These apparent Errors in the Doctrine of Thwackum, served greatly to palliate the contrary Errors in that of Square, which our good Man no less saw and condemned. He thought indeed that the different Exuberancies of these Gentlemen, would correct their different Imperfections; and that from both, especially with his Assistance, the two Lads would derive sufficient Precepts of true Religion and Virtue. If the Event happened contrary to his Expectations, this possibly proceeded from some Fault in the Plan itself; which the Reader hath my Leave to discover, if he can: For we do not pretend to introduce any infallible Characters into this History; where we hope nothing will be found which hath never yet been seen in human Nature.
To return therefore; the Reader will not, I think, wonder that the different Behaviour of the two Lads above commemorated, produced the different Effects, of which he hath already seen some Instance; and besides this, there was another Reason for the Conduct of the Philosopher and the Pedagogue; but this being Matter of great Importance, we shall reveal it in the next Chapter.
CHAPTER VI.
Containing a better Reason still for the before mentioned Opinions.
It is to be known then, that those two learned Personages, who have lately made a considerable Figure on the Theatre of this History, had from their first Arrival at Mr. Allworthy’s House, taken so great an Affection, the one to his Virtue, the other to his Religion, that they had meditated the closest Alliance with him.
For this Purpose they had cast their Eyes on that fair Widow, whom, tho’ we have not for some Time made any Mention of her, the Reader, we trust, hath not forgot. Mrs. Blifil was indeed the Object to which they both aspired.
It may seem remarkable, that of four Persons whom we have commemorated at Mr. Allworthy’s House, three of them should fix their Inclinations on a Lady who was never greatly celebrated for her Beauty, and who was, moreover, now a little descended into the Vale of Years; but in reality Bosom Friends, and intimate Acquaintance, have a Kind of natural Propensity to particular Females at the House of a Friend, viz. to his Grand-mother, Mother, Sister, Daughter, Aunt, Niece, or Cousin, when they are rich; and to his Wife, Sister, Daughter, Niece, Cousin, Mistress, or Servant Maid, if they should be handsome.
We would not, however, have our Reader imagine, that Persons of such Characters as were supported by Thwackum and Square, would undertake a Matter of this Kind, which hath been a little censured by some rigid Moralists, before they had thoroughly examined it, and considered whether it was (as Shakespear phrases it) ‘Stuff o’ th’ Conscience’1 or no. Thwackum was encouraged to the Undertaking, by reflecting, that to covet your Neighbour’s Sister is no where forbidden; and he knew it was a Rule in the Construction of all Laws, that ‘Expressum facit cessare Tacitum.’ The Sense of which is, ‘When a Law-giver sets down plainly his whole Meaning, we are prevented from making him mean what we please ourselves.’2 As some Instances of Women, therefore, are mentioned in the Divine Law, which forbids us to covet our Neighbour’s Goods, and that of a Sister omitted, he concluded it to be lawful. And as to Square, who was in his Person what is called a jolly Fellow, or a Widow’s Man, he easily reconciled his Choice to the eternal Fitness of Things.
Now, as both these Gentlemen were industrious in taking every Opportunity of recommending themselves to the Widow, they apprehended one certain Method was, by giving her Son the constant Preference to the other Lad; and, as they conceived the Kindness and Affection which Mr. Allworthy shewed the latter, must be highly disgreeable to her, they doubted not but the laying hold on all Occasions to degrade and vilify him, would be highly pleasing to her; who, as she hated the Boy, must love all those who did him any Hurt. In this Thwackum had the Advantage; for while Square could only scarify the poor Lad’s Reputation, he could flea his Skin; and, indeed, he considered every Lash he gave him as a Compliment paid to his Mistress; so that he could, with the utmost Propriety, repeat this old flogging Line, ‘Castigo te non quod odio habeam, sed quod AMEM. I chastize thee not out of Hatred, but out of Love.’ And this, indeed, he often had in his Mouth, or rather, according to the old Phrase, never more properly applied, at his Fingers Ends.
For this Reason principally, the two Gentlemen concurred, as we have seen above, in their Opinion concerning the two Lads; this being, indeed, almost the only Instance of their concurring on any Point: For, beside the Difference of their Principles, they had both long ago strongly suspected each others Design, and hated one another with no little Degree of Inveteracy.
This mutual Animosity was a good deal increased by their alternate Successes: For Mrs. Blifil knew what they would be at long before they imagined it; or, indeed, intended she should: For they proceeded with great Caution, lest she should be offended, and acquaint Mr. Allworthy. But they had no Reason for any such Fear; she was well enough pleased with a Passion, of which she intended none should have any Fruits but herself. And the only Fruits she designed for herself, were Flattery and Courtship; for which Purpose, she soothed them by Turns, and a long Time equally. She was, indeed, rather inclined to favour the Parson’s Principles; but Square’s Person was more agreeable to her Eye, for he was a comely Man; whereas the Pedagogue did in Countenance very nearly resemble that Gentleman, who, in the Harlot’s Progress, is seen correcting the Ladies in Bridewel.3
Whether Mrs. Blifil had been surfeited with the Sweets of Marriage, or disgusted by its Bitters, or from what other Cause it proceeded, I will not determine; but she could never be brought to listen to any second Proposals. However, she at last conversed with Square with such a Degree of Intimacy, that malicious Tongues began to whisper Things of her, to which, as well for the Sake of the Lady, as that they were highly disagreeable to the Rule of Right, and the Fitness of Things, we will give no Credit, and therefore shall not blot our Paper with them. The Pedagogue, ’tis certain, whipt on, without getting a Step nearer to his Journey’s End.
Indeed he had committed a great Error, and that Square discovered much sooner than himself. Mrs. Blifil (as, perhaps, the Reader may have formerly guessed) was not over and above pleased with the Behaviour of her Husband; nay, to be honest, she absolutely hated him, till his Death, at last, a little reconciled him to her Affections. It will not be therefore greatly wondered at, if she had not the most violent Regard to the Offspring she had by him. And, in fact, she had so little of this Regard, that in his Infancy she seldom saw her Son, or took any Notice of him; and hence she acquiesced, after a little Reluctance, in all the Favours which Mr. Allworthy showered on the Foundling; whom the good Man called his own Boy, and in all Things put on an intire Equality with Master Blifil. This Acquiescence in Mrs. Blifil was considered by the Neighbours, and by the Family, as a Mark of her Condescension to her Brother’s Humour, and she was imagined by all others, as well as Thwackum and Square, to hate the Foundling in her Heart; nay, the more Civility she shewed him, the more they conceived she detested him, and the surer Schemes she was laying for his Ruin: For as they thought it her Interest to hate him, it was very difficult for her to persuade them she did not.
Thwackum was the more confirmed in his Opinion, as she had more than once slily caused him to whip Tom Jones, when Mr. Allworthy, who was an Enemy to this Exercise, was abroad; whereas she had never given any such Orders concerning young Blifil. And this had likewise imposed upon Square. In reality, tho’ she certainly hated her own Son; of which, however monstrous it appears, I am assured she is not a singular Instance, she appeared, notwithstanding all her outward Compliance, to be in her Heart sufficiently displeased with all the Favour shewn by Mr. Allworthy to the Foundling. She frequently complained of this behind her Brother’s Back, and very sharply censured him for it, both to Thwackum and Square; nay, she would throw it in the Teeth of Allworthy himself, when a little Quarrel, or Miff, as it is vulgarly called, arose between them.
However, when Tom grew up, and gave Tokens of that Gallantry of Temper which greatly recommends Men to Women, this Disinclination which she had discovered to him when a Child, by Degrees ab
ated, and at last she so evidently demonstrated her Affection to him to be much stronger than what she bore her own Son, that it was impossible to mistake her any longer. She was so desirous of often seeing him, and discovered such Satisfaction and Delight in his Company, that before he was eighteen Years old, he was become a Rival to both Square and Thwackum; and what is worse, the whole Country began to talk as loudly of her Inclination to Tom, as they had before done of that which she had shewn to Square; on which Account the Philosopher conceived the most implacable Hatred for our poor Heroe.
CHAPTER VII.
In which the Author himself makes his Appearance on the Stage.
Tho’ Mr. Allworthy was not of himself hasty to see Things in a disadvantageous Light, and was a Stranger to the public Voice, which seldom reaches to a Brother or a Husband, tho’ it rings in the Ears of all the Neighbourhood; yet was this Affection of Mrs. Blifil to Tom, and the Preference which she too visibly gave him to her own Son, of the utmost Disadvantage to that Youth.
For such was the Compassion which inhabited Mr. Allworthy’s Mind, that nothing but the Steel of Justice could ever subdue it. To be unfortunate in any Respect was sufficient, if there was no Demerit to counterpoise it, to turn the Scale of that good Man’s Pity, and to engage his Friendship, and his Benefaction.
When therefore he plainly saw Master Blifil was absolutely detested (for that he was) by his own Mother, he began, on that Account only, to look with an Eye of Compassion upon him; and what the Effects of Compassion are in good and benevolent Minds, I need not here explain to most of my Readers.
Henceforward, he saw every Appearance of Virtue in the Youth through the magnifying End, and viewed all his Faults with the Glass inverted, so that they became scarce perceptible. And this perhaps the amiable Temper of Pity may make commendable; but the next Step the Weakness of human Nature alone must excuse: For he no sooner perceived that Preference which Mrs. Blifil gave to Tom, than that poor Youth (however innocent) began to sink in his Affections as he rose in hers. This, it is true, would of itself alone never have been able to eradicate Jones from his Bosom; but it was greatly injurious to him, and prepared Mr. Allworthy’s Mind for those Impressions, which afterwards produced the mighty Events that will be contained hereafter in this History; and to which, it must be confest, the unfortunate Lad, by his own Wantonness, Wildness, and Want of Caution, too much contributed.
In recording some Instances of these, we shall, if rightly understood, afford a very useful Lesson to those well-disposed Youths, who shall hereafter be our Readers: For they may here find that Goodness of Heart, and Openness of Temper, tho’ these may give them great Comfort within, and administer to an honest Pride in their own Minds, will by no Means, alas! do their Business in the World. Prudence and Circumspection are necessary even to the best of Men. They are indeed as it were a Guard to Virtue, without which she can never be safe. It is not enough that your Designs, nay that your Actions, are intrinsically good, you must take Care they shall appear so. If your Inside be never so beautiful, you must preserve a fair Outside also. This must be constantly looked to, or Malice and Envy will take Care to blacken it so, that the Sagacity and Goodness of an Allworthy will not be able to see thro’ it, and to discern the Beauties within. Let this, my young Readers, be your constant Maxim, That no Man can be good enough to enable him to neglect the Rules of Prudence; nor will Virtue herself look beautiful, unless she be bedecked with the outward Ornaments of Decency and Decorum. And this Precept, my worthy Disciples, if you read with due Attention, you will, I hope, find sufficiently enforced by Examples in the following Pages.
I ask Pardon for this short Appearance, by Way of Chorus, on the Stage. It is in reality for my own Sake, that while I am discovering the Rocks on which Innocence and Goodness often split, I may not be misunderstood to recommend the very Means to my worthy Readers, by which I intend to shew them they will be undone. And this, as I could not prevail on any of my Actors to speak, I myself was obliged to declare.
CHAPTER VIII.
A childish Incident, in which, however, is seen a good-natured Disposition in Tom Jones.
The Reader may remember, that Mr. Allworthy gave Tom Jones a little Horse, as a Kind of Smart-money1 for the Punishment, which he imagined he had suffered innocently.
This Horse Tom kept above half a Year, and then rode him to a neighbouring Fair, and sold him.
At his Return, being questioned by Thwackum, what he had done with the Money for which the Horse was sold, he frankly declared he would not tell him.
‘Oho!’ says Thwackum, ‘you will not! then I will have it out of your Br—h;’ that being the Place to which he always applied for Information on every doubtful Occasion.
Tom was now mounted on the Back of a Footman, and every Thing prepared for Execution, when Mr. Allworthy entering the Room, gave the Criminal a Reprieve, and took him with him into another Apartment; where being alone with Tom, he put the same Question to him which Thwackum had before asked him.
Tom answered, He could in Duty refuse him nothing; but as for that tyrannical Rascal, he would never make him any other Answer than with a Cudgel, with which he hoped soon to be able to pay him for all his Barbarities.
Mr. Allworthy very severely reprimanded the Lad, for his indecent and disrespectful Expressions concerning his Master; but much more for his avowing an Intention of Revenge. He threatened him with the entire Loss of his Favour, if he ever heard such another Word from his Mouth; for he said, he would never support or befriend a Reprobate. By these and the like Declarations, he extorted some Compunction from Tom, in which that Youth was not over sincere: For he really meditated some Return for all the smarting Favours he had received at the Hands of the Pedagogue. He was, however, brought by Mr. Allworthy to express a Concern for his Resentment against Thwackum; and then the good Man, after some wholesome Admonition, permitted him to proceed, which he did, as follows.
‘Indeed, my dear Sir, I love and honour you more than all the World: I know the great Obligations I have to you, and should detest myself, if I thought my Heart was capable of Ingratitude. Could the little Horse you gave me speak, I am sure he could tell you how fond I was of your Present: For I had more Pleasure in feeding him, than in riding him. Indeed, Sir, it went to my Heart to part with him; nor would I have sold him upon any other Account in the World than what I did. You yourself, Sir, I am convinced, in my Case, would have done the same: For none ever so sensibly felt the Misfortunes of others. What would you feel, dear Sir, if you thought yourself the Occasion of them?—Indeed, Sir, there never was any Misery like theirs.’——‘Like whose, Child?’ says Allworthy: ‘What do you mean?’ ‘Oh, Sir,’ answered Tom, ‘your poor Game-keeper, with all his large Family, ever since your discarding him, have been perishing with all the Miseries of Cold and Hunger. I could not bear to see these poor Wretches naked and starving, and at the same Time know myself to have been the Occasion of all their Sufferings.—I could not bear it, Sir, upon my Soul, I could not.’ (Here the Tears run down his Cheeks, and he thus proceeded) ‘It was to save them from absolute Destruction, I parted with your dear Present, notwithstanding all the Value I had for it.—I sold the Horse for them, and they have every Farthing of the Money.’
Mr. Allworthy now stood silent for some Moments, and before he spoke, the Tears started from his Eyes. He at length dismissed Tom with a gentle Rebuke, advising him for the future to apply to him in Cases of Distress, rather than to use extraordinary Means of relieving them himself.
This Affair was afterwards the Subject of much Debate between Thwackum and Square. Thwackum held, that this was flying in Mr. Allworthy’s Face, who had intended to punish the Fellow for his Disobedience. He said, in some Instances, what the World called Charity appeared to him to be opposing the Will of the Almighty, which had marked some particular Persons for Destruction; and that this was in like manner acting in Opposition to Mr. Allworthy; concluding, as usual, with a hearty Recommendation of Birch.
Square argued stron
gly, on the other Side, in Opposition perhaps to Thwackum, or in Compliance with Mr. Allworthy, who seemed very much to approve what Jones had done. As to what he urged on this Occasion, as I am convinced most of my Readers will be much abler Advocates for poor Jones, it would be impertinent to relate it. Indeed it was not difficult to reconcile to the Rule of Right, an Action which it would have been impossible to deduce from the Rule of Wrong.
CHAPTER IX.
Containing an Incident of a more heinous Kind, with the Comments of Thwackum and Square.
It hath been observed by some Man of much greater Reputation for Wisdom than myself, that Misfortunes seldom come single.1 An instance of this may, I believe, be seen in those Gentlemen who have the Misfortune to have any of their Rogueries detected: For here Discovery seldom stops till the Whole is come out. Thus it happened to poor Tom; who was no sooner pardoned for selling the Horse, than he was discovered to have some Time before sold a fine Bible which Mr. Allworthy gave him, the Money arising from which Sale he had disposed of in the same Manner. This Bible Master Blifil had purchased, tho’ he had already such another of his own, partly out of Respect for the Book, and partly out of Friendship to Tom, being unwilling that the Bible should be sold out of the Family at half Price. He therefore disbursed the said half Price himself; for he was a very prudent Lad, and so careful of his Money, that he had laid up almost every Penny which he had received from Mr. Allworthy.
The History of Tom Jones (Penguin Classics) Page 19
