The Lonesome Dove Chronicles (1-4)

by Larry McMurtry

  All this made Pea Eye feel gloomy. He felt that he had stopped knowing how to be useful. He often felt that way at home, too. Lorie was as good at what she did as the Captain was at what he did. Pea Eye wasn’t as good as either one of them, at anything. It made him wonder why the Captain had wanted him along in the first place.

  Call was sufficiently alarmed by the sound of so much gunfire that he woke Brookshire and Deputy Plunkert. He also put out the fire. In the brilliant darkness, on the long plain, even a speck of fire as small as theirs could be spotted by an experienced eye from many miles away; as many miles, at least, as an experienced ear could hear a dog bark.

  Call could sometimes distinguish calibers of weapons, if the firing was slow, but the men who shot the dogs hadn’t been firing slow. The forty shots had been fired in a minute or two. Call thought he heard six or seven guns, but that was a guess. There could have been ten or more, or there could have been only three or four.

  Famous Shoes had not returned to camp. The man seldom waited for instructions, and he was apt to rove all night, when he was on a scout.

  “Where’s our Indian?” Brookshire asked. He had taken a liking to the old man, although he wasn’t exactly businesslike. When he noticed that Brookshire had a book or two in his baggage, Famous Shoes had started pestering him to teach him to read. The old man seemed to think it was something he could start doing immediately, if only he were given the right clues. Famous Shoes had even insisted that Brookshire dismount, so he could show the Yankee a number of animal tracks and identify them. He seemed to think that Brookshire ought to be able to instruct him in reading just as quickly. When Brookshire attempted to explain that the two things weren’t the same, Famous Shoes became irritated. Then Brookshire made the mistake of mentioning sentences. Famous Shoes immediately started asking him to explain what sentences were. Brookshire felt sure that he knew what a sentence was, but he found it damnably difficult to explain the sentence to the old Indian.

  He liked the old man, though. It astonished him that a man Famous Shoes’ age could travel faster on foot than the rest of them traveled horseback. He stayed ahead of them all day, moving at his strange little trot.

  The four of them watched the rest of the night, but there was no more shooting. About dawn, Call thought he heard something, a kind of cry or keening. But he couldn’t figure out what might be making it.

  “Could it be an eagle?” he asked Pea Eye. “They say eagles scream, but I’ve never heard one.”

  Pea Eye heard the sound only faintly. He had no idea what it was.

  Before it was fully light, Call had them headed toward the east.

  “What about Famous Shoes?” Brookshire asked. “Shouldn’t we wait for him?”

  “He’s a tracker, we don’t have to wait for him,” Call said. “He’ll find us.”

  Famous Shoes did find them, about an hour later. He was down in a little ravine, and he had Ben Lily with him. The old hunter was shaggy, filthy, and mad.

  “It was the manburner,” Famous Shoes said, as he trotted up out of the ravine. “He has seven men with him.”

  “He burnt my best dog,” Ben Lily said. “Kilt all nine of them, and burnt one alive.”

  “That’s what we heard, I guess,” Call said. “That’s the sound a dog makes when it’s being burned alive.”

  “He wanted to burn me,” Ben Lily said. “I hid in a snake den. His men shot my dogs. They roped old Flop and burnt him.”

  “Not to eat, though,” Famous Shoes said. “You can see—the dog is a little ways ahead.”

  Ben Lily sat on a rock, unkempt and bewildered. Call offered to let him ride one of the pack horses, if he wanted to come with them, but the old man didn’t even answer. He sat on the rock, shaking his head and mumbling.

  “I think he’s gone loco,” Famous Shoes said quietly, to Call.

  “He’s always been loco,” Call said. “Now he’s old, and he’s lost his dogs. If I were him I’d quit, but I ain’t him.”

  Call went over to the old hunter, who seemed stunned by the calamity that had befallen him in the night. He held an old Winchester; apart from two cartridge belts, he seemed to have no equipment. Ben Lily was reputed to be an exceptional shot, exceptional enough to have killed more than two thousand bears and an unreckoned number of mountain lions. Call remembered him as having keen, mean eyes. This morning, his eyes seemed vague.

  “He burnt old Flop,” Ben Lily said. “Old Flop was my best dog.”

  “You’re lucky he didn’t burn you, Mr. Lily,” Call said. “You’d better follow along with us for a day or two, until we know where he is and where he’s going. Next time, you might not make it to the snake den.”

  The old man shook his head. He wore a ragged cap, which looked as if it had been made from a wolf skin. He kept putting it on, and then taking it back off.

  “I’m going to Santa Fe,” he said. “I got to get some new dogs.”

  “You won’t need them, if Mox Mox catches you,” Call said. “You better come with us until we stop him.”

  “I got to get some dogs,” Ben Lily repeated. “I can’t run no bears or tree no lions without some dogs.”

  “I can’t take you against your will, Mr. Lily, but you’d be wiser to come with us,” Call said. “This man’s not your ordinary killer. He’s the manburner.”

  Ben Lily paid no attention; he was looking to the southwest, toward the distant mountains. His eyes seemed blurred and tired, but Call supposed they might clear quickly enough if he had a lion, or better yet, a bear in his sights.

  “Them mountains are full of lions, but there ain’t no bear,” he said. “I be going on to Wyoming, I guess. There’s bear up there in Wyoming.”

  He stood up and looked around, as if surprised to see that he was among people and not dogs.

  “That killer kilt my dogs,” he repeated. “I best go to Santa Fe.”

  His eyes turned to the northwest; he stared at the distances.

  “You could go with us to Roy Bean’s,” Call suggested. “He usually has a few dogs.”

  “No, I don’t like Bean,” Ben Lily said. “His dogs are just hounds. One mean lion could run them all off. I won’t hunt with dogs that run from lions.”

  “Be careful, then,” Call said, but the old man either didn’t hear him, or didn’t care to respond. He put his Winchester on his shoulder and climbed out of the ravine, heading north. Though he seemed stiff in his movements, he kept moving north and was soon out of sight.

  Brookshire couldn’t get used to the way people behaved in the West. The old man had no blanket, or kit of any kind. No doubt he had matches somewhere about his person, but otherwise he was setting out to walk hundreds of miles, in the wintertime, with nothing but a gun and two cartridge belts, and in country where there were at least two deadly killers on the loose.

  “He just hunts?” Brookshire asked.

  “Yes, all his life,” Call said. “I never heard of him doing anything else.”

  “If he was born today, he’d have to do something else,” Deputy Plunkert said. “There wouldn’t be enough varmints to satisfy him. I’ve never even seen a wild bear. The circus come once and it had a little bear, but it was tame.”

  “You’re right,” Call said. “Mr. Lily’s worked himself out of a job, where bears are concerned, unless he heads for Alaska.”

  Call felt some sadness as he watched Ben Lily disappear into the sage and the distance, his rifle on his shoulder. It was unlikely that he would ever see the old man again. Call had never liked him, really. The two of them had probably not exchanged a hundred words in all their various brief meetings over the years. Ben Lily would talk of nothing except what he was hunting at the time, and Call hunted only for practical purposes and had nothing to say about it.

  But Ben Lily was one of the old ones of the West. Ben Lily and Goodnight and Roy Bean and a few others. None of them were particularly likable, although Charles Goodnight had become friendlier than Call had ever expected him to be. B
ut all of them, and those like them who had fallen—Gus McCrae and old Kit Carson, the Bent brothers, Shanghai Pierce and Captain Marcy—had been part of the adventure. Gus McCrae had declared the adventure over before the Hat Creek outfit had ever crossed the Yellowstone. A few days after he said it, he had gone off adventuring and been killed. Gus had been both right and wrong. The exploring part of the adventure had ended, but not the settling part, and settling, in the time of the Comanche and the Cheyenne and the Apache, had plenty of adventure in it.

  Now, the settling had happened. Ben Lily and Goodnight and Roy Bean and, he supposed, himself—for he, too, had become one of the old ones of the West—were just echoes of what had been. When Lily fell, and Goodnight, and Bean and himself, there wouldn’t even be echoes, just memories.

  Call mounted up, feeling that he had begun to miss Ben Lily, a man he had never liked. Yet, a time or two in his life, he had even missed enemies: Kicking Bird, the Comanche chief, was one. Missing Gus McCrae, a lifelong friend, was one thing; missing Ben Lily was something else again. It made Call feel that he had outlived his time, something he had never expected to do. Now he had begun to listen for echoes, an unhealthy form of distraction when there were still men in the country who burned people and dogs.

  It was an unhappy thought, but soon it might be that the bad men, the Wes Hardins and the Mox Moxes, would be all that was left of the West as it had been. The bad men, in the end, were the ones who wouldn’t settle.

  A few miles farther on, Famous Shoes showed them the burned dog. It was large—part mastiff, Call reckoned. Its four feet had been tied together, and its mouth wired shut. The fire hadn’t been hot enough to consume the animal, but it had been thoroughly seared. Even its teeth were black.

  Brookshire looked at the dog, got off his horse, and threw up. Deputy Plunkert took one quick look and rode on by. He stopped fifty yards farther on, but kept his back to the group. Pea Eye looked, and felt more than ever at a loss. He had seen far worse sights than a burned dog, in his days with the Rangers, and he knew men did bad things to other men. That was an old lesson, learned and learned well in the Indian wars.

  Pea Eye realized that he was just tired of it, tired of such sights and such memories. He had been feeling tired since he’d had to help pull Captain Call off Sheriff Doniphan. Pea Eye didn’t want to see the Captain beat a person to within an inch of his life, even if the person deserved it, as the sheriff had. He didn’t want to see burnt dogs or burnt people, or people with bad gunshot wounds in the belly, or any of that. What he wanted to see was Lorena, his wife, nursing their baby at the breakfast table. He wanted to see his three little boys, and his big girl, Clarie; his big girl, that all the boys were already wanting to court. He wanted to hold his wife in his arms, not bury corpses of people killed by outlaws. It was time for all that to be over. It should have already been over, at least where he was concerned. He had never had the appetite for it, and now he really didn’t have the time for it, either. He had different work to do.

  Famous Shoes studied the tracks for a while, and Call dismounted and took a look too. The tracks went east—several riders and two extra horses.

  “They don’t hurry,” Famous Shoes remarked.

  “No, I guess they wouldn’t,” Call said. “If they hurried, they might miss something Mox Mox wants to burn.”

  He felt uncertain as to how to proceed. The killers were within twenty-five miles of them, probably, and there were several of them. If Mox Mox would take the time to stop and burn Ben Lily’s dog, then killing was probably their main object, though no doubt they would rob, too, when the opportunity arose.

  Call’s instinct was to go after Mox Mox at once. It wasn’t the job he had been hired to do, but Mox Mox was between him and the job he had been hired to do. Besides, the killers were a danger to anyone they encountered, wherever they were. If they had the leisure to burn a dog, they were not expecting either resistance or pursuit.

  Call was traveling with a largely untried troop, though. Pea Eye would probably fight well enough, when the time came—he always had—but the others might just get in the way. Brookshire had indulged in a good deal of target practice on the trip. He was a fair shot at stationary targets, but of course he had never shot at a living target, much less one that could shoot back at him. Deputy Plunkert was also a question mark. By his own admission, he had scarcely left Laredo in his whole life. What he would do in a running fight was anybody’s guess; get himself killed, probably.

  “The manburner has a big man with him,” Famous Shoes said. He had found a track that was as deep as any track he had ever seen. “His horse is tired, from carrying him.”

  “That’s good. Big men make easy targets,” Call said. “Once we shoot the big one, we won’t be so badly outnumbered.”

  Brookshire felt that the clock of his life had run backward, to the time of the War. The sight of the burned dog did it. In the War, the sight of dead horses, some of them scorched, some with their stomachs burst open or their innards spilled, upset him more than seeing the bodies of men. He didn’t know why they upset him more; they just did.

  In the time he had traveled with the Captain, Brookshire had thought often about their quarry, Joey Garza. Joey had killed, and in fact, he killed often, but he killed with a bullet. It scared him to think of Joey crouched behind a rock somewhere, looking at him through a telescope sight, ready to end his life with a bullet. Still, it was a bullet; Katie dying of her sickness probably suffered more than he would suffer if Joey Garza did kill him.

  But the man who had burned the dog, this Mox Mox, was different. Joey was a killer; Mox Mox must be a maniac. Brookshire had observed Captain Call over a fair stretch of time, and had much confidence in his abilities. The man was a little stiff in the morning, but he kept going. He had no tendency to recklessness that Brookshire could detect. He consulted Brookshire fully when there were decisions to be made. Brookshire had confidence in the Captain’s ability to locate and subdue Joey Garza. He thought Call could do it, and do it handily.

  But Mox Mox was a maniac, and he had several men with him. He wasn’t interested in killing with bullets, either. What he was doing went beyond stopped trains, passengers who lost their valuables, and Colonel Terry’s profits. The thought of Joey Garza left Brookshire scared, but the thought of Mox Mox left him terrified.

  Call knew he had a ticklish decision to make. He could keep the men with him, try to catch up with Mox Mox, and hit him in force, such as the force was. Or, he could go alone, and hope to ambush Mox Mox and the men himself. The fact that he would be one against a gang didn’t disturb him much. Very few men could fight effectively, and there might be only one of the outlaws who was really formidable. Blue Duck had been formidable, but from what Call could remember of the Goodnight trouble, Mox Mox had merely been mean. No one seemed to think much of his abilities as a killer. He had led Goodnight a merry chase, and had eluded him, but in that instance, he had a week’s start. The main problem in attacking Mox Mox and his men alone was to determine which one had the ability. That was the man to kill first.

  His only source of information, at the moment, was Famous Shoes. The old tracker had walked off to the east and was squatting on his heels, smoking. Call loped out to where he rested. It was time to decide.

  “He’s got a giant with him, you said,” Call remarked. “Who else has he got?”

  “Three Mexicans who spur their horses too much,” Famous Shoes said. “Their horses jump when they spur them. The manburner himself is small. He makes little tracks when he is burning something.”

  “That’s three Mexicans, the giant, and the manburner,” Call said. “That’s five. What about the others?”

  “There’s a Cherokee,” Famous Shoes said. “He has the best horse, and his horse is not tired.”

  “What makes you think he’s Cherokee?” Call asked.

  “Because I know him,” Famous Shoes said. “I tracked him once before. He stole a woman that Quanah Parker wanted to marry
. His name is Jimmy Cumsa. He is very quick. I tracked him two years ago, and he is still riding the same horse. He takes good care of his horse. I think he is a better killer than the manburner.”

  “If you tracked him, why didn’t Quanah get him?” Call asked.

  “I don’t know,” Famous Shoes said. “I tracked him to Taos Pueblo. But Quanah had to go somewhere on a train, for many days. I think he went to see the President. When he came back, he was too busy to go get Jimmy Cumsa.”

  “I don’t know where the last men come from,” Famous Shoes admitted. “One rides a pacing horse—he is not a good rider and his horse is not strong. The other man is small. He rides a little ways apart. Maybe the manburner doesn’t like him too much.”

  The other men came and joined them. Brookshire looked sick. Deputy Plunkert looked scared. Pea Eye was calm enough, but it was clear to Call that the man’s heart wasn’t in what he was doing.

  Call decided not to leave the men. When the time came to strike Mox Mox, he would leave them, but he wanted them to be in a more protected place before he left. If he sent them alone to Roy Bean’s, with Famous Shoes to guide them, they might make it and they might not. Even if they traveled by night, they would be vulnerable. Ben Lily had been traveling by night, and he had still lost his dogs, and nearly his life.

  “We’ll go to Bean’s,” Call said. “We’ll find out what he knows. Then I may separate from you for a few days and see what I can do about these killers.”

  They started at once, but all morning, Call felt torn. He felt he should break off and go, while he was so close to the killers, but he feared for the men. They were all grown men, and he should let them fend for themselves; he’d often had to leave men in dangerous situations. This time, though, he didn’t feel he should leave them. He didn’t want to come back and find them burnt, like Ben Lily’s dog.

  Brookshire was relieved, when the Captain said he would stay with them. Looking around him, he could see nothing but an endless distance. It seemed that the West just kept opening around him, into greater and ever greater distances. When he thought the horizons could get no farther away, he awoke to horizons that were yet farther. Brookshire had a compass, but he didn’t use it. Captain Call was his compass. Without him, Brookshire doubted that he could find the will to keep himself going across the empty country, toward the dim horizon. He would simply stop, at some point. He would just stop and sit down and wait to be dead.