The Children of Silence

by Linda Stratmann

  ‘At least we now know who the man in the canal was. All credit to you for that one,’ the Inspector added reluctantly. ‘Dr Magrath has come clean and taken the blame on himself.’

  ‘Does Mrs Antrobus know?’

  ‘Oh yes, Mr Rawsthorne went hotfoot to tell her. He’s hoping for new business on behalf of Mr Wylie, suing either Magrath or the Asylum Company or both for all those wasted legal fees.’

  The rest of Frances’ day was taken up with receiving the last of the reports on behalf of Mr Candy, writing to him with the results and acting on a sudden inspiration on how she might alleviate the troubles of that affectionate yet mistrusting couple Mr and Mrs Reville. She also wrote to Harriett Antrobus to advise her of recent developments, although she decided to omit the detail concerning the unusual friendship between her husband and the lady witness at the railway station. Although Lionel Antrobus was not really her client he was paying for Tom’s work to find the woman who pawned the ring, and it seemed only courteous to write to him too.

  That evening she and Sarah attended a meeting of the Bayswater Women’s Suffrage Society and were accorded the plaudits of the members for their work. Whenever Frances appeared at the meetings there was always a small spate of new clients to follow, and on the way home she reflected that there were bound to be some bad husbands and dishonest servants whose careers would soon come to an end.

  Even in Sarah’s company Frances still found the night-time streets unsettling, and although it was a warm evening she was unwilling to walk home. They took a cab, thus avoiding the narrow pathway where the attack had taken place. She usually slept well after such a busy day, but this time it was not to be.

  There was the stench of unwashed clothing, bad teeth and stale tobacco, the bristly scratch of an unkempt moustache. She fought hard against a horrible strength, the hard muscles of a man so much more powerful than she. All her resources could do nothing against him, the weight and force of a brute. His body pressed violently against hers. He was trying to force a chloroformed pad over her face, and she turned her head aside and fought as hard as she could, dreading the shock of a blow with his fist when she would not give in. Then another figure appeared, a dark presence, tall and strong but not threatening, holding her firmly, taking her to safety, and she smelled the rich warm spice of a cigar.

  France awoke, gasping for breath, her whole body shaking convulsively, and found herself enveloped in the warmth of Sarah’s massive hug. Some minutes passed before she could or even wanted to speak. It was still night and her room was unlit and very peaceful.

  ‘Another one of them dreams?’ asked Sarah.

  Frances nodded. She had never told Sarah about them, but somehow was unsurprised that she knew, and she supposed that she must have been crying out. Sarah slept in the adjoining room, and Frances often heard the low rumble of her snores, which was a great comfort. ‘I only wish they would stop.’

  ‘They will,’ promised Sarah. ‘But if you think one might come on, go for a long walk. Walk till you sweat. Sweat hard and then sweat harder.’ She was so assured that Frances did not need to ask if she had ever had such dreams herself. ‘And you want to come to the ladies’ classes,’ she added. ‘I’ve got them exercising with a big stick. You can do a lot with a big stick.’

  Sarah wiped Frances’ brow with a handkerchief and settled her back onto her pillow. ‘I would be nothing without your companionship,’ smiled Frances, and she soon drifted into a dreamless sleep.

  CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE

  At the resumed inquest on Mr Eckley, Ratty appeared in the new suit of clothes, hat and shirt supplied by Cedric, his face scrubbed to a shine. He looked quite the man, albeit a very nervous one.

  ‘Now then, young fellow, if you are to make your way in the world you must have a name,’ advised Cedric. ‘Even if it is Smith or Jones or Wilkins.’

  ‘I dunno,’ said Ratty. He glanced at the door as if tempted to dart through it. ‘Ain’t got no name ’cept what I get called. It’s done all right for me, but the coppers don’ like it.’

  ‘When the coroner asks you for your name,’ suggested Frances, ‘tell him you are called John Smith. I am sure Mr Smith will not mind you borrowing his name for the morning.’

  Ratty nodded. ‘Will you be ’ere?’

  ‘Of course.’

  ‘ ’N you, Mr Garter?’

  Cedric smiled at the curious rendition of his name. ‘Your first public appearance as a boy detective? I wouldn’t miss it for the world!’

  Ratty managed a grin, squared his shoulders and stood up straighter.

  ‘If you are very good then Mr W. Grove might write a story about you, and you will be as celebrated as Miss Doughty.’

  ‘Wot, are you Mr Grove?’ asked Ratty. ‘Tom’s bin showin’ me the books ’n I c’n read a lot of it now, ’n it’s very ixcitin’ wot with all the thieves ’n that.’

  ‘Would that I had the talent to write such immortal works of literature!’ exclaimed Cedric, with elaborate regret. ‘Sadly I must confine my efforts to such tawdry trifles as lectures on art.’

  The crowds were beginning to gather. Dr Goodwin did not put in an appearance, which might have been commented upon by the press had he done so, but Mr Wheelock, Mr Rawsthorne’s unpleasant clerk, was sitting at the back, sucking ink from his fingernails, and Frances surmised that he had been sent to watch the proceedings on the doctor’s behalf.

  Frances looked about her to see if there were any faces in the assembled throng that she did not know, but there were not. Even the pressmen were becoming familiar to her by sight. Mr Gillan was there, as she might have expected, and young Ibbitson, who had been permitted to attend his first inquest, sat enthralled by his surroundings. She wondered if the detective employed by Mr Eckley had been traced. If so, he was not present.

  The first medical man on the scene had been Dr Collin, who had certified death caused by a single stab wound to the abdomen that had severed the aorta. He could not comment on whether the assailant had been experienced with a knife or not. Some abdominal wounds gave more hope of survival, but the fact that this one had been rapidly fatal could have been mere chance. The knife had been driven to the hilt in a slightly upwards direction, probably when the victim and the attacker were at close quarters. A torn piece of paper, the corner of an envelope, had been found clasped firmly between a forefinger and thumb of the victim. He theorised that Mr Eckley, not believing himself to be in any danger, had been handing the envelope to his attacker when he was stabbed.

  The position of the wound suggested that the murderer was neither very much taller nor very much shorter than the victim, who was five feet, nine inches in height. A woman might have done it, but Collin doubted that. The single swift stab showed both courage and resolution; he thought a woman would have been more hesitant, less firm.

  Ratty, who had given his name to the coroner’s officer as Mr Jonsmith, was called to give his testimony, and Dr Thomas, seeing that underneath his smart exterior the young witness was trembling with fright, spoke to him gently and guided him through the events with careful questions.

  ‘Can you tell the court where you were at about eight o’clock on the evening of Wednesday the 22nd of June?’’

  ‘Yes, yer ’ighness, sir, I was near Pembridge Mews up by the deaf school.’ The wry smiles of the scribbling pressmen were tempered by close interest when Ratty explained that he had been doing some secret work for ‘Miss Doughtery, wot is the best ’tective in Lunnon.’

  ‘And what did you see there?’

  ‘Well there was the dead gent, only ’e weren’t dead yet, ’n ’e wen’ inter the mews walkin’ all smart like, not jus’ loafin’ about. So I knows summink is goin’ on, cos yer don’ ’urry inter a mews ter do summink less’n it’s ter be kep’ secret.’

  ‘Did you follow him?’

  ‘Yes, yer ’ighness sir, ’cos I thort well wot’s ’e a doin’ of, so I creeps arter ’im all quiet like, wot I am very good at ’cos I’m a ’tective, ’n prop
er ’tectives are very good at that, sir.’

  ‘Tell me what you saw next.’

  ‘Mr Ecklerley ’e wen’ roun’ the corner, and I stayed back.’

  ‘No one else came into the mews as you stood there?’

  ‘No sir.’

  ‘Were you able to hear any conversation?’

  ‘No sir, nuthin’ I dint even know there was another person there, I thort ’e was waitin’ to meet a doxy.’

  Sniggers in court.

  Dr Thomas ordered silence before continuing the questioning. ‘What happened next?’

  ‘Then there was a gaspin’ noise like what gents make when they are wiv a doxy sir, an’ I ’eard ’im fall over, which they don’t usually do, ’n I thort ’e might ’ave been took bad, ’n I wen’ to see if I could ’elp but this person came out runnin’ and knocked me down an’ I banged me ’ead. ’N when I woke up I went ter see if the gent wuz ill, ’n ’e wuz lyin’ there with blood all over ’is front. ’N I ran out in the street an’ shouted “murder”, ’n then the coppers came ’n took me down the nick.’

  ‘Did you see the face of the man who knocked you over?’

  ‘No, yer ’ighness, sir, I din’t see nothin’ it were all black, not even eyes.’

  It was with enormous relief that Ratty was finally able to take a seat beside Frances, and she and Cedric both reassured him that he had done very well.

  The next witness was the young man who acted as secretary to the school. On the day of the murder there had been several items of post, three of which had been marked for the personal attention of Mr Eckley, which he had passed to the headmaster unopened, as was usual. Two of the envelopes were addressed in handwriting he recognised, a governor of the school and the parent of a pupil. The writing on the third he had never to his knowledge seen before. When he tidied Mr Eckley’s papers, he had found only the first two letters. Shown the fragment of paper found in the dead man’s hand, he said that it looked very like part of the envelope of the third letter. Mr Eckley would usually have gone to his home by eight o’clock, but on that occasion he had intimated that he would work a little later than usual.

  The implication was very clear. Mr Eckley had received a letter arranging a meeting in the quiet dusk and had been asked to bring the letter with him. Once he lay helpless on the ground, the killer had removed the evidence. Neither the meeting nor the murder was chance.

  Once all the testimony was heard the jury returned the verdict that Mr Eckley had been murdered by a person or persons unknown. The pressmen did not scamper away as usual but sent messages via runners and waited for the next inquest.

  ‘I think the coroner was pleased with you,’ Frances reassured Ratty.

  He grinned with relief and puffed out his thin chest. ‘Mr Jonsmif, ’tective! That’s me!’

  ‘Now I had meant to tell you something about the signs you saw when you observed the conversation between Mr Isaac Goodwin and the schoolboys,’ Frances went on. ‘This one,’ she made the gesture as if drawing a closed mouth, ‘means silence.’

  Ratty nodded. ‘Yes, ’e did that ’n then the boys did it too. It was like —’ he thought hard. ‘Like he wuz askin’ ’em to be quiet and they wuz saying “yes”.’

  ‘But what about, I wonder? And then there was the sign like this —’ she did the clawing movement at her shoulders. ‘That means a monkey or, more likely, a scamp or scallywag. Perhaps someone has misbehaved.’

  Ratty shook his head. ‘It weren’t like that, it were like this.’ He did the movement but this time Frances saw that the clawed fingers were not at his shoulders but met at his chest and were drawn outwards. ‘Is that diff’rent?’

  ‘It looks different,’ she agreed. Frances puzzled about it not only because she wanted to know what the gesture meant, but also because she had a feeling that she ought to know what it meant because she had seen it before.

  There was a surge of excitement as Dr Bond arrived, which signalled the fact that he had finally concluded his examination of the skeleton that had been deposited in the cellar of Queens Road, and it was hoped that the inquest on the remains could be concluded.

  Mr Marsden arrived together with Lionel Antrobus, and on seeing Frances he uttered some words to his client with a sour twist of his mouth. Antrobus’ expression was unreadable.

  ‘I wanter go now,’ said Ratty, when he saw Inspector Sharrock appear. ‘Don’ like coppers and don’ like him!’ he was out of the door before Frances could say another word.

  The inquest on the unnamed skeleton resumed, and Dr Bond was called.

  ‘Since the last hearing I have examined additional pieces of bone, pieces of a human fibula, recovered from the site where the earlier remains were found. They are compatible with the conclusion that they are part of the same skeleton. None of the human bones have been duplicated. At the last hearing, and based on the condition of the right tibia, I was of the opinion that the deceased would have made a good recovery from the fracture. The new remains have led me to revise that opinion.’

  There was a stir of interest in the court.

  ‘The injury to the fibula was very substantial. I think that the deceased must have twisted the leg and either struck or collided with some hard uneven surface. The bone was shattered into several fragments, some of which would undoubtedly have protruded through the flesh. The process of healing would have been a long one. The fracture was not skilfully set and the bones have not knitted well. There is evidence of a subsequent infection. The deceased would have walked with a noticeable limp. I have also, on the basis of the new evidence and further examination of the tibia, concluded that the injury was suffered less than five years before death. I cannot be more accurate than that.’

  ‘Have you any suggestions to offer concerning the identity of the deceased?’

  ‘I am afraid not.’

  Dr Bond stood down, and Lionel Antrobus was called forward to state very emphatically that his brother had walked with an entirely normal gait.

  There was no further evidence and the jury could only conclude that the identity of the remains was unproven and the cause of death was in all probability a broken neck, but whether by accident or design it was impossible to say.

  Frances and Sarah discussed the outcome of the inquest over a simple luncheon of ham and stewed peas, with bread and butter and tea.

  ‘The limping man, whoever he may be, is very probably the same individual seen in Bristol with Mr Antrobus,’ Frances concluded. ‘He travelled on the Paddington train, and he could have met with an accident or been robbed and killed soon after he arrived. But precisely where that occurred and how and why his remains came to be at Queens Road no one can say. Why was Mr Antrobus’ bag found with him? Did he steal it? Or did Mr Antrobus, wishing to disappear, kill his companion and leave his bag by the body in the hope that when it was found it would be thought to be him?’

  ‘But how would he know when, or even if, the body would be found?’ asked Sarah, reasonably. ‘Seems to me that it was just chance.’

  ‘Suppose the man was not killed where he was found. His body had been left in another place where it had been reduced to a skeleton and then put in the lodging house quite recently. The interior of the sack was not stained by decomposition, so the body was already dry bones. Whoever moved it might have been frustrated that the body had not been found and, knowing about the work that was to be done on the properties, put it there so the workmen would find it.’

  ‘Why not just leave it in plain view?’

  Frances could not answer that. She sipped her tea. ‘Perhaps I am looking at this the wrong way about. The body was hidden somewhere where it has lain undiscovered for long enough for it to become a skeleton, probably several years. It was then, quite recently, moved to a new location. Perhaps whoever hid it didn’t want it found, and it was in danger of being found if it remained where it was.’

  ‘That house wasn’t going to be shut up forever, though. Not with the way Mr Whiteley goes about his busines
s. They must’ve known it was going to be found sooner or later.’

  ‘That is true. So maybe it is not when it was found that was important but where. The police have been looking into possible connections with the lodging house, which of course is a perfectly correct course of action, but perhaps the one thing we might be certain of is that the individual and the person who hid the body have no connection with the house at all, and the bones were placed there because it was conveniently unoccupied, in order to draw attention away from the original location. The fact that the house was standing empty would have been well known to anyone who passed it by.’

  She put her teacup down and inspected the pot, which was empty, and sighed.

  ‘Well, one thing’s for sure, it wasn’t Mr Antrobus,’ said Sarah. Frances had been distracted by the puzzle over the bones but reflected that the fact that they were not the remains of the man for whom she was searching did not necessarily mean his identity was not her concern. Putting a name to the skeleton could lead her directly to Mr Antrobus.

  The best clue as to what had happened to the missing man was probably the signet ring, and Frances remained hopeful that the person who pawned it would be found.

  Frances and Sarah were busy during the next few days, and their other work was bearing fruit. The new suitor of Miss Digby, who had so coldly spurned young Mr Candy, was shown to be quite genuinely the cousin of a baronet. Ratty had followed him to a gentleman’s club, which turned out to be one of the many establishments patronised by Chas and Barstie where they made valuable business associations. The gentleman was known to several of the members, and he had been seen in the company of his noble, if impoverished, cousin. He was handsome, amiable, courteous, single and excellent company. He was also a habitual gambler who had squandered his inheritance and was in desperate need of money. Recently he had assured his creditors that his situation was about to change, and he would soon be able to pay his debts.