Where They Found Her: A Novel

by Kimberly McCreight

  “The night before last,” she said.

  “And how old are you?”

  Shit. Child Protective Services—Sandy hadn’t thought of that. But she couldn’t lie now. Too big a risk that she would get caught. She just had to hope that leaving a kid her age alone wasn’t some kind of crime.

  “Sixteen. But I don’t want to get her in trouble or anything. She’s a great mom, really.”

  Except Sandy had already said that Jenna wasn’t that dependable. Why had she said that? The police officer stared at her some more, squinting now, like he was trying to figure out where he’d seen Sandy before. But no one had seen her. She was sure of that much. He reached over the desk and held out his hand. “I’m Steve,” he said. “What’s your name?”

  “Sandy.”

  “Okay, Sandy. Lucky for you, I’ve got a soft spot for daughters.” He waved for her to follow him into the next room. “If I put your mom in the system, there’s a chance this will end up getting bounced to Social Services, and that could make a mess of things for both of you when your mom shows up an hour from now. Why don’t we start with a quick off-the-record search, just to make sure she hasn’t been in an accident or anything.”

  “Thanks,” Sandy said. “A lot.”

  “No problem,” Steve said, leading the way to his office.

  Sandy sat in the chair in front of Steve’s desk as he hunted and pecked his way across the keyboard, finally getting to a screen filled with numbers and blank lines. Then he reached for some reading glasses, peering down his nose through them at the screen. At this rate, Sandy could be there for hours.

  He turned to her and smiled. “As you can see, I don’t do this much.”

  And judging from his big office, Steve wasn’t a regular police officer. He was the police officer, the one in charge. Sandy looked up at the bookcase over his head: a couple of framed certificates, a diploma, and a trophy with a basketball player on top. On the second shelf, she noticed the pictures. Dozens of family snapshots. Her eyes settled on one in the middle: a family of four, clustered together on the beach, all smiles and lit up by the sun. And right there, in the center, a face she fucking recognized: Hannah.

  Jesus Christ. That would have been something nice to know. You know: Hey, FWIW, my dad’s the chief of police. But it wasn’t like Hannah had lied. They’d never talked about their dads, only their moms. Always their moms.

  “Wait, your mom wouldn’t let you what?” Sandy had asked a month or two into their sessions, choking on her coffee. Hannah had been telling another insane story about her mom—they seemed extra insane because Hannah seemed to think they were totally normal. At least Sandy knew Jenna was screwed up.

  They’d been studying at the Black Cat again. Hannah always wanted to go there, said she felt more comfortable around the college kids, though Sandy always felt like Hannah was waiting to see someone. Like maybe she had a crush on a barista or something. Sandy even asked once whether there was someone, and Hannah had blown her off with the usual “You know I don’t date yet.”

  “My mom wouldn’t let me wear sparkles,” Hannah said.

  “Sparkles? What are you, Dora the Explorer?”

  Hannah started laughing so hard that her face got all red. “I mean when I was little,” she said when she’d caught her breath. “I always wanted to wear those sneakers that are all covered in glitter. You know?”

  “No, I don’t know,” Sandy said. Like the junk drawer, glitter sneakers: another of life’s mysteries. “But I gotta be honest, they sound ugly as shit.”

  “Yeah,” Hannah said this time with a forced laugh. But she looked kind of sad as she turned to look out the window. She was so pretty in the light. Delicate and soft in a way Sandy would never be. As Hannah’s smile sank, Sandy watched her try to lift it back up. “They were ugly, I guess. But I cried for so long when she said no. I couldn’t stop crying, which only made my mom madder.” Her eyes got wide, remembering. “Like she really, really hated me.”

  I’m sure she doesn’t hate you, Sandy thought about saying. But she didn’t like it when people said that kind of bullshit to her. As if them thinking the world was always so perfect and right would make it so.

  “That’s messed up. What did you do?”

  “Do?” Hannah blinked at Sandy. “With my mom, there’s nothing to do except try not to make her mad the next time. I’m always trying to do that. To be the person she wants me to be.”

  “Is it working?”

  “Not really.” Hannah shook her head. Her eyes were glassy.

  “Don’t you ever just want to say fuck off instead?” Sandy asked. “I mean, no offense, but isn’t she supposed to be the person who loves you no matter what?” Even Jenna did that.

  “I think about it sometimes—a lot, even,” Hannah said, looking down. She was quiet for a while before she looked up. “But that would just make her hate me forever.”

  “Maybe it wouldn’t. Maybe it would make her change.” Sandy wasn’t sure who she was talking about: Hannah’s mom or Jenna.

  “No,” Hannah said softly, picking her pencil up and focusing again on her schoolwork. “My mom will never change.”

  “Yikes,” Steve said. When Sandy snapped her eyes down from the pictures, he was pointing toward the scab on her arm. “What happened there?”

  Shit. Sandy had let her sleeve ride up. “Oh, I fell off my bike.” She wrinkled her nose like a little kid—you know, “these things happen.” But her heart was pounding. Breathe. Fucking breathe. It’s just a question. One that anybody would ask, not just a cop. “At least my bike’s okay.”

  “I don’t know about that.” Steve shook his head. “Bike can be replaced. You can’t. Hope you’re not riding around at night without reflective gear. I’m telling you, there are more bicyclist fatalities that way. Got to be careful out there.”

  “Yeah. I mean, no. I mean—” Sandy shook her head, feeling sick. “I have reflectors.”

  “Good, good. Okay, now I’m ready here with this system. Spell your mom’s full name for me?” Steve was leaning over his computer again, fingers raised above the keyboard.

  “Jenna Mendelson. M-e-n-d-e-l-s-o-n.”

  Steve didn’t type. Didn’t move. He stayed frozen like that, hands floating over the keys. Sandy could feel her stomach pushing up. Was Jenna already dead, and Steve knew it? Did the mention of her name click the pieces into place? Slowly he turned to look at Sandy, peeling off his glasses. The friendly-dad look on his face was totally gone. Now there was a full-on cop there. And it was scaring the hell out of her.

  “I think maybe we should start again. At the beginning,” he said, staring dead at her. “When exactly was the last time you saw your mother?”

  MOLLY

  MAY 18, 2013

  What I told Dr. Zomer was not the whole truth. I didn’t even tell Justin that. But I think he knew. Of course he did.

  I did drop a glass and I did slip and cut my hand a little when I was trying to clean it up. That’s all true. But when I saw the blood on my hand, I didn’t feel upset or worried. I felt relieved. Like the world had been rebalanced.

  I don’t even remember picking up the piece of glass that I cut my arm with. But I did. I must have. I do remember being careful not to cause any real damage, in my nonexpert medical opinion. Because I could have if I’d wanted to. I could have done so much more.

  And then Ella started to cry—one of her night terrors. And so I ran to her without thinking, because I could do that by then, comfort her after a bad dream. I didn’t realize how much that small cut was already bleeding.

  I had Ella in my arms when Justin came home a few minutes later. As soon as he saw us, he started yelling: Where’s she bleeding? Where’s she bleeding? It wasn’t until I looked down that I saw Ella’s head was covered in blood.

  A second later, I passed out. Luckily, Justin caught me—and Ella, thank God—as I fell. Next thing I knew, the paramedics were lifting me into the ambulance. Halfway to the hospital, they realized
that the cut to my arm wasn’t serious. That I’d passed out not from blood loss but from the sight of it all over my daughter.

  Justin lied and told the paramedics that he had been there, seen the whole thing. That it had been an accident, me and the broken glass and my arm. And watching Justin do that for me, lie like his life depended on it, like my life depended on it—and it might have, they could have hospitalized me against my will—I have never loved him more.

  And so when he’d insisted the next day that I go see Dr. Zomer, I went. It was the least I could do.

  Molly

  “I got you a latte,” Stella said when I got to the Black Cat. She was at a table by the window, two coffees already in front of her. “Full-fat milk, of course. Because that’s all they serve in this godforsaken place.” Her nostrils flared. “Honestly, I don’t understand why you like it here.”

  “It reminds me of the city,” I said as I sat down across from her, trying not to think of the box of files I’d had Steve leave in our living room. The box that was left by some stranger. A reader, maybe, but an angry one? A happy one? Who was to say? Thinking of it still inside my house filled me with dread. I wasn’t sure that I’d done the right thing, not reporting it as a crime.

  I’d gone back inside after Steve left, but only long enough to get Ella dressed and to change out of the yoga pants I’d slept in. I’d deliberately avoided looking at the box. After Ella was safely at school, I’d planned to go home and look inside. Except now I was doing my damnedest to avoid the house. I was so stressed about the whole thing, I was even tempted to tell Stella. But that box was exactly the strange turn of events she lived for. She’d have us rushing back to my house to go through every last page.

  “Cockroaches would remind you of the city, too, you know,” Stella went on. “But that doesn’t mean we need to start importing them. Oh, wait, I didn’t tell you, did I?” She leaned forward conspiratorially. “Zachary and I are having lunch after my lesson today.”

  “Really?” I was relieved to be talking about something silly like Stella’s endless—but largely halfhearted—pursuit of her thirty-one-year-old tennis coach. It gave me an excuse not to ask the questions I had about Rose and her baby and Aidan. I wasn’t sure I was ready for the answers.

  I startled when my phone buzzed on the table.

  “Wow, jumpy much?” Stella asked, intrigued. “Who is it?”

  Richard Englander. I was surprised it had taken Richard all the way until nine thirty to call me again. It was his third call. There had also been a couple of texts. He was back in the office and wanted in on the biggest story that had hit Ridgedale in years. In fairness, it would have been his if he hadn’t been out. His first message, the night before, had been nice—just checking in to see if I needed any help. But each one had gotten more insistent. I let his call go straight to voicemail, fairly certain I’d never listen to the message. And absolutely sure I wasn’t giving him the story back. Not unless and until Erik made me.

  “So you were saying: lunch with Zachary?” I turned back to Stella. “Really?”

  “Wait a second, don’t try to change the subject.” She pointed a finger at me. “What’s wrong? Who was that?”

  “It was just that guy, the other reporter from the Reader. The young one.”

  “The asshole?”

  “Yes, him. He’s the news reporter. The baby would have been his story if he hadn’t been out sick,” I said. “He wants me to hand it over.”

  “Screw him,” Stella said. “You’re doing a great job. I read that piece of yours this morning about—what’s it called—neonaticide. It was really . . .” She searched for a word. “Impassioned.”

  “Yeah, well, it would definitely make Justin happy if I let Richard take over.”

  “Oh yeah?” She paused, pressing her lips together. I could always see Stella bracing to pounce whenever I complained about Justin, which was why I never did. She loved to bitch about husbands—ex, current, prospective, it didn’t matter.

  “He’s worried I’m going to have some kind of breakdown because it’s about a baby.”

  Stella stared at me for a long time, her expression unreadable. “Are you?” Her tone was matter-of-fact. As though, yes, a calamitous mental breakdown was always a possibility, just an utterly unremarkable one.

  And that was why I loved her.

  “No,” I said. Not only did I mean it, but it felt true. “I’m really not. I know it doesn’t make any sense, but I actually feel better than I have in years.”

  “Then, as your friend, I say you need to do it,” Stella said with unusual seriousness. There was an unfamiliar look on her face, too—sincerity. “Regardless of what makes sense. And notwithstanding what Justin wants.”

  “Right, screw the damn husband,” I said with a gentle smile. I didn’t think that was what Stella meant, but she could be flip about marriage.

  She looked wounded. “I’m just saying sometimes there are things you need to do, no matter what anyone says about it.”

  “So what ended up happening with Rose?” I asked, knowing it was time to change the subject. And I needed to clear the air. My suspicions were surely ridiculous; they felt ridiculous. But a little proof would be nice. “You know, the police called me looking for her. And you.”

  “Yes, apparently I needed permission to take my aunt to the Philadelphia Flower Show.” Stella didn’t seem the least bit surprised or concerned. “Anyway, Rose took off. I told the police that. And can you blame her? They will eventually figure out that it wasn’t her baby, but in the meantime, why should she stick around while they harass her? Anyway, I don’t think that’s why she left. I think it was the baby’s father. She told me she wasn’t on her way to work when she got into that accident. She was leaving town. She wouldn’t tell me details, but I think she was scared.”

  “How can you be sure she’s okay? Have you spoken to her?”

  “Are you saying you think I lied to the police when I said I didn’t know where she went?” Stella asked with exaggerated offense. “Working on this story has made you awfully suspicious, Ms. Sanderson.”

  “I’m just saying, what if the baby’s father came and took her from the hospital?”

  “That’s what you’re worried about, Rose’s safety?” Stella asked. She could tell I wasn’t convinced Rose was in the clear. Stella was hard to manipulate. “That baby is not Rose’s baby. Didn’t they say it was a newborn? Rose’s baby was at least three weeks old. And she wasn’t a small baby.”

  “Approximately newborn,” I clarified. “I don’t think they know for sure.”

  “Well, well, you’ve certainly drunk the Kool-Aid,” Stella said. “You sound just like them, Molly. And I don’t mean that as a compliment.”

  Before I could defend myself—and it would have been a lame defense—Stella was distracted by a text.

  “Great,” she said. Then she spoke aloud at an annoyed clip, the contents of the response she was typing. “Why aren’t you in school, Aidan?” She shook her head and looked up at me. “You’d think he’d know enough not to text me when he’s supposed to be in class. Aidan’s crappy behavior might bother me less if it didn’t always make him look so damn stupid.”

  “Sounds like things are the same with him, then.”

  Aidan. The flower girl. I could still hear Ella’s little voice: What’s a slut, Mommy? There was surely an explanation. I just needed to hear it. And I needed to figure out a way to get Stella to tell me without having to ask her outright. Because I liked Stella, and I wasn’t sure our relationship could survive that kind of direct accusation.

  “Things with Aidan never change.” She shrugged, frowned. “I just have to accept that I have no control over what he does. Maybe Aidan will end up fine, and maybe he won’t. That’s terrifying, but it’s also reality. I can’t drive myself crazy waiting to see how he’ll turn out.”

  “Maybe he needs a girlfriend,” I said. “You know, somebody to keep him in line.”

  “Bite your
tongue,” Stella said. “The one thing—probably the only thing—we have going for us is that Aidan doesn’t have a girlfriend.”

  When I got home, I stood in the open door, staring down at the box, afraid to open it. Finally I crouched down and jerked off the lid as if ripping off a Band-Aid. My pulse was racing when I looked in, but Steve had been right, just some ordinary files.

  I pulled one out at random. It was for a girl named Trisha Campbell from 2006. Inside were photocopies of a hodgepodge of Ridgedale University records—transcripts, dorm information, food-plan data. Trisha had been a good student, a double major in English and history who’d studied in Spain her junior year. I had Trisha’s file open in front of me as I pulled out another, this one from 2007. A girl named Rebecca Raynor. Inside was a slightly different mix of records. Rebecca had been a biology major with less impressive grades but several awards for music achievement. I put Rebecca’s file next to Trisha’s. Then I saw a name I recognized: Rose Gowan, 2014.

  When I looked back at Trisha’s file, sure enough, there it was: VW, in the middle of her senior year. Rebecca had voluntarily withdrawn as well. As it turned out, every one of the students in that box—six, all female—had withdrawn voluntarily from Ridgedale University. One in 2006 and two in 2007, the remaining three from 2012 to 2014. The only obvious connection I could find was between the three girls who’d withdrawn in 2006 and 2007: They’d all taken the same American studies class, taught by a Professor Christine Carroll. Otherwise, the remaining girls’ schedules and backgrounds were completely different.

  I rushed out of the house, gripping the box of files, intent on confronting Director of Security Ben LaForde. But as I drove toward campus, I began to wonder what I was confronting him about. A series of improperly investigated sexual attacks on campus that led half a dozen women to leave school—that’s what I was thinking. I felt sure that Ben LaForde was hiding something. But what proof did I have?

  Six young women had withdrawn from Ridgedale University in about a decade. What was an average rate at any university? Perhaps many male students had withdrawn as well. There was no note in the box of files, nothing to explain what their assemblage meant. My theory was based largely on the fact that Stella suspected Rose Gowan had been raped on campus and then withdrawn. It was something of a leap to assume that the box implied that the same bad thing had happened to all the other girls.