by Selena Kitt
"Tony..." she answered, her mouth going dry. His brow creased as he considered her calling him Tony, something she rarely did.
With hesitation he slowly lowered his lips to hers. She closed her eyes and sighed as his lips barely grazed hers, touching hers so lightly, she wondered if she had imagined it or not.
"I've wanted you from the first day I met you Gabby," he whispered softly against her lips. "So many years I've been waiting to do this. Fantasized about it."
Gabriella's lust-filled eyes flew open and she stared up at him. Was he serious? "But... but why didn't you ever tell me?"
He pulled back from her slightly to look her in the eye and gave her a shy grin. "Because I was a horny teenaged boy and just before you and your mother moved in here, Dad warned me if I ever touched you or made an advance on you of any kind he'd cut off my balls and feed them to the dog."
Gabriella giggled. "Fair enough."
“Dad nearly did when he caught us that night.”
“Ohhh.” Why hadn’t she thought of that?
“Yeah, I was pretty sure I was going to enlist, but that night Dad made it clear it was the time to make the decision.”
She felt so stupid for blaming him without getting the full story, but he hadn’t offered the full story to her; how was she to know any different?
Anthony released her hands and she slid one around his neck, while her index finger of the other hand traced his strong, chiselled jawline. There was a one-inch scar on his cheek, close to his left ear. It seemed new, and added to his dangerously sexy appeal. She wondered briefly how he'd gotten that scar.
His cock continued to grow and press against her, and the ache between her legs intensified. Could she cross this line with him after all these years? Should she?
"You smell so good Gabby," Anthony said softly, lowering his lips to her neck and kissing it tenderly. The faint, simple touch of his lips caused every nerve ending in her body to come alive.
"Tony..." She moaned softly as his lips leisurely teased their way across her jaw to brush against hers. Her panties were quickly becoming uncomfortably damp as her desire for him increased.
He pulled back up again, a hand braced at either side of her head as he looked down at her. Their mouths were within an inch apart, their breaths intermingling and breathing synchronizing. "God, I need to kiss you Gabby," he whispered, his eyes lowering to her parted lips.
"Then what's stopping you?"
He closed his eyes for a moment, his body tense over hers. When he opened them, the fire was raging within them as he lowered his mouth fully to hers. He caught her lower lip between his teeth and sucked. A shiver rushed through her and she fisted his shirt, attempting to rein in her raging desires.
"Oh Tony..."
His lips touched hers again, and when she sighed, parting her lips slightly he thrust his tongue into her mouth. She moaned as his tongue caressed hers. Her body writhed under him, longing to feel his cock slamming into her.
Changing positions so that he was settled in between her legs, Anthony slipped his hand along the outside of her thigh to her backside. He squeezed her bottom while pulling her up tighter against the ridge of his cock under the denim. Despite the layers of clothing dividing them, the friction of jean against her white cotton panties was excruciating. Her panties were uncomfortably soaked with the evidence of her arousal.
"I want you," she gasped, bucking under him as his lips left hers and began to work their way down the side of her neck.
He chuckled, low and sexy. "That's a dangerous thing to say to a man who hasn't had a woman in five years, Gabby."
"Oh God!" Gabriella tensed and moaned loudly as his fingers cupped her bottom, pushed her panties aside and slipped into her heated core.
"So wet," he murmured as his lips reached her collarbone and he began to make his way to her breasts, straining against the thin material of her gravy-stained bodice.
Her breathing became ragged and broken. His fingers stroking and digging deep into her wetness were almost becoming her undoing. He had barely begun touching her, and she was already almost at her breaking point.
"You're going to make me come, Tony," she gasped, clutching tighter to his shirt.
He chuckled, unbuttoning the front of her sundress, exposing her breasts covered in white lace. "That's the idea, sis."
She squirmed under him. She didn't want to come so quickly, but his fingers stroking her inner wall and the ridge of his cock against her pelvis were too much to bear.
Anthony pulled down the lace covering her left breast, lowered his mouth and captured it between his lips, nipping the sensitive bud. His mouth on her nipple was her undoing. She cried out, her body tensing as a tidal wave of pleasure crashed over her and exploded between her legs. Her juices dripped from her, fully saturating her panties as she released a slow ragged breath.
* * *
"Fuck, that was as sexy as hell, Gabby." Anthony released her nipple, which had turned into a tight, long nub, sat back on his heels and began to undo the rest of the buttons down the front of her dress. His steel grey eyes eagerly took in every inch of her body as the material parted, revealing her ivory skin.
He was positive she hadn’t been this stunning or sexy when they were younger. She couldn't have been because there was no way he'd have been able to keep his hands off of her if she had – even the threat of being castrated wouldn't have been able to stop him.
With the dress now completely open, he unclasped the front of her bra and it sprang open, revealing her generous breasts with large pink nipples. His eyes travelled lower, over her stomach and to her groin. She had on plain white cotton briefs that were soaked from her arousal. Cotton briefs had never looked so damned sexy to him. Hooking his thumbs into the waistband of her panties he was about to give them a tug when her hands on his stopped him.
Looking back up into her eyes, their gazes locked and he could see her desire raging within those blue eyes. But he could also see her hesitation, as if she was struggling with whether this was right or not.
Anthony attempted to rein in his desire, despite the painful throbbing in his jeans. "We don't have to do anything more if you're not comfortable, Gabby." As the words came from his mouth, he silently prayed she wouldn't stop him. He was dying to taste her and then feel her hot, wet pussy around his dick. It was taking every last ounce of his restraint to hold himself back and make sure she was pleasured before he took what he needed from her.
She gave him a soft smile and nodded, he hesitation in her eyes slowly slipping away. "No. I want you, Anthony." She released his hands. "Take off your shirt. I want to see you."
"Don't have to ask me twice, Ma'am."
She grinned and she caught her lower lip between her teeth as she watched him remove his shirt and toss it to the floor, displaying his beautifully toned chest, abdominals and shoulders. "You're gorgeous, Tony."
The admiration in her eyes as they travelled up the length of his body tugged at his heart and made him feel like the sexiest man on earth. His cock jerked in his jeans, reminding him of the task at hand.
In an attempt to hide his embarrassment from her compliment he gave her a wink. "Well, I work out." Moving back from her, he tugged her panties down slowly over her hips, revealing her shaven mound. Moments later, he had her panties off and was tossing them to the floor.
Leaning down, he placed a light kiss on her stomach and smiled when he heard her sharp intake of breath. Slipping one of her legs over his shoulder, he worked his kisses lower until he reached her mound. She squirmed and gasped, her fingers grasping the fabric of the sofa under her.
"Take off your jeans," she gasped as he parted her pussy lips, displaying her quivering nub. "I want to see all of you."
"If I take them off I'll be fucking you before I have a chance to taste you, Gabby."
His tongue flicked at her clit and she arched her back and groaned loudly. "Oh God!"
He chuckled lightly as he sucked on her clit, and plunged tw
o fingers deep into her. She wiggled and squirmed under him, bucking up against his mouth and hand. Removing his fingers from her, he spread her soft folds and ran his tongue along her, from her anus to her clit. She cried out, bucking wildly.
Damn, it was too good. Her squirming and moans were driving him near the edge of insanity. It was taking all of his willpower not to whip out his dick and slam it into her. He licked the length of her a second time, lapping up every ounce of her juices.
* * *
Anthony's tongue was sheer torture of the best kind as it teased, darting in and out of her opening and putting her on edge. She wanted to grab his head and force him to thrust his tongue into her as deeply as possible. The thought had just entered her mind when his fingers pinched her clit and his tongue slipped into her. She moaned. Her pussy was aching from her need and she was building her way up to another orgasm.
She groaned again. The thought of releasing in his mouth, her juices dripping from his chin was so erotic she nearly came just from the thought alone. "I need it, Tony!"
"Then come for me, Gabby," he countered, a hint of amusement in his tone before going back to work, his tongue fucking her needy pussy.
"Mmmm. Soon." Her hips began to work in time with his tongue's thrusts. His mouth moved back up to her clit and he once again sucked it into his mouth. She groaned even louder, thankful they were alone at their parents' house and not at her tiny apartment with the paper-thin walls.
"Do you need a little more incentive, Gabby?" he murmured, his tongue flicking at her clit as his finger pressed at her back entrance and his thumb slipped into her pussy.
"Oh God, Tony. I never.... Ohhhhh!" She attempted to pull away from him. She'd never had anyone near her ass before and the idea wasn't the most tempting to her. She was at his mercy and upon realizing this she relaxed and whimpered as his finger slowly pressed into her ass. With him working her two holes with his hand and her clit with his tongue she was immediately brought to the brink. Her stomach clenched and her body vibrated; she had crested the summit and was now teetering on the edge.
Anthony glanced up and his lust-filled grey eyes caught her blue ones and the intensity of his stare was all she needed to push her over the edge for a second time. Fisting the sofa under her, she was swept away as a wave of pleasure rocked through her, leaving her breathless and slightly lightheaded.
She closed her eyes for a moment as several more light tremors rocked through her. When she opened her eyes back up Anthony was standing. He quickly undid his jeans and pulled them down, his boxers with them, to display his thick erect cock, the head glistening with his pre-cum. His cock was virtually begging her to take it into her mouth.
Licking her lower lip, Gabriella sat up and reached out to grasp him in her hand when he stepped back a foot. What in the hell? Frowning, Gabriella looked up to meet his gaze, a questioning look in her expression.
Stepping out of his jeans and kicking them to the side he placed a hand on her shoulder and pushed her back down on the sofa. "It's been five years, Gabby. You take me into your mouth and I'll be done for."
"But –"
Anthony sank back onto the sofa, settling between her legs, his mouth kissing its way back up her stomach. His lips stopped long enough to pay attention to each of her nipples, first flicking them with his tongue and then teasing with his teeth and lips until they were even harder than they already were, sending short jolts through her, igniting the fire between her legs once more.
He continued his way up the length of her neck, across her jaw and then placed a chaste kiss on her lips. His lips tasted of her and hiked her arousal up a notch as her mind drifted back to the image of him, his face buried between her legs. "Besides. If I blow my load right away, what kind of impression would that leave?" he teased, as he settled onto her, his rock hard cock nestling itself between her wet folds.
She wiggled under him, hoping to impale herself onto him by fluke. "But if you blow your load right away, it means we get to do it again," she countered, placing a string of kisses down his neck and across his chest.
"Mmm. Good point." He moved up against her, increasing her torment as his cock slid back and forth along her. "So, you're still on..."
"Mmm-Hmm," Gabriella confirmed, slipping her hands to his tight ass and pulling him tighter to her.
Rubbing against her, Anthony gave her a wicked smile that sent her pulse racing as he lined the head of his dick up to her awaiting entrance. He cupped the side of her face in his palm as he lowered his mouth to her, and as their lips touched he pushed up into her. Her nails dug into his ass and she moaned against his lips as his cock stretched her.
Her pussy took him in as he pressed himself deeper, so exquisitely deep, until he was balls deep into her channel. He settled in her, his hips rocking against hers, torturing her with tiny, micro thrusts. She parted her lips, needing to tell him she needed more. She needed him moving within her – hard, fast, now! But her words were muffled as his tongue invaded her mouth, caressing hers.
Just when she didn't think she could handle another moment of his horrid teasing, he pulled out nearly all the way and then slammed back into her, so fast and hard that her whole body moved an inch up the sofa.
"You want it hard, Gabby?" he growled, tearing his lips from hers and staring down at her. His expression was tense, and she took some satisfaction in knowing the strain of holding back was as torturous to him as it was to her.
"God yes, Tony." Her hands moved up to his shoulders and she wrapped her legs around his waist. "Give it to me!"
"Then hold on."
Hold on? She didn't have time to consider his words as he pulled out and forcefully thrust back in. She screamed out as the jolt of pleasure rushed through her. Not wasting any more time he began to jackhammer into her, thrusting fast and hard, forcing whimpers and moans from her with each thrust.
"Oh, so fucking good Gabby. So tight," he growled with his mouth against her neck, as he nipped at her neck and collarbone between thrusts.
It was good, so good, too good. She wanted to meet each of his thrusts with her own, but he was moving at a frantic pace. All she could do was hold tight to him and enjoy the waves rushing through her.
She became lightheaded as she reached the summit. So close. Teetering on the edge.
"I can't hold back any longer, Gabby." Anthony claimed her mouth roughly as he slammed into her a final time, burying himself to the hilt and unloading spurt after spurt of his cum into her. The sudden rush of cum filling her, beating against her inner walls was enough to send her over the edge. She moaned against his lips, her nails digging into the hard muscle of his back as she released.
Anthony pulled up from her while keeping himself embedded within her, a self-satisfied smile on his lips. "So does this mean you forgive me for ruining your prom?"
Running a finger along his jaw, she peered up into his grey eyes. "Oh, we have a lot more making up to do before I forgive you for that," she teased.
"Hmmmm." Leaning down he kissed her forehead, the bridge of her nose and her chin. "Then I guess we've got a long night ahead of us."
Gabriella loved the sound of that!
Chapter 3
Gabriella was pulled from her deep, satisfied sleep by a loud scream and the feel of Anthony thrashing on the bed next to her. Pulling her naked body into an upright position she looked down at Anthony; his face was contorted into a look of anguish, a sheen of sweat coating his chest.
“NO! STOP!” he shouted out in his sleep.
She sat frozen watching him a moment, her brow furrowing, unsure of what to do. Deciding to wake him she leaned over him and gave his shoulders a gentle shake. “Tony… Anthony.” It didn’t seem to wake him; his thrashing became more intense.
Beginning to panic, Gabriella grabbed him more solidly in her hands, shaking him violently. “TONY!”
Suddenly, Anthony’s eyes sprang open. Gabriella screamed as his hand shot up, grasping her throat and threw her back onto the bed. He
quickly straddled her, his hand tightening on her throat, beginning to cut off her air supply. Gasping for breath she clawed at his hand grasping her throat, staring up into vacant eyes.
What’s going on? Oh dear god, what’s wrong with him? This was the first time in her lifetime she’d felt fearful for her life.
And just as suddenly as he sprang into action, the vacant look in his eyes began to clear. “Oh fuck…” He immediately released her throat and slid from her. “Oh fuck me. Oh fuck. Gabriella. Gabriella, I’m so fucking sorry.”
Gasping for breath and still in shock, Gabriella didn’t know what to say. She couldn’t answer, just stare up at him.
Anthony sat up straight on the bed and clasped his hands behind his neck, lowering his head and closing his eyes. “I’m sorry. God, I’m so sorry.”
