by Philip Dray
If anyone thought Sumner would similarly acknowledge reality and fall in line behind the president, they received a rude shock on the last day of May 1872, weeks before the Republican convention, when the New Englander unloaded another barrage against Grant on the floor of the Senate. For four hours he lambasted the party's standard-bearer as inept, corrupt, and ignorant of the workings of democratic government. Referring to a comparison that someone in the Senate had made between Grant and George Washington, the nation's first president, Sumner listed the current chief executive's distinctions: "first in nepotism, first in present-taking, and first in every species of diplomatic blundering." Accusing Grant of wasting his time on fast horses, expensive carriages, and vacationing at seaside resorts, he declared, "I protest against him as radically unfit for the presidential office!"
Republican loyalists were again deeply troubled by Sumner's antics, for earlier that month a breakaway faction, the Liberal Republicans, had convened in Cincinnati to declare their intention to deny Grant another term. Their pet cause was the overturning of the spoils system—the patronage and nepotism for which Grant was well known. But just as they decried the handing of lucrative offices to those who did not merit them, so did they speak out against the continuing "spoils" of war in the South—the restrictions on once-rebellious Southerners and the "favoritism" shown the freedmen. The movement's leaders—Senators Carl Schurz and Lyman Trumbull, the feminist orator Anna Dickinson, and the influential journalists Murat Halstead of the Cincinnati Commercial, Horace White of the Chicago Tribune, and E. L. Godkin of The Nation —opposed the Ku Klux Klan Bill and the ongoing interference of federal forces in the former Confederacy. In addition to their appeal for sectional reconciliation, they asked that greater attention be given to big business, western expansion, and immigration, as well as the labor strife then gripping the North, such as the demand for an eight-hour day. In short, they wanted the federal government to begin addressing the many ways in which the whole country, not only the South, had been transformed by the war.
The rise of the Liberal Republicans promised to make the election of 1872 the first, since the inception of the party a generation before, characterized by splits and oppositions among party members, which rendered Sumner's assaults on Grant all the more dangerous. As Sydney Howard Gay, a black New Yorker, reminded Sumner, "We believe, as Frederick Douglass has said, that 'The Republican Party is the deck; all the rest is the sea.' We do not propose to go overboard. We have been drifting astern of civilization, hanging on by a rope, for several generations, and have had enough of it." Discussing the president's alleged offenses, Gay offered that they were "infinitely small when weighed against his services to the Republic and to my race," adding, "The nepotism which assumes such formidable dimensions in your eyes seems in ours a small blemish when we remember the cruel despotism from which this man was the chosen instrument to deliver us."
South Carolina's black congressman Robert Brown Elliott, in an address honoring the tenth anniversary of emancipation in the District of Columbia, seemed to pick up on Gay's theme, warning that the Republicans could not afford the luxury of overconfidence. Speaking on the historical precariousness of social and political progress, he cautioned against faith in the belief that "revolutions never go backward." The Jews, he explained, were led from Egypt after 430 years of slavery, but within a few generations they were enslaved again by the Assyrians and Babylonians. The French staged a noble revolution, but it devoured them, so that they again had an emperor. The Declaration of Independence had vowed all men were created equal, but only eleven years later the Constitution preserved the concept of men as property. Thus, Elliott said, "It will be seen that we hold our rights by no perpetual or irrevocable charter. They are confronted by constant hazards. The enemies of the ancient Israelites, the Egyptian monarch, with his multitude of horsemen and chariots, were buried in the waters of the Red Sea, while our foes have crossed with us. Yet, perhaps by the inscrutable order of Providence, the very dangers that menace our rights are intended to admonish us to be vigilant in guarding them."
Sumner, however, proved impervious to all counsel and advice and broke with the traditional Republican Party to endorse for president the Liberal Republican candidate Horace Greeley, editor of the New York Tribune. As many had feared, Greeley's candidacy was also backed by the Democrats, who had not bothered to nominate a candidate of their own. A bookish, awkward-looking man with huge white whiskers and a "big round face of infantile mildness," Greeley was an unlikely choice for high office, and Sumner's endorsement only further rankled and confused the Republican faithful. Greeley had supported emancipation and was friendly to the plight of the freedmen, but his views were eccentric; he had at various times been a booster for socialism, feminism, spiritualism, and vegetarianism, and was hardly a longtime abolitionist, as Sumner now claimed. "I need not tell you, my friends, what Horace Greeley is," Wendell Phillips assured Boston's African American community. "A trimmer by nature and purpose, he has abused even an American politician's privilege of trading principles for success ... You and I know well when abolitionist was a term of reproach how timidly he held up his skirts about him, careful to put a wide distance between himself and us."
The doubts about Greeley soon were reflected in the difficult fusion of Liberal Republicans and Southern Democrats. There was no real cohesion between the two factions, no plan to win a unified campaign. The Liberals were motivated primarily by their anger with Grant over spoils, corruption, the Ku Klux Klan Act, and Santo Domingo, and the Democrats by the desire to reassert states' rights. Nor did Greeley lose any time in demonstrating his unsuitability as a candidate. In a speaking tour that swept through New England, the eastern seaboard, and the Midwest, he appeared disorganized, wandered off topic, shuffled his papers, became defensive when challenged, and overall cut a poor figure. The demanding schedule of the tour—at one point he made twenty-two speeches in a single day—no doubt also took a toll on the sixty-two-year-old candidate. By the time he limped back to the relative safety of New York, the nation's press was comparing the experience to Andy Johnson's dismal "Swing Around the Circle" of 1866 and praising President Grant as statesmanlike for wisely staying off the campaign trail.
WENDELL PHILLIPS
Among the allies Grant had retained, few proved as valuable as the cartoonist for Harper's Weekly. After the election of 1868, Grant had credited his victory in part to "the pencil of Thomas Nast," but it was the 1872 contest that saw Nast at the height of his influence on national politics. The artist had deeply admired Abraham Lincoln, but he idolized Grant, whom he saw as a homespun American version of the Italian patriot general Giuseppe Garibaldi, whose insurrectionary campaigns across Italy Nast had covered as a young artist and reporter. The Liberal Republicans, on the other hand, he viewed as betrayers of the war's great sacrifice, and Greeley's exhortation to his Southern Democrat partners that the war's former adversaries "Clasp Hands over the Bloody Chasm" was, in Nast's view, infamous. In a series of cartoons lampooning the slogan, Nast showed Greeley physically propping up a badly wounded freedman and encouraging him to accept the greeting of a white desperado standing on the other side of a pile of black corpses; another depicted the editor extending his hand southward over the graves of the thirteen thousand Union soldiers who had perished at Andersonville.
Nast's other caricatures of the campaign itself were equally devastating: Schurz as a demented pianist-composer writing the same piece over and over; Sumner as a Roman senator breaking his bow as he tries to shoot one last arrow; Columbia using the shield of Truth to protect Grant from Liberal arrows. Nast at one point depicted Greeley as a Ku Klux Klansman, and not having an image handy of Greeley's running mate, the little-known Missouri governor B. Gratz Brown, drew him as a label stuck to Greeley's jacket, reading "...and Gratz Brown," perfectly lampooning Brown's insignificance and the general hopelessness of the ticket. Another cartoon presented a comatose Greeley being carried on a hospital litter, with the captio
n "We are on the Home Stretch." So deadly were Nast's efforts throughout the campaign that Leslie's Illustrated, a competitor of Harper's, sent abroad for a renowned cartoonist from London to possibly counter him; but the effort was futile. Horace Greeley was a target who only seemed to grow larger, Thomas Nast was at the top of his game, and it appeared certain that Ulysses'S. Grant, "the Man on Horseback," would continue to ride in command.
In his new role as the lieutenant governor of Louisiana, Pinchback embarked on a speaking tour of his own that summer of 1872, visiting Maine on behalf of the Republican congressman James Blaine, who was up for reelection. It was a way for Pinchback to shore up his recognition and support among national Republicans and a chance for the party to show off one of its rising Southern stars at a time when confidence in Southern Republicanism was desperately needed. But the journey led to one of the strangest cloak-and-dagger escapades in American political history, and rather than demonstrate Pinchback's readiness for the national political stage, it revealed his provincialism.
At home in Louisiana, where both the national and state campaigns were competitive, Pinchback supported President Grant's reelection, breaking with Warmoth, who aligned himself with the Liberal Republican-Democratic ticket. This brought a sudden thaw in Pinchback's relations with the Grant-oriented Customhouse faction; the state Republican convention even offered to place his name in nomination for governor. Pinchback declined, pointing out that a black gubernatorial candidate on the ballot would only scare more white Republicans into the camp of Horace Greeley. The Republicans ultimately settled on a state ticket of William Pitt Kellogg for governor, C. C. Antoine for lieutenant governor, and Pinchback for congressman at large.
On his way back from New England, Pinchback stopped in New York City, staying at the popular Fifth Avenue Hotel, headquarters of the Republican National Committee and a favorite political gathering place where President Grant was known to keep a suite of rooms. To his surprise, Pinchback learned that one of his fellow guests was none other than Governor Warmoth, who invited his lieutenant to join him in his room that night for a late supper. Pinchback agreed, then went to meet vice presidential candidate Henry Wilson of Massachusetts, who at the Republican national convention in June had been nominated to replace Schuyler Colfax, and William E. Chandler, secretary of the Republican National Committee. When Chandler asked what the party's chances were of carrying Louisiana, Pinchback confessed they were poor. He explained that because of his state's archaic election laws, the voting process could easily be abused, almost certainly resulting in diminished black voter turnout and fewer votes recorded for Grant. So harmful were the regulations, Pinchback said, that the state legislature had recently passed new laws to reform the process and make it more difficult to commit election fraud; Warmoth, however, had refused to sign the reforms into law.
Listening to Pinchback's explanation, Chandler suddenly had an idea: since Warmoth was planning to tarry in New York awhile, and Pinchback was headed home, what if Pinchback were to hurry back to Louisiana and, invoking his status as acting governor while Warmoth was out of the state, sign the election reform bills into law? Wilson and Chandler emphasized that Louisiana's eight electoral votes might be key to a Republican victory for the national ticket and that it would be a "grand thing" if Pinchback were to undertake such a mission. The ambitious Pinchback instantly recognized an opportunity to play hero to both the party leadership and President Grant. "If the success of the Republican party is at stake, I dare do anything that will save it," declared Pinchback, and agreed to start for Louisiana at once. There was a small technicality, however—the promise Pinchback had made earlier to have dinner with Warmoth. To avoid leading the governor to suspect that his lieutenant governor had left town, Pinchback parked his trunk, with his name written on it, outside his hotel room. If Warmoth passed by, he would assume that Pinchback was still in the city and had simply become distracted and forgotten their dinner arrangement.
At first the plan worked. Pinchback failed to appear at Warmoth's room, but Warmoth thought little of it and went to bed, figuring his dinner guest had found something more entertaining to do in the big city. Pinchback had conspired with his friend Henry Corbin, the editor of the Louisianian, to seek out Warmoth the next day and make his apologies, explaining that Pinchback had been called away at the last minute to give a speech. But Warmoth, upon going downstairs the next morning, encountered not Corbin but another of Pinchback's friends, A. B. Harris, a state senator from Louisiana. Pinchback had lacked the time to let Harris in on the scheme, and when Warmoth inquired after Pinchback, Harris replied that he had not seen him since the prior afternoon. Warmoth, thinking this information a bit odd, thanked him and walked away.
Pinchback, meanwhile, having left New York by the first train available, had gone to Pittsburgh, then on to Cincinnati, and encountered an exasperating six-hour layover at each stop. The only consolation was that he had not heard from William Chandler back in New York, who had promised to telegraph immediately if Warmoth was seen starting toward Louisiana. Exhausted already from the trip, but fairly confident that Warmoth was not on his trail, Pinchback at last boarded a train for New Orleans, nestled into a comfortable berth, and went to sleep.
Several hours and many miles later he was awakened by someone shining a light in his eyes. "Are you Governor Pinchback?" a voice asked.
"I am that man."
"Then I am directed to inform you that there is a telegram awaiting you in the telegraph office, which the operator is directed to deliver only to you in person."
"Where are we?" Pinchback asked.
"Canton, Mississippi."
Sure that this would be a message from Chandler, Pinchback threw on some clothes and hurried off the train and into the tiny office. Once inside, it seemed to take a very long time for the operator to locate the envelope bearing the telegram. When he finally handed it over, Pinchback opened it, but there was nothing inside except a blank piece of paper. Pinchback, confused and still not fully awake, was struggling to make sense of the situation when he realized that, outside, his train was starting to move. At that moment, as one New Orleans newspaper related, "the consciousness flashed upon the sagacious Pinch that he was sold." He leapt to the office door and found it locked; he rushed to a window and tried to yank it open, but it also was closed tight. Returning to the door, he banged on it loudly enough to attract the attention of someone on the platform, but by the time he was released, the red lanterns on the rear of his train were vanishing around a bend, a quarter-mile away.
Moments after speaking with Harris in New York, Warmoth had suspected what Pinchback was up to and resolved on the spot to return to New Orleans. With the aid of Major E. A. Burke, a Louisiana campaign official and railroad executive, Warmoth arranged the fastest rail connections possible, including a special train consisting of a single car and locomotive for maximum speed, that would wait for him at Humboldt, Tennessee, just north of Memphis, and rush him to New Orleans. At Humboldt, Warmoth learned that Pinchback was twelve hours ahead of him. When the engineer warned Warmoth that the locomotive could do no better than forty-five miles per hour, the governor ordered him to improve on that as best he could, saying his aides were dispatching telegrams to stations down the line to clear the track. Warmoth's men also sent a telegram to the Canton depot, arranging for the deception that would lure Pinchback out of his slumber, and with that, Warmoth's one-car express shot out of Humboldt and headed south. Late the next morning, as it rumbled into the Canton station, Pinchback was waiting on the platform.
"Well, governor," Pinchback greeted Warmoth, "your lucky star is still in the ascendant."
"Hello, Pinch, old fellow." Warmoth smiled. "What are you doing here?"
"I am on my way home," Pinchback replied, "and if you have no objection, I will go on with you the balance of your journey."
Racing, usually involving horses or steamboats, had long been a special passion in Louisiana, and the hometown papers found the conte
st between the carpetbag governor and his troublesome lieutenant irresistible; by the time the train bearing the two politicians entered New Orleans, hundreds of the curious lined the tracks. The press evaluated this strange "sporting event" in detail, not missing the interesting fact that Warmoth had, in addition to catching Pinchback, set a new record of sixty-two hours for covering the distance between New York City and New Orleans. The Louisianian worried that locking Pinchback in a strange office in the middle of the night and forcing him to search in panic for an escape constituted "scandalous and disgraceful measures," but the Democratic Daily Picayune was more astute, inquiring, "What have the people of Louisiana done, how have they sunk so low, that they should be subjected to the shame ... of having a Lieutenant Governor who, by an arrangement with the official partisans of President Grant ... rushes back from a remote extremity of the Union to seize the state executive office?" As for Pinchback, he seems to have weathered what for any other man might have been a fatal humiliation by considering it from a gambler's perspective. Warmoth, Pinchback conceded, had simply "taken the big trick," and he did not bother chastising himself for having misplayed the hand.
