“I thought so!”
“Seriously, it was as much a surprise to me as it was to you. I’ve never given any woman a thought like that.”
“Really? No wild college experiences?”
“Oh, there were some of those, but not with other girls.”
“Do tell.”
“Maybe some other time. That was not even on my radar until Maggie kissed me, and I thought, that was fun. She’s a lovely kisser. It got me curious. And then last night, it just seemed like everything was on the table.”
“Turned out that way, didn’t it?”
“I’d say we covered all of the bases,” Alexandra agreed.
“All? Not quite all.” Adam looked like he had something particularly dirty in mind.
“What do you think we should have done that we didn’t do?”
“I don’t know if it’s a case of should’ve as much as we didn’t really do everything.”
“Are you saying you want to suck Gary off?”
“You’re insane!”
Alexandra kept a straight face for as long as she could and then succumbed to laughter.
“You’re trying to kill the mood, aren’t you?” he asked. “No, nothing gay. But last night you two girls were together, and then we had that orgy moment, but there were no threesomes.”
“I don’t know that Gary would have been cool to sit back while Maggie and I gave you all of our attention.”
“It didn’t have to be that way.”
She thought about it and realized what he was getting at. Adam was definitely kinkier than one would expect. “You’re talking about you guys sharing me, or I bet you’d rather it was Maggie.”
Adam didn’t answer. Her tone made him wonder if he should admit it, but her expression showed she knew it was true. He couldn’t help it. Having his wife blow him while Gary fucked her would be so hot. Not that sharing Alexandra wouldn’t be fun too.
“It’s okay. I think that could be fun to watch—as long as you boys kept enough in reserve to take care of me.” She was not actually sure her husband would be up for anything like that. She was stunned he took part the way he did when they were all together.
“That’s not the only thing,” Adam said, rolling onto his side. He gently rubbed her breasts and then teased her nipples when they became hard. He didn’t know if he had it in him to fuck her again—he needed more of a break at this point—but he just couldn’t stop touching her. She bit her lip when he tweaked her nipple and looked at him helplessly. He could tell she thought she should stop him, but wouldn’t.
Her pussy was red and swollen and he touched it lightly. She was still soaked and he wet his fingers as he dipped them between her lips. Alexandra whimpered and then jumped when he teased her clit. Her breathing was getting deeper and deeper. Adam knew she was too sore to fuck, but it seemed like she could just come endlessly if he played with her. That, however, was not his target. He slid his wet fingers lower, over her taint, and pressed one to the rosebud of her asshole.
“Whoa!” she exclaimed, pulling his hand away. “We never talked about that.”
“You don’t like it in the ass?” Adam asked.
“Does Maggie?”
“I don’t know. I never thought she would be up for it.”
“But you think I am?”
Adam just grinned. “I think you’re up for just about anything, Lexi.”
She smacked his chest. “You’d better adjust your expectations, mister.”
“So you’re not?”
A smile slowly spread across her lips. “I didn’t say that. It has been a long time, and I didn’t particularly enjoy it way back when, but maybe with the right attitude and the right preparation I’d try again.”
That was all Adam needed to hear. Obviously Gary did not use her ass, so he would love taking it.
“Listen. I’m going to take a shower,” she said. She’d taken one before bed, but she wanted to truly be fresh when she saw her husband. Also, she wanted some time on her own to think.
“I’ll be here waiting for you.”
~~~
The couples sat across from each other at the table still paired off in switched couples. Alexandra was ready to return to her husband, but Maggie remained lingering by Gary, and had sat next to him when the room service arrived. The table was loaded with eggs and pancakes and waffles and fruit, toast and coffee. It looked like Adam had ordered everything on the room service menu. There was also orange juice and champagne for mimosas, but Adam was the only one interested in drinking. Everyone else was on the coffee. Alexandra took hers black. Smalltalk flowed between the couples, but it was obvious no one wanted to be the first to bring up what had happened the night before. It came down to Adam to make a joke.
“Think we should tell them to throw out that sofa?” he said.
“Maybe they should put a plaque on it,” Alexandra said. She’d attacked the food. All that play had left her wolfishly hungry.
“This is usually a high rollers suite. I kind of doubt that was the craziest thing that’s ever happened up here,” Gary said.
“Really?” Maggie made a face.
“Hookers and blow, babe,” Adam said.
“I guess you guys are lucky then,” Maggie replied. “You didn’t have to pay for it.”
“But having a little blow would have been interesting,” Adam said.
“We might be in the ER in that case,” Gary said.
“Look at us,” Alexandra said. “Who would have guessed that two boring suburban couples would come down to Atlantic City and have an orgy in a high rollers suite.”
“God, what would the neighbors think?” Maggie asked. “They would never guess in a million years we’d be capable.”
“Not someone as sweet and innocent as you—that’s for sure,” Gary said.
Maggie squeezed his thigh under the table. “Do I have to show you again just how innocent I’m not?”
Gary smiled. “Maybe later.”
“I think all the guys in the neighborhood would be jealous. If they got to watch what we did last night—if they had what we had—they’d never be able to handle it. Josh would have a heart attack!”
“Nicole would be saying a thousand Hail Marys!” Alexandra said.
“I don’t know about Megan and Mal, though. There’s something about those two. I think they might be into it,” Gary said.
“Do you think?” Maggie asked.
“Yeah, there’s something different about those two these days,” Alexandra agreed. “She’s got a spring in her step that I don’t think comes from regular domestic bliss.”
“Do we have that now?” Maggie asked.
Adam smirked. “I know I do.”
“I think he might be up to something, too. I wasn’t spying or anything, but I saw some hot young thing at their house while Megan was away,” Gary said.
“Well, I hope no one is paying as much attention to us as you appear to be paying to Megan and Mal,” Maggie said.
“Maybe Mal was bringing his work home. Doesn’t he run a yoga studio or something? Maybe we should swing over for a lesson sometime,” Alexandra said.
Maggie’s eyes lit up. It was hard not to notice how fit their neighbor was. “That’s a great idea.”
“Settle down, ladies. I think we have a complicated enough situation already,” Gary said.
“Speaking of our situation. Where do we go from here?” Adam asked. “Is this a thing now?”
“I think that’s something we should talk about. Privately,” Alexandra said.
“But what are we talking about? Is anyone interested in keeping this going?” Adam pressed.
Gary gave Maggie a sidelong look. He didn’t know that he was ready to give her up yet. If he continued seeing her every day, the temptation would be too great—especially now that he knew what he’d been missing. But was Alexandra becoming Adam’s mistress a price he was willing to pay? “I think it’s something we can talk about, if that’s what everyone wants
.”
“We need to get a move on anyway,” Alexandra said. They are going to kick us out of here at eleven.”
They wrapped up breakfast, and for the first time since they’d paired off the night before, the married couples were alone together. Adam and Maggie went off to pack and Alexandra followed Gary into their room—the one she’d shared with Adam the night before.
Alexandra closed the double doors and stood by them, watching her husband as he begun to pack. He might have wanted to wait to talk until they were really alone, but she could not hold out. She had to know what he thought after all that had happened. It felt like he wouldn’t make eye contact with her all through breakfast. Spending the night swapped had been Adam’s idea and she’d happily gone along with it. Did Gary resent that?
“Well?” she asked.
Gary stopped packing and sat on the edge of the bed. He looked exhausted. “Well what? Don’t you want to think about this more before we talk about it?
“I think it’s better we talk now, while the feelings are all raw. It’s too easy to rationalize things if we wait until later.”
“Okay, what do you want to talk about? Going forward or last night?”
“Let’s start with last night. Are we okay? We need to know that before we decide anything else.”
Gary sighed. “I’m okay. I’m actually more okay than I thought I would be. Last night was not at all what I imagined. When we agreed we’d all be together, I just assumed we would maybe start in the living room and then go to our bedrooms. I certainly did not think we’d end up as a big pile of bodies. I’m still not sure how that happened.”
“I think I started it,” Alexandra confessed. “It felt sort of like we were in a real life porn movie and I got a little carried away. Everything felt so good and I wanted it all.”
“I could tell.”
“Are you pissed?
“No. Just surprised. I probably shouldn’t be—I know you well enough…”
“What does that mean?” She put her hands on her hips.
“Let’s not kid ourselves. We both know you love attention and last night was sort of the logical conclusion of that. For a minute there you were really the center of attention. I’m not complaining. It’s good that it happened in a safe environment. I always wondered what you’re craving for attention meant—what it could lead to unchecked—and I think we found out last night.”
“It wasn’t just about that,” she said. Alexandra didn’t know whether to be offended or not. There was a lot of truth to what Gary said, but that did not explain what happened.
“No, I don’t think it was. I think you find Maggie as sexy as I do.” He finally smiled.
“Sort of. It really did start as curiosity, but she is a lot of fun. She knows what she’s doing. How are you with me and Adam?”
“It was weird watching you two, I’m not going to lie. It’s strange how different you are with him. But it’s okay. I don’t have the problem I thought I would with it.”
“It sounds like there’s a but there somewhere,” she said.
“It’s not something I think I need to see. If we do go forward, I don’t know that I’m up for another night like last night.”
“I understand. I think Adam’s the opposite of you. He really likes seeing Maggie like that.”
“I sort of got that sense. But he’ll have to figure out a way to indulge it another way.” Gary chuckled. “He can take you out all dressed up and see the guys come on to you. That way everybody wins.”
Alexandra shook her head. “You’re a pill. It sounds like you want to keep this going.”
“I do, but I think we should keep to ourselves, if you know what I mean. If you and Adam go out, that’s fine. And Maggie and I can have our time together.”
“I’m good with that. I bet they will be, too.”
“I think Maggie will. It sounds like Adam might not be.”
“Don’t worry. I can get Adam to play along.”
“So we’re swingers now?” Gary was incredulous.
“Are we swingers if we only play with one other couple? Is this an open marriage?”
“It doesn’t matter what we call it as long as it works for us.
Alexandra finally crossed the room and they held each other. “I love you, you know,” she said. “I could never share with Adam what I share with you.”
“I love you too, babe. I know Adam’s no threat. We just all have to make sure we’re honest with each other about what’s going on as we go forward.”
“Agreed.”
~~~
In the other bedroom, Adam and Maggie were having much the same conversation, except they agreed they wanted to carry on very quickly. Their feelings were much less complicated.
“I know you want to screw Alexandra, but are you sure you’re okay with Gary and I sneaking off together?”
“I’m more than okay with it, Maggie. I think it’s hot. You don’t have to sneak off.”
“Gary wasn’t entirely comfortable with last night. I don’t think you should be planning on a repeat performance.”
Maggie sat on Adam’s lap, playing with his shirt buttons. His hand was on her thigh, just under the hem of her skirt. She wore a cute, clingy purple sundress.
“That kind of sucks.”
“I promise I will share all of the details with you. How’s that?” Maggie kissed his cheek. She could feel him stiffening underneath her.
“That’ll have to do. You guys should go on a date. Lexi and I can watch the kids.”
“You just want to play naughty babysitter with her.”
“Maybe,” he conceded. His hand slid higher under her dress. He touched the satin of her panties. “I think you do too.”
“Mmm, maybe. She’s so sexy.”
“Who knew my wife was a secret lesbian all this time?”
“Stop it! I am not.”
Adam pressed into her panties and felt she was damp. She squirmed as he rubbed her mound and he watched the rise and fall of her tits as she became more aroused.
“I don’t know. You seem to be getting turned on thinking about it. I don’t mind, baby. I think your shopping trips are going to be much more interesting from now on.”
“Could be, but I’m getting wet because you’re touching me.” Maggie moved her butt on his lap to tease his cock.
“So you still want your old husband even after Gary?”
“You’re silly. I want you more for letting me have Gary. Why don’t you pull those pants off so I can show you how grateful I really am.”
Maggie fell back onto the bed and peeled off her panties, while Adam lost his pants. She kept the dress on. Adam fell on top of her. His thick cock slipped right into her and she reflected on how lucky she was to have two such different lovers to please her. Except for maybe Alexandra, Maggie thought she was the luckiest woman in the world.
ebooks by Kirsten McCurran
Domestic Bliss
Queen of Hearts
Her Other Husband: The Complete Series
Hot Dates 2: Living as a Shared Wife
Meghan is Wild
Ana’s Forbidden Fantasy
Hot Dates: Becoming a Shared Wife
Emma's Escape
Blank Canvas
The Wedding Party
Devil's Bargain
Sydney's Sin
Truth or Treat
Bound By Two
The Coach’s Wife
Flirting With Trouble
Swinging Saved Our Marriage
Her Other Husband Series
A Snap Decision/Kissing In a Tree
Kelly Crosses the Line
Kelly Can't Help It
Kelly's Last Date
Substitute Wife
Swapping Around the Christmas Tree
Sex Equity
Stormbound: Seduced by the Neighbors
Because He's Watching
Eve & Friends Series
It Started With a Joke
It Started W
ith Mistletoe
It Started Over Coffee
It Ended With an Announcement
about the author
Kirsten McCurran is the nom de plume of an average thirtysomething woman with a dirty mind and the drive to share her vivid fantasies. She is especially interested in tales of women like her, who are tempted by the forbidden and give in—only to discover the complications that can cause. Like many of her characters, Kirsten lives in the ‘burbs and has a loving husband and a couple of children, so she understands how difficult it might be for one of her characters to balance a real life with her erotic adventures. Her neighbors may be scandalized to discover what is going on in her head, but Kirsten’s husband fully approves, and even lends a hand in the creative process where he can.
Kirsten has written over 25 ebooks, all of which can be found on Amazon. Some are available in other formats on BN.com and Smashwords. She loves to hear from her fans and can be reached on Twitter @kirstenmccurran or by email at [email protected].
Domestic Bliss: A Tale of Two Couples Page 19
