by Luxx Monroe
Just as we were getting into what we did for fun, which I assumed for her was studying, her phone chimed and she ran over to retrieve it.
“It’s from Mandy. She says the snow is finally letting up in Boston, but the highways are closed all around the outskirts of the city. I guess it’s bad, and most of the Northwest got hit by this storm. Shit, Connecticut is shut down as well. Looks like it may be a while before we get out of here.”
I didn’t know why, but for some reason, I wasn’t ready to say goodbye to Sutton. I knew the minute our lives went back to normal, I probably wouldn’t see her again. I wouldn’t see her amazing body or that ripe pussy, which for some reason I had a feeling it was made specifically for my cock.
Quickly pushing back those thoughts, I decided I would make the most out of our time together. “Want to watch a movie? Then we better turn off the generator and save it for tomorrow.”
Sutton smiled and rinsed off our plates with some of our melted snow. “What do you want to watch?”
“Something bloody with zombies and guts. You know, a guy show.” I wiggled my eyebrows at her and let out a loud laugh. Damn, this felt good, just to relax and have fun. I had been so uptight for the past few years that I honestly forgot what it felt like.
Rolling her eyes, she tried to flick some dirty water at me. “No way. I won’t be able to sleep. Do you have The Notebook?”
I stopped in my tracks and stared at her. “You’re fucking kidding me? We are not watching The fucking Notebook.”
I could see a playful smile curl at the edge of her mouth. “What’s wrong with The Notebook? It’s a classic.”
An idea popped into my mind, and I had the perfect way to solve our problem. Well, that and I felt like a damn teenager again when I was around Sutton, because all I could think about was getting her naked. “Well, since we both want to watch something completely different, how about we make a little bet?”
I noticed one of Sutton’s eyebrows raise, and I knew I had her. “Okay, what kind of bet?”
Slowly, I walked over to her as she dried her hands on a dishcloth. Eyes widening, she started to back up. “Come here.” I motioned my finger for her to come my way.
She hesitated for a second, but then switched gears and took a few steps toward me.
I reached out, cupped her cheeks with my hands, and brought her face to mine. When my lips touched hers, I could feel a spark ignite my body. This girl was doing strange things to me, but I liked it. A lot. When I pulled back, I could see the desire in her eyes. I knew I was probably going to lose the bet I was about to propose, but hell, I didn’t give one shit. “I want to have a face-off, so to speak. Let’s get you out of your shell and see who can give the other person the most earth-shattering orgasm. What do you say?”
Sutton started to breathe hard and looked me up and down. “Can we do it with your shirt off?”
I leaned my head back and laughed, not expecting that answer at all. “It’s a no-clothing contract.”
Sutton shivered when I reached out and grabbed her around her waist, pulling her nightshirt over her head. All she had on underneath were very short pajama bottoms and a little see-through white bra. I couldn’t help myself when I leaned over her and sucked one of her nipples into my mouth. We both moaned at the different sensations. The soft cloth was instantly drench, and I felt her back bow, giving me better access.
I pulled back and picked her up, so her legs wrapped around my waist, pushing my now erect cock right into the spot I was about to ravish the hell out of.
Placing her down on the kitchen table should have been gentle and sweet, but I was not in the mood to wait. It had been a few hours since I had my mouth on her wet cunt, and I needed to do it again.
“Let’s see if I remember what you look like.”
Sutton giggled and helped me shimmy her out of her panties, then reached back and unclipped her bra.
I also ripped my shirt off and was in just my boxers in seconds. I grabbed her legs and threw them over my shoulder, not wasting one second. “Now, remember, whoever makes the other person admit who gave the other the most Earth-shattering orgasm, wins.”
Sutton’s head snapped up, but then she threw it back when I went straight for her clit, which was already soaking wet. I sucked her in and took in her sweet scent. I could do this for days. “Goddamn, your pussy is amazing.”
Just as I was about to reach up and start working my magic with my fingers, Sutton quickly pushed me off her and jumped off the table. I almost thought I’d said the wrong thing, or offended her, but when she shot me one of the most seductive smiles I’d ever seen, I knew I was in trouble.
“I really want to watch The Notebook, so shut up and let me take this home.”
My eyes must have been bulging out of my head, because when Sutton pulled down my boxers, exposing my huge hard-on, I knew I was done for.
Chapter 9
Sutton
I was in the zone and I was going to kick the hell out of this bet. I may have not really known what the hell I was doing, but I had a pretty experienced roommate who had told me a few tips and secrets here and there. “Now, let me show you how it’s done.”
I heard Chase’s breath hitch when I leaned down and licked the tip of his dick. “Mmm, you taste good, too.”
Chase reached down and pulled the hair tie from my loose braid. I could feel my long locks fall free, and I loved it when his hands laced through my hair and gave it a quick tug. The pain only lasted for a second, only to be replaced by a new want. I wanted to make him lose it, to show him I could match him.
I remembered Mandy saying that cupping the man’s balls was a must and a blowjob was more about sucking than licking. I decided to go for it, like a champ, and when I took him in completely, I heard his holler and felt him tighten in my grip. I finally reached up and cupped his balls, sucking as I pulled my mouth off his hard cock. I was in the zone; I was owning this moment.
“Fuck, Sutton. That feels so damn good. Are you sure you’ve—?”
I shut him up when I sucked one of his nuts in my mouth and made a loud popping sound when I pulled back. Another trick I’d heard about. “Shut up and let me do my thing.”
Chase laughed and didn’t say another word as I sucked and pulled on his dick. I could feel him swell further, and I wondered if he was close. Only, just as I was getting ready for his ejaculation, he reached down and picked me up, throwing me over his shoulder.
“What the hell are you doing?”
Chase let out a low grunt and carried me into his living room, setting me down next to the couch. “I want to taste you, but I don’t want you to stop giving me the best fucking blow job I’ve ever had.”
I smiled with pride, not knowing if he was telling me the truth, or just trying to make me feel good at the moment. I didn’t care either way.
“I’m going to lie down on the couch, and you’re going to lay on top of me. Sixty-nine, baby.” He gave me a wink, and I almost started to get nervous. Almost. I decided, What the hell? You only live once.
I watched as Chase laid down on the couch and I got a good look at his body. He wasn’t a bulky guy, but he was most definitely in shape. His cut abs and come-fuck-me lines led straight down to his perfect, erect cock. I started to feel a little self-conscious about my soft curves, but hoped that he preferred that in a woman. Although with his line of work, he was probably use to those stick-skinny models in New York.
He interrupted my thoughts when he pulled me over to him, and judging by the look in his eyes he liked what he saw. “Come here, let’s get this bet going.”
I gasped when he placed me right over his face and started to lick and suck on my pussy. “Holy, man, that feels good.”
I looked at his eager dick and leaned down, opening myself more to him then took him into my mouth. The sensations were amazing. Him on me, and me on him. It was my first sixty-nine and I was loving every minute of it. It only took what felt like seconds before we were both moaning thr
ough our releases. I drank him up as he took me in, and when I turned around to collapse on his chest, I wasn’t sure how a winner was going to be decided.
“You won,” we both said at the same exact time.
Chase chuckled and sat up, as I wiped my mouth and smiled at him. I was having fun, actual honest-to-God fun. Sure I was being a dirty little ho, but I didn’t give a crap. Mandy was right, letting lose and having an actual orgasm was just what the doctor ordered, but I couldn’t help and wonder if I would still be able to have the big O when it came to sex.
I also knew that Chase and I would go our separate ways once this blizzard was under control, and the snow had been plowed. This thought was depressing for some reason, so I pushed it aside and decided to live in the moment.
I pushed off Chase, and walked over to retrieve my shorts and shirt, then slowly put them back on, feeling my insecurities start to emerge. I decided it would be awkward to sit and watch a movie with Chase now, and I laughed at the irony because his mouth had just been on a very intimate area. Twice.
“That was amazing, and I’m taking the win, but I think I’m going to call it a night. Maybe we can argue about a movie tomorrow?”
Chase raked his eyes over me, and I could tell he was a little confused about my sudden change in mood.
“Okay, if that’s what you want. Just know that this doesn’t need to feel weird. We’re just messing around and having fun.”
I knew that’s how he felt. But the more time I spent with Chase, the more I understood that he would be hard to replace out in the real world.
I wiggled my eyebrows and put on a good front. “I know, I’m having a great time. I’m just tired. I’ll see you in the morning and we can check on the animals?”
Chase smiled and nodded, but it wasn’t as genuine as I was hoping.
We didn’t say another word as I decided it was time to go to Mandy’s room. It was going to be a very long night, because all I could think about was Chase’s perfect cock deep inside of me. I had a feeling that I didn’t truly belong to the no orgy during sex club, and I secretly couldn’t wait to test my new theory out with him.
Chapter 10
Chase
I didn’t know how in the hell I was going to get any sleep when I knew an extremely hot girl with a body that drove me crazy was just down the hall. I could feel my cock getting hard again and knew I was in trouble. I had tried to alleviate some pressure, two times actually, and nothing. My dick was on strike, because he only had one thing in mind: Sutton.
I looked over at the clock on my nightstand, and grunted when it had only changed by two minutes since the last time I’d looked. It was the middle of the night, and I was seriously contemplating sneaking into Sutton’s bed. What the hell was wrong with me?
I’d almost decided it was time to close my eyes and get some sleep when I heard a little commotion out in the hall. I turned and looked through the open doorway, catching a figure walking by. I held my breath, wondering if Sutton was facing the same dilemma, but then slowly exhaled when the figure was gone and I could hear footsteps on the stairs. Damn. I started to think maybe she was starting to second-guess our time together. I also knew that if she backed out from letting me give her the best orgasm of her life with my dick, that my member would be on strike for a long fucking time.
Deciding to make sure everything was okay, I stepped out of bed and looked down at my stiff cock pitching a tent in my boxer-briefs. I told myself I didn’t give a shit. I wanted Sutton to see the affect she had on me.
When I walked down the stairs, I could see Sutton standing by the sink in the kitchen. I debated if I should bother her, but when I finally saw what she was wearing, I stopped dead in my tracks and felt my dick grow even more. Fuck me.
I knew I had probably overheated the house with the fire I had going in the fire place, but I wasn’t expecting to see Sutton in a little see through nighty, clearly not wearing anything underneath.
I couldn’t wait anymore. I needed her like I needed my next breath.
I knew she hadn’t heard me yet, so when I snuck up behind her and placed my hands around her waist, she let out a startled cry, but relaxed when she realized it was just me.
“Couldn’t sleep?” I asked, moving my hands forward, inching down her stomach. I loved the feeling of Sutton’s curves. I realized then that I hadn’t been with a natural woman in such a long time, I’d almost forgotten what one felt like. I couldn’t even think of the last time I felt honest-to-God curves and not boney hips. I loved it. I couldn’t get enough.
Sutton didn’t say a word, but I knew I had her attention as I was getting closer to the spot I couldn’t get out of my mind. “Well, I couldn’t. I can’t stop thinking about you.”
Sutton sucked in a little breath. Placing one of my hands on her thigh, I pushed her legs apart and inched my way up. When I felt how dripping wet she was, I knew it was only a matter of minutes until I would be inside her.
She laid her head back against me and moaned when I finally pushed one of my fingers inside her. Closing her eyes, she pushed her ass into my rigid cock. “Is it crazy that I couldn’t sleep because all I could think about was you? You coming into my bed and having your way with me? That’s why I’m wearing this, because I was hoping you’d come to me. I don’t know who I am, but I can’t stop thinking about it—about us.”
Her words turned me on more than her slick, wet folds, and I couldn’t help myself when I leaned down and sucked on her neck. I wanted to leave the largest mark possible, so when she woke up in the morning, she would remember what I’d done to her. How I made her feel. I pulled back and pushed another finger into her. “Me neither. I didn’t know if you still wanted that, or trust me, baby, I would have been in there hours ago.”
“I do. I want you more than anything I’ve ever wanted. I want you to show me how much I’ve been missing out on all these years. Show me, Chase.”
That’s all I needed to hear. I pulled my fingers out of her and pushed her nightgown up over her ass. “You have such an amazing body. I can’t wait to know every inch of it.”
I bent down and spread her legs even farther apart, causing her to grip the edge of the counter in front of her. When I gripped her ass and lifted it so I was able to lick her sensitive clit that was calling my name. Sutton moaned, but then pushed off the counter and reached down to slip her nightgown over hear head. I could tell this was new to her, hooking up with someone who she wasn’t in a relationship with, and I appreciated her boldness. “Damn,” I said quietly and stood back up, cupping her heavy breasts. “I also love your boobs.”
She giggled and leaned forward again, pushing her ass to me. I reached down and removed my own underwear, freeing my member, which was as eager as I was to get this started.
“I just want you inside me. Now.”
Well, I wasn’t going to argue with her; I spread her legs apart, and just as the tip of my dick hit her wet entrance, I gasped and realized I’d almost forgotten something. “Dammit, a condom. I think I have some upstairs.”
I was just about to pull away, when she turned around and wrapped her hand around my cock. “I’m on the pill and I’m clean. After I found out my boyfriend of two years was screwing half of his employees, I decided I needed to get a check-up.”
I stared into her eyes and wondered what kind of idiot would cheat on a girl like Sutton. She was the complete package, which only came around once in a lifetime. I was shocked by my own thoughts, but pushed them aside. What she was really telling me was I had permission to go bare—something I’d never done.
“Are you sure? I mean, I’m clean too, but this is something we can’t come back from.”
One nod was all it took, and I had her spun around, gripping the sink within second. I hadn’t imagined our first time would be in the kitchen from behind, but I couldn’t wait one more second.
I lined up my dick and was almost inside her when I realized I needed it to be different. “I want to see you.”
Sutton let out a breath and turned around. I leaned forward and placed my lips on hers as I gently lifted her so she could wrap her legs around my waist. When my dick slid through her slickness to her entrance, I thought I was going to lose it right then and there. I held on and started walking us toward the stairs. I knew we’d be more comfortable in a bed, and I couldn’t wait to give her first orgasm while having sex. I honestly didn’t know if it would be this time, or next. I had a feeling I wasn’t going to last very long.
“Let’s take this upstairs,” I grunted while trying to hold on to my control until we made it upstairs so I could have a better look at her naked body.
As I rounded the corner into the living room and headed for the stairs, I caught a glimpse of the rug in front of the fire. It looked so inviting, I changed my mind.
“Change of plans. I’m not going to make it upstairs. Besides, you’ll look amazing while I fuck you by the fire.”
Sutton moaned when I lifted her up so her taut nipple was aimed right at my mouth. I sucked her in and her legs tighten around me. Damn, she felt amazing.
“This feels so good,” Sutton slurred, like she was losing her mind and trying to stay with me. I loved that I was doing this to her.
“You haven’t felt anything yet. Hold on.”
I gently laid Sutton down in the middle of the rug directly in front of the fireplace, and the glow that illuminated her face made her look breathtaking. I kicked myself for not being closer to my sister, because there was a chance I could have met Sutton earlier.
I looked at her one last time before I braced my arms by her head and gave her one hell of a kiss. I slowly entered her and had to close my eyes. I couldn’t believe how different this felt without a condom. I was always so careful. I never took chances, but for some reason, with Sutton it was different.
When I opened my eyes, she was looking up at me, and I completely lost it. She was so beautiful by the fire, and I needed to hear her scream my name. “You look so fucking amazing right now.”
