by Gars Méchant
I figured this was the sign that it was time for me to go cherry picking.
Chapter 17
Pump And Circumstance
I waited for a chance to break in, and when I saw it, I said, “Okay, the final part of tonight’s finals is: ‘Who Has The Tightest Pussy?’”
“The final part of the final? Finally!” Lisa said.
“Are you mocking me?”
“Definitely,” she said with a huge smile.
“How are you going to judge it?” asked Maricela in her musical voice, breaking our repartee.
“I think I know,” said Goldilocks. “Are you going to fuck us?”
“Well,” I said slowly. “There’s only one real way to judge something like this: I have to stick my hard cock into your wet pussies and feel you myself.”
“So, if this is a contest,” asked Lisa, “what’s the prize?”
“Well,” I said. “First, all of you get down on all fours and line up, and I’ll tell you.”
All of them quickly got into position with many giggles, and then Lisa looked back at me and asked again, “What’s the prize?” as she wiggled her ass at me.
“Well, whoever has the tightest pussy gets a shot of hot jizz wherever she wants it. Remember; grip my cock with your pussy muscles when I enter you. That’ll make you feel tighter,” I said as I lined up behind Lisa.
I rubbed the head of my cock playfully over Lisa’s clit a few times, eliciting a moan from her. “Don’t just tease me, fuck me!” said Lisa.
So that’s what I did. After pushing the head of my cock between her pussy lips I took hold of her hips and slowly pushed my way inside her wetness.
“Oh, whoa,” Lisa said as I entered her.
“How’s it feel?” asked Goldilocks.
“Really good. Much better than the vibrator. He’s warm and hard,” she finished.
“Cool! I can’t wait to try!” Goldilocks exclaimed.
Lisa had very good muscle control, and gripped my cock tightly in her pussy. After the first couple of thrusts I leaned forward and started caressing her breasts and stomach. I love the feeling of the smooth skin of a woman, and Lisa’s felt great.
“I’ll take a few strokes with each of you to judge who has the tightest pussy,” I said. I thrust into her a couple more times. “How’s that feel,” I asked Lisa.
“Great. That feels wonderful,” she said in a deep, animal growl.
I pushed in one more time and stayed there, enjoying her tight wetness, and finally pulled out. Lisa whimpered a small complaint as I pulled my cock out of her wet tunnel.
“Okay, your turn Goldilocks,” I said as I lined up behind her.
“Cool! This is gonna be, like, really great! I just know it!” she said.
“I’ll line it up here, like so,” I said and ran the head of my cock over her clit a few times. “And are you ready for it?” I said as I took hold of her hips and slowly thrust inside.
“Ohhhhhh!” moaned Goldilocks as I rammed my hard cock all the way into her to the hilt. I just stayed there for a bit, grinding my crotch against her and enjoying the feeling of being balls deep inside her tight pussy.
Maricela lay down on her side, so she could get a good view of how my cock had impaled her friend. “Doesn’t it hurt?” she asked.
“No, not really,” explained Lisa.
“Noooooo, it feels perfect!” said Goldilocks.
“I thought it was supposed to hurt,” said Maricela as she got under Goldilocks for a better view.
“Nah, the vibrators stretched us enough that his cock doesn’t hurt a bit,” said Lisa.
“No, it doesn’t hurt at all!” said Goldilocks. I started moving in and out of her, and she said, “It feels really…like…great!”
“You like this, huh?” I asked Goldilocks.
“Oh, yeah! Don’t stop!” she pleaded. Goldilocks didn’t have Lisa’s muscle control, but she did push back to meet my thrusts with enthusiasm. I saw Maricela lean in closer, and I felt her lick my balls once, and I could feel her fingering Goldilocks’ clit, but I had to stop.
“Sorry, I have to try one more pussy before I can judge. However, I will give you a couple more strokes,” I said.
“Darn. That felt good,” said Goldilocks as I pulled out. “I wanted to cum!”
“That’ll happen soon enough,” I said.
“Promises, promises,” Lisa and Goldilocks said together, and then they laughed.
“Okay, Maricela,” I said, “get ready for your turn.”
“Okay!” she said enthusiastically as she got onto all fours in front of me.
I got behind her and lined up my cock with her pink pussy, and I said, “Are you ready for this?”
“I think so,” she replied, and arched her back to give me better access to her wet pussy.
“You may feel a small prick,” said Lisa jokingly.
“Hey!” I exclaimed. “No comments from the peanut gallery!”
“Just joking!” said Lisa, and Goldilocks laughed.
“Let me know if I need to stop,” I told Maricela.
“Okay,” she almost whispered.
I rubbed the head of my cock all around her pussy, massaging her clit several times before pushing the head between her lips. She gasped. Finally, I took her by the hips and slowly pushed into her with little thrusts. I heard a low moan slowly escape her as I bottomed out. I just savored the moment as I ground my cock inside her. She was the third girl I had deflowered that night, and she was by far the tightest. After a few seconds, she seemed to remember what I told Lisa before entering her, and Maricela gripped my cock with her pussy muscles—hard.
“Well, do you like the feel of me?” asked Maricela.
“Oh, yeah,” I replied.
“Do we have a winner?” she asked playfully, grinding back at me.
“I need to check everyone just once more to be sure,” I explained.
“If you say so,” Maricela said. I started pumping her for my ceremonial test, reaching around to cup her nice, firm breasts.
Maricela was really getting into it and was pushing back with each thrust. I didn’t feel like pulling out, but I wanted to try the other two just to be fair (sure I did.)
“Okay,” I said, “I have to check Lisa and Goldilocks. Ready for me to pull out?”
“No, but go ahead if you have to,” Maricela said.
I heard a popping sound as I pulled my heard cock out of the small woman’s wet sheath, and a sigh of disappointment.
“Okay, Lisa, you ready for another check?” I asked.
“Sure, if you stick me with that thing there,” she said as she gestured at my cock.
“Okay, assume the position!” I commanded, and Lisa instead lay down on her back.
I decided to go ahead with what she wanted and got on top of her. This time I didn’t play around and just pushed straight in. Lisa tried to clamp down on me, but couldn’t manage to hold my cock the way Maricela had. That’s not to say she didn’t feel great.
I pumped inside her for a minute or so, and then pulled out.
“Just as I was really beginning to like it,” said Lisa.
“Ya know, it looks sexy from right next to you guys, and the slurping sounds are hot,” said Goldilocks.
“You ready for round two?” I said as I looked at the blond-bushed woman.
“Yep, shove it in here! No lines, no waiting!” said Goldilocks.
Goldilocks lay down, just like Lisa, and I lined my cock up with her opening and started to push back into her familiar wetness. It felt good, and she gripped my cock as hard as she could with her pussy but it was really no contest.
I drove into her for another minute or so. She was enjoying it, but wasn’t doing much more than exploring the new sensations of having a cock in her pussy. I finally pulled out to Goldilocks’ protestations.
“Okay, time to try the last one again,” I said as I looked at Maricela.
“Saving me for last?” she asked innocently.
&n
bsp; “You could say that. Now do you want to try me again?” I said.
“Yes,” she said and scrambled into position on all fours as before.
I lined my cock back up with Maricela's eager pussy, looking forward to feeling her warm, tight muscles wrapped around my cock again. I took a deep breath and slowly reentered her hot wetness in one long push. Just as soon as I was entirely inside her, she gripped my cock with her near-vice-grip again.
Maricela reared up and asked me, “So, am I the tightest? Do I win?”
“Yes, I believe we do have a winner,” I said as I massaged her breasts.
“Oh, well,” Goldilocks said.
“Damn,” protested Lisa.
“Well, ladies, we have a winner,” I said. “Can we get on about your prize now?” I asked Maricela.
“Yes, lets,” she said huskily.
I slipped out of her pussy for a bit, and wondered at the suction of her pussy lips on my hard cock. It felt like she was pulling my cock inside her with a vacuum cleaner. I asked her, “Now, where do you want your prize?”
“Right here, deep inside my pussy. Ram it hard and deep inside me. I want to feel you spurt your hot cum inside my wet pussy,” she said huskily.
“That was just what I wanted to hear.”
She was sitting down in front of me now, one knee up, her other leg out in front of her. It was a devastatingly sexy pose, showing her wet pussy lips to advantage, and making her small pert breasts visible to my gaze.
“Well,” I started, “how do you want me to deliver your prize? What position?”
“Jump on top of him and ride him like a horse!” blurted out Goldilocks.
“I want it Missionary position. I want to feel your body pressed against mine when you pump your cum inside me!” Maricela said.
“That will do just fine,” I said as I leaned over and kissed her passionately on the lips. She put her arms around me and held me close as I started kissing my way down her body.
I decided to take my time to get her as turned on as possible before I reentered her. The obvious place to work on was her breasts. I started licking down her neck and shoulders between kisses, and finally managed to reach her right breast. I took her nipple in my mouth and started nibbling all around, licking and sucking the tip until she started moaning and heaving in pleasure.
Lisa and Goldilocks were watching us as I lay Maricela on the floor. I looked over at them as I licked Maricela’s nipples. Lisa had gotten her vibrator and was idly flicking the tip over Goldilocks’ pussy lips as Maricela and I put on a fuck show for them.
I spent several minutes just sucking on Maricela's breasts and kissing her deeply while caressing her sides and kneading her ass, before working my way lower, licking down her belly and finally between her legs. There I was treated to the view of her very tight little pussy. I do enjoy eating pussy, and I was really going to enjoy licking hers. Her pouty lips stuck out just waiting to be licked and sucked. I placed my finger at her opening and slowly massaged her lips before running the tip over her clit. I spent some time circling her clit with my fingertip, enjoying how wet she was before finally pushing it inside her slick tunnel.
“How does that feel?” I asked her.
“It feels great, baby!” she moaned. She was too turned on to say more.
“You two really know how to torture us, don’t you?” commented Lisa.
I had almost forgotten that Lisa and Goldilocks were there. I became aware of the buzzing of a vibrator, which Lisa had completely inside Goldilocks’ pussy as she turned it back and forth.
“Hmmmmm, sounds like we need to speed things up just a bit,” I said to Maricela.
“That’s fine,” she moaned quietly.
I took that as my cue to start eating her out. I bent my head forward and kissed her pussy, and then slowly licked her across her lips, just enjoying the flavor of her juices and not really going down on her. She seemed to like that, so I licked her gently on her outer labia on either side of her opening. I heard her moan loudly, so I decided to pick up the pace a bit and pushed my tongue between her lips and flicked the tip over her sensitive bud, causing her to cry out and heave her hips at me.
I could feel her trying to hold back her orgasm, and I wanted to keep her from cumming just a little longer, so I started licking up the inside of her thighs for a minute or so. I then decided to feel how tight she was inside and pushed my tongue between her lips and into her pussy. “Oh, God, baby! That feels so good!” she moaned. She tasted great, and I treated her to a considerable licking out. When I could sense that she wasn’t going to hold off much longer I started running my tongue over her clit until she came in waves.
I could see at this point that Goldilocks had gotten out another vibrator and had worked it into Lisa’s pussy, and they were now sitting side-by-side on the couch, fucking each other with the buzzing vibrators.
I kept licking Maricela for a few minutes after she was finished cumming until I couldn’t take it any more, and finally I moved between her legs where she took hold of my cock and rubbed the head over her clit several times, moaning loudly.
“Ready for it?”
“Yes! Jam it deep in me! I’m really ready for it! Fuck me!” Maricela exclaimed as she aimed the head of my cock at her opening.
I held off, just pushing the tip of my cock between her lips. Maricela was getting impatient and pushed her hips up toward me, impaling herself on my hard cock. Instinct took over and I started pistoning deeper into her as she met each of my thrusts until I was hilt-deep inside her.
Damn it felt good pushing inside her tight pussy again. She looked me straight in the eye as she wrapped her legs around me and held me tightly inside her. I looked into her eyes for a moment before I sank down on top of her and kissed her deeply. I could feel her pussy muscles throbbing around my cock, and God, it felt wonderful!
Maricela smiled at me, mouth wide open in lust, and started humping her hips against me, and I took that as my cue to start pumping her. I pulled almost all the way out before I pushed my way back inside and ground my crotch against her. I fucking her with more force, and she was pressing her body as closely against mine as possible, her arms and legs locked behind my back to press us together; mouths locked and tongues searching each other out. I’d been worried that this little lady couldn’t take a hard fuck, but she was proving that she was more than up to the task, and was encouraging me to fuck her harder!
We lay there for what seemed like forever, just fucking as passionately as possible, jamming our bodies together and enjoying the sensations, until I felt Maricela start to tense up. I could feel her pussy muscles tighten around my cock, and she pushed her pussy against me as she came. After the first convulsion of her crashing orgasm, she tore her lips away from mine and screamed out in pleasure! None of the girls had cum that hard before as far as I could tell.
After a few moments of this her pussy muscles started to relax a bit, so I pulled out and pumped back inside her. This seemed to trigger another orgasm, or perhaps her last one hadn’t finished yet, because she again clamped her legs around me, pushed her hips against mine, and her muscles clamped down on my hard cock as she moaned loudly.
“Oh, fuck! Baby, I’m cumming hard!” she cried out loud.
I dimly heard one of the other girls cry out in orgasm, but I was too involved in what I was doing to tell which.
I could feel Maricela's orgasm start to subside, so I pumped her again, and it started all over again.
“Oh, baby! It feels sooo good!” whimpered Maricela.
“Better than the vibrator, huh?” asked Lisa.
“Oh, fuck yes!” said Maricela, as she continued to cum.
This continued for several minutes until Maricela finally collapsed on the floor, and I could continue fucking her for real.
After about a minute of pumping her small pussy full of my hard cock I could feel her start to cum again. Her latest orgasm wasn’t as strong as the last one, but her pussy muscles tightened e
nough to massage my cock. That was too much for me and I came with her, filling that wonderful, tight, wet pussy of hers with the largest load of jizz I have ever shot. It felt like I was shooting it all in one long spurt inside her as we screamed out and tore at each other. I couldn’t imagine there was enough room inside her for more than a little of my cum, and some did leak out around my hard member and coated our pubic areas.
After cumming, we lay on the carpet for a few minutes, breathing hard and slowly moving together, more out of inertia then anything else. Maricela looked like she had run a marathon, and lay on her back with her mane of hair spread around her head and shoulders, tears running down her cheeks from the effort of cumming so strongly, and her body shining from our mixed sweat.
After catching our breath, we both started laughing. It must have been from the exertion, or perhaps just the humor of making so much noise. I kissed her again and pulled my softening cock out of her perfect pussy so I could collapse next to her.
Chapter 18
Extra Credit
As we caught our breath, we both looked around the living room. Lisa and Goldilocks were no longer paying any attention to us. They were too caught up in what they were doing with each other. I could now tell that it was Goldilocks who had cum first from the masturbation-a-thon that she and Lisa had been enjoying on the couch, and she was kneeling between Lisa’s legs, using the vibrator and her tongue on Lisa’s pussy.
I found a cushion to prop up Maricela's head, and I shared it with her as we watched them for a while. The show they were putting on was working on me since I was starting to get hard again. Maricela put her hand around my growing erection, and kept it warm.
Goldilocks was using a technique on Lisa where she would just leave the vibrator completely inside her pussy, vibrating away, and lick Lisa’s inner thighs and outer labia. I could tell Lisa was really enjoying this by the vacant look on her face and the occasional moans she let out. She had no idea that Maricela and I were there by this point. I’m not sure if Maricela was getting bored or turned on by the other two girls, but she decided to distract me by going down on me while I watched the other girls.
