Eat the Beetles!: An Exploration into Our Conflicted Relationship with Insects

Home > Other > Eat the Beetles!: An Exploration into Our Conflicted Relationship with Insects > Page 34
Eat the Beetles!: An Exploration into Our Conflicted Relationship with Insects Page 34

by David Waltner-Toews


  need to politicize, 281

  as normal culinary option, 294

  as rising trend, x, 47, 222, 292

  as seasonal, 38, 62–63, 65–67, 274

  insect-human relationships

  complexity of, 147–148, 273

  framing of, 130

  with honey bees, 66–71

  management of, 91, 282

  need to reimagine, 140

  insecticidal music, 166

  insecticides. See also pesticides

  collateral damage from, 127

  DDT, 125–127

  locust plagues and, 154–155

  resistance to, 133

  risks to farm workers, 133

  insect-insect relationships, 80–82

  insectivory. See also entomophagy; insect-eating

  amongst primates, 61–62

  cultural benefits of, 62

  vs entomophagy, 14

  insect-microbe relationships, 78–80

  insect-mineral relationships, 76–78

  insecto-theology, 299–300

  insect-plant relationships, 57, 82–83, 87, 89–90

  insects. See also social insects

  allergic reactions to, 258

  as animal feed, 210–219, 230

  in art, 63, 67

  attitudes towards, 118, 124, 145, 153, 223–224, 227–228

  beauty of, 248–249

  communication by, 83–84, 91–97, 100–101

  consciousness in, 241–243

  counting populations of, 3, 9, 17–19

  cultural images of, 124, 141–142, 151

  as disgusting, 104–105

  ethical considerations for, 234–235, 245–247, 256

  evolution of, 51–60

  in film and literature, 105–107, 119–120

  as garnishes and supplements, 38, 229

  harvesting of, 261

  importing of, 184, 248, 278

  light polarization and visual cues in, 97–99

  love of, 239

  magnetoreception in, 99–100

  natural predators for, 160–161

  as not kosher, 221

  nutritional value of, xi–xii, xviii, 26–38

  as optional ingredient, 200–201

  pheromones in communication, 91–94

  pre-history of, 51–52, 54–55

  primates eating, 61

  semi-management of, 274

  sexual cannibalism in, 122

  in song and music, 144

  stinging and biting by, 91

  storage and preservation of, 155–156, 201, 260, 274

  suffering in, 240–245, 249–250, 307

  supply-side sustainability of, xviii, 202

  as threats to food sources, 66, 113–117

  trained to detect contaminants, 260–261

  as vulnerable, 91

  war against, 125–129

  Insects as Human Food: A Chapter of the Ecology of Man, 118–119

  Insects for Food and Feed Conference (2015), 280–281

  Insects Inter (chain of street vendors), 229–230

  Integrated Pest Management (IPM), 161

  intercropping, 158

  International Livestock Research Institute, 42

  International Platform for Insects as Food and Feed (IPIFF), 271

  J

  Japan International Volunteer Center (JIVC), 187

  Japanese beetles, 161

  Jianchu, Xu, 168–169

  Johns, Jasper, 143–144

  Jotï people, 178–179

  Journal of Insects as Food and Feed, 211

  K

  katydids, 24, 55, 59, 144. See also bush crickets

  keyhole amphibians, 53

  keystone species, 78

  killer bees, 128

  kissing bugs. See assassin bugs (triatomine bugs)

  koinobiosis, 81–82

  kosher paleontology, 237

  Kwong, Kylie, 226–227

  L

  lacewings

  in aphid control, 161

  pre-history of, 55

  ladybugs (ladybird beetles)

  in literature, 140

  many species of, 163

  in pest management, 161–163

  Lampyridae, 98

  Langstroth, Lorenzo Lorraine, 68–69, 283–284

  language

  baggage associated with, 303–304

  in insects, 100

  laser vibrometry, 97

  Le Festin Nu (restaurant), x, xiii–xv, 120

  lead, in chapulines, 258–259

  leaf-cutter ants, 225–226

  leaflitter mantid, 24

  Lennon, John, 147, 307–308

  Lepidoptera, 9–10. See also armyworms; butterflies; moths

  in Cretaceous period, 57

  in human diet, 10

  Lesser, Friedrich Christian, 299

  lesser water boatman, 95. See also true bugs

  lice, 121–122

  life cycle assessment (LCA), 44–45

  life on earth, beginnings of, 50–52

  light polarization and visual cues, in insects, 97–99

  lignocellulose, 79

  Linepithema humile virus 1, 269

  Linnaeus, Carl, 18, 141

  livelihood strategies, 175–176

  Lockwood, Jeffrey

  on entomapatheia, 166, 239–240

  on insect terminology, 6, 14

  on insects as conscious beings, 241–242

  on locust extinction, 114–115

  on locust plagues, 155

  on sanctuaries, 173, 312

  Locust: The Devastating Rise and Mysterious Disappearance of the Insect That Shaped the American Frontier, 115

  locusts

  Bombay locusts (Patanga succincta), 153

  consumption of, 66, 154

  extinction of, 114–115

  vs grasshoppers, 84–85, 113

  in literature, 148–149

  loss of habitat for, 115–116

  nutrient levels in, 154

  plagues, 113–115, 127, 146, 154–155

  primates eating, 62

  storage and preservation of, 155–156

  swarming of, 85, 113–114

  as threats to food sources, 113–114

  longhorn beetles, 97

  Looy, Heather, 14–15, 126

  love

  of animals, 239

  biophilia and, 238

  vs caring, 240–241

  and ethics, 238–241

  of insects, 239

  as life force, 307

  lower termites, 79

  luna moths, 92

  M

  mad cow (BSE), 262

  maggots, 107–108

  Magicicada, 95

  magnetoreception, 99–100

  malaria, 14, 125–126, 164–165, 171

  mantises

  European praying mantis (Mantis religiosa), 12

  in film, xxii, 120

  leaflitter mantid, 24

  sexual cannibalism in, 122

  walking flower mantis, 24

  walking leaf mantis, 24

  manuka honey, 268, 282

  Marchant, Brad, 211, 215, 218

  Martin, Daniella

  on eating insects, 170, 172

  Girl Meets Bug, xi

  scorpion-eating video, 182

  mayflies, 22

  mead, 69–70, 156

  mealworm beetles, 13

  mealworms. See also darkling beetles

  animal feed from, 219

  FAO study of, 34

  Feed Conve
rsion Ratio (FCR) for feed from, 219

  life cycle assessment (LCA) of, 45–46

  most popular insect as food, 11

  nutrient levels in, 32–34

  origin of name, 6

  powder from, 260

  as recyclers, 86

  as snack, 292

  Tenebrionidae family, 13

  mealybugs, 131

  meaning of life, search for, 301–313

  Meganeuridae, 54

  Meganeuropsis permiana, 54

  melon flies, 164

  metamorphosis

  described, 5

  ecological implications of, 22–23

  history of, 55

  methane. See also greenhouse gases (GHG), insect production of, 43–44

  methanogenesis, 43

  methylglyoxal, 282

  miasis, 107–108

  midges, and chocolate (cacao), 87–88

  Milbenkäse, 263–264

  Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (2004), 193

  millipedes, 52–53

  mimicry, 24

  mini-livestock, xx, 44

  mirid bugs

  Macrolophus costalis, 97

  Macrolophus pygmaeus, 97

  mole crickets, 196

  monarch butterflies

  loss of habitat for, 115

  sanctuaries for, 173

  monocultures, 143, 268, 283

  Monster of God: The Man-Eating Predator in the Jungles of History and the Mind, 106–107

  mopane caterpillars/worms, 5. See also emperor moths

  cadmium levels in, 259

  cash income from, 180

  consumption of in Africa, 63, 175–176

  copper levels in, 259

  foraging for, 275

  and mopane trees, 83

  nutrients in, 35

  overforaging for, 275

  preparation method for, 259

  salt and manganese in, 258

  as semi-managed, 274

  storage and preservation of, 260

  zinc levels in, 259

  morality

  defined, 235–236

  vs ethics, 235–236

  religious scriptures and, 237–238

  mosquitoes

  Anopheles gambiae, 14

  dengue fever and, 110–111

  malaria and, 125–126, 164–165, 171

  management of, 161

  moth larvae

  armyworms, 161

  bamboo worms (Omphisa fuscidentalis), 168–169

  farming of, 25

  mopane caterpillars/worms (Gonimbrasia belina), 5, 35, 63, 83, 175–176, 180, 258–260, 274–275

  tobacco budworms, 161

  witjuti grubs (Endoxyla leucomochla), 5, 63

  moths

  bamboo borer (Omphisa fuscidentalis), 168–169

  cecropia moths, 82

  cossid moths (Endoxyla leucomochla), 5

  emperor moths (Gonimbrasia belina), 5, 83, 175

  luna moths, 92

  peacock moths, 92

  pheromones in communication, 92

  silkmoths, 183

  wax moths, 67

  Mymaridae, 12, 21

  myriapods, 7–8, 52–53

  N

  National Institute of Nutrition (Rome), 29–30

  nature

  caring about, 240

  complexity of, 12, 106

  genius of, 299

  learning from, 56, 309–310

  as useful, 301

  working with, 128, 159

  neo-Darwinism, 299

  neonicotinoids, 134–135

  nest-provisioning wasps, 58

  nocturnal beetles, 99

  Noma (restaurant), 225, 291

  non-insect eaters

  as addicted to pesticides, 160

  horror of insects, 105–106

  vs insect-eaters, 4–6

  naming of insects by, 11

  revulsion for insects, 107–108, 119–120

  North America, 63

  Canada, xii, 135, 202–208, 211–215

  Mexico, 30, 63, 95, 115, 156–157, 259

  United States, 95, 114–115, 117, 135, 154–156, 162, 280

  nutrient content in insects, xi–xii. See also specific insects, e.g. mopane caterpillars

  anecdotal evidence of, 27–28

  dry-weight basis, 29, 32

  as-eaten basis, 29, 32

  scientific evidence of, 28

  O

  obligate symbiosis, 79

  ommatidia, 98

  orchid bees, 90

  orchids, Brazil nuts, bees and, 89–90

  organic waste

  in insect farming, 215, 217

  recycling of, 211–212

  organophosphate pesticides, 156

  Orthoptera, 9. See also crickets; grasshoppers; locusts

  in human diet, 10

  as nutrient recyclers, 84–85

  survival of Permian extinction by, 58–59

  overconsumption, 128, 253–254

  overforaging, 101, 179, 254–255, 275

  P

  Pacific beetle cockroach, 37

  pacts

  with animals, 249–252

  with insects, 250–251, 256

  palm weevil larvae

  fats in, 33

  flavor of, xv

  nutrient levels in, 37

  nutritional value of, 180

  and palm trees, 83–84, 179

  palm weevils. See also beetles

  farming of, 179–180

  and palm trees, 83–84, 178

  as pests, 84

  as semi-managed, 31, 274, 276

  pandemics, xix–xx, 105, 264

  parasitic wasps

  in chemical detection, 261

  Darwin on, 304

  in pest management, 161, 163

  parasitoids, 12–13, 21–22, 80–82, 158

  parasitosis, 106

  parthenogenesis, 20, 23–24, 139. See also virgin-birth

  Payne, Charlotte

  on categories of edible insects, 31–32

  on declining insect consumption in Japan, 278

  on hunting hornets, 189

  on politicization of insect-eating, 281

  on salt and manganese in mopane caterpillars, 258

  PDB (paradichlorobenzene), 130

  peacock moths, 92

  pentachromatism, 97–98

  perception in insects, 100

  periodical cicadas, 95–96

  Permian extinction, 54, 58–59

  pest management. See also Integrated Pest Management (IPM)

  insects controlling insects in, 159–160

  role of foraging in, 58, 179

  use of bacteria in, 161, 164

  use of parasitoids in, 21, 82, 158

  pesticides. See also insecticides

  in beehives, 135

  Rachel Carson’s work on, 125–126, 131, 157

  resistance to, 126

  as short-term solutions, 152

  pestilence as punishment, 127–128

  pet food, insect protein for, 216–217

  pheromones

  alarm pheromones, 92–93

  aphrodisiacs, 92

  in insect communication, 91–94

  in insect control, 158

  pinion engraver beetles, 97

  pinion trees (Pinus edulis), 96–97

  place-based science, 286

  Planet of the Bugs, 10, 24, 54

  Pliny the Elder, 8

  pollination services, 268

  polyphenism, 85
r />   post-normal science (PNS), 265, 287

  pot-bellied pigs, 253

  primates

  first appearances of, 59

  as insectivores, 61

  processed animal proteins (PAP), 262–263

  proctodeal trophallaxis, 79

  propolis, 70

  protein powder from insects, xii, 193, 208, 211

  Protorthoptera, 55

  Pterostichus lucublandus, 92

  Public Bar and Restaurant, 228

  Q

  Quammen, David, 106–107

  R

  Ramos-Elorduy, Julieta, 30, 63

  Rangoli (restaurant), 222

  red palm weevils, 178–179. See also palm weevils

  red-blindness, 97

  Reduviidae, 111

  Regier, Henry, 239, 307

  regulations

  re honey bees, 268

  re insect consumption, 257–272

  re insects-as-food (EU), 217–219, 263, 271–272

  reasons for, 266–267

  as reflecting social ideals, 237

  Renewable Food for Animals and Plants™, 211

  revulsion

  defined, 119

  roots of, 107

  rice grasshoppers, 31

  Riley, Charles Valentine, 18, 117, 162–163

  river blindness, 121, 139

  roaches, 54. See also cockroaches

  rock art

  grasshoppers in, 63

  hive-harvesting in, 67

  Rothenberg, David, 96, 144, 166

  r-strategists, 20

  S

  sago worms. See palm weevil larvae

  sal de hormiga, 225–226

  San people, 73

  sanctuaries, 280–281, 312–313. See also insect sanctuaries

  sawflies, 21, 56

  scale insects

  California red scale (Aonidiella aurantii), 13

  cochineal scale insects, 221, 279

  cottony cushion scale (Icerya purchasi), 162–163

  exudate of, 131

  scaling up

  challenges in, 203

  technology and, 233

  scientists

  classification of insects by, 4–6, 8, 11

  on insect population size, 18–19

  place-based science and, 286–288

  preconceptions of, 123–124

  as skeptical of anecdotal claims, 27–28

  scorpionflies, 55

  screw-worm flies (Cochliomyia hominivorax), 164

  selenium, 77–78

  sericulture, 280. See also silkworms

  sexual cannibalism, 122

  Shakespeare, William, on flies, 108

  Shaw, Scott Richard, 10

  on insect ears, 54

  on insect legs, 24

 

‹ Prev