"What?" she asks, catching me looking her over.
"You look so much like..." I stop. I can't bring myself to say it. What if she really is Nicole? Then that would mean she's lying. And why would she do that? Unless... she's got something to hide. Or she has no idea who she is.
"Who?" Nyelle asks as I hold the door open for her.
I hesitate again. If I call her out on being Nicole, there's a chance I may never see her again. And I just got her back, well... sort of.
"No one," I recover quickly as she walks past me. "Forget it."
I bump into someone as I exit. I look down to find Carly. Before I realize what's happening, a stinging slap lands across my cheek.
"Holy hell, Carly! What was that for?!"
"You are just like the rest of them. I can't believe I was so stupid."
I've had enough. She's been making my life miserable for the past week, and this time, I know I didn't deserve it.
So as she's about to turn away, I raise my voice. "You ended things, Carly. You did, so you could hook up with another guy. So just... leave me alone!"
Carly's eyes grow wide with shock, and her face flushes. She opens her mouth, but nothing comes out. Finally, she says, "Don't worry. I will." Before storming off, she adds, "But I'm keeping the Cal sweatshirt."
I shake my head in amused disbelief. I think she got the point.
"Well, that was entertaining." Nyelle laughs. She begins to walk away.
Unsure of when I'll see her again, I quickly call after her, "Need a ride?"
Nyelle hesitates, and just when I think she's about to accept, she shakes her head. "No thanks. I'll walk. But maybe I'll see you tomorrow." She smiles and starts down the sidewalk.
*
"She slapped you?" Rae laughs. "Seriously?"
"Rae," I say sternly into the phone, quieting her. "You're not listening. I think--I'm almost positive anyway--this girl is Nicole."
"What is with you lately?" Rae asks. "You've been weird about Nicole for a while now. You need to stop obsessing. I'm starting to become embarrassed for you."
"I'm not obsessing. And this has nothing to do with her ditching us in eighth grade, Rae. There's something really messed up going on. And I don't know what it is. This girl looks so much like Nicole Bentley, it's crazy. But she acts nothing like her. She doesn't even talk like her. I'm really starting to think she was in an accident or something. Head trauma can cause amnesia and alter your personality."
"You've watched way too much House," Rae accuses. "We live in a small town. Don't you think someone would've said something? You know the vipers would've been all over any rumors about Nicole."
Rae's right. And after watching them carry on like she never existed this past summer, I know they have no idea Nicole's here, or how much she's changed. They would've said something.
"Check her Facebook status. See when she posted last," I say.
"I'm not friends with her, remember? On Facebook or anywhere else."
"Right." I'm not either.
While we're still on the phone, I click open Facebook on my laptop and type in "Nicole Bentley." There's a picture of her, smiling brightly and wearing a pair of sunglasses. I click on her page, and the cover picture is Harvard's crest. She has more than a thousand friends, but all of her pictures and posts are private.
"Cal, you still there?" Rae asks. "The girls should be here soon for band practice."
"Huh? Yeah, uh, go ahead," I tell her as I type in Nyelle Preston. "I'll talk to you later."
I still have the phone tucked under my chin when I get the results. There's only a Noelle Preston--who doesn't look anything like the girl at Crenshaw. I set my phone down on the desk, staring at the screen without focusing on the words.
What happened to Nicole to force her to become Nyelle Preston?
I keep circling back to the night that I can't remember.
RICHELLE
Day After Nicole Moves In
I shovel the last bite of pancake into my mouth and jump up to put my plate in the sink. "Where are you going in such a rush?" my mom asks.
"To see if the new girl can play," I tell her, practically running for the door.
"Richelle, it's early. You might want to give them time to eat breakfast."
"I'm done. Maybe she is too," I holler back and push the screen door open. "Bye, Mom!"
I run across my lawn and stop at the little trees between my house and hers. I poke my head through and listen. I don't hear anything. I step closer to the edge of the driveway, and I hear, "Did you put all your clothes in the dresser?"
They're awake.
I jump over the flowers planted on the edge of the driveway and hop up the front steps. I push the doorbell and wait. But waiting is hard. So I push the doorbell again.
Mrs. Bentley opens the door. "Well, good morning, Richelle. Aren't you prompt?"
"Can Nicole come out to play?" I ask. I've been dying for this day all summer, ever since I knew someone was moving in next door and that they had a kid going into fourth grade too. Cal was hoping for a boy since he's the only boy on our street who's our age. But I'm happy she's a girl.
Nicole pokes her head around her mom.
"Hi, Nicole!" I say. She steps forward and I grab her hand. "Want to come play with me?" I pull her out the door and down the steps before she can answer.
"Nicole, please be careful. And be home for lunch," her mom calls to her.
When we reach the sidewalk, I let go of her hand. She pushes down the skirt of her blue dress like she's trying to make it flatter. She has a matching blue bow in her hair. She looks like she's going to a birthday party with her shiny black shoes on.
"Where'd you come from?" I ask her, heading down the street toward Cal's and Rae's houses. Just then, I see Cal coming out his front door. "Cal!" I run across the street. When I reach the sidewalk, I realize Nicole isn't next to me anymore. I turn around and yell to her, "C'mon, Nicole! We're going to play in the woods."
Nicole continues to walk, not run. She must be afraid of slipping in her shiny shoes.
"Did Phil finish it yet?" Rae hollers to Cal, cutting across her yard.
Nicole finally catches up, and we meet up with Cal and Rae between their two houses.
"No." Cal sighs. "It takes him forever to get anything done."
"God, we're never going to have a tree house," Rae complains, like she always does.
"We can still play back there," I say. "Oh, this is Cal and Rae," I tell Nicole, who is standing a couple steps behind me, looking at the ground.
"Hi," Cal says. She looks up at him and quickly looks down again. How could she be afraid of Cal? There's nothing scary about him.
"Hey," Rae says.
Rae, on the other hand, is definitely scary, but you don't really find that out until you get to know her. On the outside, she looks like she should be selling lemonade to the neighborhood, with her blond braid and freckles speckled across her face. But once you get to know her, you realize she'd rather dump lemonade over your head than to serve it to you.
"What are we going to play today?" I ask, excited to have someone new with us, even though she doesn't talk.
"Let's catch bugs and make our own bug zoo," Rae suggests.
"Or bug circus!" I exclaim, picturing butterflies flying through hoops as I dance around an arena. "Let's go!" I start running toward the woods, cutting through the tall grass where the wildflowers grow. Then I stop when I see something hop in front of me. I get down on my hands and knees and look for it.
"What is it?" Cal asks.
"Ssshh." I'm concentrating on the grasshopper that's landed on a tall blade of grass. As fast as I can, I cup my hands around it. I can feel it jumping around. It tickles. I squeal and open my hands, dropping it in the grass.
"Why'd you do that?" Rae asks. "You let it go."
"It felt funny," I answer, doing a jittery dance, thinking about how it tickled my hand. Someone laughs. I look up and find Nicole giggling. It's the first s
ound I've heard from her, and it makes me laugh too.
Chapter Three
I wait around the coffee shop the next morning, hoping Nyelle will show up. I leave when I can't wait any longer without being late for sociology.
I'm swearing under my breath as I stalk across campus, taking the most direct route to Stewart Hall. Dr. Tenor likes to embarrass late arrivals, and I'd rather not be today's victim.
I'm jogging down the slope behind the Student Union. Before I start climbing up the other side, I stop. A girl is rolling down the hill. I watch as she tumbles down the steep incline in a blur of hair and blue, dragging a green scarf behind her. She comes to a stop on her back on the flat ground between the two hills, with her arms flopped out beside her. Then she just lies there.
I'm too shocked to move at first. This isn't something I see every day... or ever. When she doesn't make an attempt to get up, I slowly approach her. She doesn't notice me. Her electric-blue eyes are still directed up at the sky. "Nyelle?"
She blinks at the sound of my voice, focuses on me, and then smiles so wide I can see her bottom teeth. "Cal!"
Not sure what to say to a girl who just voluntarily rolled down a hill, I ask, "Need help up?"
"Not yet. I'm dancing."
"What?" She's not making any sense. I'm beginning to suspect the head trauma theory may not be far off. Or maybe she's drunk.
Her eyes return to the sky again, and she inhales deeply, still wearing the vibrant smile. "I've wanted to do that for so long."
"Um, okay," I say, offering her my hand. She grabs ahold with a cutoff knit glove and hoists herself off the dying grass.
She doesn't brush off the dried blades clinging to her sweater... and everywhere else.
"You have a little something," I say, reaching for the grass stuck in her hair. She shakes her head wildly, her hair whipping around under the brown woven hat. It doesn't help, but she doesn't seem to care. Which is nothing like the girl I used to know. "Where are you going?"
"Class. And I'm late," I say, dreading going.
"I'll walk with you," she offers, heading back up the hill she just rolled down.
I catch up to her. "So do you have a thing for rolling down hills?"
"Nope. That was my first."
"Really?" I question, amused by her answer. "So what made you do it?"
"It was on the list." She says this like it makes perfect sense and I should understand. Except I don't. When she notices I'm waiting for her to continue, she exclaims with a laugh, "And it was fun! C'mon, Cal. Haven't you ever had the urge to do something just for the fun of it?"
"Probably." I hesitate. "I just can't remember when."
"Really? That's sad." She truly sounds sorry for me. "You'll have to do it with me next time."
I laugh. "Uh, I'm not sure about that."
We reach the top of the hill and enter the building where my class has already started. I pause in the corridor, about to thank her for the escort, when I hear, "Hey, gorgeous," behind me. I know he's not talking to me.
Nyelle's eyes narrow as three guys walk by us. "Fuck off."
Her words take them, and me, by surprise. I'm not sure who said it, or what he ever did to offend her, but he'll probably never call her gorgeous again. They whip their heads around. "Bitch."
I feel like I should defend her, but the malicious grin on Nyelle's face keeps me silent. I let them walk out the door without interfering. "Do you know them?" I ask her, trying to understand what just happened.
"No," she responds shortly, still staring at the door.
"Then what was that about?"
"They know nothing about me," she says between her teeth.
"O-kay," I say with a slight shake of my head, confused by the extreme mood change. They seriously pissed her off. But then I consider who I'm dealing with and what I saw the night of the Halloween party and laugh to myself.
"What?" she asks, turning her attention back to me.
"I've wondered where she went."
"Who?" Nyelle asks, studying me carefully.
"The girl under the mask."
"Which one?" She smirks.
Her answer steadies me. I know she's being cryptic. This isn't the first time. Yet it keeps throwing me off because all I can think about is what she isn't saying.
She turns to walk away. "Bye, Cal."
"Nyelle," I call to her, before she can get too far. She faces me, walking backward. "Do you have plans this weekend? Can I call you?" I hope the request doesn't sound as desperate as it feels, but I can't let her walk away without knowing I'll see her again.
"I don't have a phone," she replies with a small smile. "I'll see you. I promise."
I push through the door to the lecture hall, smiling at the image of her, littered with grass from her hat down to the edge of her sweater, stuck in my head. "Well, thank you for making time for us, Mr. Logan!" bellows throughout the room. Every head turns my way. Shit.
I nod apologetically and duck into the back row, taking the first empty seat I find.
I end up only half paying attention to the lecture, thinking back to the girl who is not who she appears to be. Whoever she is, I like her. She's unexpected, and yeah, maybe a little extreme. So different from the perfectionist who refused to talk to me in high school. Regardless of how much I like the transformation, no one changes that drastically. Not without a reason.
NICOLE
The Week After Moving
"Nicole, you are a mess," my mom scolds when I come back into the house after spending the afternoon running around in the woods, lifting rocks and rolling logs over to find bugs. I couldn't touch them; neither could Richelle. We'd just find them, scream, and make Rae and Cal pick them up and put them in the buckets.
I look down at my blue dress and notice the smear of dirt from all the times I ran my hands down the front of it. And my black shoes are covered in dirt too.
"You are a little girl," she continues. "You should not be getting dirty! Does Richelle not like playing with dolls? Where did you go?"
I fold my hands and duck my head. "I'm sorry, Momma. She was, um, showing me where these really pretty flowers were behind Cal's house." I've never lied to my mom before. But I'm afraid she'll take my friends away if she thinks they're too messy.
"Who's Cal? You're not playing with a boy, are you?" She makes it sound like playing with a boy will make me sick or something. I shake my head. I don't think I can get away with telling another lie out loud.
"Go clean up and change before your father gets home " she instructs me. "He will be very upset if he sees you like this. And we're supposed to make him happy, not disappointed in us."
"Okay, Momma," I respond, taking my shoes off so I don't track dirt all the way to my room.
*
The next morning I'm in our backyard, setting up the pink table for a tea party, when Richelle comes running over. I don't think she knows how to walk. She's always running.
"What are you doing?" she asks as I set the cup on the saucer.
"Playing," I answer, straightening the chair like my mom does at our dinner table.
"Do you want to play with us?" she asks.
"Not today," I answer. I don't want to tell her that my mom told me I couldn't get dirty. That I needed to act like a lady. And that means I shouldn't play in the woods.
"Well, can I play with you?"
I look up in surprise. "You want to have a tea party with me?"
"Sure!" she answers excitedly. "Wait. I'll go put on a dress too." And she runs off, cutting between the small Christmas trees, toward her house.
*
Richelle came over every morning for the week. Then she'd play with Cal and Rae after lunch. I tried not to be too sad about it, but I was. I could hear them laughing, or Richelle and Rae arguing like they do, from my backyard. I'd try to ignore them and do other stuff so I felt busy. I'd help my mom stick flowers from our yard in vases, put things away in the house, or get dinner ready for Daddy.
&nbs
p; The weekend was the hardest because Cal's family had a cookout. They invited us, but we had to go visit my grandma. There aren't any kids where my grandma lives. Only other old people.
Now that it's finally Monday, I can't wait to see Richelle. I stand by the trees, waiting for her. I really want to go over to her house to ask for her to come out, but my mom says it's not polite to invite yourself over. Even though I'm inviting her to my house. But my mom still won't let me.
When Richelle finally jumps down her steps, I begin to smile, until she starts walking the other way, toward Cal's house. She almost trips over her shoelace, so she stops to tie it. When she looks up, she sees me. I don't say anything. She waves.
"Hi, Nicole! Guess what?!" She sprints over to me, her ponytail whipping around. "The tree house is finally done. Cal's dad had a bunch of family over this weekend, and the guys helped finish it. Wanna come see it?"
I open my mouth to say yes, because I'm excited to see it too. But then I look down at my pink dress and white shoes and shut my mouth.
"I... uh." I want to tell her how I'm not supposed to get dirty, that ladies don't belong in the woods. But I don't want her to think I'm saying she's not a lady. I don't want to hurt her feelings.
Richelle takes my hand. "C'mon." She practically drags me to her house.
"I should tell my mom that I'm coming over," I tell her, looking back at my house over my shoulder.
We enter her house, and her mom comes out of the kitchen.
"Hi," she says. "You must be Nicole. I'm Mrs. Nelson, Richelle's mom."
"Hi," I say, folding my hands in front of me. "Richelle brought me over, but I need to make sure it's okay with my mom first."
"I was actually going over to visit anyway. I'll let her know you're playing. Richelle, where will you be?"
"The tree house," she says.
"Um," I say, my heart beating really fast. "I don't..."
"It's okay," Richelle assures me. "Mom, Mrs. Bentley doesn't like Richelle to get dirty. So I'm going to let her borrow my clothes so she doesn't get in trouble. Okay?"
What If Page 3
