by Ramona Gray
“Do you like it, sweetheart?” Seth asked with a grin.
“It’s the most unique Christmas gift I’ve ever gotten,” I laughed.
“And most romantic, right?” Theo said.
I laughed even harder. “Oh, definitely.”
“Theo wanted to go with the kitty cat tail one, but I talked him out of it,” Seth said.
I poked Theo in the stomach. “Don’t be a brat.”
“What do you say we go to the bedroom and try out your new Christmas gift?” Theo said before kissing me. “If we use it for a few more days, you should be stretched enough.”
“I’ve, uh, been using a butt plug every day since Thursday,” I said. My cheeks reddened and I wished I didn’t feel embarrassed by my admission.
Seth gave me a look of glee. “Seriously?”
“Yes,” I said. “I bought one and have been using it daily.”
“Fuck, you are the perfect fucking woman,” Seth said before leaning in and kissing me hard on the mouth. “Theo, get our perfect woman to the bedroom right now while I shut off the lights.
Theo tossed the box with the plug on the couch and pulled me to my feet. I followed him to the bedroom and he undressed me and himself in record time before pushing me onto my back on the bed.
“Theo, what – oh my god!”
Theo was lying between my legs with his face buried in my pussy before I could even blink. “Theo!” I moaned when he sucked on my clit.
He raised his head. “Yes, love?”
“Wh-what are you doing?”
“It’s called foreplay,” he said with a teasing grin.
“Shouldn’t we wait for Seth?” I whispered. My hands were already tangling in his hair and I whimpered with pleasure when Theo nipped my inner thigh.
“He’ll be here soon. I’ve spent the last four days dreaming about your cunt and how sweet it tastes. Don’t even think of denying me, Libby.”
“I’m not,” I said quickly.
“Good. Let’s see how wet I can make your pussy before Seth shows up.” He dove back into my pussy and I closed my eyes and arched my back when he licked my clit with warm strokes of his tongue. He teased and licked and nipped until I was digging my feet into the small of his back and grinding my pussy against his mouth.
My eyes popped open the moment I felt a warm mouth cover my aching nipple. Seth was lying on the bed beside me and he licked and sucked at my nipple almost lazily as Theo ate my pussy with undisguised enthusiasm.
“Are your nipples still sore, sweetheart?” Seth asked.
“No,” I panted as I rocked my hips against Theo’s face. “No, they – they’re fine.”
“I’m glad. If you’re our good girl, we won’t use the clamps tonight.”
I didn’t reply and Seth gave my nipple a hard pinch. “Libby? Are you paying attention to me?”
“Fuck, no I’m not paying attention to you!” I retorted. I glared at him and he laughed and pinched my other nipple until I cried out.
“Theo, stop for a minute,” Seth said.
“No! Theo, do not stop!” I shouted.
Theo lifted his head and smiled at Seth. “What’s up?”
“Goddammit!” I shouted and tried to shove Theo’s head back between my thighs.
Seth grabbed my wrists and yanked them above my head, pinning them to the bed. I cried out when Theo gave my pussy two hard slaps. It stung like hell so why was I spreading my legs in a silent plea for more?
Instead of slapping me, Theo pressed a kiss against the swollen lips of my pussy as Seth nipped my collarbone. “Be our good girl, Libby.”
“I am, Sir” I said desperately.
“Say it.”
“I’ll be your good girl, Sir,” I said frantically.
“What do good girls do?”
I stared at him for a moment before hit with inspiration. “They suck cock, Sir.”
Seth smiled and I felt an absurd tingle of pride when he said, “That’s right. Open up, good girl.”
I opened my mouth as Seth shifted until he was kneeling next to me. He slipped a hand under my neck and lifted my head, supporting me as I sucked his cock into my mouth.
“Fuck, that’s good,” he muttered as he thrust in and out of my mouth. “Suck my cock like my good girl.”
Theo sucked on my clit again and I moaned around Seth’s cock. The vibration made Seth groan and he thrust even harder into my mouth. I barely noticed my inability to breathe or the spit that was running down my chin as Seth pushed in and out. Theo was teasing my clit with small flicks of his tongue and I was on the verge of climaxing.
Theo nipped my clit and I screamed, the sound muffled by Seth’s thick cock, as I came in a violent rush of dizzying pleasure. Theo held my lower body still with hard hands on my hips and licked and sucked at my clit as my climax rolled through me.
I screamed again and Seth’s hand tightened around my neck before he abruptly pulled out. I sucked in a lungful of air and let it out in a loud moan as Theo rubbed my oversensitive clit with the pad of his thumb. I jerked away and waited for the spank, but Theo simply pressed a kiss against my quivering thigh before standing up and opening the nightstand drawer. He pulled out a bottle of lube and condoms and handed a condom and the lube to Seth. Both men rolled on their condoms as I panted and moaned and twitched on the bed.
The bed dipped as Theo reclined on his back. “Climb on, Libby.”
My legs were still shaking but I sat up and straddled him. I realized I wasn’t worrying one bit about hurting him and scored myself a mental victory as Theo cupped both my breasts. “You’re so beautiful, Libby.”
“Thank you,” I whispered. “So are you. Both of you.”
Theo cupped my face and tenderly stroked my cheekbone with his thumb. “If it hurts too much or you want to stop at any time, say your safe word, okay? We won’t be upset.”
I glanced at Seth who was opening the bottle of lube. He smiled and leaned forward to kiss me. “We won’t be, sweetheart. I promise.”
“Okay,” I said. “So, uh what do we do first?”
“First you put my cock in that soaking wet cunt of yours,” Theo said.
I blushed a little but grasped Theo’s cock at the base and guided it to my opening. He was right about being soaking wet and I sank down on his cock with ease despite his size. Theo released his breath in a low groan before urging me to lean over him.
I braced my hands on the bed on either side of his head and we kissed with slow, deep strokes of our tongues as Seth kneeled between Theo’s spread legs. Theo made a few lazy thrusts into my pussy as we kissed and I moaned into his mouth. God, it felt so good to have his cock again.
Feeling a little drunk on pleasure, I whispered, “I love your cock, Theo.”
He nuzzled my neck before sucking on my earlobe. “I love your hot little pussy, Libby. You’re an amazing woman and fucking you is all I can think about.”
I moaned when he cupped my breasts and tugged on my nipples. Behind me, Seth was rubbing lube into my anus and I took a deep breath and pushed against his fingers when he pushed them deep into my ass. He made a scissoring motion with his fingers to stretch me. I pushed my breast against Theo’s mouth and he sucked obligingly on my nipple as he made gentle little thrusts with his hips.
“Are you ready, sweetheart?” Seth asked.
“Yes.”
“I’ll go slow, I promise. Remember to breathe and to push back against me, okay?”
I looked over my shoulder at him. “Yes.”
“You’re sure?”
“Positive. Fuck my ass, Seth,” I said.
He groaned and a look of almost feral need crossed his face before he moved a little closer. “Theo, stop moving.”
Theo held still and gave me a reassuring look as Seth pressed the head of his dick against my anus. I took a deep breath and pushed back against the steady pressure. I groaned and bit at my lip. Fuck, even with the plugs, it was hurting more than I thought it would.
I was ab
out to say stop and ask for more time when Theo’s hand slipped between my legs and rubbed at my swollen clit.
“Oh!” I squeaked as pleasure immediately mixed with the pain. “Oh, that helps!”
“Good,” Theo said. “Concentrate on my fingers touching you, love. Your little clit is so swollen and hard. You want to come again, don’t you?”
“Yes,” I moaned. “I really do.”
“Soon,” Theo said soothingly.
There was a sudden flare of pain and I groaned. Seth rubbed my ass and Theo rubbed my clit as I hung my head and took deep breaths. The pain subsided rather quickly, leaving a feeling of dull pressure that was actually a little pleasurable.
“Is it in?” I panted.
“The head is,” Seth replied.
I groaned and swivelled my head to stare at him. “Just the head?”
I already felt stuffed to the brim and couldn’t imagine taking any more of Seth’s cock. “I don’t think I can take any more.”
“Yes, you can,” Seth said. “Take my cock up your ass like a good girl or I’ll give you a spanking.”
That made me clench around both men’s dicks and Theo groaned. “Jesus, Seth, stop threatening to spank her!”
“Rub her clit again,” Seth ordered.
Theo rubbed my clit and I moaned and rubbed my pussy against his fingers as Seth pushed and retreated slowly until I felt his pelvis pressing against my ass and he made a satisfied grunt.
“Good girl,” he said.
“Oh God,” I moaned. “It’s too much. I can’t take it.”
Seth ignored me and made a few gentle thrusts that sent lightning coursing up and down my nerve endings.
“Fuck!” I squealed. “Oh God, that’s – that’s good.”
Both men laughed and I blushed but gave Theo a pleading look. “Please touch my clit again.”
He shook his head. “No, we’re going to make you come with just our dicks this time, love.”
I gave him another pleading look, but he ignored it and cupped my breasts as Seth held my hips. They began a slow rhythm of one man pushing in while the other withdrew. It made my toes curl and I panted and moaned as they both fucked me.
“Feel good, little Libby?” Seth pressed on my lower back.
“Oh God, fuck, yes,” I groaned. “I think – harder, please.”
They moved faster and harder. My body was buzzing and twitching with pleasure and I wasn’t sure if I should be happy or ashamed at how much pleasure I was deriving from a dick in my ass. Having Seth’s cock in my ass made Theo’s cock feel even thicker in my pussy. I squeezed around both of them experimentally and both men immediately did hard and out-of-control thrusts that made me squeal.
“Fuck! Don’t squeeze like that, love,” Theo begged below me as Seth panted harshly behind me.
I squeezed again and Seth slapped my ass hard. I squealed a second time and turned my head to pout at him.
“Behave,” he said but there was a pleading tone to it that I’d never heard in his voice before.
I grinned and rocked my body a little. “What’s wrong, Seth? Going to blow your load before you make me come?”
I received another glorious slap to the ass for my impertinence. I flushed with happiness and didn’t object when both men pounded roughly into me. In fact, their roughness ratcheted up my excitement and I clutched at Theo’s shoulders and made soft cries for more.
“She’s so fucking tight,” Theo suddenly moaned. “Seth, I can’t…”
“Make her come first,” Seth demanded but he sounded as frantic as Theo.
“Fuck, I’m trying,” Theo panted.
To my surprise and delight, he reached beneath me and rubbed my clit in hard, rough circles. I cried out happily and rocked against his fingers. I was coming against his fingers in less than thirty seconds, my pussy and ass tightening around their cocks helplessly as I climaxed. Seth made a hoarse roar of need and then both men were pounding into me. I clung to Theo as a new and unrecognizable pleasure grew in my body.
“Oh, oh, God,” I moaned. “What is that? What – oh fuck!” I was gasping and sobbing with need as both men moved harder and faster. I couldn’t stop clenching around both dicks. The motion heightened my pleasure and I heard Theo groan loudly.
He arched beneath me. I barely registered that he was coming as Seth shoved his dick in and out of my ass. The only thing mattered was the orgasm that was agonizingly close. I squeezed my eyes shut and ground my pussy against Theo’s dick as I reached for my climax. As Seth made a low roar and his hands dug into my hips, I shrieked with pleasure and came wildly. My body shook and I screamed again before collapsing on top of Theo.
I could feel Theo’s heart beating like a drum beneath my cheek and I told myself to roll off of him before I crushed him. I made a half-hearted attempt to move before collapsing on him again. He rubbed my back and I was only vaguely aware of Seth moving away to the other side of the bed.
After a few minutes, Theo kissed the top of my head. “Okay?” He asked hoarsely.
“Yes,” I mumbled. “Sorry, I’ll move.”
“You’re fine,” he said as his arms tightened around my waist. “Give it a minute.”
I snuggled against him and it wasn’t until his heart was beating a normal rhythm again that I eased off of him and lay weakly between the two men.
Seth had already removed his condom and as Theo removed his and tossed it in the trash, I stared at Seth. He was lying on his back, staring at the ceiling and I touched his chest tentatively.
“Seth? Was it okay for you?”
“Okay?” He rasped. “Libby, I nearly fucking passed out when I came.”
I laughed and leaned against Theo when he spooned me and kissed the back of my shoulder. I squeezed his hand. “Theo? You, um, enjoyed it, right?”
“Do you really have to ask?” He said before patting my ass. “How are you? Are you sore? Do you want me to run you a hot bath?”
“I’m good,” I said. I wasn’t lying. My ass was a little sore, but the rest of my body felt incredible. I’d never had orgasms like that before. Hell, the last one was so good, I thought my head was going to blow off.
“It was amazing,” I said suddenly. “Thank you so much. It was incredible.”
“Good, we’re glad,” Seth said.
“I don’t think I’ll be able to ever have sex with just one man again,” I said without thinking.
There was silence and I cleared my throat. “Uh, I didn’t mean – that is, I know this is it for us. I wasn’t trying to imply that the two of you had to keep fucking me.”
“What if we want to keep fucking you?” Theo asked.
I stiffened and Theo sighed. “Sorry, I shouldn’t have said that.”
I licked my lips. “Did you want to keep having sex with me?”
“No,” Seth said bluntly and my sudden hope deflated like a balloon.
“I should go,” I whispered. I didn’t regret what I had done with them but the knowledge that they didn’t want to continue hurt way more than it should have considering we had agreed on a casual sex agreement.
Before I could squirm away from them, Theo’s arm was tightening around my waist and Seth was cupping my face. “Sweetheart, we don’t want to just have sex with you. We want to see if it could be something more.”
I stared in shock at him. “You – you’re kidding, right?”
“No,” Theo said solemnly. “We’re not.”
“We’re good together, Libs,” Seth said. “You know we are. I know it’s not a conventional relationship, but you said yourself that you couldn’t sleep with only one man anymore. You don’t have to. You have two men right here very willing to kiss, lick, suck and spank this delicious little body of yours. Let us.”
“I’m your boss,” I said in a low voice. “If the other partners found out…”
“We can find new jobs,” Theo said.
“Are you – you can’t quit your job because we enjoy fucking each other,” I said.
“Have you lost your minds?”
Seth laughed. “No, I don’t think so. Neither of us thought we’d be at Martin, Clarke and Bones forever anyway.”
“You can’t quit your job for me,” I whispered. “We don’t even know if this dating thing would work out.”
“No, I suppose we don’t,” Seth said thoughtfully. “Tell you what, we’ll give it a couple of months. We can keep it a secret from our coworkers if we’re very careful. If we can convince you at the end of two months that this could be something more than just sex, we’ll start looking for new jobs. What do you think?”
They waited patiently as I thought it over. What they were suggesting was madness, but it was incredibly tempting. I liked both of them, and getting to know them better was dangerously appealing.
“What if it doesn’t work out between us?” I asked.
“We won’t say anything to the other partners about what happened between us if it doesn’t,” Theo assured me.
I blinked at him. That thought hadn’t even crossed my mind. I knew instinctively that they wouldn’t use a failed relationship to blackmail me, just like they weren’t using what we were doing now to blackmail me. They were good men – possibly the best men I’d ever met - and I would be a fool not to see where this would lead.
“I only meant that it will be incredibly awkward at work,” I said.
“Possibly,” Seth agreed. “But that’s only if it didn’t work out. Do you believe that it won’t?”
I studied him before shaking my head. “No, I don’t think that.”
Theo nuzzled my neck. “So, is that a yes to dating us?”
“This is crazy as hell but yes. Let’s see where this goes,” I replied.
A huge smile crossed Seth’s face and he pressed a kiss against my mouth as Theo kissed my neck.
“You won’t regret it, sweetheart. We promise.”
ABOUT RAMONA GRAY
Ramona Gray is a Canadian romance author. She currently lives in Alberta with her awesome husband and her really cute dog. She's addicted to home improvement shows, good coffee, and reading and writing about the steamier moments in life.
