“You came,” I tell her as I settle in beside her slim frame.
She toys with the glass, turning it ever so slightly, causing the liquid to splatter against the sides. The silence surrounding us is thick with emotion. I know I hurt her by fucking her and then telling her about what her father had done, but I couldn’t bring myself to admit what a coward I was.
Perhaps I was scared. I’m still afraid. But it’s no longer for Sienna’s father’s wrath, it’s because I don’t want her to hate me. Even though we’re still so new in this… relationship, she already means a great deal to me.
“I needed to hear what you had to say. I was always taught to listen to both sides of an argument, and even though I cannot speak to my father right now, I’m going to allow you the first chance at explaining yourself,” she speaks as if she’s far older than her nineteen or so years.
Matured.
Grown-up.
She’s no longer a child.
She’s definitely not the person her father made her out to be.
“I made a mistake,” I start, signaling for a Coke for myself, and a refill for Sienna. “When I was eighteen, I’d gotten arrested for drunk driving. I had friends in the car with me, and stupidly, I believed I was above the law.”
Our drinks arrive, and I grab mine, gulping down the fizzy, sugary liquid before turning to Sienna who’s watching me closely. Her lashes flutter when she blinks, and I can’t help but stare at her for a long while.
“Nobody is above the law, and when I walked into a house with my friends and the girl I was seeing, I realized far too late that my asshole best friend had broken into the property. Needless to say, your father wasn’t impressed.”
“That was you?” she whispers in shock, her eyes wide as she stares at me.
I nod. It was so long ago, but it feels like it was yesterday.
“What happened?”
“Your father had us all locked up for the night, the next morning when I woke up, I was sober, realized how much I could’ve fucked up my life if he didn’t walk into the cell and offer me a way out.”
“What? Did he make you promise to one day break his daughter’s heart?” she bites out in frustration, and I have to shake my head in response.
“Not at all. He offered me an out, if I made something of my life, he’d find me a good job when I finished my studies.” This time, I’m the one looking away. Not out of guilt, but the shame that I’d fallen so far down the rabbit hole. My parents were good, they always doted on me, but I was the one who fucked up worse than Ty ever did.
“And he got you the job,” she said slowly.
“He did, but… if I didn’t agree to watch over you, to take the money, he would’ve closed down my father’s company, he would’ve taken everything from us.” Admitting something like this is awkward. It hurts and aches right down to my soul. “Your father owns both my father and me. He knows things my father has done that could cause damage to our family, Sienna,” I plead, taking her hand, thankful for her not pulling away from me. “I am trying to save my family, but I’m also trying to save us.”
“Is there a us?”
Her question stills me for a moment. But I don’t have to doubt my answer, I just want her to know I’m not lying. I’m no longer hiding things from her, so I look her dead in the eyes.
“There will always be us. As long as you want me,” I affirm. It’s true, there are so many things I should say, like send Sienna on her way to find a good boy her age. But I don’t want her to. I want her to crave me the way I do her. I want her to ache for me like I’ve ached for her since the moment I stepped into that interview room.
“I do want this. Want you, and Ty, but I can’t live with lies.” She’s so beautiful, so strong and resilient, and the fire that burns in her eyes makes me smile.
“I’ll never lie to you again,” I promise. And it’s true.
“Are you two love birds having something stronger to drink, or are you heading home to have some makeup sex?” Ty questions as he leans on the bar counter.
“Fuck off, man,” I gulp down the last of my Coke, and turn to Sienna. I don’t want to make a decision for her, I’m allowing her the choice. Something her father clearly hasn’t ever offered her.
“Perhaps you both would like to take me home?” Sienna utters, shocking us both silent for a beat. This woman, this girl that’s astounded me from day one has literally caused every nerve in my body to light up with electricity.
I want her. Every part of her.
Right, the fuck now.
“I think we should oblige the lady,” Ty smirks, shoving the tea towel he’d been holding onto the barman’s hands and rounding the counter.
This is going to be one hell of a makeup session.
17
Tyler
Reaching the house, I’m in the kitchen, leaning against the counter when Hayden and Sienna walk in. She’s smiling at something he said, and when his gaze meets mine, she offers a shy grin which makes me want to see her on her knees.
I love being in charge, and with her, I’ll certainly enjoy the night while she obeys my every command. Hayden tugs her into his arms, her back against his chest. I watch in awe as he teases his hands up from her hips to her shoulders.
When he finds her hardened little nipples, he tweaks them, causing her to whimper. I lean back, watching from my perch because the show is as enticing as knowing what’s about to happen.
“I promise you,” Hayden whispers in her ear, loud enough for me to hear. “I’ll never lie to you, never hide anything from you,” he tells her, and I know he’s being honest. One thing about my brother, he keeps his promises.
“I… I…” Sienna’s mewls are sensual and sweet as his one hand lowers between her legs. My cock is aching, but I make no move to near them or join them. Not just yet.
Delayed gratification.
“Please,” she begs as his fingers taunt and tease her. They massage her pussy through the denim shorts, and soon her legs are buckling under the pleasure coursing through her.
I smile when she looks over at me. She knows I’m enjoying the show because she offers me a smile that’s worth a million fucking dollars. This woman is everything. Priceless.
Hayden’s hips roll, pressing against her back and I know he’s hard. No sane man could resist this beautiful woman. A soft gasp falls from her lips, and I can’t stop myself.
I free my erection, fisting the hard shaft and pumping it twice, causing Sienna’s eyes to widen considerably. She watches in fascination as I pleasure myself.
“Do you like that, princess?” Hayden questions behind her, the words tumbling over her skin, and she nods. “Do you like watching Ty jerk his cock for you?”
“Yes,” she hisses.
Hayden moves slowly, undressing her as he tugs the tank top over her head, leaving her tits bare to my gaze. Next, he slips her shorts down, and soon, she’s naked, ready for us to devour.
The air in the house is thick with lust. Drenched in desire. I crook my finger, calling her over as I settle in the chair, my legs spread so she can fit between them.
The seductive kitten drops down and crawls toward me, causing me to groan at the sight. Fucking beautiful. Sienna grips my dick, her small hand holding it tight as she strokes me while her tongue darts out to lick at the arousal collecting there.
Her wide eyes latch onto mine as Hayden kneels behind her. His face lowering to her core, and the moment he swipes his tongue along her seam, she cries out in pleasure.
He continues to lick and tease her with his fingers while I grip her hair, fisting it to hold her steady as I guide her to my cock. Her plump lips wrap around the shaft as she slides her hot, wet mouth down, eliciting another deep growl from me.
My head drops back when I hit the back of her throat, and she chokes, gagging on me as she takes me even deeper than I ever thought possible. Fuck. She continues toying with me like I’m her favorite candy. Licking and sucking, stroking and jerking and soon,
my balls draw up and I empty myself into her waiting throat.
Fuck, she’s exquisite.
18
Sienna
I’ve never been so bold. But something about both men makes me lose all inhibitions. I want to please them and be pleasured by them. Nothing would make me happier.
I don’t know when my fantasy will come crashing down, so instead of thinking about it, I empty my mind and live in the here and now. We make it to the bedroom where we had this exact same scene only a few nights ago has become a place where my wildest fantasies seem to come to life.
My body is pliable. I allow both Hayden and Tyler to touch, taunt, and tease me as both men enjoy me as if I were their toy. Predators seeking out their prey and I don’t stop them. I can’t because I crave this with every part of me.
Ty’s mouth finds mine, and Hayden’s teases my nipples. The hardened buds taut, needy for him to devour. I’m craving something more, and my fingers tangle in each man’s hair, tugging them closer.
Ty’s tongue slips into my mouth, dancing with mine in an erotic tangle which makes my body shiver with need. The anticipation of what’s to come rips through me when Hayden lowers himself between my thighs, and soon, his tongue is lapping at me as if I were his last meal.
A shiver wracks through me when Hayden teases two fingers inside me, taunting me like I’m a toy for his amusement, and I can’t stop him. I don’t want to stop him.
He pumps into me, once, twice, and I’m flying. My eyes snap open to find Tyler smiling down at me as he rises, his cock hard, and ready as he paints my lips with his arousal. I’m coated in him, and I lick off the musky flavor as he slips into my mouth.
With him inside me, and Hayden’s fingers pushing me higher and higher, I feel my stomach tightening with need. My release so close, I’m on edge, teetering as they both take me, own me, claim me.
At this moment, I’m no longer the girl who doesn’t have any freedom, I’m the woman wanted by two strong men. The thought sends me reeling as Hayden’s fingers crook against a spot inside me that curls my toes and I hum my approval with Tyler’s thick cock in my mouth.
“Time for you to take us both,” Tyler murmurs, slipping from between my lips. “Are you ready?” He questions gently, placing a kiss on my forehead.
“Yes, I’m ready.”
19
Hayden
When I finally lie back, my body is taut with need. I’m so close to release, I don’t know how to hold back not taking Sienna and claiming her as mine right here and now.
Lying back, I grip her hips and pull her over me till she’s straddling me with her delicate palms on my chest. The contact causes my blood to boil with need and desire.
Tyler’s gaze is on me, hooking me with merely a glance. He knows how much I want her, and I know he’s taunting me with being here. We’ve done this so many times, but now, I know why I don’t want him here because I want Sienna all to myself. This will be the last time.
He knows it.
I know it.
“Come, princess,” Tyler crawls up behind her, positioning her until she’s slowly sliding down my cock which only serves to elicit pleasured groans from me. I want her, I need her to feel me, and she’s moving so slowly, I don’t think I can hold on.
Every inch of me that is entering her is alive with electric passion, and nothing can stop my hips from lifting to meet hers. She smiles down at me, leaning forward as Tyler picks up the lube and gets her ready. She’s not moving, and the moment she does, I’m going to have to grit my teeth to keep from filling her.
The moments pass as if time falls through an hourglass, and a second later, Ty is sliding into her, causing every muscle in her body to tense as I hold her to me.
Her eyes are wide, watching me, focusing on mine. “You’re a good girl,” I smirk up at her feeling the tension ease as we slowly start to move. She’s tight, so fucking tight, she’s going to milk me for all I’m worth.
Soft moans and whimpers fall from her lips, the rough growl from Ty is behind her, and my own pleasured grunts only add to the symphony that’s clouding my mind.
I no longer see our limits.
I see the happiness on her face, the exquisite pleasure that’s lighting up her expression, and I want it there all the time.
We move in sync.
I slide in, Ty slides out, in and out. Sienna is our toy, our vessel, and as her nails rake down my chest, she cries out when her orgasm hits her like a tidal wave. Her pussy tightens, clenching around me as if she’s trying to break me down and dissolve my restraint. Which she does in the next second when her mouth latches on, and her teeth bear down on my shoulder.
I can’t stop. I cannot focus. All I feel is the heat and slickness of Sienna’s body, which pushes me over the edge, and I empty myself inside her.
We lie there for long moments.
Soft breaths.
Sweaty bodies.
And a calmness washes over me and sleep steals me.
My eyes open and I take note of the red numbers on the clock. It’s not even five in the morning, and I’m awake. Pushing off the bed, I leave Ty and Sienna under the covers and pad into the kitchen to grab a drink of water.
When I pick up my cell phone from the counter, I find an email from Mr. Gardier. He wants to see me. I’ve decided what I want. There’s no turning back because she’s mine and I’m no longer going to allow him to rule my life.
He can’t get me fired if I quit.
I accept the meeting request for later today but ask for it to be shifted to the afternoon. First thing in the morning, I’ll head out to the school and hand in my resignation.
I can teach anywhere.
There are schools, there are colleges all over the country, but there is only one girl that I want and need. And I’m not about to give her up because some rich asshole tells me to.
Grabbing a mug, I wait for it to fill with coffee from the machine before settling with my laptop on the sofa and open my emails. I sit in silence as I tap out my letter of resignation to the Dean. I’ve never once done anything wrong over the two years I’d been working there, and I’m not about to let Sienna’s dad tarnish my name.
Once I hit send, I don’t wait for a response. Shutting the lid of the laptop, I set it on the coffee table and grab my drink and swallow down the bitter liquid.
In a few hours, I’ll officially be unemployed, and I’ll never be happier. Then the hard work starts because I’m taking Sienna to her father, and I’ll stand beside her when I tell him how much I care for his daughter.
Nothing is taking her away from me.
20
Hayden
“Why are you even doing this?” Sienna questions from beside me in the car. We’re almost at her house, but I haven’t told her everything.
“I told him I’ll meet him. He doesn’t know I’m bringing his daughter to tell him how much I want her,” I offer a wink hoping to calm her down. She doesn’t realize this morning before she woke up, I’d met with the Dean and told him I’m leaving.
He didn’t understand, but I couldn’t explain why. All I told him was there was another opportunity that I was pursuing. He doesn’t need to know much more than that. It’s none of his business.
We pull up to the gates, and when they slide open, I inch the car toward the large house that sits on the hill. This place is like a goddamn palace, and I wonder how growing up here must’ve felt like. Probably like being in a fortress, locked up without access to the world outside.
I stop the car at the entrance and exit the vehicle before making my way around to the passenger door to help Sienna. We walk together toward the door, but before we can knock, it slides open, and we’re met with what I’m guessing is the maid.
She offers a smile while stepping aside, allowing us to enter the ample space of the entrance foyer. There’s a small reprieve before I notice Mr. Gardier walking toward us and Sienna’s body stiffens.
“What are you doing here?” he grits out
at his daughter, causing her to cower for a moment before I reach for her hand. “What the hell is going on?”
“Mr. Gardier, I came here out of respect for—”
“Get in my office, both of you,” he grumbles turning on his heel and leading us toward a hallway, and soon enough, we’re in an old looking office which is filled with antiques of every kind.
He settles in the chair behind a large dark wood desk before gesturing toward us to sit opposite him. Once we’re both seated, he opens his mouth to speak before regarding us.
“Talk,” he orders me.
“I’ve appreciated your help over the past few years, sir,” I start. “However, I feel that I would like to pursue a relationship with Sienna.”
He guffaws at this before looking to his daughter. “You like being a paid girl for this man?” he bites out angrily. “He’s being paid to watch over you.”
“I know, Dad. I’m tired of you ruining my life.” She looks so confident, and pride swells in my chest that she wants to be with me.
“You’re a child for god’s sake!”
Sienna shakes her head, “I’m not a child anymore, Dad. Please—”
“Over my dead body will this happen,” he grits through clenched teeth. He turns his glare on me. “I will have you fired.”
“I’ve resigned with immediate effect as of this morning. You no longer have anything to hold over me.”
Sienna’s gaze darts to mine, I can feel her shooting daggers my way. I never told her what I did because I know she would’ve tried to talk me out of it.
“You’re giving up everything for my daughter?” He sneers. “You have a lot to learn, this isn’t something that will last forever, and you’re giving up a prestigious career for some teenage crush.”
Sweetest Obsessions - Anthology Page 240
