To Lose a Battle

Home > Nonfiction > To Lose a Battle > Page 73
To Lose a Battle Page 73

by Alistair Horne


  Chabrehez, 276, 279, 281

  Châlons-sur-Marne, 644

  Chamber of Deputies, 104–5, 454–6

  Chamberlain, Neville, 124, 133, 134, 135, 156, 181, 182, 215, 548

  Chambrun, Captain René de, 572

  Channel ports, German drive for, 534–5, 542, 596–601, 608

  Chanoine, General, 285, 392–3, 425

  Chapelle, La, 366, 400

  Charleroi, 376, 407, 428, 507

  Charleville-Mézières, 306, 333, 393, 416, 566

  Chasseurs Ardennais, 241, 263, 265, 276, 284, 307, 330, 527

  Château de Vignolles, 634, 635

  Château Porcein, 425, 644

  Chaumont, 334, 359–60, 363, 365, 531

  Chautemps, Camille, 100, 101, 104, 652, 660

  Chéhéry, 334, 365, 383–4

  Chémery, 362, 383–4, 386, 387, 423

  Cherbourg, 643, 647

  Churchill, Winston S.: on 1918 victory, 45; on French Army, 67; and reoccupation of Rhineland, 84; on Siegfried Line, 85; on coming of Pitt, 86; on Seeckt, 89; on Munich ‘breathing space’, 124; on decline of French Air Force, 125; on Polish guarantee, 134; Georges’s influence on, 168; and French Army dispositions, 175; on Chiefs of Staff System, 190–1; and ‘special operations’, 208; and mining the leads, 214–15; on Reynaud-Daladier feud, 226; becomes Prime Minister, 228, 271; on lack of French activity, 236–7; and Hurricane squadrons, 434, 444, 446, 460–3, 506, 510; on Reynaud’s telephone call, 445–6; misled by Gamelin and Georges, 446–7; flies to Paris, 447, 456; meet French leaders, 456–61; ‘no strategic reserve?’, 457–8; on Gamelin, 459; attempts to rally French, 460–1, 548, 633, 651; lack of confidence in French, 462, 548; and magnetic mines in Meuse, 509; on Panzers – as ‘scythes’, 511; as ‘tortoise’, 552, 564; on need to bomb them, 544–5; prepares for ‘Dynamo’, 550, 567; and Weygand’s journey north, 587; visits Paris again, 592–6; impressed by Weygand, 592, 595; telegram to Gort on Weygand Plan, 593–4; lack of recent experience, 596; orders Calais not to surrender, 598; urges Weygand Plan, fears no French initiative, 603–4; and Gort’s withdrawal, 606, 625; on deliverance of Dunkirk, 609, 611, 612, 632–3; and Belgian surrender, 621; Reynaud visits, 628; on Gort, 630–1; warns of ‘heavy tidings’, 631; orders Gort to leave Dunkirk, 632; and evacuation of French, 633; visits Tours, urges defence of Paris, 650; and Georges and Pétain, 651–2; last visit to Tours, 656–7; on Mandel, 656; on French capitulation, 658–9; on de Gaulle, 661; and Gort, 678–9

  Ciney, 273, 282, 307, 308

  Clairfayts, 474, 475

  Clemenceau, Georges, 45, 47, 53, 59–62, 555

  Cojeul, River, 577–8

  Colville, ‘Jock’, 636

  Commune: influence of, 102, 108; fear of, 443, 652

  Communists, French, 55, 62, 106–11, 117–18, 132–3, 134, 137, 156–60, 448–9, 455, 533

  Compiègne, 562, 609, 663–6

  Conill, Sergeant-Gunner, 297–8

  Conrad, Florence, 235–6, 342, 360

  Corap, General, character, career, 323–4; in Dyle-Breda Plan, 174; and Ninth Army, 188, 233–5, 273–4, 300, 306, 310, 329–33, 373, 377–80, 392–4; Brooke on, 234–5; withdraws, 406–7; attempts to re-form, 413; Army breaks up, 414, 418; sacked, 429; failure to reinforce, 440; visits Gamelin, 554; in Amiens, 560; Reynaud condemns, 590, 678; later career, 678

  Cot, Pierre, 125–6

  Coulommiers, 164, 434, 504

  Courbiere, Senior Lieutenant von, 351–2

  Couvin, 413

  Crécy-sur-Serre, 501, 537

  Croix de Feu, 104–5, 107, 226, 555

  Czechoslovakia, 133–4

  Daladier, Édouard: character, career, 220–2; resigns (1934), 105; in Popular Front, 107–8; complacency, 116; distrusts professional army, 117; and Munich, 133–4; boasts of low casualties, 153; and Gamelin, 164, 227, 442–3, 510, 536–7; lack of authority, 164; and Reynaud, 168, 223, 225–6, 445; and Finnish war, 181–2; Government falls, 182, 219; Bonnet and Herriot, 219–20; and ‘softs’, 220; meeting with Belgians, 296; and threat to Paris, 448–50; the ‘unpardonable mistake’, 457; Churchill exhorts, 460–1, 548; Foreign Minister, 538; later career, 678

  Darlan, Admiral, 633

  Dautry, Raoul, 139–40, 232, 449

  Davy, Lieutenant Colonel George, 621

  ‘Declaration of Union’, 659, 681

  Denain, General, 125

  Denmark, 214–15, 635

  ‘Deployment Directive Yellow’ (Aufmarschanweisung Gelb), 185–94, 197, 201–2

  Deuxième Bureau: on Panzers, 113; on German strength, 119, 229–30; split, 166; on Hitler’s plans, 169; on German tactics in Poland, 178; and Belgian plans, 242; on German order of battle, 245–6, 292; and Goering’s speech, 247; and Sedan, 370; and German thrust to Channel, 534

  Dieppe, 642

  Dietl, General, 217, 218

  Dijon, 659

  Dill, General Sir John, 447, 462, 547, 567, 592

  Dinant, 207–8, 274, 306–7, 308, 324, 326, 373, 680, 683

  Dizy-le-Gros, 469, 491

  Donchery, 334, 354–8, 387, 391

  Dorgelès, Roland, 362

  Douaumont, Fort, 69, 73–4, 266, 381

  Doullens, 517, 561, 577

  Doumenc, General Aimé, 166, 331–2, 370–1, 378, 393, 440, 479, 529, 536, 551

  Doumergue, Gaston, 105, 114

  Dowding, Air Chief Marshal Sir Hugh, 434, 446, 462, 627

  Duffet, General, 333, 412–13, 473

  Dunkirk, 548, 549, 587, 596–618, 620, 625, 631–4

  Dutourd, Jean, 672

  Dyle, River, 171, 174–5, 290, 295, 296, 369, 430

  Dyle-Breda Plan, 171, 173–7, 203, 234, 272, 281, 290–1

  ‘Dynamo’, 550, 614

  Eben Emael, Fort, 170, 267–71, 272

  Echternach, 262

  Eden, Anthony, 603–4, 678

  Ehrenburg, Ilya, 157, 645, 668

  ‘Enigma’ decoding machine, 634, 635, 636

  Escaut River, 170, 369, 431, 508, 546, 588, 600

  Esch-sur-Alzette, 262, 275, 285

  Étalle, 274

  Etchberrigaray, General, 393, 425

  Fabre-Luce, A., 141, 145, 148, 150, 180, 248, 523, 527, 644

  Ferdonnet, Paul, 130, 154–5, 218

  Ferté-sous-Jouarre, La: .H.Q. N.E. Front, 166, 168, 272, 313, 370–1, 437–43, 448, 508–9, 534; army fugitives at, 520

  Fifth Column: origin, 129; bogy, 129–32, 270–1, 290–1, 312, 362, 396, 523–32, 619; ‘false orders’ given by, 525, 529; facts, 524–5, 530–2

  Finnish war, 179–82

  Fitzalan-Howard, Lieutenant Miles, 546

  Flack, Werner, 257–8

  Flandin, Pierre Étienne, 84, 222

  Flavigny, General, 386, 396, 401, 419, 423, 465, 483

  Floing, 351, 353

  Florennes, 377–9, 407, 409

  Foch, Marshal Ferdinand, 47–50, 53, 55, 63–4, 167, 323, 436, 554–6, 595, 664–5

  fortifications: maisons fortes, 72, 239–40, 302–3; effect of German anti-tank guns on, 178, 681; deficient on Meuse, 238–42, 327–8, 342–4, 348–50, 357; at Eben Emael, 267–70; locked on Meuse, 274, 413, 472; at Sedan, 336; empty on Escaut, 546; see also Maginot Line, Siegfried Line

  Fortune, Major-General, V. M., 642

  forty-hour week, 110–12, 135

  France: class-warfare, 54–5, 102–8, 129, 132, 158–9, 673, 681; reliance on America, 56; economic difficulties, 57–9, 60, 107, 111–12; reparations, 59–60; occupies Ruhr, 60; governmental instability, 63–4, 101, 219, 226–7; population, 64; defence policies, 66–76, 83–5; lack of manpower, 76, 229; anti-militarism, 97–9; escapism, 98–9; political scandals, 99–101; disillusion with politics, 101; ‘Republic of Pals’, 101, 103, 625; gloire, 103; unemployment, 107, 135; elections, 108; devaluation, 111; fear of Fascism, 128; war production, 134–5, 139–40; mobilization, 139, 229; ineffectual propaganda, 153–4; sabotage, 159–60; censorship, 451–3, 562–3; spymania, civilians shot without trial, 526–9; rumours, 528–
9; defeatism, 618, 624; bitterness over B.E.F. withdrawal, 620; intelligence, 637; civilians attack soldiers, 649; fear of internal disorder, 653; reaction to Armistice, 661, 667–8; responsibility for defeat, 672–3; post-war history, effects of Dunkirk, 682; see also ‘honour’, ‘treachery’

  Franchet d’Esperey, Marshal, 168, 314

  Franco-British Declaration, 227, 626–8, 652, 656

  Franklyn, Major-General Harold, 573–81, 605

  Frederick the Great, 67, 163, 184

  Freiburg-im-Breisgau, 260

  French Air Force: pre-war disarray, 125–8; deficiencies, 127–8, 297; system of command, 164–5; numbers, 232–3, 627; concentrated on Holland, 278, 297; reluctant to bomb, 277–8; reconnaissance reports, 292, 299; losses, 298–9, 432, 515, 627, 667; at Sedan, 340–1, 389, 431–2; strafes Stonne, 394–5; night bombing, 432; Z.O.A.N. removed to Chantilly, 504; sorties on 16–17 May, 504–5; Z.O.A.N. strength on 19 May, 543; dive-bombs Forest of Mormal, 545; increasing strength of, 627, 640

  French Army: in Victory Parade (1919), 46–53; casualties in Great War, 49; colonial troops, 51, 76, 367, 377–8, 617, 629, 682; demobilization, 53; influence of Verdun, 67–70; defensive mentality, 70–1; ‘continuous front’, 70–1, 79, 114, 176, 371, 640; pay, 76, 148–9; inertia, 77; doctrine of war, 78–80, 112–19, 127, 176, 179, 419; rearmament, 112–13; military service, 112; command structure, 119, 164–7; anti-aircraft defences, 128, 232; morale, 147–60, 361, 547, 602; indiscipline, 150–1, 311, 463, 547; drunkenness, 150–1, 303, 305, 463; susceptible to propaganda, 153–60; Anglophobia, 155–6; forces opposing Germany, 229–35; lack of training, 237–8; normal leave, 249; looting, 303, 361, 547; false reports, 359; bogus orders, 360, 363, 396; panic, chaos, disintegration, 360–3, 379, 385, 393, 396–7, 403, 412–13, 442, 469–70, 473, 476–7, 518–23; artillery, prestige of, 360; rumours, 396; ‘containment’ and ‘counter-attack’, 397; as prisoners of Germans, 415–16, 478, 516, 642–3; summary of troop movements, 439–40; ‘no strategic reserve’, 457–8; lack of air support, 506; deserters ‘shot’, 520; breakdown in co-ordination, 612; defeatism, 624; final battle line-up, 639–40; losses up to Dunkirk, 639; ‘hedgehogs’, 640–1; determined resistance, 641, 643–4; final retreat, 648–9; unused supplies, 649; total losses, 667; campaign analyzed, 674–5

  French Navy, 650, 651, 659

  French North Africa, 652, 661

  Frère, General, 508, 517, 594, 602, 678

  Fritsch, General Werner von, 189

  Frömmel, Corporal, 356

  Gamelin, General Maurice: ancestry, character, career, 161–4; fails to act over Rhineland, 83–4; disparages tanks, 116–17; system of command, 119, 164–7; unsympathetic to Air Force, 126–7; on dive-bombers, 127; and ‘Saar Offensive’, 140–2; miscalculates over Poland, 143; out of touch, 153, 166, 312; lack of authority, 164; relations with Georges, 167, 293, 437–8; strategy, 169; ‘Instruction No. 8’, 170–1; Dyle-Breda Plan, 173–6, 267; keeps B.E.F. away from sea, 174; on forces in Maginot Line, 176–7; and Scandinavian campaign, 181, 219; encourages attack on Caucasian oil-wells, 182–3; and Bonnet, 219; on French armoured strength, 229; and defence of Sedan, 236, 239–40, 246, 303–4; and Ardennes, 244; reaction to German invasion, 271–2, 277; reluctance to bomb, 278; preoccupied with Holland, 291–2; and parachutists, 312; and Rommel, 333; telephones G.Q.G., 333; unjustified calm, 371, 446; Orders of the Day, 371, 509; and counter-attack from north, 403; ill-informed, 403–5, 437; confirms ‘bad news’, 405; ‘surprised’, 405, 437–8; does not ‘intervene’, 438, 441, 536; was he responsible?, 437–9; troop movements ordered, 439–40; ‘stricken by… fear’, 441; ‘no more reserves’, 442–3; direct news reaches, 447–8; and threat to Paris, 448–50, 464; dislike of journalists, 451; expounds situation, 457; ‘no strategic reserve’, 457–8; hopeless, 459, 464; Reynaud decides to sack, 510; on ‘parachutists’ and Communists, 533; still hesitates, 535–6; Pétain’s sympathy, 537; goes to La Ferté to intervene, 551; ‘Instruction No. 12’, 552–3, 558, 566, 591; sacked, 554; rumoured suicide, 590; later career, 678

  Gauché, General M., 93, 166, 178, 249

  Gaulle, General Charles de: and NATO, 83; on need for professional armoured division, 113–16; protégé of Pétain, 113; on Gamelin, 163; Keller’s reply on tanks, 179; on danger of Panzers, 226; and 4th Armoured, 231; Guderian misattributes tanks to, 469; leads tank attack on Montcornet, 489–94; its value, 494–6; lack of air support, 505, 540; and ‘treachery’, 533; leads tank attack on Crécy-sur-Serre, 537–40; on Weygand, 556; leads attack on Abbeville, 629–30; Under-Sec. for Defence, 645, 650; on evacuation of Corps Diplomatique, 645; backs Reynaud, 652; and Declaration of Union, 659; flies to England, 660–1; return to power, 680

  Gembloux Gap, 290, 312, 402, 505

  Gennep, 266

  George V, King, 45–6

  George VI, King, 180, 271, 668

  Georges, General: character, career, health, 167–8; at Victory Parade (1919), 50; military doctrine, 118; and ‘Saar Offensive’, 141; relations with Gamelin, 163–5, 167–8, 437–9; C.-in-C. N.E. Front, 166; on Escaut and Dyle-Breda Plans, 170–2, 175; blind to German threat, 246; and air operations, 277, 289, 299; and Meuse front, 293, 313, 333, 364, 370–1, 384, 391, 399–400; delegates powers to Billotte, 293, 296; meets Belgians, 296; ‘a rather serious pinprick’, 333, 371; in tears, 371; and 1st Armoured, 376–7, 439; misleads Gamelin, 403–4; orders counter-attack, 419, 441; and Touchon, 424–5; and 2nd Armoured, 428–9, 439; sacks Corap, 429; was he responsible?, 438–9; troop movements ordered, 439–40; and fighting at Stonne, 441; fears for Maginot Line, 441, 443, 464; and threats to Paris, 443, 464; ‘calm’ misleads Churchill, 446; orders to Billotte, Giraud, Touchon, 464–5; appoints Frère, 508; Reynaud and Pétain visit, 536; and defence of the Somme, 537; orders attack on Cambrai, 547; and Gamelin’s last ‘Instruction’, 550–4; Weygand and, 557–8, 566–7; and plans for Gort’s counter-attack, 567, 576; defeatist, 651; later career, 678

  Germany: condition in 1919, 57; unable to pay reparations, 60, 65; demilitarized, 63; population, 64; training of youth, 95–6; adroit propaganda, 153–6, 270; news of victories in, 481–2; war production cut back, 669; see also Luftwaffe, Wehrmacht

  Gibbs, Anthony, 143, 146

  Giraud, General Henri: in Dyle-Breda Plan, 174–5, 267, 289, 291; withdraws, 295, 369; replaçes Corap, 429–30; Brooke on, 429–30; disquieting message to Billotte, 430; and 2nd Armoured, 469–70; thinks line ‘stabilized’, 472; Martin misinforms, 474; and 9th Motorized, 497; and Kosak, 498; avoids capture, 512; surrenders, 518; later career, 678

  Givet, 239, 240, 292, 378–9, 413, 639

  Goebbels, Joseph, 148, 153, 158, 270, 404, 433, 531

  Goering, Hermann, 120–1, 185, 211, 218, 247, 265, 611

  Gontaut-Biron, C. A. de, 252, 275

  Gort, Lord: character, career, 568–71; and Air Component, 165; command structure, 165, 293, 296, 570; all quiet, 369; ordered to retire to Escaut, 431; informs Belgians, 431; and retreat to Dendre, 507; and attack at Arras, 546; to fall back on Calais?, 547–8; and Billotte’s plans for counter-attack, 549–50; no confidence in French, 549, 588–9; warns of possible evacuation, 550; ordered to ‘force his way south’, 567; and Weygand’s take-over, 568; lack of orders from French, 570; and Churchill, 570–1; and counter-attack on Arras, 573–6, 582; misses Weygand at Ypres, 585–6; meets Billotte and Leopold at Ypres, 588; cannot attack without French, 603; telegram to Eden, 603; Eden’s reply, 604; withdraws towards Dunkirk, 604–5; decides to save B.E.F., 608; Dunkirk perimeter defences, 611, 620; Churchill on, 630–1; ordered to evacuate, doubtful of success, 631; leaves Dunkirk, 632; and B.E.F., 635, 636; and ‘Ultra’, 636, 637; later career, 679

  Goutard, Colonel A., 230, 358, 379, 397, 399, 489, 575, 591

  Grandsard, General C., 235, 236, 238–9, 241, 313, 315–16, 336–9, 342–3, 358–9, 362–5, 384–6, 629

  Greece, 610

  Grubnau, Lieutenant, 354–5, 365, 382–3

  Guderian, General Heinz: early career, 90;
tank pioneer, 90–4; Achtung–Panzer!, 90–4, 205, 207, 246, 337; Gamelin ignores, 117; on combination of horse and motor, 118; and Stuka, 122–3; in Polish campaign, 142–3; on Manstein, 196; and plan to attack Sedan, 198–9; protests at Hitler’s distrust, 200; and Manstein Plan, 201, 205; and Sichelschnitt, 207–8, 210, 211–12; on Panzer strength, 229–30; on tank breakdowns, 231; into Luxembourg, 258, 261–2; disagreements with Kleist, 279–80, 401, 434–5, 487; diverts Reinhardt, 283; advances to Sedan, 284–7; crosses Semois, 300–2; escapes bombs, 301; and crossing of Meuse, 304–5, 317–18, 333–7, 342–6, 351–8, 365–6, 386; heads west, 387, 392, 418, 424–6; on Sedan Bridge with Rundstedt, 388; and flak batteries, 390; battle at Stonne, 418, 422, 424, 441; on Balck, 426; to Montcornet, 467–8; misattributes action to de Gaulle, 469; order to attack captured, 471, 534; ordered to halt, 487–8; ‘reconnaissance in force’, 488–9, 501; and de Gaulle’s attacks, 493–5, 538–41; to Péronne, 512; orders advance across Somme, 538; and ‘burnt out’ fuel depot, 538–9, 541; to the Channel, 558, 562; frets for lack of further orders, 565; and ‘Frank-force’ attack, 578–9, 596; to Calais and Boulogne, 597–8; ordered to halt on Aa, 610; allowed to advance ‘too late’, 614; to Gravelines, 617; and ‘Ultra’, 635–6; in final battle, 639, 643–4, 647; later career, 676

  Guillaut, Lieutenant-Colonel, 442–3

  Habe, Hans, 237, 516, 529, 648

  Halder, General Franz: character, career, 192; and ‘Directive Yellow’, 186–7; and ‘resistance’ to Hitler, 192–4; caution, 194; and Manstein Plan, 198, 201, 204–6; transfers Manstein, 201, 204–5; and Kleist, 208, 279; and Sichelschnitt, 209–11, 251; and Brauchitsch, 284; on advance through Ardennes, 287; ‘little danger’ of counter-attack, 484; plans to smash France in one blow, 484; on Hitler’s nervousness, 486–7, 515; and manning the flanks, 502; accorded freedom of movement, 516; concerned lest Allies escape, 562; tempted to turn south, 565; and British attack on Arras, 582; and Lorette Heights, 599; fury at Hitler’s halt-order, 613–14; satisfaction at fall of Dunkirk, 638–9; and fall of Verdun, 647; ‘administrative work’, 669; not honoured, 669; later career, 676

  Hanke, Lieutenant, 327, 477–8, 499

  Harsch, Joseph, 138, 144, 154, 249–50

 

‹ Prev