The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels

Home > Nonfiction > The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels > Page 23
The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels Page 23

by Alex Epstein

quality of, 13, 21, 194–95

  transformation of, 32, 85, 200–202

  as wilderness, 170

  Environmental Defense Fund, 136

  ethanol, 12, 56, 68

  experts:

  as advisers, not authorities, 26–28, 92, 135

  combined knowledge of, 28

  dire forecasts of, 4, 6–8, 33

  focus on negative outcomes, 15, 18, 25

  in real-estate bubble, 27

  what they don’t know, 27, 93, 113–14

  extinction, 173–74

  Fallon, Jimmy, 45

  false-attribution fallacy, 163–66

  famine, 80

  farming, see agriculture

  Fenton, John, 162

  fertilization, 82–83, 116

  fertilizer effect, 92, 114–17, 115, 138

  fleas, 146

  flood control, 130–31

  floods, deaths from, 23, 121, 124, 124

  food prices, 56–57, 57

  food production, 81–82, 126

  fossil fuel industry:

  author’s recommendations to, 202–6

  Green movement vs., 191, 194–200

  in jeopardy, 190–91

  as moral industry, 201, 205, 206

  prejudice against, 135–36, 193–94, 198–200

  thanks to, 140

  fossil fuels, 65–88

  addiction to, 3, 5–6

  alternatives to, 12, 46, 58

  benefits of use, 4–5, 16–25, 92, 100, 137, 143, 181, 193

  bias against, 29

  complex interdisciplinary questions about, 27–28

  from dead plants, 65–66, 114, 151

  energy from burning of, 2–3, 97,

  114

  and the environment, 85–86, 175–76, 198

  extraction of, 18, 66, 139

  future uses of, 182–86, 207–8

  hidden and trapped, 66, 73

  and human progress, 77–78, 77, 119–20, 137

  as hydrocarbons, 67, 68

  and life expectancy, 13, 14, 15, 30, 77–78, 77, 119–20

  as moral choice, 13, 30, 33–35

  and more resources, 16–19

  as necessary for life, 88

  as nonrenewable, 6, 8

  pollution from, see pollution

  reliability of, 12

  restricting use of, 3–4, 8, 9, 10, 26,

  30, 58

  risks and side effects of, 15, 26, 28–29, 92, 134, 151–54, 156–59

  in underdeveloped nations, 136–37

  use of term, 66

  worldwide use of, 10, 11–13, 11

  Fox, Josh, Gasland, 162–63

  fracking, 26, 70, 161

  and abuse-use fallacy, 162–63

  and “artificial” fallacy, 168–69

  and false-attribution fallacy, 163–64

  and no-threshold fallacy, 167–68

  freighters, 82

  Friedman, David, 110

  Friedman, Milton, 42

  Fukushima nuclear accident, 62

  G7 countries, climate-related deaths in, 124–25, 125

  Gambia, The, 38–39, 40, 50, 78, 197

  gas:

  fertilization, 82

  natural, see natural gas

  supply issues of, 69

  gasoline, burning, 66, 159

  gasoline engines, 71

  GDP, 77, 78

  genetic science, 81

  Germany:

  air quality in, 165

  solar and wind in, 50–55, 51, 52

  global cooling, 21

  global greening, 114–17

  global warming:

  beneficial, 138

  clarifying the questions of, 91–92

  focus on, 21–23, 23, 89–91

  and greenhouse effect, 99

  97 percent fabrication, 109–11

  overpredictions of, 102

  Goklany, Indur, 23

  Gore, Al, 132, 194

  An Inconvenient Truth, 106

  Graber, David M., 30–31, 197

  Great Recession, 102

  greenhouse effect, 7, 90, 96–104

  and climate change, 21–22, 23, 91–93, 96, 99, 106–8, 107

  computer models of, 100–104, 102, 103, 138

  diminishing effect of, 98–99, 98

  discoverers of, 108

  fear of, 96

  logarithmic, 108

  positive feedback loop of, 99

  use of term, 92

  what it is, 97–98

  Green movement, 191, 194–200

  green revolution, 82, 83

  guano, 82

  Haber, Fritz, 83

  Hansen, James E.:

  on the evils of fossil fuel companies, 135–36

  failed models of, 102, 102

  on greenhouse effect, 7, 22, 96

  happiness, pursuit of, 84–85, 133

  hazelnuts, as energy source, 45–47, 55, 56

  health trends, 174–76, 174

  heavy metals, 154, 168

  Holdren, John, 8, 9, 179, 194

  Holocene era, 127

  Hull, Gary, 189

  human beings:

  adaptability of, 127, 132, 171

  calories needed by, 40

  impact of, 94, 126

  ingenuity of, 18–19, 41, 170, 181

  perspective of, 85

  weakness of, 40

  human life:

  environmental nonimpact of, 31–32, 197

  flourishing, 13, 85, 87, 119–20, 175

  protecting, 25

  as standard of value, 30, 60, 84, 85, 88, 92, 114, 136, 173, 197, 201

  hunger, 80–81

  hurricanes, 24, 25, 106, 125

  hydraulic fracturing, see fracking

  hydrocarbons, 67, 68

  hydroelectric power:

  limitations of, 59–60

  opponents of, 54, 60, 135

  reliability of, 12, 59

  as supplement, 44

  hydrofluoric acid, 154

  hydrogen atoms, 66, 196

  Ice Age, return to, 21

  ideas:

  in history, 184

  track records of, 5

  Idso, Craig, 111, 114

  Idso, Sherwood, 114

  income:

  and fossil fuel use, 13, 14, 15

  as leading indicator of human flourishing, 119–20

  India:

  Chipko movement in, 32–33

  fossil fuels used in, 13, 14, 15, 67, 137

  infant mortality in, 15

  technological progress in, 137

  transportation to, 82

  Indonesia, prosperity in, 100, 127

  industrialization, 125, 131, 137

  industrial progress, 200–202

  Industrial Revolution, 78, 152

  infant mortality, 15, 67, 128, 174–75, 174

  infrared absorbers, 97

  insects, disease-carrying, 128, 142, 145–46, 173

  Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), 3, 26, 130, 147

  intermittency, 48, 50–53, 65

  internal combustion engine, 68, 132

  Internationl Energy Agency, 28

  irrigation, 83, 123, 126, 128

  Jackson, Lisa, 164

  Japan:

  Fukushima accident in, 62

  tsunami in, 130

  jet engines, 71

  Jevons, William Stanley, The Coal Question, 78–79

  Kennedy, Robert F. Jr., 192

  Kenya, electricity in, 53–54

  kerosene, 73
<
br />   Kerry, John, 87, 100, 109, 127

  Keystone XL pipeline, 9, 190

  knowledge, integration of, 28, 33, 113–14, 183

  Krupp, Fred, 136

  land:

  for farming, 56, 81–82

  and rising sea levels, 130–31

  scarcity of, 46, 178

  lice, 146

  life, and energy, 37–39

  life expectancy:

  and climate livability, 128

  and fossil fuel use, 13, 14, 15, 30, 77–78, 77, 119–20

  as leading indicator of human flourishing, 119–20

  and natural environment, 86

  rising, 174–76, 174

  Life magazine, 7

  Lindzen, Richard, 90

  liquid fuel, 55, 68

  Lovins, Amory, 9, 12, 194, 196

  machine calories, 40–42

  Maddison, Angus, 77

  malaria, 145–47

  malnutrition, 15, 174–75, 174

  manure, 82

  McKibben, Bill, 135, 178, 197

  debate with author, 5, 187–91

  dire forecasts of, 8, 22, 108, 127

  Eaarth, 31–32

  The End of Nature, 30–31, 108

  influence of, 9, 189–90, 194

  on outlawing fossil fuels, 9, 189

  mechanization, oil-powered, 81

  media:

  dramatic stories in, 164–65

  on pollution, 6–7, 8

  mercury, 165–66

  methane, 83

  methanol, 68

  methyl alcohol, 68

  Michaels, Patrick, 90

  Miliband, David, 178

  mobility, 132–33, 171

  models, see computer models

  Monterey Shale, California, 191

  morality, 13

  mosquitoes, 145–46

  Mother Nature, 86, 128, 129

  NASA, on temperature change, 22

  natural gas:

  availability of, 17, 18, 178

  consumption of, 11, 18, 44, 44

  drilling of, 74

  energy from, 3, 66, 69–70

  and fracking, 70

  LNG terminals, 70

  methane, 83

  and peak-load electricity, 69

  reliability of, 12

  resources required for production of, 49–50, 49

  and safety, 159

  nature:

  enjoyment of, 170

  hazards of, 176

  nonimpact on, 194, 195, 199

  preservation of, 32, 171–73

  pristine, 30

  transformation of, 129

  Neff, Wes, 190

  neodymium, 49

  Netherlands, sea level in, 130–31, 134

  Newcomen, Thomas, 141

  New Scientist, 45

  New York Times, 80

  97 percent fabrication, 109–11

  nitrogen:

  and coal, 154, 168

  plant absorption of, 82, 93

  synthetic, 83

  nitrogen oxides, 68

  no-threshold fallacy, 166–68

  nuclear fusion, 195–96

  nuclear power, 59, 61–63, 135, 195

  government control of, 62–63

  opponents of, 9, 54

  reliability of, 12

  resources required for production of, 49–50, 49

  and safety, 61–62, 159, 168

  as supplement, 44

  Obama, Barack, 109, 206–7

  oil:

  availability of, 17, 17, 178

  consumption of, 11, 17, 44, 44

  crude, 73

  energy from, 3, 61, 71–72

  exploration and extraction of,

  71, 152

  portability of, 71, 72

  as raw material, 72, 73, 74

  and resource creation, 73

  shale, 71

  spills, 159

  strength to weight ratio of, 71

  as transportation fuel, 68, 70, 71, 81–82

  oil sands (tar sands), 26, 71

  oil wells, first, 73

  oxygen, 93

  Paracelsus, 166

  Parry, Simon, 155–56

  peat, 131

  Phelps, Michael, 40, 41

  philosophy, study of, 5

  phosphorus, 49

  photosynthesis, 55

  plants:

  and CO2, 92, 114–17, 115, 208

  dead, 65–66, 114, 151

  energy from, see biomass

  poisonous, 168

  plastics, raw material for, 69, 74, 154

  poisons, 62, 166–68

  polar melt, 4, 130

  polls, limited value of, 27

  pollution:

  catastrophic, 16

  legislation of, 160–61

  media stories about, 6–7, 8

  overregulation of, 158

  reduction of, 19, 19, 149–50, 156–59, 199

  risks and side effects of, 151–54, 153, 165

  smog, 20, 79, 143, 152, 158

  polymers, 74

  population, growth of, 15, 77–78, 77, 121

  positive feedback loops, 99–100

  Powder River Basin, Wyoming, 192

  power:

  cost of, 8–9, 63

  definition of, 41

  and energy, 41

  out of control, 152, 159

  rationed use of, 9

  see also specific sources

  precipitation, 93

  predators, threat from, 128

  quantification, use of term, 110

  radiation, 97, 168

  radiation poisoning, 62

  radioactive metals, 61

  radioactive waste, 47

  railroads, 82

  Rand, Ayn, Atlas Shrugged, 138–39

  rare-earth elements, 49, 154–55

  Reiter, Paul, 146–47

  religion, standard of value in, 30

  renewability, 181

  resources:

  creation of, 18–19, 73, 75, 180–82, 185, 195

  depletion of, 8, 16, 179

  evolution of, 75–76

  increases in, 16–19, 181–82

  proven reserves of, 17, 17

  underpredicted availability of,

  17–18

  Ridley, Matt, The Rational Optimist, 81

  Rifkin, Jeremy, 196

  risks:

  and alternatives, 43

  and benefits, 15, 28–29, 134

  dire forecasts of, 16, 18, 21

  media attention on, 15

  minimizing, 43, 159–60

  Rockefeller, John D., 74

  Rokita, Todd, 29

  Rolling Stone, 108, 189

  Russia, gas from, 69

  sanitation systems, 21, 142, 147–49, 148

  SASOL, 68

  Saturday Night Live, 45

  Scafetta, Nicola, 111

  scalability, 56–57, 63, 65, 86–87

  Schneider, Stephen, 111

  scientific method:

  ethical bind in, 112

  and hypothesis presented as fact, 113

  sea levels, rising, 4, 95, 106, 107, 130–31

  shale energy technology, 191, 207; see also fracking

  shale oil, 71

  Shaviv, Nir, 111

  Shikwati, James, 54

  silicon, 49

  Silliman, Benjamin Jr., 73

  SkepticalScience.com, 110

  slavery, 41

  smog, 20, 79, 143, 152, 158

  Socrates, 91
r />   solar cells, 47

  solar power:

  backup required for, 53

  concentrated solar power (CSP), 47–48

  cost of, 46

  cutting-edge promise of, 12

  diluteness of, 48–50, 49, 65

  energy from, 3

  in Germany, 50–55, 51, 52

  inadequacy as energy source, 57–58, 135

  intermittency problem of, 48, 50–53, 65

  niche uses for, 58

  process of producing, 46

  solar photovoltaic (solar PV), 47

  supporters of, 9

  unreliability of, 12

  world use of, 11, 12, 44, 44

  specialists, specialization, 27, 71, 112–14

  standard of value, 29–33, 136, 195, 201; see also human life

  Standard Oil, 74

  statistics:

  about disasters, 120–26, 121–25

  cherry-picking, 54

  computer models, 100–104, 102, 103, 108, 138

  explicit endorsement without qualification, 110–11

  hindcasting with, 101, 103

  limited value of polls, 27

  manipulation of, 17, 29, 99, 108, 109, 111–12

  political uses of, 109

  satellite data, 120

  speculative models, 164–65

  steam engine, 68, 74, 141, 142, 184

  storm energy, 105, 105

  storms, deaths from, 23, 121, 123–25, 123, 125, 128

  storm walls, 131

  sugarcane, energy from, 56

  sulfur, 154, 168

  sulfur dioxide, 47, 68, 158

  sun, infrared radiation from, 97

  sunlight, see solar power

  Superstorm Sandy, 24, 25

  supply and demand, 75

  sustainability, 177–79, 180–81

  synthetics, 72, 83

  technology:

  abuse of, 162–63

  and climate livability, 126–29, 133, 137

  development of, 18

  energy needed to run, 129

  energy needs met by, 34, 128–29, 172–73

  opponents of, 196–97

  solutions via, 134–35, 156–59, 207

  technophobia, 164

  temperature inversion, 158

  temperatures:

  and CO2, 22, 23, 108

  deaths from, 23, 121

  excessive, 128

  and greenhouse effect, 22, 97, 102–3

  rising, 7, 22, 104

  and weather, 93

  Tesla Roadster, 72

  thorium, 61

  3D seismic imaging, 71

  Three Mile Island, 62

  time, 172, 183, 185–86

  titanium dioxide, 49

  Tol, Richard, 111

  transformation, as moral ideal,

  200–202

  transportation:

  cost of, 82

  high-energy, 128

  improved, 123

  travel, 84–85

  trucks, 82

  tsunamis, 130, 142

  tuberculosis, 145, 146, 175

  Turkey, hazelnuts grown in, 46

  underdeveloped nations, 136–37

 

‹ Prev