“Try, at least, because if you can’t, I doubt your father would approve of using my methods on her, so we might never find out.”
Sarah sighed as they turned the corner and could see the Devrieses’ house down the block. “I just remembered that my father called you in on this case because he thought he might not want to see the killer punished at all. I wonder if he still feels that way.”
“We talked about that on Saturday night, and he’s changed his mind.”
Sarah blinked. “Why?”
“Because he wants to see Roderick’s killer punished.”
“He does? Good heavens!”
“Why are you so surprised?”
Sarah had to think about this for a moment. “Because…I’m afraid I would have thought my father would consider Roderick’s death of little consequence, certainly as compared to the death of one of his friends, and he wasn’t even sure he wanted to see Devries’s killer punished.”
“I would’ve thought that, too. In fact, I think he was a little hurt when I said so.”
“Really?” Sarah could hardly believe they were talking about her father. “He’s changed.”
“Maybe.”
“You don’t think so?”
They’d almost reached the Devrieses’ front steps, and they slowed their pace.
Malloy looked down at her. “I don’t think a man can change who he really is.”
“But he’s behaving so differently than…than I’ve ever known him to. That’s what he and my sister used to argue about. He didn’t think people like Roderick were important.”
“Maybe he’s just changing his idea of what’s important.”
“I’d like to think so, but can he really do it? What if it turns out Garnet stabbed Devries while she was trying to protect her honor? Could you bring charges against her?”
“Not for killing Devries, but if she killed Roderick to cover it up, then, yes, I could.”
“But would my father?”
“Let’s hope we don’t have to find out.”
Sarah sighed again. They’d stopped at the foot of the Devrieses’ front steps. “What are you going to do now?”
“I’m going to see the medical examiner and find out what killed Roderick. I’d like to question Paul Devries, but I guess I’ve got to wait until tomorrow to do it.”
“Oh, yes. You wouldn’t dare question him about killing his father on the very day of the funeral.” She looked up at the Devrieses’ front door with its black wreath. “But this is the perfect time to question Garnet about her demons.”
The maid who answered the door stared at Sarah in alarm. “Are you coming from the funeral already?”
“Oh, no,” Sarah said, feeling guilty for causing her a fright. “They’re just on their way to the cemetery. I came to see Mrs. Paul Devries. I heard she wasn’t feeling well, and I wanted to see if there was something I could do for her. I’m Mrs. Brandt. I was here to see her the other day, you’ll remember.”
The girl sighed with obvious relief and admitted Sarah. “I’ll tell her you’re here.”
“Is she very ill?” Sarah asked, her earlier concerns rushing back.
“Oh, no,” the girl started to say, then caught herself. “I mean, I’m sure I don’t know.”
Sarah felt her own surge of relief. “Is she in bed?”
“Oh, no, ma’am. She’s up and dressed for the wake. She just didn’t feel like she could make the trip to the church and out to the burial.”
“If you’ll take me to her, I’ll see what I can do for her.”
The girl would know she should announce Sarah and see if her visit was welcomed before taking her upstairs, but Sarah knew how harried she and the other servants would be preparing for the funeral dinner. She might be able to take advantage of this.
“There’s no need to announce me. I’m sure Mrs. Paul will be happy to see me.” And if she wasn’t, the poor girl would probably never know it. Sarah smiled as reassuringly as she knew how, and finally the maid relented.
“Follow me, please.”
She took Sarah up to the third floor, to Garnet’s bedroom. At her knock, Garnet bid her enter, and she said, “Mrs. Brandt is here to see you.”
Sarah didn’t wait to hear what Garnet might have replied. She slipped in behind the maid and said, “When I heard you were ill, I came at once.”
Sarah wasn’t sure who was more startled, Garnet at Sarah bursting in on her or Sarah at finding she wasn’t alone.
12
GARNET ROSE TO HER FEET, AND SO DID THE OTHER LADY who had been sitting with her in front of the fire. Both wore the unrelieved black of full mourning. The contrast of the black with Garnet’s pale face was startling. She really did look ill, and Sarah wondered if she dared ask if Garnet had found the remedy she had been seeking. Common wisdom said there were mysterious herbs or potions a woman could take to rid herself of an unwanted pregnancy, but Sarah knew such treatments were either completely ineffectual or potentially lethal to the mother as well as her child. She couldn’t ask until she knew who this other woman was, however.
“I’m sorry. I didn’t know you had a visitor,” Sarah said.
“Would that really have stopped you?” Garnet asked.
“Garnet,” the other woman chided in a tone Sarah recognized instantly as one her mother often used on her. That and her slight resemblance to Garnet told her the woman’s identity.
“You must be Mrs. Richmond,” Sarah said. “I’m very pleased to meet you.”
“And, Mother, this is Mrs. Brandt,” Garnet said, “about whom you have heard me complain. Mary Catherine, could you bring us some tea and cakes? I know you’re being run ragged, but I’m afraid my guests might grow faint if they have to wait until the funeral dinner for something to restore them.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
When the girl was gone, Garnet turned to Sarah. “I envy you. How delightful it must be to simply go wherever you wish and do whatever you wish with no regard for the consequences.”
Mrs. Richmond gasped, but Sarah smiled. “I assure you, it is far from delightful, and I often must deal with consequences. For example, I must now feel terrible for interrupting your visit with your mother.”
“Don’t do that,” Garnet said. “We actually welcome your arrival. I’m afraid we were simply wallowing in our mutual misery when you burst in.”
Garnet sat down, signaling her guests to do the same.
When they were settled, Sarah turned to Mrs. Richmond. She was a handsome woman, and her gown had been made for her by a skilled dressmaker, but not recently. She, too, was pale and looked as if she hadn’t been sleeping well. She also didn’t know quite what to make of Sarah.
“My daughter is exaggerating,” Mrs. Richmond said with a polite smile. “I’ve just been keeping her company while we wait for the rest of the family to return from the funeral.”
“I’m sure she appreciates that.” Sarah turned back to Garnet. “Someone told me at the church that you were too ill to come, so I thought I should make sure you were all right. I was afraid you might have taken something that didn’t agree with you.”
“Like poor Roderick?”
“Good heavens, Garnet, what a thing to say!” her mother cried.
“Mrs. Brandt isn’t easily shocked. Are you, Mrs. Brandt?”
“Not at all. And I was sincerely hoping you hadn’t suffered the same fate.”
“Your concern is gratifying, but I assure you, I am perfectly safe.”
“If you’re feeling unwell because of the child, I can suggest some things to do that will make you more comfortable.”
“My mother is ahead of you there. The two of you share a touching concern for my well-being. Did I tell you Mrs. Brandt is a midwife, Mother? She is a widow who earns her own bread.”
“Isn’t that really why you envy me?” Sarah asked.
Garnet widened her eyes. “Am I so transparent?”
“Not at all. Any woman could understand your interest
.”
“Any woman who had been left penniless and helpless, you mean.”
“You aren’t penniless,” Mrs. Richmond said almost desperately.
“No, I’m not,” Garnet agreed. “At least so long as I stay here, in this house, at the mercy of everyone in it.”
Mrs. Richmond reached out and laid a hand on her daughter’s arm. “But he’s gone now, my darling. He can’t hurt you anymore.”
“Can’t he? And what about you? He left you penniless and helpless, too.”
From what Sarah knew about Mrs. Richmond, this was certainly true, but to her surprise, Mrs. Richmond stiffened and snatched away her comforting hand. “Penniless, perhaps, but not completely helpless.” For a moment, Sarah and Garnet stared at her in surprise, and seeing their reaction, Mrs. Richmond instantly softened her expression with a smile. “In many ways, we are the stronger sex, are we not, Mrs. Brandt?”
“Anyone who has seen a woman in childbirth would agree,” Sarah said.
“A woman will do what she must to protect those she loves,” Mrs. Richmond said. “My daughter is still learning this lesson.”
Mrs. Richmond and Garnet exchanged a look. Sarah would have given much to know its true meaning, but Garnet said, “And a bitter lesson it is, too.”
A knock at the door announced the arrival of the maid with their tea. Mrs. Richmond took charge of serving it, and like the proper hostess she had once been, she directed the conversation to trivialities. By asking Sarah about herself and her family with the skill of one who has been taught from birth how to fill the hours with conversation without ever touching on anything of real importance, she managed to pass the time until the maid came to inform them that the rest of the family had returned.
“Mrs. Devries wants you to help her greet the guests,” the girl told Garnet.
Garnet actually winced.
“Mrs. Paul couldn’t possibly stand on her feet for so long,” Sarah said. “Please tell Mrs. Devries that she will be available in the parlor for anyone who wishes to see her.”
“The rear parlor,” Garnet added with a perverse smile. Few of the guests would find her there.
This time the maid winced, probably dreading Mrs. Devries’s reaction to this refusal. When she was gone, Garnet turned to Sarah. “Will you stay with me?”
Malloy had wanted her to report to him what happened at the house, and she would see little if she stayed with Garnet, but she said, “Of course.”
Garnet turned to her mother and took her arm. “We will be as brave as Mrs. Brandt thinks we are.”
An expression that might have been despair flickered across Mrs. Richmond’s face, and she gave her daughter a brief, fierce hug. Then, smoothing out her expression to cool unconcern, she walked out with Garnet into the hallway.
For the next few hours, Garnet held court in the family parlor. As Sarah had predicted, few of the guests found her there. To Sarah’s surprise, one of them was a handsome young man who greeted her warmly.
“Garnet, my darling,” he said, taking her hand in both of his. “How are you bearing up?”
“I’m so much better now that you’re here,” she said.
“Of course you are,” he said, winning from her the first true smile Sarah had seen that day.
From where she sat unobtrusively in the corner, Sarah was busily rethinking her opinion of Garnet, nearly convinced this fellow was her lover, when Garnet said, “Mother, allow me to present Paul’s oldest friend, Hugh Zeller.”
Hugh and Mrs. Richmond made all the correct responses to the introduction, and he accepted Garnet’s invitation to sit with her.
“Paul sends his most affectionate regards,” Zeller said, “and asks you to forgive him for not attending you sooner, but he will find you the moment the witch is done with him.”
“I know he will. She’s keeping him away from me as a punishment for not going to the funeral.”
“Of course she is, and for not standing at her side while people gush about what a wonderful man her husband was. I keep telling Paul to stand up to her, but the habits of a lifetime are difficult to break.”
“We all do what we must to protect those we love,” Garnet said with a meaningful glance at her mother.
“Now tell me, my darling, are you really ill?” he asked, studying her intently. “You are as ravishing as ever, but I’m afraid now it is more in the manner of the tragic heroine wasting away for love.”
“Not for love, surely,” she said.
He grew solemn. “Tell me the truth. Are you really ill?”
“Nothing that time won’t cure.”
She was exactly right, Sarah thought.
“You know we would move heaven and earth for you. All you need do is ask.”
Garnet smiled at him fondly and patted his hand. “I’m sure I won’t require anything so ambitious as all that. Paul might, however, if you don’t get him away from his mother soon.”
“Have you assigned me a quest, fair lady?”
“I most certainly have.”
He took her hand and bowed over it, then rose. “I will bring him back with his shield or on it.”
“What did he mean by that?” Mrs. Richmond asked when he was gone.
“I have no idea. He always says the most outrageous things.”
Sarah’s parents came in then, distracting her from her eavesdropping. She greeted them, then introduced them to Mrs. Richmond. They didn’t bother to express their condolences to Garnet, for which she was undoubtedly grateful. Sarah’s mother, who was also a master of meaningless conversation, managed to get Mrs. Richmond’s history in a few short minutes.
While the two women were chatting, Sarah’s father drew her aside. “I see Garnet is still alive.”
“Don’t tease, Father. If Roderick was killed because he knew who the killer was, other people might be in danger as well.”
“I wasn’t teasing. I’m as relieved as you are. I just can’t believe Paul or Lucretia would commit murder.”
“Maybe they don’t consider it murder if it’s just a servant.”
She saw her barb hit home, but he said, “Many in their place would not, I’m afraid.”
“I’m glad you aren’t one of them.”
Her compliment seemed to please him. “Where is Mr. Malloy?”
“He’s meeting with the medical examiner to make sure Roderick really was poisoned.”
“Then I assume he’ll question Paul.”
“Yes, but not until tomorrow.”
“Will he be able to find out the truth?”
Sarah didn’t know the answer to that question.
FRANK HAD TO WAIT FOR DOC HAYNES, WHO WAS IN THE middle of an autopsy when he arrived. Sitting in Haynes’s cluttered office, Frank spent the time mulling over all that he had learned about Chilton Devries. Usually, when he investigated a murder, all he needed to do was figure out who would profit most from the person’s death. In this case, however, he wasn’t even sure the person who stabbed Devries had intended to kill him. The weapon—which might’ve been a nut pick, of all things—wasn’t particularly large or dangerous enough to give the person wielding it confidence in its ability to do serious damage.
No, the incident that caused Devries’s death had probably been a spontaneous act of anger or frustration meant only to cause him pain or divert him from causing it to someone else. If Felix Decker had left it alone, that person would have gone unpunished but rightly so, in all probability. And Roderick would still be alive. If Sarah felt guilt about that, Frank felt even more. He should have used his considerable skill to force Roderick to tell him everything he knew about Devries’s encounters with his family when he’d first had the chance. Instead he’d chosen to bide his time and win Roderick’s cooperation. That decision had cost Roderick his life.
When Doc Haynes finally returned to his office, he plopped wearily into his chair and peered at Frank with bloodshot eyes. “Killers have no imagination, Malloy.”
“If they did, maybe they
could figure out a better way to deal with their problems.”
“You’re probably right. The whiskey had been laced with arsenic, just like you thought. Rat poison, straight out of the box. It works pretty fast if you take enough of it, and there was plenty in the bottle. I’m surprised he didn’t balk at the taste.”
“He’d only had a glass or so, judging from how much was left.”
“So maybe he did notice the taste, but he’d already drunk enough. Any idea who did the deed?”
“Yes, unfortunately. A bunch of swells.”
Haynes muttered a curse. “Poor fellow. He was the butler or something, wasn’t he?”
“Valet to Chilton Devries.”
“Oh, the one I saw last week.”
“Yeah, and I wanted to ask you something. Do you think a nut pick could’ve made the wound that killed Devries?”
“A nut pick?”
“Yes, that thing you use to pick out the inside of a walnut when you’ve cracked it open. It’s about this long—”
“I know what it is. Would it be sharp enough?”
“It’s got a point, and if somebody stabbed hard enough, I think it would probably break the skin.”
Haynes considered the possibilities. “Could be. It’s the right size and shape. What made you think of that?”
“Devries liked walnuts. He was always walking around, eating them and dropping the shells. And one of the nut picks is missing from a set he had in his bedroom.”
“So you need to find out who has the missing nut pick.”
Frank was very much afraid he already knew.
SARAH’S PARENTS HAD LONG SINCE WITHDRAWN. GARNET and her mother had easily dealt with the trickle of mourners who found them, accepting their condolences with such a blatant lack of appreciation that they soon fled.
At last Paul appeared, followed by Hugh Zeller. He hurried to Garnet’s side. “How are you feeling?”
“I’m fine,” she said with a small smile.
“This must be ghastly for you.”
“No worse than it is for you, and Mother has been keeping me company.”
Murder on Fifth Avenue: A Gaslight Mystery Page 19
