When I open the door and catch sight of her beauty, the first thought that pops into my mind is to yank her over my shoulder, walk towards my desk, drop her there, unzip my jeans with one hand while holding her down with the other and fuck her once again under my best friend’s watchful eye. I blink a few times before shaking my head. Focus. Get your mind out of the gutter.
“Allison, you look absolutely radiant. The pink shirt looks so feminine on you and I’m happy to see you’re taking my advice to heart by letting your hair flow seductively over your shoulders.” I wink at her and extend my hand to invite her in.
Hmmm, I wonder if her no doubt provocative underwear matches the color of her shirt.
“It was another steamy day and I had to take a shower before coming over.”
I wish I were able to join you. There’s nothing quite like shower sex.
“Hunter’s right. The soft shade brings out your features.” Jake gets up the second she walks in the room.
I’m glad to see I’m not the only who zoomed in on her ample breasts.
My best friend’s compliment flushes her cheeks and my dick twitches.
“Why, thank you, Jake.” I’m dying to lick the lower lip she’s biting. “Wow. The two of you sound like you’re buttering me up for something.” Allison immediately focuses on the generous assortment of cakes and the bottles sitting on the filing cabinet.
“Now that cuts real deep,” I say, holding my chest. “You say that as if I haven’t been tripping all over you since you arrived here.”
“I have to agree with Hunter. That hurts.” Jake winks.
“Forgive me if I’m wrong, but when a man resorts to decadent sweets and wine, there’s often more to it than what meets the eye.”
“Who says those are for you?” I cross my arms over my chest, pretending to be offended.
She takes me in for a few seconds before bursting out laughing. Jake and I join her.
“Okay. You win. Those are for you. I hope you like chocolate?”
“Are you kidding me? Is there a woman on this planet who’d say no to chocolate?”
“Glad to hear it. Sit down and I’ll grab you a plate and a glass. White?”
“I’ll be honest, after the eventful morning and the busy day, I couldn’t ask for anything more than some cake and a glass of chilled white wine.”
“That’s music to my ears.” I take a step towards the filing cabinet, but Jake raises his hand to stop me.
“Why don’t I bring Ali the treats and the wine while you sit down with her?”
I pick up on my best friend’s not-so-subtle way of telling me to start talking.
“Oh, God. Jake, you are very mysterious, and you didn’t give me much to go by in your text message.”
“I hate to quote my sister, because that would imply she’s right for once”—Jake chuckles—”but there are certain things that are best said in person.”
“I hope you won’t have me on pins and needles holding my breath too afraid to make the slightest sound like this morning in Riley’s house.” Allison’s freaked expression has both of us bursting out laughing. “That was a bit too dramatic for me.”
“Well, we are talking about Hunter.”
“Ignore him.” I roll my eyes before focusing my attention on the blonde. “Similar to our meeting this morning, what I want to discuss with you does involve all of us in this room, but I can’t promise I’ll be able to match Jake’s sister’s theatrical delivery… even if my best friend thinks otherwise.”
“Good. One of those a day is quite sufficient.” She grins.
“Since Jake and I had to go rescue his sister last night and the storm made things complicated, we got home after you had already fallen asleep. Jake didn’t have the heart to wake you up, so we were never able to talk about what happened inside the cabin.”
“But I thought Jake said we were okay.” Her big, beautiful hazel eyes search Jake’s for confirmation.
“Ali, I meant what I said. You and I are okay. My relationship with Hunter remains unscathed and that’s what’s most important to me. My best friend wants to talk about an idea we’ve been bouncing off of each other and we’d like your input.” Jake hands Allison a plate of sweets before handing her a glass of wine.
“That makes me feel so much better because I was afraid you’d be upset by what you witnessed, or worse, that I had come between you two.”
“I won’t lie, I was surprised and I was even a little irritated watching you take so much pleasure at his mercy, but once I was able to calm down, I realized this opens the door to a lot of possibilities for us.”
“What do you mean?” Allison frowns while shaking her head.
“Why don’t I let Hunter explain.”
“I think both Jake and I have been quite forward about our attraction to you. And a few days ago, you were able to experience firsthand how much we want you.”
“Oh.” She blushes so much the color matches her shirt.
“You don’t have to be shy about it. You’re a gorgeous woman with sensual curves and you’re so passionate. It shouldn’t come as a surprise that you’ve seduced us and that we’ve fallen under your spell.”
“I have to agree with Hunter. The way you respond to me when we’re together nearly drives me mad.”
“If the two of you keep showering me with compliments, I’m going to demand you lower the temperature on the A/C because I’m burning up here.”
I smile before continuing. “Do you remember when Jake walked in on us?”
“How can I forget?” She lowers her eyes to the plate on her lap.
“Having him in the room didn’t stop me. On the contrary, it fueled me. When he was watching me take you with such unrestricted fury, it only made me want to fuck you harder.”
“Hunter.” She says my name with so much lust.
I reach out for her plate and drop it on the desk next to her before cupping her hands into mine. “I also noticed you didn’t ask me to stop even when Jake was squatting in front of you kissing you with such ardor I could feel your body quiver under his touch.” My voice is so low the tremor hardens my dick.
“I… Well… I mean…” She stops, trying to regain her composure. “I really don’t know how to respond to this.” Her shyness is endearing.
“It’s okay if you enjoyed having me inside you while my best friend watched.” I bring my index finger to her face and trace the contour of her jawline.
“It is?”
“Absolutely. We both enjoyed it as well, didn’t we, Jake?”
“You definitely seemed to enjoy yourself more than I did, buddy, since her pussy was clenched around your dick, not mine, but I took a lot of pleasure from watching Ali submit to you.” His voice is coated with desire and I can just imagine that his cock is as hard as mine.
“My God,” she exhales, wiping her forehead with the back of her hand as if the cool temperature isn’t enough to tame the fire burning inside her.
“Allison, we were hoping you’d consider doing it again.”
“You mean us together,” she says, waving her finger between us, “while he watches?” Her eyes bounce from mine to Jake’s and it’s clear she’s shocked by my proposition.
“It would be a little different…”
“How so?”
“In the sense that this time Jake would participate fully.”
“Huh?” Her jaw drops.
“It’s more fun when we’re all naked.” I grin.
“Hunter, what do you mean?”
“Allison, have you ever had two men worship your body at the same time?”
“Until a few days ago I had never had two different men in the same month, let alone the same day. What you’re suggesting is so far out of my comfort zone, it’s not even funny.”
That might be the case, but she isn’t making any effort to run out the door.
“Hunter, may I?”
“Jump right in, buddy.”
Jake takes a step towards us
and I scoot my chair back a little to give my friend some room.
He kneels in front of the blonde and takes her hands into his. “Ali, when I took you in the barn, you trusted me implicitly.” Allison nods and shifts her eyes to me. I smile and she returns a shy grin. “And you were more than open to the idea of me giving you more pleasure than you’ve ever experienced in your life. Am I right?”
“Yes, but—”
“Ali, neither of us would ever do anything to harm you. You believe me?”
She nods. “I know you wouldn’t, Jake.” She turns her attention to me. “The same goes for you, Hunter.”
I extend my arm and caress her cheek with the back of my hand to reassure her.
“What Hunter is suggesting is another way for us to take your sexual awakening to a whole other level… one that’s unparalleled by anything else you’ve ever even dreamt of. I can promise you, when two men yearn for you as badly as we do and focus their insatiable hunger on your heavenly body, it can be mind-blowing.”
“Gosh,” she whispers.
“Sweetheart, when you climax sandwiched between the two of us, you’ll think you’ve seen God.”
“Oh. Your words are going to make me lose it, Jake.” She’s fanning herself profusely with one hand and I can’t help but focus on the other hand slowly travelling down her chest. Damn. I’d pay good money to have those tits in my hands right about now.
Snap out of it. “Jake’s right. It wouldn’t be much different than it was a few days ago inside the cabin, except for the fact that we’d all agree in advance to give and to take as much pleasure from each other as we possibly can.”
She lowers her eyes and squeezes Jake’s hands. “Do I have to decide right now?”
My buddy shakes his head. “Both Hunter and I feel it would be unfair to force you to make a decision on the spot, since this is most likely very new to you.”
“It is. Until a few days ago, I had always assumed I needed a bed in order to have sex.” She flashes a wry smile.
“I guess you know differently now?” I couldn’t resist.
We all laugh.
“Talk about bursting my bubble.”
“What we’re suggesting will make everything else you’ve experienced so far tame and predictable, but it’s well worth the ride,” I add.
“That it is, but we don’t want to pressure you. We want you to be comfortable with the idea and let our conversation sink in.” My best friend chimes in.
“And if I did accept, what would this look like… between the three of us?”
Allison might not have said yes yet, but everything about her demeanor suggests we’ve piqued her curiosity and she could be open to exploring more naughtiness at the hands of two alpha males.
“Since my sister is leaving tomorrow mid-afternoon, why don’t you come over to my house at about seven o’clock for a barbecue and you can let us know your decision then? You’ll have plenty of time to ponder the idea of being with the two of us. You’ll either be aroused by it or not.” Jake stretches back up, pulls up a chair and sits next to Allison.
“If you decide you want both of us as much as we want you, I have a gift for you,” I say, getting up and walking to my desk. I grab the little sex toy I hid at the bottom of my drawer and walk back to Allison. “This is for you.”
“Wow. You’re giving me a gift before I even make a decision?”
“If you say yes, this will come in handy.”
“What is it?” She reaches out, drops the little silver bag on her lap and impatiently fumbles through the star-printed tissue paper.
“If you decide you want to know how heavenly it feels to be fucked by a man while you suck another guy’s cock, this will make things much more pleasurable for you.”
Allison’s eyes widen so much, if they were to get any larger they’d take over her whole body.
“Hunter.” Jake scowls. “Didn’t we talk about you not shocking Ali?”
“I thought you meant at the beginning.” Jeez. “But why be shy about it now?” I grin from ear to ear.
She pulls out the purple silicone toy and brings it up to eye level. After a few long seconds, she flashes me a perplexed look. “What is this?”
“It’s a naughty toy.”
“As in a sex toy?”
“Yup,” I respond.
“Have you ever bought anything to enhance your pleasure before, Ali?” Jake asks the question that’s been on my tongue since I left Pleasure Principles.
“Oh, God, no.”
“You’re going to enjoy this a lot.” Jake’s half-closed eyes speak volumes.
“And what am I supposed to do with it? Do I bring it with me if I decide to take the plunge?”
Her innocence is such a turn-on.
“Yes and no.” I know I’m being vague, but I’m enjoying seeing the puzzled look on her face as she tries to figure this out.
“Huh?”
“Ideally, you should use it as soon as possible.” Jake raises his eyebrows and Allison flushes.
“I don’t follow.”
“Ali, it’s a butt plug.” My best friend delivers the news with such calmness. Had it been me, I would’ve surely turned this into a raunchy moment.
“A wh-what?” The color drains from her face like it did earlier today right before Riley delivered her big news. She opens her mouth a few times, but nothing comes out. I’m tempted to speak, but I decide to give her a minute to digest everything.
“Does this go where I think it does?”
Her reaction is priceless.
“As smart as I am, I’m no mind-reader. You’re going to have to speak your mind, girl,” I tease.
“Hunter, give her a break.” Although he tries to adopt a stern tone, Jake is obviously struggling to bite off a smile.
“Let me jump in before my friend scares you. This is simply an option if you decide you want to explore… your darker side.”
“Good Lord, I didn’t even know I had one of those,” she huffs before rolling her eyes.
“We all have one. Yours is simply untouched,” Jake adds.
“Will this… you know… hurt?”
“You mean the butt plug?” Jake asks.
Smooth.
“Yeah.”
“No. It shouldn’t hurt one bit. Hunter bought you a smaller size. So it should be very comfortable. We assume this is your first time…” Jake lets his sentence hang and we both lean in, awaiting her answer.
“Oh, definitely. I’ve never had this kind of conversation with any man before and I certainly didn’t know you could insert objects up there,” she says, wiggling her nose and pointing to her bum.
That’s not quite what Jake wanted to know, but I guess there’s no point in freaking her out too much.
It takes all my will not to laugh and when I look at Jake, he’s also struggling to keep a straight face.
“Gosh, this is so much,” she says, placing the toy back into the bag.
I really hope she agrees.
“I like being with you, Allison,” I say to make sure she understands how important this is to me.
“I do as well, Hunter.”
Jake gets up from where he’s sitting and drops a soft kiss against Allison’s cheek. “And I could gorge on your celestial body every day and never get enough.”
“Jake…”
“Seriously, Ali. I haven’t enjoyed being with a woman like I have with you in a very long time.”
“I love being with you as well.”
“You see, you like both of us and neither of us can get enough of you. That’s why we’re hoping you’ll take us up on our proposition.”
“I have a lot to think about, I guess.”
“Take your time. We’re meeting tomorrow night at my house,” Jake says, caressing her long silky mane.
“I have a suggestion in terms of letting us know which way you decide.”
“Oh, there are options?”
“Of course, baby, this isn’t black and white, t
here are a few wicked shades in between,” I mock. “You have full say in this. One, you may want to be exclusively mine. Two, you might want Jake to keep taking you in the barn while I slave like a dog manning the ranch.” I grin. “Three, you might be willing to take both of us at the same time.”
“Whatever you decide, we’ll respect your choice, Ali.”
“Jake’s right. I have a clever idea that will make it easier for you to let us know which option you’re most comfortable with. Do you want me to share it?”
“I’m all ears.”
CHAPTER FIVE
ALLISON
This must have been the craziest day since I arrived on the ranch. Scratch that, this was the craziest day of my life.
When I received Riley’s text message calling us all in for an urgent meeting, my heart sank. I thought for sure Isadora put two and two together and I was going to get fired. Imagine my surprise when I find out Riley got presented with an amazing opportunity. As if that wasn’t excitement enough, the chat I had with Hunter and Jake at the end of the day left me dumbfounded. After a frantic afternoon with Riley, who was desperately trying to give me a list of to do’s, I received a text message from Jake the second my boss got in her vehicle to head to Denver.
Although Jake said he had discussed things with his best friend, I expected the two of them wanted to talk to me about what Jake had witnessed when he caught me inside the cabin getting my brains fucked out by his best friend, but I was dead wrong. Of all the things they might have suggested, I surely didn’t see that one coming.
I mean I’ve had dreams about both men pleasuring me, but it’s very different when you have the opportunity to it live out. Let’s be honest, that’s a whole other ball game—one I never thought would present itself to me.
I’ve been replaying the conversation in my head as I leave their office and race to my house to call my best friend. My heart is still beating so fast from all the emotions rushing through me as I fumble with my phone. After a few frustrating minutes, I finally compose myself enough to dial Gwyn’s number. Lucky for me, she picks up.
“Hey, Ali, I was thinking of you and I was going to call you after work.”
“Oh, is this a bad time?”
Wicked Pleasure Page 4
