“I’m just wondering why you put up such a stink this morning when the commissioner asked if we could use the mansion here to stage his operation. Of course, that’s when those of us looking for Salma Zunega had no idea where she’d been dumped.”
“One had nothing to do with the other, Chapman. Are you suggesting I intended to keep you away from here because I knew where this—this whore—was disposed of? That’s a shocking suggestion.”
I was pained at his choice of words for the dead woman.
“Maybe you ought to rethink your language, Mr. Mayor,” I said.
Statler put his hands in his pockets and looked at me. “Do you really think that Paul Battaglia wants you to ambush me? I’ve got nothing to say about this matter. I came up here to get answers from you.”
I stood up, practically face-to-face with Vin Statler. “We haven’t got any answers to give you, Mr. Mayor. This wasn’t the direction we were hoping the case would take.”
“How did the girl die?”
“Too early to know.”
“And here? Was she killed on this property?” Statler was agitated, and clearly not used to being the last to know.
“That’s unlikely.”
“Congressman Leighton, what does he have to say about this?” Statler looked from me to Mike to Mercer. “I see, I see. You’re not giving me anything. You’re treating me like I’m irrelevant.”
“We haven’t spoken with Leighton yet. I’ll call his lawyer when we leave here.”
“I’ve got a lawyer, too, Alex. I’ve got the best. You call Justin Feldman from now on if you have any questions for me.”
“Good choice, sir,” I said, venturing a smile at the mayor. “Smart man. I may need to come back and see the grounds again. Check the access to the property from every angle. May I call him for that? Or would you prefer I stay in touch with Detective Kitts?”
“My assistant will make all those arrangements, as you need them. Roland, will you give her Nancy’s number?”
Mike had walked to the window and pulled back the curtain, watching as the CSU men worked at processing the scene before dusk.
“And you, Chapman, you like your assignment? Homicide’s a big deal in the department, isn’t it?”
“I like it fine, sir.”
“Then show me the proper respect, Detective. Do I look like a common criminal to you?” The mayor smoothed his tie and tried to joke with Mike.
“You see that water out there, Your Honor?”
“The East River? Are you talking about the river?”
“I’m talking about what people call a river.”
Vin Statler smirked. “But you’re going to prove to me you’re smarter than I am, Chapman, aren’t you? I guess I was supposed to say it’s an estuary. It’s the place where the river and the ocean mix, is that where you’re going?”
“Sorry, sir. But it’s not an estuary either.”
Statler’s expression changed, and the men standing beside him stiffened. “What are you doing here, Chapman?”
“See, it’s a tidal strait, Your Honor. It’s a water passage between Manhattan and Long Island. It’s not an actual river because rivers flow from freshwater sources like springs and mountain runoffs. This? This connects on both ends to the Atlantic Ocean. So it’s a strait, really, but because of the tides, it seems to flow just like a river.”
“What’s your point?” The three words came out sharply, like bullets at a target.
“Congressmen, governors, prosecutors, mayors, police commissioners. They don’t necessarily look like common criminals, to answer your question. But just like this river, sir, things aren’t always what they appear to be.”
EIGHTEEN
“You went way too far, Mike.”
“He pressed the wrong buttons with me.”
“Your buttons are so loosely attached that anybody pressing them might get tangled in the threads,” I said. “I’m only surprised Battaglia hasn’t beeped me yet to try to rein you in.”
We were just leaving the back steps of Gracie Mansion.
“Relax. Statler will never admit to being humiliated by the likes of us. You want to see how Hal’s doing with Salma’s apartment?”
“Sure.”
“Here, Alex,” Mercer said, reaching into the pocket of his overcoat. “This should get you past the photographers without a problem.”
He handed me a black knit watch cap, and I stood at the curb, twisting my hair into a knot and pulling the hat down to cover half of my face.
“Perfect. You look like an ordinary mook,” Mike said. “Nobody’d ever make you.”
Cops had set up wooden horses to keep the paparazzi back from the entrance of the building. “Why don’t we back-door it?”
No one seemed to notice as we trekked around to the rear. Mike buzzed, and this time, with a uniformed cop at his side and the camera focused on the badge Mike held up next to his face, we were let in immediately.
When we stepped off the elevator on the tenth floor, the apartment door was ajar and Hal waved us in from the foyer. “Hey, guys. Alex. You here to get in my way?”
“Nah. Just trying to make sense of all this,” Mike said. “ESU did a great job getting the body out.”
“So I heard. My second team’s over there.”
“You alone?”
“No. Jack Egan’s beginning to work the back rooms.”
“What’s taking you so long, Hal? You’ve been here half the day.”
“Interruptions like you, pal. Explaining things to all the big-wigs.”
“Like who?”
“Like Scully. Like the mayor’s office. Like Leighton’s old man, who thinks he had a right to come in here ’cause his son paid for the pad. I’m trying to get it done, Mikey. You want to help? Gloves and booties, please.”
“Have you found anything of interest yet?” I asked as Mike passed us each another pair of latex gloves.
“Sarge called from ESU. Took a white wool blanket covered with blood out of the bottom of the well,” Hal said. “Jack found white fibers in one of the trash bins they use to take recyclables down in the service elevator.”
“We saw some of those out in back.”
“That must be how whoever did it got her out of here.”
“But she had these awful gridlike marks on her shoulders,” I said. “What do you think could have caused those? Is there any surface like that in the apartment?”
We were following Hal through the living room toward the kitchen.
“I’m not sure exactly what you mean. Nothing in here that I’ve seen.”
“I can do a sketch of it for you,” I said.
“Coop’s not content unless she’s butting into everybody’s job,” Mike said, throwing up his hands. “The ME will tell you what did that to her skin.”
Two people rarely saw the same things when they looked at a dead body. The medical examiner searched for signs of the fatal injury, cops for any clues that might offer a solution to the killer’s identity, and often I was hoping—quite unrealistically—that the corpse would tell me how its final moments were spent.
“Any word yet on your corkscrew?” Hal asked.
“Human blood. Now they’ll have what they need to compare,” Mike said.
“Isn’t it odd that the place would be in such good order but the killer would leave that behind?” I asked.
“You wanna know what I think?”
“Yes.”
Hal planted himself in the middle of the living room floor. “First of all, Salma wasn’t entertaining a stranger, right?”
“She may have started life here as a hooker,” Mike said, explaining the tattoo to Hal. “Can’t rule that out entirely.”
“This guy knows the building well enough to get himself in, and there’s nothing in the apartment to suggest a struggle.”
“So it was a blitz attack,” Mercer said.
“She’s in her nightie,” Hal went on. “Gets rid of her kid for the evening—no word on
that front?”
“Nothing.”
“Sets out the vino and the glasses, and when she goes into the kitchen, bam! Her buddy gets her into a chokehold and jabs the tip of the screw right into her neck.”
“Good thinking, Hal,” Mike said. “He’s either a surgeon or a damn good wine steward, right?”
“I’d expect blood to be everywhere,” I said, holding my hand to my throat as Hal spoke.
“And it was, Counselor. And it was.”
“No, Hal, there was nothing when we got here last night except the wine opener.”
“Bleach, Alex. He bleached the kitchen floor and sink. Just took a couple of minutes to sponge it down. Might have been more blood on him than on the tile. But we picked up some spatter in there. Probably thought he’d gotten the corkscrew too. Then he sprayed air freshener to mask the smell.”
“The princess wouldn’t know from cleaning the kitchen floor. The only bleach she cares about is the kind that keeps her hair blond.”
“What does that tell you about him?” I asked. “Chance he’s an ex-con?”
We had seen lots of cases recently in which men sent to jail by DNA evidence continued their criminal ways when released, but came to crime scenes armed with condoms when they raped or prepared to destroy evidence as they departed.
“Or he watches too much TV,” Hal said. “Everybody’s an expert on TV, you know? Every lazy slob thinks he could do my job. Find this guy soon and get a warrant for his laundry bag. He’s gonna have blood all over his shirtsleeves, if I’m right about how he was holding her. And blood on his shoes. It had to drip on his shoes.”
“I should be that lucky I find him soon,” Mike said. “Or her.”
“Her?” I asked.
“Why, you think it couldn’t be a broad? You don’t figure Claire Leighton had a grudge to settle? Maybe while Salma was waiting for her date, Claire knocked on the door and the girls had a catfight.”
My stomach churned a bit. I’d never thought about Leighton’s wife as a possible suspect, but there was good reason to consider her.
I was scanning the clean white walls and stainless steel appliances, looking for any signs of blood, but there were none. “Too clean for a catfight.”
“Just like a dame to straighten up the mess.”
“Hey, Hal!” His partner was shouting for him from the other end of the apartment. “Bring your equipment and get your ass down here quick.”
Mike stepped aside so Hal could go first, stopping to pick up his camera from the living room sofa.
“Whatcha got, Jack? You find a skeleton in the closet?” Hal made his way quickly down the hall to the master bedroom.
Jack Egan was standing on a stepladder. At his feet were half a dozen cardboard shoe boxes—all designer labels—with their lids removed, and another two dozen stacked on shelves in the closet.
“Better than that,” Jack said, opening the cover of the box he was holding. “I found a gold mine.”
Like the one in Jack Egan’s hands, the boxes on the floor were filled with money. Mike crouched beside them and scooped out a fistful of bills.
“Hundred-dollar bills—Ben Franklins all,” he said, playing the edges of them as he counted the wads. “Each one of these little wrappers holds ten thousand dollars. I know Coop would just as soon have the shoes, but we’re probably looking at a million or more in cash.”
“What the hell was this broad doing with all that money?” Hal asked. “Where’d it come from, do you think?”
“You’ll be the first to know, Hal. Meanwhile, you better tell your other team to check the bottom of the well for loose change.”
NINETEEN
“You don’t want to be where the money is, Coop,” Mike said. We had taken the elevator down to the rear entrance, making our way out past the lineup of shopping carts left behind the building, no doubt, by lazy deliverymen who’d been relieved of their bags.
“Why not?”
“By the time it’s sorted and accounted for, some muckety-muck will demand that Internal Affairs empties the pockets of all of us who were up there. Big money scares me.”
“Why don’t we go back down to my office? We can spend the evening putting this whole thing together. It’s so much more quiet than the squad.”
“She’s right, Mike,” Mercer said.
“You take her with you. I’ll stop by the morgue and then meet you there.”
The damp cold and darkness didn’t seem to bother the press corps. They were still staked out on East End Avenue, hoping for a sighting of someone related to the scandal of the disgraced congressman or news of the missing woman.
I got in Mercer’s car and as he made a U-turn to get on the Seventy-ninth Street entrance to the drive, I called Nan to tell her everything that had happened. I also asked if she could round up at least one of the other women in our group so that we could reboot our investigation over takeout and triple doses of caffeine.
My next call was to Donovan Baynes. I hesitated before dialing, wondering whether he was passing information to his old friend Ethan Leighton, but his position in charge of the task force left me no choice but to tell him. He was as intrigued by the news of Salma Zunega’s abduction and murder, and the rose tattoo, as we were. Baynes agreed to participate in our evening meeting.
Traffic slowed us as we inched downtown on the FDR Drive. I put the phone in my pocket, my head on the headrest, and closed my eyes.
“Things okay with you, Alex?” Mercer asked.
“Everything’s been good till this series of disasters.”
“Your folks?”
“Happy to spend some downtime with me,” I said, shaking off my exhaustion to talk about something more personal than the investigation. Mercer knew that my parents, who retired to a small island in the Caribbean, had spent the week leading up to Christmas with me in the city, before going out West to visit with my brothers and their kids in Colorado.
“And Luc?”
I had flown to Paris the day after Christmas. Luc Rouget, the divorced restaurateur I’d been dating, lived in a small village in the south of France. But we had planned a romantic interlude in the glamorous city of lights.
“We had a wonderful time together. He’ll be here next month,” I said. He was making progress in his business plans to open here in Manhattan, where decades ago his father had created one of the world’s classic French restaurants, Lutèce. “You and Vickee will have to have dinner with us.”
“Happy to do that. You know how I feel about this.”
Mercer had become so grounded and pleased with his newfound family life that he had taken to urging me to ease up on my professional duties and put my relationship with Luc in full gear.
“It scares me a bit, Mercer. I’ve told you that.”
We were slowed to a standstill in the underpass next to the United Nations. “It wouldn’t mean anything if it didn’t do that.”
“It’s different,” I said, looking at him. “I know these decisions aren’t easy for anyone, but Luc doesn’t live here. Even if he gets the restaurant going, he’s in this country six months a year at best. I’d have to give up all of this—”
“Give up what? Chasing these animals around town? Righting all the wrongs of the world? You’ve proven you can do some of that. Time to turn a page, maybe.”
“I’m afraid I like it too much.” I knew it seemed strange to my friends outside the criminal justice system when we described our jobs in such upbeat terms. But the satisfaction in doing justice—convicting the guilty, exonerating the innocent, and trying to restore some measure of relief to those victimized—was a constant source of pride. “I can’t see myself sitting on a stool behind the cash register in Mougins, asking people if they enjoyed the special of the day.”
Mercer laughed. “The man’s too smart to have you doing that, Alex.”
“That’s why his first wife split.”
“Is that what makes you leery, my friend, or is it the intimacy? The fear that i
f you give in to happiness something will come along to destroy your center again?”
I had been engaged to marry a medical student I’d fallen in love with while I was at law school in Virginia. Together Adam Nyman and I had bought our dream house on Martha’s Vineyard, and I’d allowed myself to plot out all the fantasies of a long life together. On the drive from Charlottesville to Chilmark for the wedding weekend, Adam died when his car plunged from a bridge on the interstate to the riverbed below.
I bit my lip. “Maybe that, Mercer.”
“Why is it you fall in love with guys who are impossible to fit into your life? First Jed, then Jake, now Luc. You’ve got to work at it some yourself, Alex. This guy is mad for you, isn’t he?”
“Who set you up for this chat?” I said, reaching to turn on the car radio. “Nina? Joan?”
My two closest friends had teamed up, from Los Angeles and Washington, D.C., to hector me about my love life and raise the volume of the ticker on my biological clock.
“Vickee’s been talking about you a lot.”
“That’s bad for me. I can tell.”
Vickee Eaton was a second-grade detective herself, with a great desk job in headquarters, and had married Mercer many years earlier. But as the daughter of a cop who’d been killed on the job when she was fifteen, she had broken up their relationship, unable to cope with the dangers that he was constantly exposed to in the field. We had all celebrated with them when they remarried several years ago.
“It’s been good for her, Alex. She wants it for you too.”
“But she didn’t give up the work she loves, and she got you in the deal. How do I make that kind of thing happen?” I said, reflecting for a few seconds before I spoke again. “Want to do a movie tomorrow night? Get our heads out of this mess for a few hours? Let Vickee tell me herself?”
“Wish we could,” Mercer said. “Her cousin’s engagement party is tomorrow. I got the whole mother lode of Eatons to contend with.”
“Who’s minding Logan?”
Mercer’s son was almost three years old. Vickee worked her schedule so that she could be with him every evening and weekend, while her younger sister was the main babysitter at other times.
Hell Gate Page 14
