by Neil, Louisa
“I don’t have a clue,” she said and swallowed Dexter’s cock again.
Thea didn’t know how long she sucked him or how long Russ ran his hands along her body, but she was starting to lick at the droplets of pre-cum from Dex when she felt Russ lean over her. His hands moved her legs wider apart, and she could feel his fingers lightly rubbing against her pussy lips.
Thea didn’t say a word or stop licking Dex. Instead, she raised her butt a bit higher, giving Russell better access to her holes. He didn’t need a verbal invitation. He dropped over her and began to lick her pussy from behind.
“I’ve always wondered what you’d taste like,” he said more to himself than her as he explored her intimately. He slid his index finger in her pussy and continued to lick around it, thrusting in and out of her body with the same rhythm she was sucking Dex down her throat. She knew she was wiggling her hips to accept his attention deeper in her body. When he slipped a second finger in her pussy, she grabbed Dexter’s balls and brought him to her chin, swallowing him down her throat.
“You’ll make me come, Thea,” Dex said with a groan. She glanced up at him and realized he was watching Russ lick and finger her.
“Christ, you have an amazing ass,” Russ uttered.
She didn’t answer. Russ was licking higher, thrusting the tip of his tongue in her anus in time with his fingers in her pussy. Dexter pulled from her lips and took only two steps to her side, shooting his load on her buttocks. He dropped over her and began to lick his cum from her cheeks. Russell did the same thing on her other side. Thea laid her head down and didn’t watch which man did what to her. Instead, she just felt.
She had fingers in her pussy and two men licking Dexter’s cum from her ass cheeks. Yet she wanted more. In an act of boldness she didn’t know she carried, she shifted until her right hand was under her body. Thea used her own fingers to rub her clit. One man was licking her anus and another was taking long swipes of her pussy. At one point, they lifted her by the hips and slid a rolled-up towel under her, laying her back down. She was much more exposed, the higher position leaving her propped for view and touch.
“Someone, please, finger my ass, too.” She didn’t wait for long. One man’s tongue began to bathe her anus and the tip of his finger slid in her. “More,” she whispered and her wishes were granted.
Thea laid her head back down and tried to imagine what this all looked like. She decided she didn’t care. It was more important that it felt amazing. Both men had large hands, and their fingers were acting as minicocks inside her. Her body was full, her muscles tightening around their fingers when they were both deep inside her. With each push and pull, her body moistened and ached for more. She’d never known a longing like this before. Never considered that two men would make love to her at the same time but so differently.
She knew Russell was to her right and it was his fingers in her pussy. That meant Dexter was on her left, thrusting his finger in her anus. With her own fingers rubbing her clit, Thea came like never before. The growling noise she heard was from her own body. She became insatiable. No matter what they did to her, she wanted more, needed more to find that place of being completely sated.
She wondered what their lives would have been like if they’d started doing this together before the plane crash. Would she and Dex have ever married, or would she want both the men to be with her all along?
While similar, each man had a different technique. With their tongues, their fingers, and their attitudes how they touched her! Finally, she realized Dex was finding himself with her again. He was beginning to take control, his demonstrative side taking over for the quiet man who was so embarrassed all day. This was the Dex she remembered and wanted to fuck. But now she couldn’t wait to get Russell’s cock inside her and feel how he’d fuck her pussy and her ass.
“More,” she said and shifted to allow Russell to slide a third finger in her pussy. Dexter used a second finger in her anus, and she came a second time. “More,” she said again, but pulled from their touch. Thea rolled onto her back and reached to both men. They moved closer to her head without direction. She took a cock in each hand and started to pump them up and down.
“Dex, you still okay with this?” she asked, staring directly at him.
“Yes, as long as you are.”
She didn’t ask again, just turned her head and captured Russell’s cock between her lips. For a long time, she licked his head and bit the underside near his crown. Then she went back to stroking him and sucking Dexter’s cock the same way.
“You’re beautiful,” Dexter said when she was swallowing Russell. “Move your legs apart. I want to see your pussy.” Thea lifted her legs and left them bent at the knee, as wide apart as the table would let her. “You’re glistening,” he said and dropped a hand to her clit. Russell reached forward and grasped her breast, gently at first. She let his cock slide from her lips.
“Harder, pinch my nipple,” she told Russell.
“Anything my queen wants,” he said and began to massage her whole breast, pinching her nipple until it became rock hard.
“Thea, I’m going to come,” Russell told her.
“Dexter, are you close?” she asked, knowing after his first release he could usually hold back for a while.
“Not yet. I want to play some more.”
“Russell, you can come on my tits or pussy, but you have to lick me clean.” Thea decided it was a silent dare, but since she’d already let him lick and finger her to orgasm, what would be the difference if he licked his cum from her tits or pussy?
“Breasts first,” he uttered and pulled his cock from her lips, pumping it only twice before his cum landed on her breasts. “Keep sucking Dexter,” he said, dropping over her and licking his cum from her chest. He used both his hands to massage her tits while he licked her clean.
“Thea, I’m going to come again. Watching this, I can’t hold back. What will get you off?”
“Finger my pussy while he licks my tits.”
“Absolutely,” Dexter said, and she felt his cum land in spurts over her clit and pussy lips. Then he buried his face between her thighs and began to lick her clean. She didn’t have to ask him to use his fingers. He slid them in her pussy and ass at the same time he suckled her clit. With Russell pinching and licking her nipples, she came harder than she’d ever known.
Thea lay back, exhausted. She didn’t know what to say, so all she said was, “Thank you.”
“Thank you,” Russell said, continuing to tweak her nipples. Dexter still had his fingers inside her and was gently pumping her body.
“If you keep that up, you’ll have to do me again.”
Russell was the one to laugh aloud and take a step back. “Honey, if you want me to do you again, I need a drink and a few minutes to recoup.”
“I agree. Rest, and then we’ll figure out how to satisfy you.” Dexter pulled his fingers from her and helped her to rise. “How about a quick turn in the hot tub without the bubbles, and we’ll see where the rest of the night takes us?”
“I thought you’d never ask.” Thea took his help and headed directly to the tub, sliding under the warm water.
Chapter Ten
Thea watched both men saunter toward the tub and held back a smile. While this wasn’t something she’d ever dreamed of, she had to admit it was a heady feeling to have two men giving her all their attention. She’d sucked both their cocks, and they’d licked and fingered her. Now she was curious to feel their cocks fill her body. For the first few minutes they were in the tub, everyone was quiet. Finally, she couldn’t hold back her smile.
“Okay, I’ll say it. That was amazing.”
“I agree. Thank you, Thea.” Russell reached toward her and dropped a kiss on her cheek. He pulled back suddenly. “Dexter, is it okay if I kiss your wife?”
“I’d say we’re beyond asking for permission,” he quipped.
“What about me? Don’t I get a say in this?”
“It’s all about
you, Thea. May I kiss you?” Russell asked Thea.
“Why not? Let’s try it and see where it gets us.” She leaned into his body and put her hands on either side of his face, pressing her lips to his. It didn’t take long before their tongues were battling. She felt herself stirring inside, the heat starting to build again. Pulling from Russ, she turned to Dexter and kissed him. As they kissed, Russ dropped his head to her breast and began to suck her nipple.
“Someone finger me, please.” Her words were muddled as she turned from one man to the other, kissing them full out. Thea let her hands drop under the water and grasped both their cocks. She realized they were both hard and stroked them faster. She spread her legs wide and accepted the fingers probing at her pussy, thrusting her hips forward to take them deeper.
“I’ll say it,” she started, pulling back from both men. “I want to feel your cocks inside me.” She glanced from Dexter to Russell. “No complaints?” she asked and grasped their dicks harder, sliding her fingers up and down each one. Dexter pushed a second finger in her pussy, and Russell reached to play with her breasts.
“Guys, this is fine, but it’s not going to get me off. I need to feel cock inside me.” She let go of them and boosted herself up on the back of the tub. Immediately Russell buried his face between her legs and started to lick her. Dexter reached over him and began to play with her breasts.
“Your nipples are rock hard. You must like the way he’s licking you.”
“I’m enjoying it,” she admitted. “He has a very different technique than you. I’m not saying one is better than the other. You’re both just very different.”
“What would you truly like, Thea?” Dexter held her gaze and smiled. “We’re past being coy. Tell us what you need to get off.”
“I want you both to be inside me.”
That got Russell’s attention, and he paused at her clit. “How?”
“How about the coffee table over there. Russ, you on your back, and I’ll straddle you so you can fill my pussy. Dexter, you behind filling my ass.”
“The lady knows what she wants,” Russell said, rising to leave the tub. He reached a hand to help Thea out and tossed her a towel. He took a second and tossed it to Dexter while dropping another on the tabletop. He lay back with his ass at the edge, pulling on his cock. Thea paused to watch him and he stopped.
“Don’t stop. You move so differently than Dexter does. I want to watch.”
“I thought you wanted to fuck,” Dexter said from behind, his laugh genuine.
“I want both,” she told him and nudged him to sit beside Russell. “Go ahead, stroke yourself,” she promoted, using the towel to blot water from her skin. “Russell, you’re much more intense than Dexter.”
“Wouldn’t you be under the circumstances?”
“I suppose so. Look, you’re both bringing up droplets of cum. Russ, lay back and let me climb on.” He did as she asked, guiding her by the waist, and she seated her pussy on his cock. “God, you’re thick,” she said, shifting around until she had him in her sweet spot. “Dex, you ready?”
“Are you?” he asked. “Are you wet enough?”
“I think so,” she said but waited impatiently while he dropped to his knees behind her and started to lick her anus. “Go ahead, Dexter, you can lick his cock, too. I can feel you trying to just stay on me, but it’s like you want to lick both of us. Do it.”
He took her advice and settled behind her, licking her anus and her pussy impaled on Russell’s cock. He dropped down farther and licked Russell’s testicles for a bit, too. Then he used his hand to lift them and licked at Russell’s anus.
“Thea, if you keep squirming, I’ll shoot my load on your ass instead of in you.” Dexter’s tone was teasing but serious.
“Then come inside me,” she said, glancing over her shoulder to watch him reposition himself behind her. “Russ, squeeze my breasts. Take them both in your hands and pump them as hard as you can. You won’t hurt me.”
They paused when they felt Dexter’s cock trying to push in her body. “Thea, I don’t think so,” he said.
“Think of me as a virgin. You just have to push past the resistance and then fuck my brains out until I can’t come anymore.”
“Grab some oil.” Russ suggested. “The bottle’s by the massage table.”
Thea continued to rise and lower her body over Russell’s cock, feeling the difference in how he felt inside her. When she dropped her weight completely, he’d throb inside her and her pussy would grasp at him. She watched Dexter move beside them and let some of the oil drip onto his cock. He used his own hand to fist it a few times before repositioning himself behind them. She knew Dex was behind her, his finger covering her anus with the oil. Finally, when she thought he’d never do it, she felt him move closer. He used one hand at her waist to steady her and the other to hold his cock as he nudged at her anus.
“That’s an interesting analogy,” Russell said through gritted teeth. “I guess we’re all virgins in this tonight.”
“Then make me want more,” she said and thrust back to meet Dexter’s push. His cock wedged in her ass, and after several moments to steady his breathing, he pushed farther, his cockhead embedded in her anus. “Damn, you’re huge in my ass,” she told him as she glanced back. “You’re on top, so you start the rhythm.”
“Yes, ma’am,” he said, grasping her hips and taking her and Russell on the ride of their lives. He fucked them slow then fast, keeping the pace uneven. Thea felt her body starting to heat with need at the strokes he was taking.
“We should have thought to slip something in Russell’s butt so he’d be getting fucked too.” Thea’s offhand comment got her a nod from Russell.
“Next time,” Russ said with a wicked smile. “And Dexter’s, too.”
“What is that smile about?” she asked. “What am I missing?”
“Just that there are toys to be utilized for a case like this.” Russ winked at her.
“Tomorrow we’ll shop for some.” Thea’s words were almost breathless. “There was a lingerie shop in town. I’ll bet they have some toys or dildos.”
“So tomorrow we’re shopping for toys?” Dexter questioned, laughing at her statement.
“Well, the way I figure it, we can only fuck so many times a day, so lunch and some shopping will give us a break and something new to play with tomorrow night.”
“I’m glad to hear there will be a tomorrow night,” Dexter said.
“So am I,” Russ said, “but, guys, I’m gonna lose my load. Thea, your pussy was tight with just me inside you, but with him in your ass, I can’t hold back much longer.” Russell dropped his hands from her breasts and grabbed the side of the table, holding himself in place.
“Dexter, reach around and pinch my nipples.” He did as she asked, and she groaned aloud. “God, I’ve missed you. Don’t ever leave me again, Dexter.”
“No way, my aqua queen.”
“I bet you never thought to experience the three of us this way?” Her words were paused between uneven breaths.
“Only in my dreams,” Dexter told her and pinched harder.
“I can’t…” Russell said, his hips bucking upward.
Thea could feel the heat of his release inside her. She felt him relax under her, his cum starting to slip out of her pussy and onto his thighs. Thea grabbed Dexter’s hands and pushed them harder against her breasts.
“Oh,” she groaned and tightened her muscles around his cock.
“Christ, Thea, you feel like a vise,” he said and pumped into her only twice more before letting his body release, his cum shooting in her ass. “Thanks,” Dexter said, his head dropping on her shoulder.
“I’m starting to lose you,” she said, and he finally pulled from her body and stood behind her. He steadied her at the waist while she lifted up and off of Russell.
“What a sight, Thea. Your hair is mussed, your nipples are hard, your breasts are swollen, and you’ve got our cum dripping from your pussy and ass.”
“Not a bad first time, if you ask me.” She headed toward the shower and paused. “At least we don’t have to worry about all the laundry,” she said with a laugh. She turned on the water and looked back to her two men. Yes, that was how she was thinking about them now. They were both her men. “I’m starved. Anyone interested in food after we shower?”
She got two positive answers and found herself smiling when rinsing her body. She was tender to the touch in some places and others were chafed. She didn’t care. It was the best she’d felt in a long time.
There was no conversation as they stood around the counter taking forkfuls of apple pie from the pie plate. They were all wrapped in terry robes, all with wet hair. From the yawns around her, they were all equally exhausted. Thea was the first one to put down her fork.
“I’ve had enough,” she said. “I’m going to bed, to sleep.” She took a few steps toward her bedroom and paused. “Either of you going to join me?”
“Maybe Dexter would rather you two slept alone.”
“Maybe Dexter should have thought about that before he started fucking you. You both said I’m the queen, so I’m making an executive decision. I want to sleep surrounded by both my men.” She just walked away, leaving the two men alone to make their own decisions.
“Dex, what are you thinking? Are you sorry we started this?” Russell didn’t meet his friend’s gaze.
“No, I’m not. Are you upset that it wasn’t like it always was between us?”
“Hell no. I’ve told you from the start I’ve always wanted to be with both of you. We’ll work out the logistics with time,” Russell told him, taking the last bit of pie from his fork. “She’s right. I’m exhausted but sated.”
“Me, too. Did you ever think when we were on the island that she’d let us both do her?”
“Only in my dreams, buddy, only in my dreams.” They headed toward the bedroom, and Dexter paused.
“Did you notice she wanted to watch us masturbate earlier? I’ll bet soon she’ll want to watch us suck each other.”
“And maybe watch us fuck.”
