by Lexie Ray
“I like a fighter,” Andrew said, breaking this kiss, out of breath. His smile scared me.
“I’m not about to fight about something we both want,” I said. The trick was to continue to catch him off-guard, continue to do things he couldn’t possibly expect.
I kept myself under so many layers that it was easy to do. He hadn’t seen Pumpkin, The Sex Kitten. Not many people had.
I stripped off my teddy and threw it to the ground, lifting my chin and watching him stare at me. This was the first time he was seeing me naked, I reminded myself. Many men and the majority of my customers had been flummoxed the first time.
Andrew seemed to take it all in stride.
“You know just what I want,” he said, grinning as he took me roughly in his arms. “It’s been nearly two weeks since I threatened to bend you over that kitchen table. Is it time I made good on that threat?”
“Past time,” I said, kissing him. Despite the danger I felt at the situation, the thin line I knew I was walking, and the fact that I was still having trouble figuring Andrew out, I was horny. I couldn’t explain the reaction my pussy was having to him. I was incredibly wet as he pawed at my breasts, tweaking my dark nipples. We kissed all the way across the kitchen, Andrew kicking off his pants and shedding his T-shirt as we made our way to the table.
When he pushed me forward over it, I gasped sharply. The coldness of the metal made me shiver on contact, made my nipples shrivel to raisins. I felt terribly vulnerable with my ass up in the air, but Andrew laughed lowly.
“You don’t know how good this looks from back here,” he said. “I’m sure you’ve heard it before, but you have an unbelievable ass.”
“I like to hear it,” I said, reminding him of our first heavy flirting in this very kitchen.
“I know you do,” he said. He parted my cheeks. “How about I take you from back here?”
He positioned his cock against my tight, puckered muscle, and I fought the urge to try to claw at the table, to try to escape. He wouldn’t be able to resist if I did, and anal sex without lube was not the way I wanted it.
“No,” I said, turning my head to rest my cheek against the cool table. “I need you in my cunt. I fucking have to have you in there.”
I kept my face carefully blank as I heard Andrew’s breath catch in his throat. There weren’t many men who could resist begging—or dirty talk. I decided to take it another step.
“Cream keeps telling me about how good your cock feels inside of her,” I moaned. “I’ve been jealous—especially since that morning I saw you together.”
“I’ve been meaning to ask you about that,” Andrew said, taking his cock away from my anus—I relaxed just a little in relief—and pressing it against my pussy. “Would you like it like that, Pumpkin? Hard? You like to be spanked?”
“Yes,” I lied. “Seeing you with Cream was so hot. I—I have to tell you something.”
“You can tell me anything, sweet girl,” he crooned, teasing me with just the tip of his dick.
The table cooled my blush and helped encourage me. It was easy to lie and easier still to be caught in one. The truth was powerful medicine. I was looking to really hook Andrew.
“I’ve masturbated, thinking of you and her together,” I said, squeezing my eyes shut, not one ounce of shame faked. “I’m so embarrassed to admit it. But nothing makes me wetter.”
Always keep him on his toes. Always keep him guessing. That was swiftly becoming my mantra until I got him all the way figured out.
Andrew sucked in air and plunged into me. His cock stretched me to my limits and beyond. It hurt, even as wet as I was, but I didn’t want him to know. I pushed up onto my toes, trying to get a better angle as he thrust and thrust.
“You dirty little girl,” Andrew panted, pounding me. “You naughty thing.”
“I am,” I gasped, pushing my legs a little farther apart, still struggling to adapt to Andrew’s cock. “I am naughty.”
“I think you need a spanking,” he said, his voice quavering a little bit.
I cried out as his cock struck my G-spot. There. I had finally found the position I needed. He took my shout as acquiescence, however, and his palm cracked against my butt. The blow came at the exact same time as a push against the G-spot, and I cried out. It hurt—getting spanked always did. That wasn’t the surprise. The surprise was that within that stinging slap, the pain, and the small degree of shame, a bundle of pleasure so potent made me come undone.
“More,” I gasped out. “More.”
He spanked me again and I cried out hotly, thinking about him and Cream fucking on the bed, the time I’d seen them. I’d pitied her when he started spanking her, thinking that it was all pain and degradation. How wrong I’d been. All these years I’d made sure to protect myself from rough sex and here I was, discovering just how much I enjoyed it. It was strange the way the world worked.
I moaned as I felt the irresistible crest of orgasm, peaking and coming crashing down on the other side. I think I blacked out briefly—the next thing I felt was the warm splatter of Andrew’s cum over my ass. He gasped as he came, and it was all I could do not to slide off the table and collapse on the floor.
After a few moments, he pulled me up and off the table and turned me around to face him, his hands grasping my upper arms.
“I have to confess, Pumpkin, that that was not the way I saw our first time together going,” he said, his chest heaving.
“You and me both,” I said.
“I look forward to getting to know you better,” he said, grinning. “And for continued surprises.”
I got on my toes to kiss him chastely on the cheek—if chaste was something that could even be considered anymore—and passed by him to pad down the hall.
I slipped back into my bedroom and crawled in beside Cream, too tired to even think about taking a shower.
“What did I tell you about that cock?” she said sleepily.
“Sorry for waking you up,” I said, freezing.
“It’s okay,” she murmured, rolling over. “Glad it finally happened for you.”
Was I glad it had finally happened? I knew that I didn’t know the true Andrew, yet, just as he didn’t know me. So I still didn’t know what to expect from him, even if we had both had our first tastes of each other.
I had no idea just how interesting life was about to get.
Chapter Eight
I woke up suddenly and violently, the bed shaking beneath me. Opening my eyes, I rolled onto my side and recoiled. Cream was staring at me fear in her eyes as Andrew plunged into her, fucking her right next to me.
He was looking at me, too, glee evident on his face.
“Is this what they call a rude awakening?” he asked, sweat beading on his forehead as he grunted with the efforts of his thrusting. Cream pressed her lips together and squeezed her eyes shut before she gave a loud, long groan. She’d told me before that she always came during sex, no matter what. What if she didn’t want to, though? What then?
Is that what I’d just witnessed?
What was going on?
Andrew’s eyes rolled into the back of his head and he moaned. Cream gasped and I could guess what was happening. He was coming right then and there. I was too shocked to do anything but watch.
“Don’t you just love surprises, Pumpkin?” he asked, pulling out of Cream roughly and walking jauntily out of the room and down the hallway. Neither of us moved until we heard the shower turn on.
“Are you okay?” I asked urgently, grabbing her.
She nodded. “What the fuck was that?” she asked. “Did something happen last night?”
“I just sucked him off and then we fucked over the kitchen table,” I said, clinical about it. “There was nothing strange at all.” Besides Andrew’s normal strangeness, that is. I didn’t know how to explain to Cream about how I felt about Andrew. There was some strange war going on right now, and I was having a hard time getting up to speed.
We both got up and o
ut of bed, Cream shaking so badly that I had to support her.
“Let’s get you in a shower and wash this ugliness away,” I said, fiddling with the faucet in the tub.
“It didn’t really hurt that bad,” Cream said, sounding like she was far away. “It was just the shock of it. I was asleep, and then I was being fucked. I came, but—but—that was kind of the worst part.”
Poor Cream. I got us both under the water and soaped her up. She was still shaking badly, so I adjusted the knobs to give us the hottest water our skin could stand.
“What was that bit about surprises?” Cream asked, when she’d calmed down a bit. The steamy air helped her as much as it did me. I was being crisis management Pumpkin—strong for the both of us. “That seemed to be an inside remark between you two.”
“It was something he said last night,” I explained, lowering my voice and ducking under the stream to rinse shampoo out of my hair. “I don’t know if it’s something we should be worried about yet. But he sort of implied that he would get tired of us one day if we didn’t keep surprising him.”
Cream blanched. “I think that is something we should be worrying about,” she said. “What should we do?”
“We need to start weighing our options,” I said. “Keep your eyes and ears open. We’ll figure out something.”
Andrew acted as if nothing strange had happened just now, sipping his espresso benignly at breakfast before heading out the door. It beeped and clicked behind him, and I waited there to hear the elevator sound. When it did, we sprang into action.
I rattled the door immediately, not surprised that it wouldn’t open.
“Try the lock,” Cream suggested. But even when I flipped both deadbolt and doorknob locks in the same direction and pulled at it, the door wouldn’t budge. It became apparent that there was an extremely sophisticated locking mechanism controlled by the security system.
“Do you think we could break down the door?” I asked, staring at it.
Cream leaned against it and knocked. “No,” she said. “It’s steel. We’d break ourselves before ever putting a dent in it.”
Only one way, in or out, I thought, not wanting to say it. Our escape had to be through that door. It was the only way we could get out.
Okay, so for right now we were trapped in here with him. I stepped back from the situation and let scary Pumpkin take a look. It was actually very strange that I could switch back and forth among my Pumpkins at will. That was more frightening than scary Pumpkin.
Scary Pumpkin had some bleak suggestions. Bum rush Andrew as he came home in the evening and opened the door, knocking him out or killing him and then running for the elevator. Jump out the window, to our death. Arm ourselves with things we could find around his home. Do nothing and accept whatever he had in store for us.
I didn’t like any of scary Pumpkin’s ideas. We cleaned as usual, but while I was taking care of the kitchen, I slipped a knife out of one of the drawers and put it in my pillowcase. I wanted the protection. It had been a knife that had stopped Jimmy from trying to strangle me to death. Maybe the knife would help.
By the time Andrew was supposed to get back from work, both Cream and I were jumpy.
“Did this morning actually happen?” she asked.
“We both saw it—and you felt it,” I reminded her.
“It seems like a strange dream,” she said, shaking her head. “Should we maybe just pretend it never happened?”
“We have to remember what he’s capable of,” I said.
When he got home and opened the door, we were both working on stir fry for dinner.
“Smells great,” he said as he walked back to his bedroom.
“It’ll be ready in about ten minutes,” Cream called.
I glanced at the door. Maybe now was the time to escape. Maybe we had to seize it now.
I tapped Cream on the shoulder and pointed at the door. She shook her head frantically, her eyes wide.
Would I leave her behind? Would I have to? I darted across the floor, my bare feet silent against the black marble. I pushed against the door, but it wouldn’t budge. Did the security code activate automatically when he came in, too?
I sagged with disappointment, then I was grabbed by my shoulders and whirled around.
“What are you doing?” Andrew asked, his voice pleasant despite the fury with which he grabbed me.
“I—I thought you left the door ajar,” I said. “I think it was just a trick of the light. It’s closed, obviously.”
“I always close the door,” Andrew said. “Always.”
“It was silly of me,” I said, smiling. “I don’t know what I was thinking.”
“Me neither,” Andrew said, pressing something cold and sharp underneath my throat. “I can’t seem to think of what to make of this, either. I found a knife in your pillowcase.”
I tried to stay calm, but it was hard with a sharp edge biting into my skin. I felt warm moisture running down my neck, and realized he’d cut me.
“What was that doing in there?” I wondered, trying to smile, trying not to panic.
“You want to fuck around with me?” Andrew growled, pushing his face close to mine. His expression was terrifying—his brows drawn together, his black eyes lifeless. “We can fuck around, Pumpkin. It’s whatever you want to do.”
“I don’t want to do that,” I said quickly. “The knife was a mistake. I must have made the bed while I was doing the dishes.”
The knife bit deeper and I squeezed my eyes shut while biting back a whimper. What could I say to get him to stop? Nothing seemed to be working.
“Please stop,” Cream begged from behind him. “It was a mistake, like Pumpkin said.”
Andrew jerked the knife away from my neck and pointed it at Cream.
“I’m just joking,” he said, letting the knife fall to the marble floor with a clatter. He started laughing. “It’s just a joke, see?”
My hand flew up to my neck and came away red. I was fucking bleeding. Some joke.
“You got us,” Cream said, her eyes darting back and forth between Andrew and me. “We thought you were super angry. You’re a good actor.”
“That’s what I have to do in my job, you know,” Andrew said. “Never let them see you sweat.”
“Dinner’s ready,” Cream said, smiling even as she trembled.
“I’m going to go wash my hands,” I said softly, edging away from the door.
Andrew whirled around, startling me enough that I pressed back up against the wall.
“Geez, Pumpkin,” he said, laughing. “You’re so jumpy. I don’t think you can take a joke.”
“I can take a joke,” I said. The blood was still flowing from my neck, staining my shirt. I pressed my hand up against it again. “I like funny things.” This was not funny.
“Let’s eat, then,” Andrew said, walking toward the kitchen.
“I’ll be right there,” I said, moving toward the bathroom.
“You’ll sit down at the goddamn table immediately, Pumpkin,” Andrew said.
Cream looked paler than usual as we eyed each other. What was this? What was going on?
I gave up on trying to staunch my neck wound or clean up the blood and went to the kitchen. Cream and I served Andrew, me making no effort to keep my blood away from his plate. If he didn’t want me to clean up, he could experience the consequences of his little “joke.”
We ate in relative silence, Andrew talking a little bit about his day at work. I tuned him out. If he wasn’t going to tell us why he was acting so strangely, I simply wasn’t interested.
“I think I’d like to try something new tonight,” Andrew said. “I got the idea this morning.”
“Okay,” Cream said, managing to sound bright. “What do you have in mind?”
“I want to watch you two have sex.”
I slowly lifted my eyes to meet Cream’s, who was standing very still, in the middle of taking her plate to the sink.
“Are—are you sure?”
she asked. “Don’t you want us to both take care of you at the same time instead?”
“Some other time,” Andrew said, waving his hand dismissively. “And I want a good show tonight, ladies. Real orgasms. I’ll know if you’re faking.”
How could he? I had to wonder. But if he had become so violent just for me rattling the door, I didn’t want to imagine what he’d do if he thought we were lying to him.
“We’re going to go get our teddies on for you, Andrew,” Cream said flirtatiously after we’d carted all the dishes to the sink.
“No, you’re not,” he said. “You’re going to go to my room and fuck each other. Now.”
I didn’t understand why he was pressing us, but I thought he might want to keep from giving us a chance to talk to each other, to formulate a plan. He wanted genuine orgasms. Fine. We’d give him genuine orgasms.
Andrew followed us down the hall and I laced my fingers through Cream’s, squeezing her hand to let her know that it was going to be all right. There might have been customers that we didn’t want to sleep with at Mama’s nightclub, but there was never a nonconsensual coupling. This was far too close to it. Neither of us wanted to put on a show for Andrew, but we were going to. He’d given us no choice. I was too afraid to oppose him.
Both of us were shaking as we slowly undressed each other, Andrew watching from a chair across the room.
“Take your time, ladies,” he said, unzipping his pants and pulling out his cock. “We have all night.”
We moved together fluidly, neither of us speaking. We kissed each other, but we were somewhere far away. I palmed Cream’s breast, but I was in East Harlem, tickling one of the babies and laughing at its chortle. I ate her out, but it wasn’t me. It was some other Pumpkin, the one who apparently came out when the real me had to go away. She protected me from the situation, doing all the dirty work.
It was that Pumpkin who pushed her fingers inside of Cream’s hairless pussy, finding the magical spot inside of her that made her feel so good. It was that Pumpkin who dragged her tongue over Cream’s hard, pink nipples, making it as good for her as possible. And it was that Pumpkin who swallowed Cream’s completion, kissing her lips as she cried out helplessly, unable to deny herself an orgasm.
