by Tom Bradby
The men were soldiers from the Cossack Escort Regiment, but as he handed over his papers, Ruzsky noticed another man-an officer of the Police of the Imperial Court -watching him from inside the gate. After a few moments, the man, dressed in a long, elegant gray overcoat, slipped out and walked toward him.
“An investigator from the city police,” one of the guards explained as the policeman took Ruzsky’s identification papers and examined them.
He looked carefully at the photograph, then up at Ruzsky. “It says here you’re the chief investigator.”
“Yes.”
“I don’t know you.”
“I’ve been away.”
“To the front?”
“No.”
The man frowned. “You are still the chief investigator?”
“I suppose so.”
“You suppose so?”
“Yes, I am.”
“Your papers are out of date.”
Ruzsky looked at him, not sure if he was joking. “I apologize,” he said, realizing that the officers charged with the Tsar’s personal protection had nothing to smile about. “You’re quite correct, they are out of date, but I’m conducting a murder investigation.”
“Not Rasputin?”
“No.” Ruzsky shook his head.
“Who have you come to see?”
“Madame Vyrubova.”
“Vyrubova?”
“Yes.”
“You have made an appointment?”
“No. I’m afraid not.”
The officer looked suspicious. “I’ll have to ask you to wait while I telephone.”
“Of course.”
The policeman retreated to the small wooden box beside the gate, the guards alongside him. Ruzsky walked forward to the railings and looked through to the yellow and white colonnades. It was infinitely more modest than the Catherine Palace, its neighbor.
He turned around, took out his case, and lit a cigarette. It was almost warm now that the sun was out, though his feet were still numb with cold. He bashed them together.
He noticed two faces in an upstairs window of the house closest to the gate. He assumed they were also officers of the palace police, watching the entrance.
The aura of calm was deceptive.
He faced the gate again and watched a gardener chipping ice from outside the steps to the nearest wing of the palace.
Ruzsky thought about the faces of those waiting in the bread queue. Were they really talking about revolution? Now that people discussed it openly, he found himself recoiling from his earlier insistence that change was inevitable and desirable in whatever form. He realized now that it frightened him. He no longer believed that change always made things better.
He thought of the arguments with his father.
If only they had spent less time being so certain they were right… but then, the same could be said for the country as a whole.
“All right, Chief Investigator. I’ll get someone to accompany you.”
Ruzsky was so surprised that he did not answer. The man returned to his box and Ruzsky waited, his hands thrust into his overcoat pockets.
There was a sudden burst of activity as three soldiers ran down from the near wing to open the gate. A long, low black saloon car followed them, the yellow and black imperial flag fluttering over its hood.
It skidded on the ice as it swung out onto the road, affording Ruzsky a brief glimpse of the man inside. The Tsar of all the Russias glanced at him, before settling back into his seat.
One of the soldiers walked over. “I will take you.”
Ruzsky heard himself say: “I thought the Emperor was at the front.”
The guard gave him a sour look, but did not deign to reply.
They began walking, stepping onto the side of the road, into the snow, where the footing was surer. “How is Petrograd?” the man asked.
“Cold.”
“We hear only bad things.”
“It will be better when there is more bread.”
They rounded the corner of the Alexander Palace and saw a group of children playing beneath the terrace. They were making something from the snow-from here it looked like a house-helped by two men and a woman. As they moved closer, Ruzsky recognized two of the grand duchesses, the Tsar’s daughters, and the Tsarevich, his only son.
Ruzsky could not take his eyes from them. Just as with the car a moment ago, it was almost like seeing an apparition. If he’d told Pavel he’d witnessed the Tsar’s children playing in the snow-just like any in Russia -the big detective would never have believed him.
It reminded Ruzsky of his own conviction as a child that the Tsar was not in fact a mere man, but a being from another world. It was an impression that he could still not entirely dispel, even though he had once exchanged a few words with the young Nicholas Romanov at a New Year’s Day reception at the Winter Palace.
The Tsarevich laughed. He was a pale child, with a thin white face, but there was no sign of the hemophilia with which rumor said he was inflicted. As the guard led him toward the group, Ruzsky tried to tear his eyes away from the boy, but could not.
“Madam Vyrubova,” the guard said.
A round-faced woman looked over toward them. She was dressed in a long white coat with a fur collar.
“This gentleman has come to see you. He is the chief investigator for the Petrograd police.”
The woman frowned. The two grand duchesses looked at Ruzsky with frank curiosity. They were strikingly beautiful. The men-tutors, he assumed-stopped what they were doing and appraised him also. Both were dressed in long overcoats and suits.
Ruzsky realized he was staring at them as he would at caged animals. He had to force himself to look away.
“I’ve not seen him before,” Vyrubova said.
The Tsarevich looked like his own son. They shared the same gentle solemnity. As he watched, the woman drew the boy to her, but the gesture was proprietorial rather than affectionate.
“I’m new,” Ruzsky said, realizing he was required to offer an explanation.
“You’re too late.”
Alexei slipped his other arm through that of the older of his two sisters. This must be Olga, Ruzsky thought, or perhaps Tatiana. It was many years since he’d seen either of them. They were pretty girls. They projected a luminous innocence. Ruzsky thought of the caricature he had seen on the wall of the office earlier depicting their half-naked mother dancing with Rasputin.
“Take him to my house. I will see him there,” Vyrubova said. Her manner was imperious and dismissive. He turned reluctantly and the guard led him away down the central path.
Ruzsky glanced back. The group still watched him.
He was chivied on by the guard. The icy path had been scattered with small stones to give them a measure of grip, but his footing was still uncertain.
The path ran through a long line of trees which stood out starkly against the snowy landscape around them. Ruzsky could see the Catherine Palace to his left and he stopped as he reached the point where the paths leading to both palaces met. He could still see the children playing beneath the curved terrace behind him. The guard chivied him again.
They passed a chapel. “Is that where they buried him?” Ruzsky asked. “Rasputin, I mean.”
The guard stopped suddenly, his face severe. “You have no power or jurisdiction here, is that understood?” Ruzsky noticed how red the man’s cheeks were from the cold, the capillaries so pronounced that they reminded him of the painted wooden maps they’d studied at school. “This is the home of the Tsar of all the Russias. You will confine yourself to addressing Madam Vyrubova, and no one else.”
Ruzsky concealed his irritation at this unnecessarily heavy-handed approach and the man turned around and marched him swiftly down to a small house in the far corner of the park. It was a pavilion that had been transformed into a comfortable, solid residence, with a white wooden fence around its garden and roses curling over the sloping roof of the veranda.
Inside
it was neatly, but not lavishly, furnished. The guard left him at the door in the hands of a young housekeeper with pretty dark eyes. She smiled and led him through to a drawing room. He accepted her offer of tea.
The room was bright, sunlight spilling in through large windows. Ruzsky stood with his back to a fire that crackled on the hearth. There was a framed photograph of Rasputin on the far wall with a collection of icons beneath it. Next to it was a picture of Anna Vyrubova sitting alongside the Tsar himself on a thin strip of sand in what looked like the Crimea. The last picture-next to a bookcase-was of Anna surrounded by the Tsar’s five children.
Ruzsky took a step toward her desk. It was arranged neatly, a pen and inkwell placed next to a pile of writing paper. On the right-hand side, alongside a small carriage clock, the Tsarina stared out at him severely from an ornate silver frame.
He heard someone coming through the front door and returned to his position in the center of the room.
Vyrubova looked at him for a moment as she entered. “What do you want?”
“I-”
“You didn’t come and see us about Father Grigory. If you are indeed the chief investigator, we should have seen you then.”
“I have just returned to Petrograd.” He shook his head. “And I believe such an important case was always likely to be treated as a political and not simply criminal matter, for reasons that will be obvious to you.”
She stared at him. “It has brought shame on our country, and our class.”
Ruzsky didn’t answer. He wondered exactly what relationship this woman enjoyed with the Empress. Technically, as he recalled, she was a lady-in-waiting, but clearly also much more. This was the woman much of Russia believed to be a lesbian lover of the Empress, and participant in orgies that were variously said to involve both the Tsar and Rasputin.
“If your business is not important,” she went on, “then why do you trouble me with it?”
Vyrubova’s small eyes were still fixed upon his. He sensed her suspicion, and her cunning.
“The body of a woman was found on the Neva this morning. She was wearing a dress made by Madame Renaud.” He paused. “A dress made for you.”
Her expression did not alter, but he saw her eyes flicker. “Who was she?”
“That’s why I’m here.” Ruzsky reached into his pocket for the photographs. He handed her one of the girl’s head and shoulders. “I was hoping you would be able to tell me.”
Vyrubova took it. She stared at it in silence. “How do you know the dress was mine?”
“Madame Renaud confirmed it.”
“How did you know it was one of her dresses?”
Ruzsky was about to explain, but thought better of it. “Do you recognize her?”
“Yes.” Vyrubova’s face was expressionless.
He waited.
“And?” Ruzsky was beginning to recover his wits enough to find the woman’s disdain irritating.
“Her name was Ella.”
They heard the front door being opened and shut and a voice in the hall. A few moments later, the Tsarina appeared, dressed in a black overcoat, gloves, and hat, a diamond brooch at her neck.
Ruzsky did not move. After a few moments, he realized that his mouth was open and he shut it. She was taller than he remembered, but there were deep lines around her eyes and her face was harsher, thinner, and more angular than he’d imagined.
For a moment, she stared at him.
The last time Ruzsky had set eyes upon her had been on the day of his arrest. He had been with his brother in the General Staff Building, overlooking a packed Palace Square as the Tsar and his wife came out onto the balcony of the Winter Palace to read a proclamation declaring the Russian Empire to be at war with Germany and Austro-Hungary.
Even now, Ruzsky could recall every detail of that crisp day: the giant crimson drape that hung almost to the ground; the Tsar dressed in the uniform of a colonel in the Preobrazhensky Regiment, his wife in white; the gigantic crowd falling to its knees and chanting the national anthem, “Bozhe, Tzaria Khrani,” over and over again, the Emperor raising his hand as he read the proclamation against the great din, his wife bowing.
The swell of emotion had touched even the most cynical hearts. And in the eyes of the young men in uniform around him, what Ruzsky had seen was nothing short of ecstasy.
Now most of those men were dead and the woman who ruled an empire stood before him, dressed in black.
His education failed him. He had no idea what he should say if she chose to address him.
“Who is this?” she demanded.
“He says he’s a chief investigator from Petrograd.”
The Empress snorted in derision, as if he weren’t there. “It’s not good for Alexei to be out in the cold so long.” She spoke Russian with a heavy German accent.
Vyrubova’s expression was instantly soothing. “He seems better today.”
“He’s no judge of his own well-being.”
“He wants to be out with the girls.”
“I know he does, but that doesn’t mean that it is good for him.”
The Empress of the Russias turned to him. “What is he doing here?”
Anna Vyrubova handed the Tsarina the photograph that was still in her hand. She studied it for a moment and then looked up again, her mouth taut. “I suppose you think it is our fault.”
Ruzsky did not know what to say.
“She was murdered,” Vyrubova explained. “It wasn’t-”
The Empress looked confused. “Murdered?”
It appeared to be a question for him. “Yes,” Ruzsky said, clearing his throat and bowing slightly. “It would appear so, Your…” Ruzsky wondered if he should have said “Your Imperial Highness,” but, as he considered the question, a hint of resentment at his mother’s own fawning approach to the imperial family acted as its own check. Their manner was damned rude.
“It would appear so? Surely you must know.”
“Yes… That is correct.”
“How was she murdered?”
Ruzsky glanced at Vyrubova to see whether he should continue to answer, but received no signal either way. “She was stabbed. Once. The man with her, seventeen times.” Ruzsky handed a photograph of the man’s head and shoulders to the Empress. She looked at it without expression and then passed it to her companion.
“How did you know she worked here?” the Empress asked.
Ruzsky looked at Vyrubova, but her face was impassive. “I didn’t,” he said.
Ruzsky thought he saw a slight flush developing in the Tsarina’s cheeks.
“Ella worked in the nursery,” Vyrubova explained. “And was very fond of the children.”
“She was a pretty girl,” the Empress said. “But unreliable.”
“She was very fond of the family,” Vyrubova went on, “and sad to go.”
They were silent. Their sudden garrulousness confused him. “If you don’t mind me asking,” Ruzsky said, “to go where?”
“She was dismissed,” the Empress said.
There was another long silence.
“Would it be impertinent…” Ruzsky kept his eyes on Vyrubova so as not to rile the Empress. “May I ask why?”
The Empress frowned, tilting her head to one side. “You may not.”
“I apologize, Your Highness.”
“She stole from us,” the Tsarina said suddenly. She sighed. “There was no choice but to dismiss her. It upset the children. She upset the children.”
“She was too close to them,” Vyrubova added. “To the Little One, to Sunbeam, especially.”
The Empress’s irritation with her colleague began to show again.
“She was sad to leave here?” Ruzsky asked.
“Devastated. Of course.” The Empress seemed suddenly to remember herself. “I did not expect anyone to be here,” she told Vyrubova. “Telephone me when you have dealt with this man.”
She walked out. They waited, watching her pass the window and the white fence around the
garden.
Vyrubova did not look at him. There was an intimacy between them suddenly, as if he had witnessed a domestic scene normally kept away from prying eyes. She stared at her shoes, a rueful smile at the corner of her lips.
“What did this girl… Ella… steal?”
Vyrubova was evasive again. “Oh, I don’t know.”
“You don’t know what she took?”
“No.” She looked out of the window. The Empress was now some distance away. “No.”
“Some money?”
“No. I mean, yes. Money.”
“How much?”
She turned back, still not meeting his eye. “I don’t know.”
Ruzsky smiled encouragingly. “You seem to keep few secrets from each other.”
“Who?”
“You and the Empress.”
“That is not your business.”
“No. Of course. I just imagined she would have told you the cause of this girl’s sudden dismissal.”
“She rules the Empire during the Tsar’s absence at the front, commanding our great forces. She doesn’t have time to deal with the minutiae of the household. This girl was unimportant.”
“But the children were upset.”
“They will quickly recover. It is best to be removed from unsuitable influences.”
“How was she unsuitable, exactly?”
“Oh… I don’t know.” Ruzsky saw the impatience in Vyrubova’s expression, but did not understand why she was making such heavy weather of the lies she was telling. “You must ask the household staff.”
“As you wish. May I go over now?”
“No.” She was shocked. “You must write. Apply in writing.”
“To whom?”
“To the household. To Colonel Shulgin. He deals with such matters.”
Ruzsky tried to prevent his exasperation from showing. “Was Ella from Petersburg?”
“No, she wasn’t. Yalta or Sevastopol. Somewhere on the peninsula.”
“How did she come to be employed here?”
“I have no idea. You’ll have to ask the household staff.”
“Did you know the girl well?”
“Ella? No. Not at all.”
“But you gave her one of your dresses?”
“Yes, but… She had not worked here long.”
