She repeated this motion, eating his cock, showing him that all other women had nothing on her. She might not have the strength of Evelyn and she might not have the stunning, natural beauty of Kalina, but she had something neither of them possessed. She had a tenacity, a power, a feistiness, and she aggressively took that out on his cock.
She pulled her mouth away and he looked down to see her smiling.
“Make love to me,” she said.
“I thought you wanted to swim with me,” he said.
“I do,” she said. “Will you let me?”
With that, he turned and dove into the water, instantly exploding into his shark form.
***
Penny hadn’t thought he would agree to swimming with her, but then he turned and disappeared into the water. She expected to see him come splashing up to the surface, but he didn’t. For a few seconds, nothing happened at all, but then she saw the fin break the surface, and she realized he was in shark form, and he was swimming in circles around the lagoon.
Every one of those shark horror movies came back to her all at once. She knew deep down that Thane would never harm her, but here she was about to willingly step into a body of water where a tiger shark was doing laps.
This is absolutely nuts. This is crazy.
Penny closed her eyes and stepped forward, shuffling her feet one after the other as she inched her way toward the water. The sand slid up between her toes and then her feet were touching the warm lagoon water. It dawned on her that if she were to be turned into a shifter, she wouldn’t be able to touch salt water again without turning into a shark.
The fin made its way past her again, and when it was on the opposite side of the lagoon, she took a few steps closer. At a little deeper than thigh level she felt the warm water on her pussy and found it odd that she was completely naked and willing to go swimming with a shark. A dolphin she could totally understand, but a shark?
Then, when the fin passed her again and circled around to the far end of the lagoon, she closed her eyes and leapt into the water. There, treading water to stay afloat, she saw the fin coming her way and it took everything in her power not to scream. Who willingly goes swimming with a shark? The fin disappeared under the water, but she could feel Thane pass by. The water near her legs swirled as it moved out of the way of the shark’s massive weight. When it did, a cool wave swished between Penny’s legs, tickling her clit, and she had to wonder if he’d done it on purpose. Surely, he hadn’t. Yet, when he did it again, she thought otherwise. It was quite possible that he was trying to get her aroused even in his shark form.
On his next go ‘round, his fin stayed above the surface and he slowed down enough so she could reach out and touch him. Her fingertips slid over the slippery, yet slightly rough skin of the tiger shark. Her body shuddered with chills.
I’m touching a fucking shark!
Then he passed again, and this time, she reached out to him and grabbed hold of his fin, allowing him to move her carefully around the lagoon. With her head tilted back, the water swept her hair to both sides, ran over her face, and rolled over her neck and shoulders. She loved it. He was inviting her into his world. When he dipped beneath the surface, she held her breath and went with him, holding her naked body against him. Her eyes remained closed, so the salt water wouldn’t bother her, and that only intensified the unexplainable sensuality of the moment.
To anyone watching, it would be nothing more than some crazy woman swimming with a shark, but there beneath the moonlight, with her skin against Thane’s, she felt like she’d snuck off to perform some forbidden underwater dance with her lover.
It was all feels. Breathless, naked, and slightly afraid, she pushed her body harder against him, feeling her tits pressed tightly against his side. She opened her legs and did her best to wrap them around him, so he could feel her pussy against his rough tiger shark skin. Her pussy felt good against him, and she wanted him to turn back into a human, so he could fuck her properly.
Am I masturbating against a shark?
The thought came as she began to slowly grind her pussy against him. Thane returned to the surface, so she could breathe, and then dipped back down again. It was an underwater waltz, two naked beings enjoying each other’s presence. Of course, she wouldn’t fuck the shark. The thought was absurd, but knowing the beast was Thane and its gigantic form was between her legs, turned her on more than she could have imagined. She needed to be fucked.
The shark sped up beneath the water, dragging her around the lagoon, and even in swimming he was rough. It was his animal side, and she couldn’t wait to climb out onto the shore and fuck him. Then, just like that, he raced her back toward the shore and turned sharply, bucking her off him. She fought to catch her breath and crawled onto the beach.
She couldn’t see him approaching from behind, but she could hear the loud rush of water coming at her, like a lustful tidal wave, and then the heavy thump of his feet landing on the sand. Then he was on her. On her hands and knees, she looked back at him, his naked human form so hungry for her. She crawled to drier sand, so he could be far enough away from the salt water.
When he grabbed her ass on both sides in his powerful grip, she smiled, because she knew what was coming. Thane kicked her knees open, and she felt a cool wind against her folds. Then the head of his cock was on her, and she was so fucking horny she didn’t need time to get wet. He entered her roughly, like a man who couldn’t wait another fucking second for his woman. Her eyes shot open and her forehead hit the beach as the entire length of his cock drove into her from behind. She slapped the sand, fighting against the pain.
Her breath came out in gasps and she fought for air nearly as much as she had underwater as each time he entered her, she couldn’t breathe. She whimpered and dug her fingers into the sand, curling them and feeling it slide between her fingers as she tried to remain quiet. His cock was too good. Every inch was delicious, and he gave her all of them, fucking her the way she imagined he’d wanted to in the water. Her quiet, shy sighs of pleasure erupted in a cry of ecstasy.
“Fuck me, Thane,” she said. “I’m your woman.”
He leaned forward and grabbed her right tit, pinching the nipple between his fingers, and kept thrusting into her.
“Make me one of you,” she said. “I think I’m ready. I want to be like you.”
He stopped mid-thrust and stayed there with his cock pulsating inside her. She backed into him, trying to force him in deeper, but he held her ass steady with his hand.
“You don’t understand what that means,” he said.
“I do,” she replied. “Ruby and Kalina told me everything. I know of the dangers, but I love you, Thane. I’m dying. If you will keep me here until my last breath, I will gladly go in your arms, but if you want me to stay here with you forever, then you need to do this.”
“It would be selfish of me,” he said.
“I’m giving you permission,” she replied. “I’m asking you to do this. Make me yours forever.”
As she spoke those final words, he turned her around. He sat down on the beach, his ass in the sand, and gestured for her to come to him. She stood and sashayed toward him, doing her best to be a tease.
***
She had no idea the power she had over him. She could have asked Thane for anything and he would have done it. Especially when she had that look in her eye. His desire for her was too strong. The feel of her body against his underwater was intense. He’d never swam with a pure human like that before. The way she’d pressed her pussy against him.
God, is there anything about this woman that isn’t spectacular? Is there anything about her that doesn’t drive me crazy? Fuck being a shark. Fuck Evelyn. Fuck patrolling the shores. Fuck everything else about life. Give me Penelope.
The way she’d opened up for him, allowing him to shove his cock into her like he had, meant she was up for practically anything. She wanted him as badly as he wanted her. But she wanted to be turned into one of his kind and
that was a bad idea.
Yet, she insisted. Now, she stood over him, her pussy drenched and waiting for him. As she sat down on his lap, facing him, he held onto her waist with his left hand and steadied his cock with his right. She carefully sat down on him, the head of his cock sliding between her folds and inching its way deep into her core.
“Oh God,” she whispered, and he mentally repeated the phrase as he enjoyed the heat of her pussy and the way it wrapped around his cock.
Her pussy devoured him and there she sat, balls deep. She rocked ever so slightly but stayed still for the most part.
“I know this is crazy,” she said, “but I feel like I love you, Thane.”
It was crazy. They hardly knew each other. But he’d been willing to say those words from the beginning. Unlike her, he had an ability to sense who was the right person for him, and she was it. So, the words came naturally. For her, it was a giant risk, a leap of faith. And he loved her even more for it.
“It’s not absurd,” he said. “I’ve fallen in love with you too.”
She smiled and bit her bottom lip as she began to grind her hips, sliding her pussy onto his cock and away from it in a fluid motion. Thane leaned forward and took her left nipple in his mouth. He loved those fucking nipples. Then he held onto the right and pushed them both together, so his tongue could lash at them both.
Penny’s hand grabbed the back of his head and her nails dug into it. She used the grip as leverage and fucked him even harder and faster. Her pussy was in control. When she leaned back, reached under, and grabbed his balls, he thought he might lose it. Her torso stretched out and he got a full view of her entire body. Her face, so lovely and horny. Her shoulders and arms, so soft, and her tits so perky. Her stomach and all the way down the length of her body. But that wasn’t all. The way her body jerked each time she slammed her pussy against him was so fucking sexy he thought he might come. He couldn’t come inside though. Not unless she was sure about becoming one of his kind.
“Penny,” he said.
“Yes?” she asked. “Ohh…ohh…yes? Fuck, Thane. I can’t handle this. Make me one of you, fast, before I come and ruin it.”
That was all he was waiting for. He knew he wouldn’t last much longer. When he’d fucked Penny from behind, he’d nearly lost it, and all that pressure was still built up inside him. She continued to ride him, but he pulled her body close to him so that her tits were mashed against his chest, and each time she bucked, he drove up high into her. He felt it in his balls first, that slight pinch that told him he was about to explode. His toes curled, his stomach ached, and his cock began to jerk inside her.
He was about to let loose and once that was done, it would be too late.
“This is going to hurt,” he told her.
She closed her eyes.
“I’m ready,” she said.
He opened his mouth, and as his cock began to pulsate inside her, he shifted only enough so that his teeth became razor sharp and then he bit down into her shoulder. She screamed. He knew how painful it would be, but he couldn’t let go now. Like the way sharks fuck underwater, she was his prey right now, and nothing mattered except his need to come inside her.
Forcing her onto her back, his teeth still clenched in her shoulder, he licked at the blood as it ran down her arm and onto the sand. With her still in his grasp, he used that grip he had with his mouth to hold her still as his cock grew another two inches. She cried out and screamed and slapped his back and tried to kick her feet, but his giant member was buried inside her. And his teeth would not let go. They never would, not until he’d finished his orgasm.
“Oh God!” she yelled. “Please!”
“You wanted this,” he reminded her through clenched teeth.
“I do!” she replied. “Keep going. Oww fuck!”
She lifted her legs and wrapped them around his waist, giving him better access to her, and he continued to drill into her, pounding away at her pussy, as he held onto her shoulder. His cock began to tremble, and then finally he let loose. She became drenched in cum as he exploded inside her, a mixture of human with a tiny bit of shark semen, just enough to turn her.
***
It couldn’t be possible. He was already so deep and then he seemed to get bigger. It was as if his cock grew inside her. It hurt so bad but felt so fucking good. The pain in her shoulder was immense, but she knew what she was getting herself into, so she held on and accepted it. She loved the aggressiveness, the raw desire he showed when he put her on her back and slammed his cock into her. It made her feel wanted.
When he began to twitch inside her, she knew it was coming. This was almost over and then what? She could think about that later because right now was…
Ohhhh. Ohhh shit. Ohhh yaaaaassssss!
Warmth filled her insides as Thane’s cum filled her, coating the inside of her pussy and dripping down over his cock. It was different from anything she’d ever experienced before. As if it contained some sort of drug, she was in an instant state of euphoria. She couldn’t concentrate. She could only lie back and enjoy. She was numb, yet she felt everything. More than everything.
When Thane pulled his teeth off her, she lifted her head and cried out in pain. Then her head fell back and the throbbing in her shoulder seemed to trigger a new sense of ecstasy. She felt the blood running down but she didn’t care. Her mind was in a different place, and if given the option, she would choose to stay there forever.
Penny felt the wind through the trees and the bugs landing on leaves and the fish swimming through water. She felt the shooting star that shot across the sky and the baby kicking from within Ruby’s stomach. She felt joy and pain and laughter and rage and even a mixture of emotions all at once. Something was changing inside her. Her senses became stronger. Where before, she’d felt his cock inside her, now she could feel every cell of her pussy as his cock slid in and rubbed against her.
What’s happening to me?
“Thane?!” she called out. “What’s happening?”
“Ride it,” he said. “Enjoy it. It’s part of the process.”
She wanted to lie back and enjoy it, but that felt selfish, so she pulled away from him, pushed him onto his back, and sat on his cock. She wanted to ride him through this. To feel him deeper inside. He continued to come inside, and each drop sent her deeper and deeper into a strange state of being. She laughed at nothing funny, and she loved the feel of her hands on her own body. She played with her tits, rubbing at her nipples as she continued to fuck him.
“It feels so good,” she said.
“You’re becoming like me,” he said.
She laughed and giggled, and she never stopped fucking. She wouldn’t dare. She wanted this feeling to last forever.
“Tell me you love me,” she said, trying to stifle her laughter.
“I love you,” Thane said as he bucked his hips, so he could fuck her harder.
She looked at her shoulder and saw that it was caked in blood. Normally, she would have freaked out, but whatever his cum contained had her so fucking high she couldn’t worry about shit like that. She continued to sit on his cock and fuck him until she blacked out.
Chapter 10
“You’re fucking kidding,” Sylvia exclaimed as she looked at Penny with a slack-jawed expression.
“I’m dead serious,” Penny replied. “Look at my shoulder.”
Standing in their shared hotel room, Penny pulled the corner of her dress down and showed the tender bite mark to her best friend. Sylvia was appalled.
“That’s fucking gross, Penny,” she said. “That’s not okay. What he’s done to you is not fine.”
“It’s fine,” Penny argued. “In fact, it’s better than fine. This mark, as painful as it looks, is practically the same as Thane putting a ring on my finger. And what I’m telling you is true. He said I could tell you if I was sure you wouldn’t tell anyone else. So here I am.”
“Like putting a ring on your finger,” Sylvia repeated with a roll of her eyes
. “So…what? You’re half shark now? Like instead of a wifey you’re a sharkey?”
Both women remained quiet for a second, neither wanting to give the other room to wiggle out of the argument. Then, Penny couldn’t hold back any longer and burst out laughing. Sylvia joined her. Yet, even through their happy tears, Penny realized she couldn’t answer Sylvia’s question. She didn’t have enough information to go on, which was strange considering she was about to abandon her life and move into his.
She knew he cared about her, maybe even truly loved her. Was she his wifey? Was she half shark? Thane had told her to stay away from salt water and only allowed her to go see Sylvia if he could supervise her journey out to Juan Diego’s boat himself, to make sure not even a drop of salt water touched her skin. Then he escorted her the entire way. Even now he was relaxing on the boat, waiting for her to finish so he could take her home.
“I think so,” Penny said, “But I’ve never shifted. Thane said it hurts like hell the first few times and he’s not sure I’m ready for it yet.”
“This is fucking crazy,” Sylvia said.
“I know it is,” Penny said as she continued packing her clothes into her suitcase.
She needed her own clothes on the island. She didn’t mind wearing Kalina’s old dresses, but she could only mooch off the other woman so much without looking bad. Having no clothes was one thing. Refusing to go get your own clothes was something else.
“So, you’re just going to ditch life back home and stay out here on Shamu Island?” she asked.
“Shamrock Island,” Penny corrected her. “And yes. I have nothing back home.”
“And your doctors?” she asked. “Your medical appointments? You’re not healthy, Penny, remember?”
“Thane promised me all that is over now,” Penny replied. “That’s part of the process. All I need to do is shift for the first time. Once I do that, I’ll be immune to human diseases.”
Oh, Bite Me: Paranormal Dating Agency Page 11
