According to his agent, Mr Monroe had been suffering from depression for the past two years - ever since work opportunities dried up after he was branded a hostile witness by the House Committee on UnAmerican Activities.
I put down the paper, unable to finish the story. I glanced out the window of the taxi. New York was as frantic and self-obsessed as ever. Everyone rushing somewhere. Everyone so preoccupied, so busy that they probably weren’t even aware of the deeds being perpetrated in their name - the careers crushed, the trusts betrayed, the lives destroyed. That was the thing about the blacklist - unless it touched you personally, you could carry on as if nothing dark was happening around you. I couldn’t fathom how we had allowed ourselves to be cowed by such patriotic demagogues. All I knew was: I had to leave. To put an ocean between myself and my country. Until the madness ended.
Joel Eberts greeted me with a paternal hug and a considerable amount of news. He’d booked me passage on the SS Corinthia, sailing that night, docking seven days later in Le Havre. He’d secured me a single inside cabin: nothing fancy, but at least I’d have the place to myself. He had all the forms ready for my passport.
‘It’s the same deal as your brother - you run up to the passport office at Rockefeller Center, you hand in all the forms and a check for twelve dollars, you show them your transatlantic boat ticket, and they should have a passport for you by five this evening. But you better hurry. The deadline for one-day processing is ten thirty. That now gives you a half-hour to get there, tops.’
Forms in hand, I grabbed a cab. It raced uptown. I made the passport office at ten twenty-five. The clerk vetted all the forms, and told me to be back at the office by close of business today. As I came out of the office, I noticed that I was opposite the Saturday Night/Sunday Morning building. I didn’t give it a second glance. I just hailed a cab and headed downtown again.
Joel Eberts had offered to bring me to lunch at a little Italian place near his office. We sat down. We ordered. The boss - a friend of Joel’s - insisted on bringing us each a glass of Spumante. We toasted my journey to foreign parts.
‘Have you thought about what you are going to do over there?’
‘No. I don’t even know where I’ll end up … though, initially, I’ll probably head to Paris.’
‘You will write me as soon as you’ve gotten settled somewhere?’
‘I’ll wire you. Because I’ll also need to set up bank transfer facilities.’
‘No problem. I’ll handle all that.’
‘And you will give me a bill for all that you’ve been doing on my behalf?’
‘Call it a friendly favor.’
‘I would really rather pay you properly, Joel.’
‘That’s one of the many things I like about you, Sara - you’re completely ethical.’
‘Look where it’s gotten me.’
He paused for a moment, abstractedly rubbing the rim of his glass with his stubby index finger. ‘Do you mind if I ask you something?’
‘Yes - I still think about him a lot.’
He smiled. ‘Are my thoughts that transparent?’ he asked.
‘No - I am.’
‘As I told you on the phone, there must be fifteen, twenty letters from him, stacked up in my office. He also called me around four times. Begging me to tell him where you were.’
‘What did you say?’
‘What you told me to say: that you had left New York and were living in an undisclosed location. Then he asked if I was forwarding on his letters. I said that you instructed me to hold all personal mail until you returned.’
‘Did he leave you alone after that?’
Another pause. ‘Do you really want to know this?’ I nodded. ‘He came to see me personally. Around six weeks ago. He sat in the chair opposite my desk, and …’
‘Yes?’
‘He started to cry.’
‘I don’t want to hear this.’
‘Fine,’ he said, reaching for the menu. ‘Shall we order?’
‘What did he say?’
‘You said you don’t want to hear this …’
‘You’re right,’ I said, reaching for the menu. ‘I don’t. Tell me what he said.’
Joel put down the menu. ‘He told me you were the best thing that ever happened to him; the center of his life. And he tried to explain …’
‘How he killed my brother?’
‘You know that’s not true.’
‘All right, all right - he didn’t physically end his life. But he certainly got the ball rolling in that direction. He pointed the finger. He handed Eric to the Feds on a plate. How can I forgive that? How?’
Joel drummed his fingers on the table. ‘Forgiveness is the hardest thing in life … and the most necessary. But it’s still the hardest.’
‘That’s easy for you to say.’
‘You’re right. It is. Eric wasn’t my brother.’
‘Exactly,’ I said, reaching for the menu. ‘And yes, I will have the veal piccata.’
‘Good choice,’ Joel said, motioning towards the waiter. We ordered. Then Joel reached into his pocket. He pulled out an envelope, and handed it to me. I saw that it was postmarked Brunswick, Me.
‘Here’s the letter you sent me,’ he said.
‘Oh,’ I said, suddenly uneasy. ‘You didn’t read it, did you?’
‘It’s unopened, Sara - at your request. As long as it’s legal, I always follow my clients’ instructions.’
‘Thank you,’ I said, tucking the letter into my bag. He looked at me carefully. I sensed that he knew what was in that letter - and how close I had skirted the precipice.
‘I hope you’ll get some rest during the transatlantic crossing,’ he said. ‘You look tired, Sara.’
‘I am tired. And yes, I do plan to spend most of the next seven days on the SS Corinthia fast asleep. If they allow me on the boat, that is.’
‘Why wouldn’t they?’
‘You can’t board a transatlantic ship without a passport, can you? And if the Department of State stopped Eric from getting a passport …’
‘Don’t worry - they’ll issue you a passport.’
Joel was right. At five that afternoon, the clerk at the Rockefeller Center passport office handed me a spanking new green travel document, valid for five years. My lawyer accompanied me to the office, just in case my application had run into difficulties. But no questions were asked, no objections raised. The clerk even wished me ‘Bon Voyage.’
We managed to find a taxi amidst the rush-hour madness on Fifth Avenue. I had just under forty-five minutes to make it to Pier 76, where the SS Corinthia was docked and setting sail that night at seven thirty. I stared out of the cab window as night fell on Manhattan. I suddenly wanted to jump out, run to the nearest phone booth, and call Jack. But what would I have said?
‘Do you believe things happen for a reason?’ I heard myself saying.
Joel looked at me with care. ‘You’re talking to the original Jewish agnostic, Sara. I don’t believe in some Almighty plan, or even that dumb thing called “destiny”. I believe you should try to live your life ethically, and otherwise hope for the best. What else can we do?’
‘I wish I knew, Joel. I wish …’
‘What?’
Silence.
‘If only Eric had gotten his passport …’
‘Sara …’
‘Or if he’d gone to Mexico the next day … If he hadn’t looked back in that taxi on the way to the airport, and seen the midtown skyline … If only …’
‘Don’t play the if only game, Sara. You can never win it.’
We inched our way west on 50th Street. We reached Twelfth Avenue. We turned south towards 48th Street. We pulled into the gates of Pier 76. We got out of the cab. The driver handed my suitcase and typewriter to a porter. He lurked nearby. I suddenly found myself clutching on to Joel’s coat sleeves.
‘What am I doing here?’ I asked.
‘Getting on that boat.’
‘I’m scared.’
‘You’re leaving the country for the first time. It’s only natural to be anxious.’
‘I’m making the wrong call.’
‘You can always turn around and come back. It’s not a life sentence, you know.’
‘Tell me I’m crazy.’
He kissed me gently on the head - like a father giving his daughter his blessing.
‘Bon voyage, Sara. Wire me when you find your footing.’
The porter cleared his throat, hinting that it was time to get aboard. I hugged Joel. Gently, he detached my hands from his sleeves.
‘What will I do over there?’ I said.
‘At the very worst, you’ll survive. Which is what we all do.’
I turned and followed the porter up the gangplank. Just before we reached the main deck, I spun around. The taxi carrying Joel Eberts was pulling out of the gate. I kept my eyes at street level. To look up would have meant paying a final mournful tribute to the Manhattan skyline. I didn’t want a long goodbye. I just wanted to leave town as quietly as possible.
Thirteen
SEVEN DAYS AFTER slinking out of New York Harbor, the SS Corinthia docked in Le Havre. I stepped on to French soil, my equilibrium still wobbly after all that time at sea. I immediately took a taxi to the railway station, and caught the express to Paris.
A week later, I checked out of my hotel on the rue de Sevres and moved into a small atelier on rue Cassette in the Sixth. I lived there for the next four years. Initially I took French lessons and squandered the days in cinemas and brasseries. Then I found a job in a small Franco-American advertising agency on the Champs-Elysees. Through colleagues at work, I was parachuted into the center of Paris’s burgeoning American community - for this was the time when the weakness of the franc, the luxury of the GI bill, and the ongoing witch hunt back home meant that the French capital was heaving with expats. Initially, I resisted mingling with my compatriots. Inevitably, though, I found myself getting more and more tangled in the American community. Especially after I met Mort Goodman - the executive editor of the Paris Herald-Tribune - at a party.
‘I’m sure I know your name from somewhere,’ he said after we were introduced.
‘Did you ever work in New York?’ I asked.
‘Sure,’ he said. ‘I was with Collier’s for three years before getting the job over here.’
‘Well, I used to write a bit for Saturday/Sunday.’
‘Oh hell, you’re that Sara Smythe,’ he said, then insisted on taking me out to lunch the next day. By the end of that lunch, he offered me the chance to contribute the occasional feature to the paper. I kept on churning out copy for the advertising agency, but started having my by-line appear every few weeks in the Herald-Tribune. Three months after I started getting published in that paper, Mort Goodman took me out for another lunch and asked if I’d like to try my hand at a column.
‘Traditionally, we’ve always had a resident American-in-Paris write a weekly piece on life in the capital, local color, la mode du moment … whatever. Now the guy who’s been doing it for the past two years has just got himself fired for missing four deadlines in a row, due to his little love affair with the bottle. Which means the position is open. Interested?’
Of course, I said yes. My first column appeared on November seventh, 1952 … three days after Eisenhower beat Stevenson for the presidency. That election - and McCarthy’s accelerating hearings in Washington - hardened my conviction that the best place for me at the moment was right here in Paris. And I liked the place. No, I wasn’t one of those dumb romantics who swooned every time I smelled the aroma of a freshly baked baguette in my local boulangerie. Paris to me was a complex, contradictory entity - simultaneously rude and gracious, erudite and banal. Like anyone interesting, it was deeply contradictory. Its epic grandeur - its sense of self-importance - meant that Paris saw itself as a unique entity within which you, the resident, were privileged to dwell. In this sense, it reminded me of New York, as it was totally indifferent to its citizenry. The Americans I met who hated Paris - and railed against its arrogance - were usually people from smaller, more intimate cities like Boston or San Francisco, where the local beau monde stroked each other’s ego, and anyone in a position of power or authority felt as if they counted. Parisian arrogance meant that nobody was important, nobody counted. It’s what I loved most about the city. As an expat, you didn’t try to be ambitious in Paris. You tried to live well. You always felt as if you were an outsider … but, after everything that had happened in New York, I embraced that etranger role with relief.
And Paris, in turn, embraced me. The column gave me a profile there. But so too, I discovered, did the circumstances surrounding my expatriatism. I never mentioned anything about my brother. Much to my surprise, however, many members of the American community knew about Eric’s death, just as they had also heard how I’d been dropped from Saturday/Sunday. I avoided talking about such matters - because I didn’t like the idea of using the blacklist as a form of social currency … and also because, according to Smythe family values, there was something deeply gauche about seeking sympathy for any personal misfortune. But I still found myself being made a member of an eclectic, raffish community. Having lived a rather singular life in New York (and having never been the most gregarious of people), it was liberating to find myself now plunged into something of a social whirl. I was out on the town at least five nights a week. I drank with the likes of Irwin Shaw and James Baldwin and Richard Wright and many of the other American writers who were living in Paris. I heard Boris Vian sing songs in some St Germain cave, and actually attended a reading given by Camus at a St Germain bookshop. I became a habitue of late-night jazz haunts. I indulged in long lunches with friends at Le Balzar (my favorite brasserie). I developed a taste for Ricard and casual affairs. Paris treated me well.
I was kept in regular contact with things New York, courtesy of Joel Eberts. We wrote each other once a week - generally to discuss financial matters (when it became clear that I was going to be staying in Paris for a while, he found someone to sublet my apartment), and also for Joel to forward any mail that came my way.
In June of 1953, his weekly update ended with the following paragraph:
There is only one personal letter in the batch of mail I’m enclosing this week. I know who it’s from - because it was hand-delivered to me by its author: Meg Malone. She waltzed in here a few days ago, unannounced, insisting I tell her where she could find you. All I said was that you had left the country. Then she handed me the enclosed envelope, and insisted that I forward it to you. I told her what I told her brother: that you had specifically requested that any mail from Jack be held by me. ‘I’m not Jack,’ she countered - and lawyer that I am, I had to concede she had an argument there. She said nothing else - except that, if I didn’t forward the letter, I’d be her sworn enemy for life. The fact that she said this with a smile made me like her … and also made me honor her request. So here’s the letter. Read it if you wish. Throw it away if you don’t want to. The choice is your own.
Timing is everything in life. This letter arrived at the wrong moment. It was the night after the Rosenbergs had been executed at Sing-Sing for allegedly selling atomic bomb secrets to the Soviets. Like just about every American I knew in Paris (even those who usually voted Republican), I was horrified by this despotic act - and one which, yet again, made me despise the forces which had destroyed my brother. For the first time in my life, I had actually done something vaguely political - attending a candlelight vigil in front of our Embassy (along with around three thousand Parisians, led by notables like Sartre and de Beauvoir), signing a petition condemning this act of state murder, and feeling completely ineffectual and furious when the word came through (around two that morning, Paris time) that the executions had gone ahead. The next day, Meg Malone’s letter arrived courtesy of Joel. My first thought was: tear it up … I don’t need to hear any apologias for Jack Malone. Instead, I ripped open the envelope and read:
The Pursuit of Happiness (2001) Page 66
