The Spell of Five

by Casey Morgan

  “Wait, I’m sore too,” said Connor.

  “Yeah, me too,” said Seth. “I said it earlier. Connor is full of shit.”

  “Ronan’s actually sore,” said Keira, turning and giving a look to the other boys. “Can everyone just relax? Let’s get a room somewhere and order takeout.”

  We found a room at a little bed and breakfast. Keira kept her promise and she gave me a nice massage on my back and on my bum. The other lads were jealous, but I just smiled through it all. Huh. Maybe I could share with them. Now that I had a victory or two, it would make sharing easier because I knew I was special in Keira’s eyes.

  Keira than snuggled up next to me and cuddled in my arms. I think I was falling for her. How could I leave her? How could she leave us? If I had to endure sharing her with a hundred other men, I would. This was all worth it. Just to be with her.

  As we sat there in each other’s arms, I thought about the relationship and how it could work. The lads and I were all brothers. We’d have our differences, but we’d resolve them. We could talk more honestly than most folk who didn’t know each other, that was for sure. And Keira seemed very honest. Almost an open book. I felt I could trust her in anything. When you’ve shared a bed with someone and three other lads, that had to be a certain level of trust, right?

  I was new at this relationship thing. I had to take things slow and not just jump right into it. With the other lads around, I could watch them and take a cue. Between the four of us, we could keep this relationship on an even keel.

  Chapter 18

  Keira

  After an excellent meal of oysters and fresh caught crab. I gave Tavish a quick massage and relaxed in his arms. But soon, I was ready for more. So, I got up, gabbed a shower to get the horse smell of me, and walked nude and went back into the living room.

  I grabbed the nearest one, who happened to be Connor, and kissed him passionately. Tavish came up behind me and started kissing the back of my neck and down my back. Out of the corner of my eye, I could see Seth and Ronan getting undressed.

  Connor laid me down on the couch, which was large and leather. He spread my legs and started lapping at my pussy. I grabbed the back of his head and pulled him closer to me. Seth, who had his pants of, walked onto the couch and straddled me so I could put his cock in my mouth. He tasted manly, like sweat and fabric. He had also sprayed some cologne on his junk. I sucked his cock and felt it engorge in my mouth.

  “You like that Seth? Huh? You like me to suck your cock?” I asked.

  Accentuating the point by running my tongue along his shaft, I started sucking on each one of his balls. He swallowed hard and steadied himself against the back of the couch.

  “Aw, yeah,” he moaned. “I love it when you suck it.”

  Connor was lapping my clit. I pressed my face into Seth’s hard shaft and moaned in pleasure. The resulting vibrations gave Seth a tingle. He started to grunt, I knew he was close.

  “Oh, God,” he moaned. “Don’t stop.”

  I took his cock into my mouth and sucked it as hard as I could.

  “Give it to me,” I begged. “Give me all of your cum.”

  “Oh, fuck!” he cried.

  Seth came in a giant burst, while holding one side of my head and going balls deep into my mouth. I choked a little bit on his cum but slurped it all up.

  “Oh, that was so good,” he muttered, as I let him go.

  Connor stood up and dropped his pants, while Tavis and Ronan moved over to the couch. Tavis was already hard and had a condom on. He sat on the couch and gestured for me to come over to him. I lowered myself down on his dick, filling my pussy with his magnificent rod. Ronan was hard too and stood on the couch, so I could suck him. Connor slipped on a condom and was too much in a hurry to take off his shirt. He got behind me and slowly pushed into my asshole.

  “Mmmm,” I moaned. “Oh, God. I’m so full of cock. So good.”

  I gestured for Ronan to come closer and I swallowed his dick, choking and slobbering on it as I continued to moan. Connor was ravaging me. I couldn’t help but open my mouth and cry out. It was a mixture of pleasure and pain. Things were a little dry back there.

  “Wait-wait-wait,” I said stopping the action. “Can you put some of that lube on Connor?”

  Seth retrieved it from the bag and tossed it to him. Connor pulled out and coated his condom with it and then shot a little bit up my ass. Then he reinserted himself and it went right in. Oh, that was good.

  “Oh, my God. So much better,” I laughed.

  The lube made the stretching seem more natural and easy. It also heightened the heat factor between our bodies so I could feel more inside me. Now I was twitching all over Tavish’s cock, while sucking Ronan and taking Connor’s shaft in the ass. We developed a three-way rhythm for a moment, but then lost it, as everyone started to reach their climax.

  Connor came first, moaning and then pressing against my back. I could feel his shirt against my skin and his condom filling up with his seed inside me. Next, Tavish finished. He seemed to want to say something, but just stammered a bunch of noises as I felt his condom fill up and fill me up with its warmness and sexual energy.

  Finally, I prepared myself for Ronan. Once again, I wanted to eat his amazing load which was like an entire meal by itself. He came and came and came. I kept swallowing and it was a little like trying to swallow the whipped cream as it came out of a can.

  “Oh, my,” he cried. “O-o-o-oh my.”

  Several swallows later and I had managed to take every drop inside me. I was actually feeling full. We sat back on the couch panting and trying to catch our breaths. Seth had already poured everyone an after-dinner/sex whiskey. We sat their sipping our drinks and relaxing. There was no rush. We could get back to having sex whenever we wanted now. We were in the zone.

  “At the risk of spoiling this relaxing mood,” I started. “I just wanted to talk to you guys to see how you feel about this group of ours.”

  “It’s good,” muttered Seth.

  “Yeah-yeah, good,” agreed Tavish.

  “Mmm, hmmm,” nodded Ronan.

  “Come off it, lads,” said Connor. “I know there’s more to it than that. Out with it then.”

  The other boys kind of looked at each other, unsure of what to say.

  “Fine, I’ll say it then,” said Connor. “We don’t want ye to leave, Keira. Right lads? I wasn’t all that keen on the group thing, but now I am. And I don’t want it to end.”

  “I am keen too,” agreed Ronan.

  Tavish and Seth were silent about it.

  “C’mon, out with it,” urged Connor.

  “Look, I don’t want to spoil the mood,” said Seth. “For now, I’m on board with this. We’re having a good time. Let’s leave it at that, okay? There’ll be time for all this relationship stuff later.”

  “Yeah, I don’t see why we have to get into now,” said Tavish. “I mean, that’s fine you’ve lads have made up yer mind, but I haven’t even heard from Keira. Are ye staying, lass? Or are ye just taking a read of us?”

  “If we can make this work,” I said. “I want to stay. But I don’t want to stay if any one of you bows out. I think that would kind of spoil it for the rest of us. I think what I’m feeling is what you’re feeling, but if you need more time, that’s fine. I’m not going anywhere until I see this through, one way or another.”

  “Siri, play that Blondie song I like,” said Seth into his phone.

  His phone started to play the Blondie hit “One Way or Another” and Seth started singing along to lighten the mood. The rest of us went along with it. We had our answer for now and Seth and Tavish needed more time. That was fine for now, so I didn’t want to press them. We danced to the song in the middle of the hotel room and had a great time.

  At some point, I’m not sure when, one of the lads got out the video game in the hotel room and started a game of Wii sports with tennis. While that was going on, Seth took me in his arms, kissed me and started to suck my tits. The oth
er lads were playing video games, while I had one-on-one sex with Seth. They seemed to be all right with it, so I was too.

  Seth stripped off all his clothes, put on a condom and entered me. He then held me close as we quietly fucked. It was gentle and sweet, just the two of us. I wrapped my legs and arms around him as he thrust in and out of me again and again. Eventually, he turned me over, stood up and did me from behind while I was on all fours. Finally, he pushed in balls deep and came. It was pretty magical. I found myself cumming intensely.

  Next, without a word, Seth pulled out and Tavish walked over. I offered my buttocks to him and he slipped on a condom and took Seth’s place. Now I was more sensitive. Tavish knew how to give a great fucking. He was buff and energetic. He fucked like I imagine a horse would. It was fast, strong and exciting. He left me quivering inside.

  Then Ronan came over and he turned me back around to face him. After sliding on a condom, he slowly entered me and then made love to me. After a few thrusts, I decided it was time for me to show him a good time. I threw him back onto the couch, jumped up on his cock and bounced up and down with wild abandon. His eyes went wide as I slapped my buttocks again and again against him.

  “That’s it, Ronan,” I moaned. “Fuck me good. Fuck me.”

  He put his head back and groaned. I could feel his cock exploding with cum and filling the condom to overflow. I seized on his cock with my pussy walls as I came back down again, and he cried out in joy.

  Finally, Connor came over.

  “Are you ready for more?” he smiled.

  “Bring it,” I told him with a smile.

  “Would you like to try something a little wild?” he said.

  “Okay,” I said.

  Connor took me from behind and grabbed me by the arms, so I couldn’t balance myself. The end result was that I felt like I was completely in his power. It was an amazing turn on and I started cumming immediately. I was squealing and moaning as Connor ravaged my poor, sensitive pussy.

  “You like this?” he growled. “You like when I fuck you like this?”

  “Yes,” I squeaked. “God. Yes.”

  He came inside me, and I saw stars. When he released my arms, I fell forward with my face into the couch and my orgasm was just intense. I couldn’t control my body anymore. I was just twitching from the orgasms and moaning. I was trying to process this new level of sexual sensation.

  I laid on the couch quivering for a bit, while the boys continued their video game. I had never been so sexually satisfied. When I was with Manny or any one man, I always felt there was something missing. It wasn’t that they couldn’t measure up. It was probably because I didn’t truly love them as I do the elves. The four of them together is like a perfect man. Perfect, not because he can change, but because the four of them are so different. Each one of them felt different, fucked different, acted different and that kept the dynamic between us alive. I never knew what to expect.

  Who knew I’d be lying here enjoying post-orgasm quakes while the four elves who gave me them played video games twelve feet away? If you had told me that in New York, I would’ve called you crazy. Before I came here, I never knew a relationship could be like this. The dynamic was totally unique and somehow it was what I wanted all along.

  After a few minutes, I got up, took a quick shower and then came out and joined in on the fun. We played the game naked in the room while drinking whiskey and laughing. Sometime very late, we decided we were too drunk and tired for any more. We retired to the bed.

  We laid down together and I snuggled up to Tavish, while Connor spooned me from behind. I felt perfectly content.

  Chapter 19

  Connor

  I awoke early and decided to go for a walk outside the inn to clear my head. I had to think about what had happened the last few days and what I would do about it. I told Keira last night that I was all in for this relationship. I wanted her, and I was ready to share her with mi brothers, but that was a big decision and now that I knew Tavish and Seth might not be on board I was rethinking my choice as well. I loved Keira, but she only wanted to be with all four of us. It was all or nothing.

  Was I really ready to be in a polyamorous relationship? Being on campus, I had supported all sorts of different people with different lifestyles. They had been born this way or that. The outside world often discriminated against them in jobs, in government and in life in general. I took up the cause when I could. I went to protests, signed petitions, or whatever.

  But this was different. This was my life. I had always considered myself “normal”. Was I ready to not be “normal”? Back in the day, we would’ve been beaten up, maybe thrown out of school or town altogether. Shunned by society at large. I didn’t think I could handle that.

  It was easy to be brave when everyone around you was doing the same thing. But being in a relationship with three other men and a woman? That wasn’t normal. Most folk I knew in Ireland in didn’t understand. They were ignorant or fearful and religious. What if they shunned me? I didn’t know if I could handle it.

  What if the town shunned mi brothers and Keira, while I was back at college getting support? I had heard of polyamorous relationships on campus. There weren’t many and some of them were bisexual or involved this gay person or that trans person. Would we get the same treatment? Should I even care?

  Far from the cottage, I found myself on the beach sitting on a rock. I rubbed my face and then looked out over the ocean watching the sunrise. Maybe this was what an adult relationship really looked like. It was full of hard choices that could impact you the rest of your life.

  Over the course of centuries, great men and women had to endure punishment for not fitting the norm. We would have to endure talk and gossip for sure. Would I hold up? Would Keira? Maybe in the end, only I would be standing. Keira and I would go off together, finally a “normal couple”. But where would that leave mi brothers?

  It felt strangely right to be with her and them at the same time. Something about it made me think it could work. But we barely knew Keira. She said she wanted to stay with us, but maybe she was lying. Maybe this was all a laugh to her. Perhaps she’d return to America with great memories and sexy stories.

  Maybe I’ll just see this to the end. I shouldn’t worry while we’re having a good time. Right? Maybe circumstances would tear us apart, but until that time we could enjoy each other’s company.

  Perhaps I’d have to make a list of all the pros and cons.

  Pros: The sex was pretty spectacular.

  Cons: I’d have to always share Keira with mi brothers.

  Pros: It’s mi brothers.

  Cons: I don’t always get along with them.

  Pros: I’ve really fallen for Keria.

  Cons? I don’t know.

  If I was truly going to give this a go, I had to set aside my own preconceived notions. I also had to trust that there were good people out there that would accept us and our relationship for what it was. Maybe someday, people wouldn’t even question a relationship like ours. Or maybe it was close enough to a normal one they wouldn’t have to.

  I headed back to the cottage feeling better about myself. My little pep talk had put it in perspective. I had spoken truly last night. I was ready for this. I would have to treat this relationship just like any other one. I would listen, try and communicate and be as honest as I could. What else could I do?

  There was a lot to like in this relationship. Keira was a wonderful person and I wanted to get to know her as well as I could. I loved her and wanted to know every bit about her life. And who knows, maybe having the lads around would make the relationship easier, not harder.

  When I got back to the cottage, I could smell breakfast. The innkeeper must had brought us some food.

  Keira met me outside, she was just pulling on a coat and shutting the door when I walked up to the inn’s door. She looked a little surprised to see me.

  “I was just coming to find you, baby,” she said, pulling her coat tighter around her
shoulders. “Are you okay, Connor?”

  I took her into my arms and ran my hands up and down her arms till they warmed up. She snuggled into me, putting her strawberry-blonde head onto my chest.

  “Of course, luv,” I told her. “Just wanted to take a walk.”

  She looked up into my eyes, searching for a lie. “You sure?” She asked. “I figured that you were rethinking what you said last night about being ready to be in this relationship.”

  I kissed her cold, red-tinted nose. “Nope,” I reassured her. “I’m all in. Come on. Let’s get inside and see where that magic sheep of yours is sending us today.”

  When we got back to our room, I saw that the innkeeper had indeed brought us food. The lads were sitting happily around the table tearing into some kind of quiche. Ronan and Tavish gave me a look but I just smiled at them and didn’t let up that I had been thinking. Tavish gave me a slight nod, which I returned and understanding passed between us.

  “Let’s see were we are off to today!” Keira announced. She held the little black ram keychain in her hands and held it in front of her. “Little magic sheep,” she intoned. “Where is the next closest orb?”

  Her eyes went distant as the location spell took over her body. “Okay,” she told us. “I’m in the ruins of a castle. There’s lots of tourists around. There is some weird railing… Oh wait, this lady is hanging upside-down! It’s the Blarney Stone! I know that one!” She came out of the spell and blinked her eyes at us a few times. By her grin, I could tell that she was excited.

  “Then Blarney Castle it is today,” Ronan announced, all smiles. “We should get going soon. I could get us on a special tour.”

  “You’ll like this, Keira,” I said, happy to be going somewhere historical. “If you kiss the Blarney Stone…”

  “I know, you get the Gift of Gab,” she interrupted.

  I must have made a face, because she mimicked my pout and then jumped into my arms. She kissed me until I laughed.

  Excited we all headed out to the van and drove towards Blarney Castle. I was super excited to be going to some ruins that I knew. There was so much that I could tell Keira. She was going to love my lecture this time.