought, because the end of this one was so unacceptable, just absolutely unthinkable.
Wade crossed to the doorway. It struck her that he wasn’t just going out on the water; he was going now.
“George and I are taking his boat out to have a look,” he answered her questioning glance. “A lot of the guys from around town are going; we’re just going to stay out there until—”
She stood. The bad ankle protested strenuously; she told it to shut up. Stupid body parts, she thought angrily.
“Now that Randy knows someone might’ve spotted him on the New Brunswick side, he might decide to go in the other direction,” Wade said.
“Through the Lubec Channel. He could make it out to Grand Manan,” she mused aloud. “I hadn’t thought of that.”
The large island between Maine and Nova Scotia was thinly settled and even more thinly policed, especially off-season. “He could lay low there,” she said.
Or he could circle on back to the coast of New Brunswick and disappear into the warren of brick rowhouses and narrow alleys of the industrial city of St. John.
She crouched once more, slotted the final loose floorboard into its place, and nailed it down.
“He’s making it all up as he goes along now, and that makes him harder to predict.”
Wade nodded. “On top of which, he knows the territory, all the isolated hiding places he can hunker down in. He can keep to the shoreline, not go too far out on open water, so he can take cover if he hears a boat or a plane. But improvising means it’s also likelier that he’ll make a mistake.” He paused thoughtfully. “There would be that last long open stretch he’d have to cross, heading for Grand Manan. He could make it, though, I guess. Just get lucky. Small boat, it’s not as easy to spot from the air as you might think.”
But then he shook his head at himself. “But we’ll still get him sooner or later,” he said. “There’s going to be a lot of guys out there all day, and into tonight if need be.”
He straightened, impatient now to get going. “If we don’t find him downriver, we’ll come back up this way, keep on looking until we do.”
He didn’t suggest she might go along, and she knew better than to do so. Between a bad ankle and her tendency to lose her lunch at the slightest ripple, she wouldn’t be an asset.
To put it mildly. “Thanks,” she said, meaning it. “Tell the other guys I said so, too, will you?”
He shot her a grin that she knew was meant to help keep her spirits from collapsing completely. “Yeah, well. You just keep your chin up.”
She forced an answering smile. But as she heard him go down the stairs, she knew Randy Dodd still held all the cards: three hostages (please, God, let there still be three, she thought) plus the willingness—possibly even the eagerness—to do very brutal things.
Topped off by a lot of what looked at least to the casual eye like genuine money. So the questions now were (a) what else did Randy Dodd want, and (b) what wou
ld he do to get it?
But they were so far unanswerable, she knew, and Wade did, too. Which was why he hadn’t promised they would find Sam alive.
Thinking this, she hammered the last nail, then swept up enough stray fluffballs of insulation material to stuff a mattress.
After that she picked up all the tools and cleaned them, collected up all the empty blue plastic insulation bale wrappers, found a trash bag and filled it with them, and dragged the trash bag downstairs to the cellar.
In this way, what remained of the morning passed. At noon, she let Bella force a bowl of soup on her, looked at the bottle of pain pills again, and ignored it again.
No call came to say that Randy Dodd had been captured or that Sam had been found. Jake haunted the house, fixing a wobbly doorknob in the front parlor and some loose carpet on the stairs.
Later on she got a new pane of glass from the hardware store and installed it in a cellar window, and oiled the bulkhead door hinges. At two in the afternoon she checked the phone line and found it working. Still no call.
She took the dogs out, forcing herself to let them romp while she threw a Frisbee for them until her arm gave out, once having to retrieve it herself from among the rosebushes over in her neighbor’s yard. The curtain twitched there, but as usual no one came out to complain, or even just to chat.
By the time the animals got tired, lolling and panting ahead of her up the porch steps, it was past four in the afternoon and already getting dark.
Bella was in the kitchen pouring kibble into their metal dog dishes. The phone rang. Heart pounding, Jake ran to answer.
By the time she did, whoever was on the other end of it had already begun speaking, the tone one of high, manic glee threaded with malice:
“… kill you!” it burbled out at her.
Hot rage coursed through her, demolishing all her careful defenses. “You do that,” she snapped to whoever it was. “You come right on over to the house here, right this minute. And give it your best shot.”
Shocked silence greeted this outburst. She could still hear someone breathing. She slammed the phone down.
Then, alone in the tiny alcove with the old gold-medallion wallpaper reflecting the evening light through the dining room windows, she sank to the floor and wept.
CHIP HAHN WOKE FLAT ON HIS BACK IN A PUDDLE OF WATER, gazing up at the massive old sentinel pine looming far away, at the top of the pit. Everything hurt. A leaf floated down toward him. He turned his head to watch it landing a few feet away. Strange …
But then he shot to a sitting position, hot pain knifing at his injured shoulder, as full consciousness returned.
Sam … where is he? Struggling up, Chip remembered the rest of it: walking with Randy, being shot, going over the pit’s edge.
Now he was at the bottom of it and what had been early morning was late afternoon, the sky darkening swiftly through the bare branches overhead and the pit filling with shadows. Getting colder, too …
Chip shivered, pulling his coat and the life vest beneath it tightly around him. Randy must have thought he killed me.
But he hadn’t, somehow. Chip didn’t know why. The life vest wouldn’t have stopped a bullet. And then … Sam, he thought again.
The last time Chip saw him, Sam had been lying unconscious near the water’s edge where Randy had flung him. Bleeding … and the tide had been rising.
Had Sam been alive? If he was, then was he still? Had he been able or even conscious enough to drag himself away from that rising tide?
Chip had a sudden very clear mental picture of Sam Tiptree a dozen years earlier, age ten or so, falling into the pond in Central Park. They’d been racing a pair of brand-new, radio-operated model sailboats, laughing and yelling and having a fine time bashing into each other’s remote-controlled vessels, trying every dirty trick in the book to cross the finish line first.
Until Sam slipped on a wet spot, hit his head on a paving stone, and fell in. Chip recalled flinging himself into the murky water, sure he’d never reach Sam in time and that he, Chip, would be responsible for his young friend’s death.
Now the same fear made him charge the steep, sandy slope, scramble up it in a frenzy, dig in with his fingers and push with his feet, not caring if his fingernails broke until they bled. Which they did, and he kept climbing anyway, grabbing onto weeds where they grew and onto nothing where they didn’t.
At times, it even seemed that he might make it.
But the sand kept slipping, and the stones flew from under his shoes. The weeds, pulled easily out by their dead roots’ good-looking handholds, turned out to be deadwood, no more substantial than sawdust.
Finally, just as he was about to fling his hand up over the edge of the pit, the whole side of it cascaded down with him on it, all the way to the bottom, where he landed gasping and weeping in frustrated exhaustion.
Some kind of big bird flew over as he lay there, its cry lonesome and harsh. A breeze rattled the branches. Pulling his shoes off and emptying them, he felt a liquid trickle of weakness go through him, and that was the scariest thing of all.
Because with it came the idea that not only did Randy think he’d killed Chip, but that Randy was right. That Chip would never get out of here, just keep trying and failing until he filled up with weakness and eventually quit.
And that someday, somebody would be digging around down here and find his bones.
Or not.
CAROLYN RATHBONE LAY MOTIONLESS IN THE LITTLE BOAT Chip had stolen, watching the daylight drain out of the sky. Every once in a while a white seagull sailed overhead, crying.
She cried, too, but not on the outside, because she was way too scared to do anything but breathe carefully. She didn’t know where Randy was taking her now, but when they got there something bad would happen, she knew that much.
So she just lay there, hoping they wouldn’t get to that part for a while yet. Hoping and freezing, because now that the sun was going down it was getting cold again.
Very cold. After leaving Sam and Chip on the island, he’d taken the boat across a narrow channel and into a sheltered cove at first, and for a long time they’d sat there.
Waiting for it to get dark, she supposed. Or dark enough. For what, she didn’t want to imagine.
Now in the gathering gloom they were motoring again. Waves thumped the boat, spray splashed in, and fog started thickening all around them once more, just as it had the night before.
Fog tasting of salt. She licked her lips thirstily. She hadn’t drunk anything since much earlier, on the big boat.
And that seemed like ages ago, back in another life where there were things to eat and drink and people who didn’t want to kill her any minute.
Randy Dodd’s dark shape at the stern loomed in silence. The boat’s engine roared monotonously. Lulled, she drifted woozily, hearing the girls singing in the engine noise.
Singing and sobbing. A wave slapped the boat’s side hard and sloshed over the rail onto her, waking her with a start. Coughing up salt water, she lurched and froze, remembering:
Sam, Chip. The sharp, popping sound of a gunshot.
Randy was staring at her. Behind him, dozens of tiny red and white lights bobbed on the dark water.
Boats. They were the running lights of a lot of little boats, she realized with sudden hope. And behind them were the lights of Eastport. The breakwater, the streets full of houses …
She drew in a deep breath, opened her mouth to scream, then met his dark gaze again.
He was holding the gun. “Lie down. Put that blanket all the way over you. We’re going to cut engine, sit here in the dark, and let them go right on by. But if you move or make a sound …”
Carolyn hesitated. The other boats drew nearer. Their lights did, anyway. But he was right: in the dark, those lights were the only thing visible. So his plan could easily work …
Everything in her said scream. Scream and scream, until the world ends, until the stars fall out of the sky.
And
the girls, all the dead girls …
They said something, too. We love you, they sang.
But they’d been with her for a long time now. So she knew something important about them. Their darkest secret …
They loved her, all right. So much that they wanted her with them.
Down there in the dark. But she wasn’t dead yet; not like them. Not quite. So she lay down obediently on the deck, pulled the blanket up, and waited for her chance.
Or for the sweet-voiced girls to welcome her home.
CURLED UP IN A BALL AT THE BOTTOM OF THE SAND PIT, CHIP thought about dying. But he just couldn’t seem to get his mind wrapped around the idea of actually doing it.
Right off the bat would have been one thing, he figured. But by some accident of fate that he still didn’t understand, he wasn’t injured enough. No, this was a long-term project, one that even here in the freezing cold would probably take hours.
A shiver went through him, then another. He felt like the meat in a refrigerated sandwich: cold ground, cold sky. A sound of teeth chattering came from somewhere.
After a moment he realized it was his own teeth making that sound. A low, sad laugh came out of him, then: God, what a mess. All that trying and failing to make something of himself for all those years, and now here he was.
Miserably, he felt around in his coat pocket. The kit he’d taken from Sam back when they were on the boat was still in there, and maybe he could at least build a warming fire with it. He’d noticed some dry branches earlier, fallen from the trees growing at the top of the pit.
Maybe he could use them. The old sentinel pine he’d seen as he’d walked to the pit, especially, had dropped a lot of burnable material. He felt around in the dark, hoping to come upon some of it.
His hand closed on some twigs, on what felt like a scrap of old rope—he dropped it fast before realizing it wasn’t a snake—then on a larger chunk, an entire pine branch. The dry needles clinging to it might make decent kindling, Chip thought.
